Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

APM*** P5 December 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***

Oopentuition_teamAdmin10y ago

Please vote in our Instant Polls about the P5 December 2015 Exam.

*** P5 December 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results *** P5 December 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results *** P5 December 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results Post your comments about P5 exam below
SStephen10y ago#1
How you guys feel? I think it's disaster!!!!
MMo10y ago#2
Same, don't think it went well at all, flunked on the EVA calculation and was horrendously time pressured - chose questions 3 & 4 as I felt they were the "easiest" but when pen came to paper it was a lot more difficult than expected. How did everyone else find it?
Ssanjacs10y ago#3
I agree.,.,.,. total disaster! I did question 3 and 4, just kept waffling on... even I wasnt confident I was answering the questions. I'll be surprised if I scrape up to 50 marks to pass this.
Nnicki10y ago#4
Massively time pressured, each requirement seemed to have two to three parts to it! Q4 seemed ok until you started working on it I liked Q3
EElena10y ago#5
Also did Q3 and Q4. Q4 seemed ok at first glance but when I had to start answering my mind was BLANK. The requirements were very ambiguous for me. My feeling is that I wrote a lot but mostly rubbish...not really answering the questions.
IIrina10y ago#6
Totally agree. Q3 was ok, all the others - awful. I tried several times to understand what is required and how to interpret the scenario, but still think that I did not answer the questions. Dissatisfied(((
Nnino10y ago#7
Complete disaster :( I attempted q2 and q3. But still think every question was horrible
MMohsin10y ago#8
difficult paper
Aagrigoryan10y ago#9
It was horrible, especially the question with Transfer pricing.I guess I lost the whole 25 marks on that question(((
Aagrigoryan10y ago#10
@mo993 said: Same, don't think it went well at all, flunked on the EVA calculation and was horrendously time pressured - chose questions 3 & 4 as I felt they were the "easiest" but when pen came to paper it was a lot more difficult than expected. How did everyone else find it?
I also was a bit confused with EVA calculation. Recalculated EVA was higher than it was calculated by junior. I got 257 or sth like this
Aagrigoryan10y ago#11
@relena88 said: Also did Q3 and Q4. Q4 seemed ok at first glance but when I had to start answering my mind was BLANK. The requirements were very ambiguous for me. My feeling is that I wrote a lot but mostly rubbish...not really answering the questions.
The same feeling. I wrote a lot, but I guess most of it was meaningless(
Aagrigoryan10y ago#12
@n.nadiradze said: Complete disaster :( I attempted q2 and q3. But still think every question was horrible
I also attempted Q2 and Q3. But Q2 was the most awful question I have ever met(
Sseagoat10y ago#13
I think many of us' initial thought was that Porter 5 forces is a nice present untill they started reading the scenario and the question itself. Oh boy this Examiner has an imagination to put such an unusual an awkward industry like events company! I always thought 5 porter is my strenght but this question revealed to be the most difficult to me. I agree some questions were like watching Inception (the movie) it was like a question in a question in question where the word and... and... and kept repeating on and on. Really not that much of calculation part for this paper. Unusual EVA approach in question and small calculations for the question with trains. Overall I think it was a fair exam however highly time pressured and extremely unusual (for me) event industry ! Probably I was waffling too much so expecting mid/high 40's fail
Fflexi10y ago#14
What a disaster...going into the exam,I told myself I will ignore transfer price if it comes in optional questions and that's what I did. I did Q 3 and 4...(I passed question 1 and 3) But 10 minutes into question 4,I realized I had zero idea what was required...I spent another 5 minutes trying to unpack it but NO.. Then I started warming up to transfer pricing with only 25 min to go.. I ended up just cleaning up Q 1 and 3 as I had no idea what was required in q4. wish I had chosen the transfer price question because I could have at least got 7 marks..but I realized that too late in the exam Oh ..what al disaster indeed..
Sseagoat10y ago#15
Flexi i did it as well. I was 100% sure Transfer Pricing will come up - i just only prayed it wont be in compulsory Q1. So for me was clear cut to ignore Q2. Ended up with waffling in Q4...
Fflexi10y ago#16
@agrigoryan said: The same feeling. I wrote a lot, but I guess most of it was meaningless(
I got $221 on EVA but the easy marks where in picking out what was wrong and what was right as you were asked to evaluate.whatever the correct Eva ..highly unlikely to get 15 out of 15 but very likely to get over 10 marks for pointing out what was wrong and what was right.
Kkenny10y ago#17
