Post your comments about F9 June 2013 exam.
How did you do? How did this paper compare to previous exams?
Vote in our Instant Poll

FM*** F9 June 2013 Exam was.. Post your comments ***
<cite>@donizback said:</cite> for me WACC was 12.2% looks a decent figure to me, Q1 i think u r wrong the project was with positive NPV
<cite>@greggie said:</cite> I got an insane npv for q1. 4.9m on a 5.5m investment or something like that. Couldnt see where i went wrong though. The mm hedge I made at around 1900 better. Again, not sure on this. On wacc I got another ridiculous figure of 8% but I think I messed up bank debt.I got 4.9m as well bro
For Q3 exchange rate, once the borrowed Euros (€489,000 approx) had been converted to $ using the spot rate, did the question state a $ deposit rate in order to earn interest? I don't remember seeing one.
Could someone please clarify this, I'm very nervous, think I may have failed, gutted!!!!
<cite>@meaurement said:</cite> For Q3 exchange rate, once the borrowed Euros (€489,000 approx) had been converted to $ using the spot rate, did the question state a $ deposit rate in order to earn interest? I don't remember seeing one. Could someone please clarify this, I'm very nervous, think I may have failed, gutted!!!!I think there was a $ rate of 4% or something like that which became 1% for 3 month apportionment. Don't know if I am right though
<cite>@meaurement said:</cite> For Q3 exchange rate, once the borrowed Euros (€489,000 approx) had been converted to $ using the spot rate, did the question state a $ deposit rate in order to earn interest? I don't remember seeing one. Could someone please clarify this, I'm very nervous, think I may have failed, gutted!!!!There were 2 rates. The deposit would earn interest that needed adding on to the final figure. And the other rate you would b charged interest on. I wouldn't worry to much. I didn't get it first time out hopefully have passed this time around. Did anyone else get 11.25% for Wacc. Easy exam u thought. When will the answers be up. Which options did everyone say we're worthwhile in the last valuation q? Also measurement I wouldn't worry you prob only lost 1 mark : )
<cite>@sanjayk said:</cite> There were 2 rates. The deposit would earn interest that needed adding on to the final figure. And the other rate you would b charged interest on. I wouldn't worry to much. I didn't get it first time out hopefully have passed this time around. Did anyone else get 11.25% for Wacc. Easy exam u thought. When will the answers be up. Which options did everyone say we're worthwhile in the last valuation q? Also measurement I wouldn't worry you prob only lost 1 mark : )Thanks for your help Sanjay K, much appreciated. It's my 5th attempt taking this exam so I need as many of those 'just 1 mark's as I can! Allah may help me!
<cite>@meazakiros said:</cite> could you tell me the answer for financial objectiveMaximise shareholder wealth and reduce financial risk
i am not sure but what i did was, i calculated taking current dividend but as that the 4% growth is after 3 year,the share price u will get is in year 2 time.i then discounted it back to year to year zero.
<cite>@sanjayk said:</cite> There were 2 rates. The deposit would earn interest that needed adding on to the final figure. And the other rate you would b charged interest on. I wouldn't worry to much. I didn't get it first time out hopefully have passed this time around. Did anyone else get 11.25% for Wacc. Easy exam u thought. When will the answers be up. Which options did everyone say we're worthwhile in the last valuation q? Also measurement I wouldn't worry you prob only lost 1 mark : )spot rate is given second last line of whole question
<cite>@evans1301 said:</cite> Concerning Question 3: The factors for the receivables policy ! I guess the same question came out last year ! Again with 8 marks ! Quite tricky and amazing at the same time. I’ve just elaborated on those factors: (1) Assessing creditworthiness (2) Credit limits (3) Invoice promptly and collect overdue debts (4) Monitor the credit system Please advise if it's right !!! I agree with you. Adddition: 1. Seting a reasonable reveivable policy. ie offer discount payment, fine for late payment, set credit term, consider cost vs benefit
<cite>@ifrah16 said:</cite> I used I(1-T) as the cost and the book value as the market value, because I thought the MV would be the same in the case of an untraded loan (i.e. bank loan).. I think that was wrong :( All I can say is, I hope we both pass! (Y) :DSame to you
<cite>@Sabrina1942 said:</cite> My friend it's not one mark u lose more since u r given one mark for correct NPV one for correct selling price and another for inflating itlol you just lose one mark and yea even if your NPV is wrong and you comment according to your NPV that it is positive accpet the project you then also get 1 mark for commenting if u know that your NPV is wrong just assume it. I asked it from my teacher who is a F9 marker :D So cheers
<cite>@phamtung said:</cite>you wrote about the key functions of receivables!! I tihnk the question asked about the faactors to be considered in formulating a receivable policy such as level of finance cost in receivables, what policies are being adopted by compeetitors, level of expertise , risk accepted etc ,,, there were 7 marks for that question and i dont know how much answer we should have given
I also got WACC of 11.6% also using 5% and 3% for the IRR calc. So long as it was lower than the highest cost of the financing mix components ,it's likely to b correct.
