Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

AAJune 10 Exams POLL Paper F8 was Post your comments here

Oopentuition16y ago
Please share here with community your comments about F8 exam!
?Take our F8 exam survey? https://opentuition.com/articles/surveys/acca-paper-F8-june-2010-exam-survey/
Vote in our instant poll!
June 10 Exams POLL Paper F8 was Post your comments here poll results
Former userFormer user16y ago#91
@emmanuel_taf said:
I do not agree - audit risks are those issues that could cause material errors in the financial statements AND those that compromise the company's going concern status.

Inherent risk,Control risk,detection risks are CLASSIFICATIONS of risks ONLY!!
Business risks such as relying on one client for 60% revenue can potentially cause going concern problems.

If you stuck to AR = IR x CR x DR then you are in trouble !

You are supposed to identify the risks,not classify them !! AND explain why those issues are risks i.e. how do they cause errors in the financial statements or compromise the going concern assumption.


You are correct that they are classifications, but identifying the audit risks under these headings is perfectly acceptable and a good way of structuring the answer. It is the way that similar questions in past papers have been answered.
Llavender2716y ago#92
really confuse ....what is the audit report ...at 1st I'm quite confidence on this paper ..now ...haha hope for pass
Former userFormer user16y ago#93
i must say the exam was quiet tricky on Question 1 part C! The perpertual inventory system. the rest was okay for me and I hope i manage to get the 50%. I loved the fact that it was highly concentrated on controls!!!:)
CChosen16y ago#94
The risk question was adopted from a past question and in the answer, the examiner didn't classify into DR CR etc but just identified the risks the coy could face.
This is not to say that the classification is wrong - at least there were control risks in the scenario but why bother wasting tour time trying to classify when you weren't asked for it. Save exam time please! Examiners have complained of students wasting time trying to classify what they weren't asked - this is a major comment of the P1 examiner. So just write to pass and not to overkill the exam.

Check the June 2005 Q1 to verify.
Former userFormer user16y ago#95
The paper was manageable, i hope to get a pass.
Former userFormer user16y ago#96
Check the June 2005 Q1 to verify.

I think this example its not relevant. Examiner comments that there were no marks given for split the answer into three sections of risks. Because 4 marks for explanations of risks were available in part(a)
Former userFormer user16y ago#97
Nice paper ! very conceptual!!
Former userFormer user16y ago#98
@emmanuel_taf said:
I think the examiner wanted you to identify those issues that would lead to errors in the financial statements - i am not sure classifying the risks into IR,CR & DR would generate a lot of marks.

I approached it this way :

Identify risk e.g. forex risk arising from importing from south asia
explain the risk & how it might cause errors in the FS : translation errors e.g. using the incorrect exchange rate

identify risk e,g, going concern risk because bulk of revenues from a single client
explain the risk & how it might cause errors : if major client becomes insolvent,(1) receivables will be overstated and (2) the company might find it difficult to continue operating

I did made a Table In which Identified them in one side Where i said which type of Audit risk it was and on the other sde i explained why was it a risk i think it should be OK this way ... What do think?
Former userFormer user16y ago#99
@emmanuel_taf said:
Threats in ACCA code of conduct are self review,self interest,familiarity etc.
Integrity,objectivity etc are the fundamental principles underlying the code....

i agree with that phew!
got it correct finally
Ssefiller16y ago#100
@gagsingh said:
I think the wording throughout the exam was difficult to work out what exactly was required by the examiner...possibly due to the fact that it was a new examiner!

Still not sure about the last part of question 4, i thought the situation was that the company has included a going concern disclosure, but while the auditor agrees with this he believes there is material uncertainty to the effect that the going concern does not exsist (ie, the auditor feels the company cannot continue to trade for the forseeable future).

SO...the going concern disclosure would say that the directors DO beleive the company can continue to trade for the forseeable future, but the auditor does not...so i would say this needs to be either an adverse audit report or a disclaimer of opinion depending on if the uncertainty is due to mis-statement or the inability to obtain sufficient audit evidence.

What are your thoughts?

Thanks




Gag


Are you sure that question was saying so?
"there is material uncertainty to the effect that the going concern does not exsist"
I don't remember that question said that going concern does not exist.....Any one remembers? If so the question is straightforward...
Former userFormer user16y ago#101
Handsome said 1 day, 5 hours ago:

Pape was easy except 20 marks in question 1

can any one confirm me that in question 3 last part (bank balance confirmation) i had written the procedure that auditor will write letter, signed by manager etc

is it ok? or i made a big blonder :-s

and one more. in last question (c) it was question to write procedure that company is going concer or not. i had written the problem with company and it was not going concern instead of procedured (even i dont know what procedure the examiner was asking)
Hi!
q3- you did write thing, also you can confirm with trial balance figure with day book on sample basis.
q5- c- you just was need too say that you check post year end documentation is there cash flow better, discuss recovery plan with management, cheque board minutes, obtain written representation in regards going concern etc.
I hope it helps.
Former userFormer user16y ago#102
@sefiller said:
Are you sure that question was saying so?
"there is material uncertainty to the effect that the going concern does not exsist"
I don't remember that question said that going concern does not exist.....Any one remembers? If so the question is straightforward...


Question said that management made appropriate disclosures, and auditor is happy that going concern assumption is ok, but material uncertainty exists. So, UNMODIFIED REPORT with emphasis of matter is the answer.
Former userFormer user16y ago#103
does anyone wrote this for:
The important elements involved in assurance engagement are:

* Independence
* Professionalism

* Information or context improvement
* Decision makers
Former userFormer user16y ago#104
that was correct answer. my one far from that
CChosen16y ago#105
@milachika it doesn't matter if the examiner asked for audit risk definition in Q1a. Read the comments in the marking scheme for that question.

