Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

AAJune 10 Exams POLL Paper F8 was Post your comments here

Oopentuition16y ago
Please share here with community your comments about F8 exam!
?Take our F8 exam survey? https://opentuition.com/articles/surveys/acca-paper-F8-june-2010-exam-survey/
Vote in our instant poll!
June 10 Exams POLL Paper F8 was Post your comments here poll results
Former userFormer user16y ago#31
Q1 A.. PLANNING stage audit risks ??? what did u write ?
Bbereank16y ago#32
The paper was fair. If I had studied hard I'd have been sure to pass! I think it will be a December job for me I'm afraid.
Former userFormer user16y ago#33
@1686844 said:
What are the elements of an audit engagement? I wrote some stupid things :)


elements means the contents...what type pf engagements it is... whome its is addressed to...n etc etc etc
Former userFormer user16y ago#34
Paper was fair... hope i'll get the magic 50... fingers crossed...!!!
Inspite of that i did quite many mistakes plus not to forget it was quite lengthy paper...
Former userFormer user16y ago#35
paper was pretty straight forward...not may tricky questions.....but I wonder y there were 7 marks for bank confirmation....donno what answer examiner is expecting....


done for this session..F6 was ok...n F8 wasnt bad either....hope to clear both the papers..
Ssi8016y ago#36
Well… for assurance engagement I wrote about 3rd party info, available records, legal services and tax services. That sort of thing.

As an aside… that Q.2 was the hardest one I’ve ever had to face. We always use the word "materiality", but from what I remember, we've never been asked what it means...

Q.3, 4 and 5 were entirely fair though. Suppose I could’ve done a bit better on 1.

For Q.5 I put a Qualification (material mistatement) coupled with an "except for" opinion. I had learnt that the going concern status was not to be affected after reading the question, but nonetheless we had to be aware of the material impact. That's why I felt my answer was fair.

I should have included more procedures for Q.3, part (c). One was "Obtain a list of balances... cast the list." Very vague, but it's all I had time to write. I did enjoy doing Q.4 for the most part though.

Q.1 was a trickier beast. Part (b) with the theory was a very difficult question to answer... I ended up referring to inherent, control and detection risk and trying to make them relevant to the question, which I knew was about spotting risk at the audit planning stage. Parts (a) and (c) weren't too bad I think, part (d) I ran out of time on. I was able to mention legal correspondence and press reports when it came to discussing the lawsuit though.

Any other thoughts?
Former userFormer user16y ago#37
F8 examiner we love you. You did make our exam paper quite fair today.
Ssherlynlum16y ago#38
@taqib4u said:
paper was pretty straight forward...not may tricky questions.....but I wonder y there were 7 marks for bank confirmation....donno what answer examiner is expecting....

same as me too ! i done F6 & F8 this time...

Hopefully can pass ^^


done for this session..F6 was ok...n F8 wasnt bad either....hope to clear both the papers..
Aatoeghan16y ago#39
Quite easy hope to pass!
Former userFormer user16y ago#40
ahhh guys cool down all those who r saying tat d paper was easy,because everytime i see the comments of the examiner he is always complainig tat i cant get the desired answers i m looking for.nyways for assurance engagement elements i write about reasonable and limited assurance but i missed the review engagement it was total fluke which i guess is write.for report it was clearly stated tat the auditor accepted that company will carry on as going concern so modified with emphasis of matter.
Former userFormer user16y ago#41
It was good. The tips from opentuition was more helpful than that of BPP
Former userFormer user16y ago#42
gud paper n i m hoping that i will pass this one quite safely inshallah
Former userFormer user16y ago#43
@minnat said:
Last Question(C) PART -
I think we have to say about de modified n also an unmodified opinion... since de directors agreed to disclose it in de f/s :)

modified with Excpt for para ... :)


I thought an emphasis of matter paragraph was more appropriate - remember that part of the question said something like 'auditor does not believe that there are going concern issues but that there are material uncertainties'

It was a 'what if' question in my own opinion....
Nnagdam16y ago#44
What do you guys think about q1 audit risk at the planning stage ?
I was big confused but managed to write something like
FD has left so ...
Inventory not being count regularly
High competitive market
and something like that but not happy with Q1 a)
Former userFormer user16y ago#45
@sherlynlum said:


@usman009 said:
Q1 A.. PLANNING stage audit risks ??? what did u write ?


There were so many risks that could cause errors in the first part of the scenario as well as the last :

i put in :

going concern risk - 60% of sales from one client only
imports from asia - forex risk translation errors from wrong exchange rate
financial controller taking over FD role - might not have enough experience therefore errors might be overlooked
going concern risk - reduction in prices
etc etc there were a lot more risks than the mark allocation which was good ! :)
Former userFormer user16y ago#46
@taqib4u said:
paper was pretty straight forward...not may tricky questions.....but I wonder y there were 7 marks for bank confirmation....donno what answer examiner is expecting....
done for this session..F6 was ok...n F8 wasnt bad either....hope to clear both the papers..

to verify the bank balance i wrote
1. bank letter
2. inspecting bank statements
3. reviewing reconciliation and re-performing bank reconciliation
4.review the cashflow statement
5. review cashflow forecasts (including past forecasts)
cant remember what else i wrote but i had 7 reasonable procedures
Former userFormer user16y ago#47
what about elements ? i wrote independent practioner, opinion, subject matter , suitable criteria etc...
Former userFormer user16y ago#48
Didn't go too bad. Assurance engagement was the main thing that threw me but only 5 marks so could have been worse. Don't think my guesses at fee/objectives/scope/any areas of potential conflicts of interest etc will get me much there!!

