Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

AAJune 10 Exams POLL Paper F8 was Post your comments here

Oopentuition16y ago
Please share here with community your comments about F8 exam!
?Take our F8 exam survey? https://opentuition.com/articles/surveys/acca-paper-F8-june-2010-exam-survey/
Vote in our instant poll!
June 10 Exams POLL Paper F8 was Post your comments here poll results
Former userFormer user16y ago#121
@boscobosco said:
Sorry, i should have been clearer. When it relates to going concern it is an unmodified report with an emphasis of matter. Slightly different. If you have the BPP book it is page 294 - "Scenario 1 - Going concern appropriate but material uncertainty which is adequately disclosed - In this situation, the opinion on the financial statements will be unmodified but the auditors report will include an emphasis of matter paragraph."

Hope its not a mistake in the book.

dude book is right and we have to be careful in understanding this sentence ..there are two ways of writing this and both means the same

a)unmodified opinion with emphasis of matter paragraph (in other words This is modified Report) Because report is modified by adding this emphasis of matter paragraph how ever opinion paragraph will remain the same/not effected so we say Unmodified opinion.. That is the trick here :)

Modified alone does not mean any thing it has to be used as modified report or Modified opinion.

So it depends on that you are modifying, an emphasis of matter paragraph modifies the report with out any effect on opinion so we have to say in this case its an unmodified opinion and a modified report!!


i really struggled a lot with this before exam so i can confirm 100% on this!

You are welcome to consult your Tutor/book of what i said :) because i have already confirmed it many times :D :D

Also read this topic on this link that i made https://opentuition.com/groups/ask-the-tutor-acca-f8-exams/forum/topic/will-we-be-asked-to-write-an-opinion-paragraph-in-exam/ confirms Again of what is said

good luck for results
Bbingopriests16y ago#122
Can anyone confirm for sure whether it is correct or incorrect to classify audit risks in Q1 into inherent, control and detection risks?
Former userFormer user16y ago#123
@bingopriests said:
Can anyone confirm for sure whether it is correct or incorrect to classify audit risks in Q1 into inherent, control and detection risks

Was it 10 marks right? if yes then identifying alone was not enough here..

if it was 10 marks then 1 mark for identifying and 1 mark for explaining so a total of 5 risks could be identified with explanations as to how they are audit risks and how they could result a material misstatement in FS.

I hope i am right
Former userFormer user16y ago#124
@akberacca said:
So it depends on that you are modifying, an emphasis of matter paragraph modifies the report with out any effect on opinion so we have to say in this case its an unmodified opinion and a modified report!!

It sounds reasonable ... The problem is that I do not remember which word I used on the exam - opinion or report :)
Ssefiller16y ago#125
@boscobosco said:
Question said that management made appropriate disclosures, and auditor is happy that going concern assumption is ok, but material uncertainty exists. So, UNMODIFIED REPORT with emphasis of matter is the answer.


ISA 570
Going Concern Assumption Inappropriate (Ref: Para. A26)
21. If, in the auditor’s judgment, the entity will not be able to continue as a going concern, the
auditor shall express an adverse opinion if the financial statements have been prepared on a
going concern basis, regardless of whether or not appropriate disclosure has been made.

Maybe the guestion said that going concern is inappropriate?
Former userFormer user16y ago#126
@sefiller said:
ISA 570
Going Concern Assumption Inappropriate (Ref: Para. A26)
21. If, in the auditor’s judgment, the entity will not be able to continue as a going concern, the
auditor shall express an adverse opinion if the financial statements have been prepared on a
going concern basis, regardless of whether or not appropriate disclosure has been made.

Maybe the guestion said that going concern is inappropriate?


Pretty sure the auditors were ok with GC assumption.

Thanks for clearing up the above opinion/report distinction. Very confusing. I've lost marks there.
Former userFormer user16y ago#127
i left my 20 marks questrion back..is tha cost me passing??
i did very well to the rest of them
Bbingopriests16y ago#128
i identified and explained 3 inherent risks and 1 detection and 1 control risk in question 1. is that ok?
Ssefiller16y ago#129
@boscobosco said:
Pretty sure the auditors were ok with GC assumption.

Thanks for clearing up the above opinion/report distinction. Very confusing. I've lost marks there.


If so then 2 marks can be expected...As 4 marks will be granted to those who stated as in ISA 570 paragraph 19:)
Former userFormer user16y ago#130
@sefiller said:
Are you sure that question was saying so?
"there is material uncertainty to the effect that the going concern does not exsist"
I don't remember that question said that going concern does not exist.....Any one remembers? If so the question is straightforward...


Perhaps I have misunderstood the question then. I thought the examiner was trying to say that the auditor feels that the company is not a going concern for any reason.

Oh well lets hope we all pass!

On the pass rates, i thought the pass mark was 50% regardless on how others have done, ie, they done pass a certain percentage of people, if they did do this, why would they present on there web site the pass-rates?

