Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

AAJune 10 Exams POLL Paper F8 was Post your comments here

Oopentuition16y ago
Please share here with community your comments about F8 exam!
?Take our F8 exam survey? https://opentuition.com/articles/surveys/acca-paper-F8-june-2010-exam-survey/
Vote in our instant poll!
June 10 Exams POLL Paper F8 was Post your comments here poll results
Former userFormer user16y ago#61
@akberacca said:
i did the same way :)


I think the examiner wanted you to identify those issues that would lead to errors in the financial statements - i am not sure classifying the risks into IR,CR & DR would generate a lot of marks.

I approached it this way :

Identify risk e.g. forex risk arising from importing from south asia
explain the risk & how it might cause errors in the FS : translation errors e.g. using the incorrect exchange rate

identify risk e,g, going concern risk because bulk of revenues from a single client
explain the risk & how it might cause errors : if major client becomes insolvent,(1) receivables will be overstated and (2) the company might find it difficult to continue operating
Former userFormer user16y ago#62
@nagdam said:
What do you guys think about q1 audit risk at the planning stage ?
I was big confused but managed to write something like
FD has left so ...
Inventory not being count regularly
High competitive market
and something like that but not happy with Q1 a)


I really messed up this question. What exacly did q1 part c mean? With the completeness and accuracy? What did you write?
Former userFormer user16y ago#63
Hi folks, just thinking Q4 (a) on the threats under ACCA code of ethics, is that self review, self interest etc or is that IFAC. Maybe it's objectivity, integrity etc, any help would be appreciated!
Former userFormer user16y ago#64
@mwalsh87 said:
Hi folks, just thinking Q4 (a) on the threats under ACCA code of ethics, is that self review, self interest etc or is that IFAC. Maybe it's objectivity, integrity etc, any help would be appreciated!


Threats in ACCA code of conduct are self review,self interest,familiarity etc.
Integrity,objectivity etc are the fundamental principles underlying the code....
Nnagdam16y ago#65
Everyone is saying the paper was easy but one thing everyone should keep in mind generally when paper is perceived harder the marking guide is generous and when is easier than strict.
Nnagdam16y ago#66
@shorty20 said:
I really messed up this question. What exacly did q1 part c mean? With the completeness and accuracy? What did you write?


Can you remind me what was the question ?
Former userFormer user16y ago#67
@emmanuel_taf said:
Threats in ACCA code of conduct are self review,self interest,familiarity etc.
Integrity,objectivity etc are the fundamental principles underlying the code....

Any one know how many marks for this question? I think I got it wrong by reading the question incorrectly. I have written the principles instead of threat, but I did give examples, of course, examples for the principles, as follow,
Integrity - Not disclose conflict interest
Objectivity - High % fee
Professional competence and due care - incompetent
Confidentiality - financial interest
Professional behaviour - not comply with law

Please give comments.....
Kkamoul4916y ago#68
Hey guys!

Was sitting for the F8 today! Waw quite a long exam... I thought the difficulty was more towards being able to complete the exam in time than the content of the questions.. Overall think I could pass depending on whether the examiner is able to read my hand writing. Should really push forward recommendations to make it a multiple choice exam or computer assisted exam lolz... Anyone of you guys attempting F7 exam on the 15th? Cant seem to be able to concentrate..

Regarding assurance engagement, I tackled the questions by comparing reasonable (positive opinion) and limited assurance (negative). I also mentioned the elements within an engagement letter...

Feedback please!!

Good luck to all, just wish it wasnt a long wait before receive the results... 27th of August right?

:)
Llavender2716y ago#69
@nagdam said:
What do you guys think about q1 audit risk at the planning stage ?
I was big confused but managed to write something like
FD has left so ...
Inventory not being count regularly
High competitive market
and something like that but not happy with Q1 a)


i didnt write FD go, because it is after balance sheet date..the auditor is doing planning ...am i right?
Lline16y ago#70
i think the paper was easier than last sitting....but i afraid that i didn't write enough points for the questions.........and i really afraid that i'll fail again this time........please, GOD BLESS ALL OF US
Former userFormer user16y ago#71
I think the paper is not easy at all, after the second thought. There are so many hidden points for us to miss out.
a few difficult points I found are:
1,the elements of assurance engagement? what the examiner want us to write? the elements in the definition or the type of the assurance engagement?
2, 10 points for the control of completeness and accuracy.... how many points do we need to write? 10 each ? it will be very difficult to write that much.
3 determine the material level, do they want us to write how (the procedure) or the relevant areas for determination( such as risk level or internal control efficiency)
The last question for going concern, it has 4 points for the last part? do we need to discuss how we get to the point of emphasis of matter.