sabeco68
<cite>@icedawn said:</cite> you wrote about the key functions of receivables!! I tihnk the question asked about the faactors to be considered in formulating a receivable policy such as level of finance cost in receivables, what policies are being adopted by compeetitors, level of expertise , risk accepted etc ,,, there were 7 marks for that question and i dont know how much answer we should have givenThe question asked about the receivables management policy and it is the credit analysis and credit control and so on
I also wrote about credit analysis and credit control and so on
Q1, How did u guys treat it? The question says we should dicsount using nominal terms approach. I solved it by applying the inflation rate to the varisbles in year 2, is that right guys? I also calculated incremental working capital.
<cite>@meaurement said:</cite> For Q3 exchange rate, once the borrowed Euros (€489,000 approx) had been converted to $ using the spot rate, did the question state a $ deposit rate in order to earn interest? I don't remember seeing one. Could someone please clarify this, I'm very nervous, think I may have failed, gutted!!!!you are right because the rate given was Euro borrowing rate... i just wrote that the dollars needed deposited will earn interest uptill 3 months.. just wrote a comment
<cite>@donizback said:</cite> The question asked about the receivables management policy and it is the credit analysis and credit control and so onassesing credit worthiness and credit control , collecting amounts due, formulating policy are key functions of receivables im pretty sure the question asked specifically about the policies surrounding receivables management and not its key functions !! well i may be wrong as well ! cheers i hope everyone will pass
<cite>@icedawn said:</cite> assesing credit worthiness and credit control , collecting amounts due, formulating policy are key functions of receivables im pretty sure the question asked specifically about the policies surrounding receivables management and not its key functions !! well i may be wrong as well ! cheers i hope everyone will passCheck the past exam paper Ulnad Co. It asked the same question and see the answer :)
<cite>@aneeb123 said:</cite> you are right because the rate given was Euro borrowing rate... i just wrote that the dollars needed deposited will earn interest uptill 3 months.. just wrote a commentOthers have said there was a $ deposit rate of 4% for once you had converted your borrowed Euros, however I only remember seeing the 9% Euro borrowing rate. Anyone else able to clarify what information was provided? I know it'll only be 1 lost mark if there was a depositing rate of interest stated, just for peace of mind.
<cite><a href="https://opentuition.com/members/Lambyang/" rel="nofollow">@Lambyang said:</cite>
1st question wacc 11.6%...am i right?
YESSS =D<cite>@thebear said:</cite> according to my study text , BPP already give a reminder that the preference shares should not be included in the WACC calculations to quote chapter 15 , page 302 of the study text by BPP " when calculating the weighted average cost of capital , the cost of preference shares is a separate component and should not combined with the cost of debt and cost of equity "wait, i have seen it in the book. they DO include pref shares, and why shouldnt you?
fair paper. Success indeed. I hope everyone succeeds.
was money market hedge preferable????
I took my answer in $'000 so my NPV was 4545000
<cite>@donizback said:</cite> lol you just lose one mark and yea even if your NPV is wrong and you comment according to your NPV that it is positive accpet the project you then also get 1 mark for commenting if u know that your NPV is wrong just assume it. I asked it from my teacher who is a F9 marker :D So cheersWell teachers knows best good luck bud
<cite>@donizback said:</cite> lol you just lose one mark and yea even if your NPV is wrong and you comment according to your NPV that it is positive accpet the project you then also get 1 mark for commenting if u know that your NPV is wrong just assume it. I asked it from my teacher who is a F9 marker :D So cheersAlso I hope she go easy on us lol, hey I was quite surprise to see the exact same quest for the receivable management policy lol good thing I work through all those papar well not all most lol
<cite>@Sabrina1942 said:</cite> Also I hope she go easy on us lol, hey I was quite surprise to see the exact same quest for the receivable management policy lol good thing I work through all those papar well not all most lol:D yea the same 7 easy marks for just telling the management policy awesome indeed it was a nice exam and I managed to complete it 10 mins before time :) i was so happy InshAllah we will pass
Insha Allah we all pass ;) it was OK Alhamdulillah
My suggested answers to the June 2013 Paper F9 exam will be uploaded later this week.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