As for going concern, i see a few people mentioning a modified report with an emphasis of matter para. Is that possible? I was under the impression that emphasis of matter para's were included with UNMODIFIED reports but where there is a material uncertainty relating to GC that has been disclosed. The text book seems to agree. Thats what i answered anyway.

Only other issue was that i don't think i related my substantive procedures to assertions enough.

Fingers crossed.
DDubz16y ago#49
This exam was not very difficult but it presented a challenge due to its length and the amount of information required. I found myself rushing in the last hour and did not complete the way I hoped to. However, I hope for the best and that I pass this exam.
Former userFormer user16y ago#50
@emmanuel_taf said:
There were so many risks that could cause errors in the first part of the scenario as well as the last :

i put in :

going concern risk - 60% of sales from one client only
imports from asia - forex risk translation errors from wrong exchange rate
financial controller taking over FD role - might not have enough experience therefore errors might be overlooked
going concern risk - reduction in prices
etc etc there were a lot more risks than the mark allocation which was good ! :)

I wrote the same points :D and i agree with you on this! how much we think alike ;)

@emmanuel_taf said:
to verify the bank balance i wrote
1. bank letter
2. inspecting bank statements
3. reviewing reconciliation and re-performing bank reconciliation
4.review the cashflow statement
5. review cashflow forecasts (including past forecasts)
cant remember what else i wrote but i had 7 reasonable procedures

i missed reviewing cash flow statements your other points regarding this is matching mines.
Ssefiller16y ago#51
Regarding the question what are the elements of assurance engagements...Every body stated the types of assurance services: review, agreed upon procedures and etc
Maybe the answer is Intended users, responsibile party, practitioner, criteria, subject matter...? I took this from the definition of assurance engagement...
Former userFormer user16y ago#52
@usman009 said:
what about elements ? i wrote independent practioner, opinion, subject matter , suitable criteria etc...

Regarding contents related to assurance engagements That is correct and you are the first person who's answer is matching with mines!

another point you missed --> responsible party :) but i missed suitable criteria
SKShahrukh Khan Niazi16y ago#53
i just bak home after attending f8
it waz nt v tough except i left qs 1 part a of 10 marks
i hope i ll pas

bestis 4 awl ma frnds....
Former userFormer user16y ago#54
@emmanuel_taf said:
to verify the bank balance i wrote
1. bank letter
2. inspecting bank statements
3. reviewing reconciliation and re-performing bank reconciliation
4.review the cashflow statement
5. review cashflow forecasts (including past forecasts)
cant remember what else i wrote but i had 7 reasonable procedures

I had a llittle more but I'm not too sure about my additional answers they were my best guesses:

I also included...
- comparing cash in trasit to previous periods for initial indication of accuary and completness,
- bank conformation that cash is not held as security for loans or as fix deposits ( valation , classification)
- ensuring the figure on the yr end recon agrees to the ledger and cash in the balance sheet ( accuary,)
Former userFormer user16y ago#55
How did you guys go about question #1?

Did anyone try to identify the risk according to inherent risk, control risk and detection risk... ?

I'm not confident but that was my approche ... first I defined AR according to those 3 component and then tryed to identify risk in the senario accordingly ...
Former userFormer user16y ago#56
@yeah2009bb said:
How did you guys go about question #1?

Did anyone try to identify the risk according to inherent risk, control risk and detection risk... ?

I'm not confident but that was my approche ... first I defined AR according to those 3 component and then tryed to identify risk in the senario accordingly ...

i did the same way :)
330800287316y ago#57
The paper was easier than i thought it would be. I was quite worried because I was expecting a more difficult paper based on past papers. I dont know if it was because of the new examiner but im thankful. Hopefully what I wrote made sense and its enough for me to pass. Good luck to all.
Former userFormer user16y ago#58
To be honest i think the difficulty of the paper is fairly irrelevant. The pass percentage will be somewhere between 35 and 45 as always so its really how you do against the other students that matters. In saying that, its always nice to answer all the questions!
Former userFormer user16y ago#59
@akberacca said:
i did the same way :)


glade to hear that i was abit unsure as to whether i did it the corrct way..... so
I hope this is a case of great minds thinking alike ... and not the converse ... a fool is seldom alone lol
CChosen16y ago#60
There's nothing better than going through the past questions before writing these papers - the exam looks like a 'recycle bin'. Thanks Pami Bahl; the questions were interesting with a variety of different sections of the syllabus unlike previous sessions where not less than 30% of the questions came from procedures, risk etc