I am very worried :(
Former userFormer user16y ago#72
The threats were:
Self Review
Self Interest
Advocacy
Familiarity
Intimidation
Former userFormer user16y ago#73
the two 10 markers in question 1 was difficult.
what the hell is the elements of an assurance engagement??? is it the types pos + neg. hope not!!!! the wording was weird.
Former userFormer user16y ago#74
hey i was wondering if everyone shaded one of the circles at the top of EVERY page or just the one at the beginning of the answer for the questions, like i did, (1,2,3,4,5) d'yall think that would be a problem? :( i am really worried
HHandsome16y ago#75
you have to write threat instead of priniciple

high fee
familiarity threat
out standing fee
senior audit work for client
etc
@maggie said:
Any one know how many marks for this question? I think I got it wrong by reading the question incorrectly. I have written the principles instead of threat, but I did give examples, of course, examples for the principles, as follow,
Integrity - Not disclose conflict interest
Objectivity - High % fee
Professional competence and due care - incompetent
Confidentiality - financial interest
Professional behaviour - not comply with law

Please give comments.....
Jjuswel21216y ago#76
It was manageable, but some questions were tricky. Kept on reading over the requirements while writing! Time is my biggest nemesis though! :( Didn't finish. Hopefully I'll get 50! In section c. Think it should be a disclamer of opinion since it was duly noted that it was a material and also contingent.
Ggoogle16y ago#77
paper was bit okay than past papers....
elements of assurance engagement....level of assurance, level of gathered evidence(detailed or less), etc..
external audit
review engagement
agreed upon procedure
compliation services

..
q5 part c would be unmodified opinion with eom para as directors were agree to disclose the issues of going concern but there were no signs of shut down or major losses this year....so only eom with unmodified opinion would be okay
...
Ggoogle16y ago#78
q1 categorisation of risk in inherent control and detection....
inherent....related to busiess....major customer, import of inventory, unusual contract terms
control....old n redundend plant, improper inventory count system, long delivery of inventory..
detection ...i could not get time to write about it
...
q5 b audit procedures for going concern

gain audit eveindences realted to going concern
review management's forecasts....cash flow etc
evaluate mgt assumption for going concern
examine board minute for discussion related
evaluate mgt process that make co as going concern
consider any event or conditions that indicate gc
examine co has given sufficient period for gc assumption that at least 12 mths
..
Ggoogle16y ago#79
q4 a.i wrote self int, self revew familiarity advocay n intimidation
and 1 eg for each
b identify n explain threat
i identified as other service than audit work
audit senior working with client and then auditing
outstanding fee
audit partner n fd has relationship
discount offer to but mobile phones
Former userFormer user16y ago#80
I agree it was a very fair paper and i hope to pass though i made some mistakes too. Like in the simplest question of all... 4a!
Former userFormer user16y ago#81
Problem face with the question of elements of asurance services.(q-2)
Write abt:
Mgt advisiory service
Tax services
Accounts preparation
IT cons
etc
Former userFormer user16y ago#82
i made a big blander i forgot to tick THE CRS indicating all the five questions i attempted.........Does it mean i wont be marked ?????????

And what the heal was Q4a asking about the five RICKS of code acca ethics............SURELY ACCA FUNDAMENTAL ETHICS CANT BE RICKS???? I wander what they where asking any1 help......
Former userFormer user16y ago#83
@fanol u should send a e-mail to ACCA explaining the problem.
Former userFormer user16y ago#84
@fanol said:
i made a big blander i forgot to tick THE CRS indicating all the five questions i attempted.........Does it mean i wont be marked ?????????

And what the heal was Q4a asking about the five RICKS of code acca ethics............SURELY ACCA FUNDAMENTAL ETHICS CANT BE RICKS???? I wander what they where asking any1 help......


Go to https://www.accaglobal.com/documents/codeec_doc.pdf and you can see that the code mentions self-interest,self-review,intimidation,advocacy & familiarity as threats.
Former userFormer user16y ago#85
@fl123 said:
the two 10 markers in question 1 was difficult.
what the hell is the elements of an assurance engagement??? is it the types pos + neg. hope not!!!! the wording was weird.


I think the wording throughout the exam was difficult to work out what exactly was required by the examiner...possibly due to the fact that it was a new examiner!

Still not sure about the last part of question 4, i thought the situation was that the company has included a going concern disclosure, but while the auditor agrees with this he believes there is material uncertainty to the effect that the going concern does not exsist (ie, the auditor feels the company cannot continue to trade for the forseeable future).

SO...the going concern disclosure would say that the directors DO beleive the company can continue to trade for the forseeable future, but the auditor does not...so i would say this needs to be either an adverse audit report or a disclaimer of opinion depending on if the uncertainty is due to mis-statement or the inability to obtain sufficient audit evidence.

What are your thoughts?

Thanks

Gag
Kkulorex16y ago#86
My first sitting. It was okay. Hope to pass anyway. Thanks OT!
Kkulorex16y ago#87
Elements of an assurance engagement:

PRACTICIONER
USERS
RESPONSIBLE PARTLY
SUBJECT MATTER
SET CRITERIA

I wrote some like this anyway
Former userFormer user16y ago#88
All those guys who wrote going concern risk and currency risk in qstn 1(a) they r in trouble because the question clearly stated audit risks and mentioned above r business risk .appropriate risks would come under the headings of inherent, control and detection risk.
Former userFormer user16y ago#89
last question answer is unqualified opinion with emphasis item,is that right?
Former userFormer user16y ago#90
@baral said:
All those guys who wrote going concern risk and currency risk in qstn 1(a) they r in trouble because the question clearly stated audit risks and mentioned above r business risk .appropriate risks would come under the headings of inherent, control and detection risk.


I do not agree - audit risks are those issues that could cause material errors in the financial statements AND those that compromise the company's going concern status.

Inherent risk,Control risk,detection risks are CLASSIFICATIONS of risks ONLY!!
Business risks such as relying on one client for 60% revenue can potentially cause going concern problems.

If you stuck to AR = IR x CR x DR then you are in trouble !

You are supposed to identify the risks,not classify them !! AND explain why those issues are risks i.e. how do they cause errors in the financial statements or compromise the going concern assumption.