To buttress this, Q4 in Dec 08 asked for risks definition and still asked students to SPECIFICALLY identify INHERENT risks in the part b. So do you see the relevance?


Thank Goodness I never ignored Elements of Assurance Engagement:
* Tripartite Relationship between Professional Accountant, Responsible party and Intended users.
* A subject matter
* The subject matter information
* Suitable Criteria
* A written report
* SAAE
Former userFormer user16y ago#106
@mustay said:
@milachika it doesn't matter if the examiner asked for audit risk definition in Q1a. Read the comments in the marking scheme for that question.

To buttress this, Q4 in Dec 08 asked for risks definition and still asked students to SPECIFICALLY identify INHERENT risks in the part b. So do you see the relevance?


Thank Goodness I never ignored Elements of Assurance Engagement:
* Tripartite Relationship between Professional Accountant, Responsible party and Intended users.
* A subject matter
* The subject matter information
* Suitable Criteria
* A written report
* SAAE


Its an irrelevant point. Nobody will lose marks for putting them in, or not putting them in either way. The important part was the risk itself and explanation.
Former userFormer user16y ago#107
my understanding of ques 5 was the comp made all the disclosures and the auditor agreed with them, but there was a material uncertainty. therefore the report must be modify with an emphasis of matter paragraph. because it most be modified to put in an emphasis matter paragraph.
Former userFormer user16y ago#108
@fl123 said:
my understanding of ques 5 was the comp made all the disclosures and the auditor agreed with them, but there was a material uncertainty. therefore the report must be modify with an emphasis of matter paragraph. because it most be modified to put in an emphasis matter paragraph.


I don't think so. As far as I am aware, unmodified reports include emp of matter paras.
Former userFormer user16y ago#110
@fl123 said:
look at this F8 Modified audit reports- emphasis of matter


Sorry, i should have been clearer. When it relates to going concern it is an unmodified report with an emphasis of matter. Slightly different. If you have the BPP book it is page 294 - "Scenario 1 - Going concern appropriate but material uncertainty which is adequately disclosed - In this situation, the opinion on the financial statements will be unmodified but the auditors report will include an emphasis of matter paragraph."

Hope its not a mistake in the book.
Former userFormer user16y ago#111
i think u are mixing it up. it is modify but unqualified
Former userFormer user16y ago#112
The quote above is taken word for word from the book.

So, as i said, maybe the book is wrong. I hope not.
CChosen16y ago#113
@boscobosco said:
Its an irrelevant point. Nobody will lose marks for putting them in, or not putting them in either way. The important part was the risk itself and explanation.


Read between the lines. I never mentioned that you'll be penalized. My view is that classification narrows your scope. What if you make an incorrect classification?

An Unqualified opinion is E.O.M

A qualified is LOS or DWM

Qualified + Unqualified are both forms of Modification.

Unmodified is ONLY when you have a TAFV FS - no hitches.
Former userFormer user16y ago#114
@mustay said:
Read between the lines. I never mentioned that you'll be penalized. My view is that classification narrows your scope. What if you make an incorrect classification?

An Unqualified opinion is E.O.M

A qualified is LOS or DWM

Qualified + Unqualified are both forms of Modification.

Unmodified is ONLY when you have a TAFV FS - no hitches.


Again, the BPP book clearly states the above (that eom can accompany an unmodified opinion) I am gonna trust that ahead of you thanks..
CChosen16y ago#115
I don't know abut that.

See this too: https://opentuition.com/groups/p7-advanced-audit-and-assurance/forum/topic/unmodified-and-qualified-reports/groups/forums/
Former userFormer user16y ago#116
@fl123 said:
look at this F8 Modified audit reports- emphasis of matter

I think I found answer of your dispute. I was thinkin like fl123 because this is written in open tuition course notes BUT I opened the ISA book and see what I found:

"ISA 570 GOING CONCERN
Use of Going Concern Assumption Appropriate but a Material Uncertainty Exists
Para 19. If adequate disclosure is made in the financial statements, the auditor shall express an unmodified opinion and include an Emphasis of Matter paragraph in the auditor’s report."
and
"ISA 706 Emphasis of Matter Paragraphs and Other Matter Paragraphs in the Independent Auditor’s Report
Para 7 (d) When the auditor includes an Emphasis of Matter paragraph in the auditor’sreport, the auditor shall: Indicate that the auditor’s opinion is not modified in respect of the matter emphasized."

So it looks like boscobosco is right. Audit opinion with emphasis of matter is unmodified (although in open tuition it is written that it is modified).
Former userFormer user16y ago#117
using of a white out for errors... any things tht myt go wrong in my results :(
Kkylefran16y ago#118
If every one is happy on the exam, any chance the assessor will be more stricter for the assessment. If you marked 50, but this time you only can be marked 48 or 49 to control the pass rate.?
Former userFormer user16y ago#119
It was ok .....but not enough tym since have loadss to write n i think the examiner should review the time set for each individual paper and be objective
Bbingopriests16y ago#120
For Audit Risk question I classified risks under headings Inherent, Control and Detection Risk. I included 3 risks under Inherent Risk and 1 risk each for Control and Detection Risk. Detection risk may occur if auditors preliminary assessment of materiality is incorrect and hence, will apply insufficient audit procedures.