I started on question 2 cos I thought "ah transfer pricing, this I have revised and I know fairly well" but man once I got into the nuts and bolts of it it was awful but it was too late, I was already committed. Then I did question 3 which restored my faith a bit.... If it was as bad as q2 I might have just packed up and gone home. Q1 I answered all the bits in report format Hopefully enough done cox I really have no appetite to do it again, my hand was aching. It really is impossible to formulate quality analysis in the time alotted.... Just firing stuff down as fast as possible. Joke
Aagrigoryan10y ago#18
@flexi said: I got $221 on EVA but the easy marks where in picking out what was wrong and what was right as you were asked to evaluate.whatever the correct Eva ..highly unlikely to get 15 out of 15 but very likely to get over 10 marks for pointing out what was wrong and what was right.
From my most odd comments re EVA were: - R&D should have been adjusted to Profit and also included in capital employed - Capital employed opening balance should have been taken -Inconsistency between operating lease;40, while in capital employed 115, given 4 years-I think I was mistaken here - Post-tax interest charge was not added back - in calculation of WACC post-tax cost of debt whould have been taken, which gave 4.7% - some comments about economic depreciation and replacement costs of assets, although there was no info in the question -also discussed other assumptions used in teh calculation
Aagrigoryan10y ago#19
@rogermellie said: I started on question 2 cos I thought "ah transfer pricing, this I have revised and I know fairly well" but man once I got into the nuts and bolts of it it was awful but it was too late, I was already committed. Then I did question 3 which restored my faith a bit.... If it was as bad as q2 I might have just packed up and gone home. Q1 I answered all the bits in report format Hopefully enough done cox I really have no appetite to do it again, my hand was aching. It really is impossible to formulate quality analysis in the time alotted.... Just firing stuff down as fast as possible. Joke
The same commitment with Q2 made me feel frustrated(( Q3 was fair but still not sure that I managed to earn the acceptable threshold. Praying for 50 marks
Fflexi10y ago#20
- in calculation of WACC post-tax cost of debt whould have been taken, which gave 4.7% - some comments about economic depreciation and replacement costs of assets, although there was no info in the question -also discussed other assumptions used in teh calculation Yes another interesting one was the gearing..in the assumptions it said 100% but in the calculation they used 50:50...so I went with the 50:50 as it made sense and do the tax adjustment on the cost of debt which was not done in the question
Sseagoat10y ago#21
@flexi I also assumed 50:50 was ok and moved on although not sure if correct..
Fflexi10y ago#22
@seagoat said: @flexi I also assumed 50:50 was ok and moved on although not sure if correct..
It's a correct assumption though..I'm sure they will mark it as correct on that one
Former userFormer user10y ago#23
scraping a 50 would be a miracle
MM439910y ago#24
Did anyone get negative EVA after assuming 100% debt to equity means multiplying by 100% as opposed to 50%? Or have i got this horribly wrong and love marks for having a much lower recalculated EVA?
Former userFormer user10y ago#25
100% meant 1:1 so I guess that was right. But I didn't calculate the EVA all over again as I presumed the task was to evaluate it. I completely forgot the question asked of assumptions made ;-(
Former userFormer user10y ago#26
It will be such a miracle for me too. I can't give up on faith till the results come.
AAlexandra10y ago#27
But didn't it say debt/equity was 100%? Which means debt was double the value of equity? I recalculated wacc and obtained 8,5%. Eva was anyway higher than original, something around 250. Overall, it was a disaster...seemed easy in the beginning, I chose q2 and 4 but it was a mistake...I didn't have time to finish q2 and when I got to write to q4 I realised I had no clue as to what the examinator wanted from us. Q1 was ok, although it took me more than 90 mins to complete... From what I read about the examinator and other students I am afraid to think what I might score. I am very dissapointed, you don't even have time to think of what to write in your answer and add this to the fact that the requirements are so twisted...you'll get a horrible exam. I think I can begin restudying in January :(
Aaisha10y ago#28
Big time disaster and time pressured. Q1 took half of the required time. Then moved to Q2 and thought this would be nice to me but as i started reading scenario i was confused and skipped to Q3 lost track of it after 2 paragraphs. Then sneaked into Q4 but it was wayyy out of my comfort level. At last attempted Q3 (which I'm not sure is correct) and Q2 (which i thought is my strong area of the syllabus). I don't think i could pass :(
Wwan10y ago#29
how do you get the percentage of 100% if the amount of debt is double to the value of equity?...doesn't make sense as it will be more 100%...debt/equity=100% means that both elements have the same value.
Ffrahmani910y ago#30
First time taking this paper and certainly won't be the last - absolutely awful. This examiner knows how to confuse people!!!!!!!!!!!!
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.