Gag
Former userFormer user16y ago#131
@boscobosco said:
Pretty sure the auditors were ok with GC assumption.

Thanks for clearing up the above opinion/report distinction. Very confusing. I've lost marks there.

understanding that question

lets read the sentence again(i've copied it from ACCA website Question paper is out!)
"Describe the impact on the audit report of Medimade if the auditor believes the company is a going concern but a material uncertainty exists."
This Confirms that Auditor is happy with the going concern assumption so Auditor will issue a modified Report with out modifying his opinion with an emphasis of matter paragraph..

The adverse opinion comes when going concern is not appropriate(also if disclosures are made or not) in auditors judgment that is when they issue modified report and modify their opinion(Adverse opinion) but this is not the case here in this question..

The question clearly says "auditor believes the company is a going concern" Which means auditor's judgment, The entity will be able to continue as a going concern

You will(i hope!) not loose marks if you have written a modified Report(with emphasis of matter paragraph) and an unmodified opinion as an answer.
Former userFormer user16y ago#132
JUNE 2010 QUESTION PAPER IS OUT https://www.accaglobal.com/pubs/students/acca/exams/f8/past_papers/int/f8int_2010_jun_q.pdf
CChosen16y ago#133
I do not agree with the Unmodified 'thingy' as that means you are failing to inform the members of a material issue.
Former userFormer user16y ago#134
@akberacca said:
JUNE 2010 QUESTION PAPER IS OUT https://www.accaglobal.com/pubs/students/acca/exams/f8/past_papers/int/f8int_2010_jun_q.pdf

ACCA not sticking at all. i still hav 3 papers to do, i cant look at that now
Former userFormer user16y ago#135
@mustay said:
I do not agree with the Unmodified 'thingy' as that means you are failing to inform the members of a material issue.


Its an ummodified opinion, but a modified report. Very confusing and unfortunately going to cost me 2 marks at least.
Former userFormer user16y ago#136
i thk the paper was easy as compared to the previos one & the pilote paper . . ..but dunno hw the correction will be :S :S
Former userFormer user16y ago#137
@mustay said:
I do not agree with the Unmodified 'thingy' as that means you are failing to inform the members of a material issue.

Auditors are already modifying the report by emphasis of matter paragraph informing members of that material issue in this paragraph.
however modifying opinion is not necessary here, to support my point of view i will definitely tell you to look at this https://www.accaglobal.com/pubs/students/publications/student_accountant/archive/sa_May2010_matterofopinion.pdf read the 2nd page reg Emphasis of matter
ABantonio blaze16y ago#138
@1686844 said:
What are the elements of an audit engagement? I wrote some stupid things :)

Professional(auditor),Subject matter(fin.performance of the co.),Subject matter info(fin. statements of the co),Criteria(ISA/IAS/IFRS) Thats what I wrote.Dont know if its correct.Havent bothered to check
Former userFormer user16y ago#139
Hi...friends i need your assistance...i want to have F7, F8, F9...earlier i had never attempted 3 papers...in fact when i taken 2 last year i got fail in one...anyways my 6 papers will be done till this result...i want to be serious in this session as i heard F7,F8 are quite tough...that's why i planned to start studying F8 after 2 3 days break...i will buy F8 Book soon, though i will join college later but i want to go through 2 3 chapters which could be done with self study without..please tell me what chapters i should start with which could be less tricky...
Former userFormer user16y ago#140
I think it was a managable one, fair questions, very clear, so ... let's see in August..
Former userFormer user16y ago#141
overall i thought the exam was ok. Hoping for 51%
Former userFormer user16y ago#142
@lavender27 said:
anyppl know what is my consequences ??

I also wanna know.
can anyone tell me?
PLZ
Former userFormer user16y ago#143
Is quite easy this term exam but i dont have enough time to done all the question. So are all the candidates that take exam at the same time.
Former userFormer user16y ago#144
paper was lengthy and an easy one but many of us has committed mistakes which could have been avoided so hope for the best from the new examiner
Former userFormer user16y ago#145
For audit risks I identified the following risks for Q1(a):

INHERENT RISKS

Since the Co. operates from one central site it has to travel inventory items sold or purchased over long distances so there is risk of inventory being damaged or lost in-transit.

The Co. has entered into a new line of business so it now faces the risks of import exports as well

CONTROL RISKS

The credit control at the client appears to be weak because it secured the contract through significantly reducing prices

This is the first time that perpetual inventory system is implemented by the Co. This means that client has no previous experience of the perpetual inventory system.

DETECTION RISKS

FD has left the Co. and financial statement are being prepared by a less experienced individual so errors in accounts may exist.

Tell me friends how good is this.
Former userFormer user16y ago#146
The new examiner method a bit quite far from expectation. The most common and major area was always been tested - sales/purchase was not in this exam.