Post your comments about F9 June 2013 exam.
How did you do? How did this paper compare to previous exams?
Vote in our Instant Poll

FM*** F9 June 2013 Exam was.. Post your comments ***
I think I'm the only person who chose the money market hedge over the forward. When I added on the 3 month interest it looked to work out better. Not looking good :)
I used two interest rates, the USD borrowing rate which was I think at 5% and the EUR deposit rate at 9%, dividing both by three to get for three months.
sorry dividing by four to get three months
Does anybody knows when results will be released?
Don't worry del I chose money market hedge as well. It did look strange to me because in all the practice question forward exchange always seem to be the better choice.
What is difference nomino and real rate?
Hey guys what did you use for the sales units in the NPV calculation.
Remember they said that the sales would increase by 9000 units every year.
<cite>@skay123 said:</cite> Hi guys, In the WACC calc....working out the cost of the redeemable loan note ......in the irr calc for df@5%and 10% for both Npv I got was negative...did anyone get this or maybe I went wrong with the calculator....????.?why didnt u use irr estimate formula? i get it and i use 3% and 5%, 3% will get you a positive npv
Did anyone take into consideration that the sales units would increase by 9000 units EVERY YEAR for the NPV calculation?
<cite>@satmah said:</cite> Did anyone take into consideration that the sales units would increase by 9000 units EVERY YEAR for the NPV calculation?for sure the machine was increase the capacity for 9000 units and it can last for 4 years...how come a machine can increase another 9000 capacity at year 2 ?==
<cite>@satmah said:</cite> Did anyone take into consideration that the sales units would increase by 9000 units EVERY YEAR for the NPV calculation?i did but i don't know if it was correct
<cite>@satmah said:</cite> Did anyone take into consideration that the sales units would increase by 9000 units EVERY YEAR for the NPV calculation?A machine has limited capacity. Isn't it rather odd for a machine to double productivity the older it gets?
Same thing i thought, but the question stated that the machine would cause sales units to increase by 9000 units every year. They had to state it in the question for a reason.
<cite>@satmah said:</cite> Same thing i thought, but the question stated that the machine would cause sales units to increase by 9000 units every year. They had to state it in the question for a reason.I don't remember the exact words but the incremental 9000 units each year was in relation with the old machine they were replacing. They could have as well given us the capacity of the old machine, and the capacity of the new machine, and we would have calculated our own incremental units. The word incrememntal meant extra contribution - as in relevant values. If you remember, the Fixed cost were also incremental - the only ones relevant to the investment. Don't you think at that level of increase in units (double each year), both the fixed costs and working capital levels will not cope!! Think about it? Forgive me if I am wrong
Thanks for your comment. But i think if they used the word incremental, that would have changed the meaning to what you are saying. But the question made no mention of incremental. What they said in the question was that as a result of investing into the new machine, it would cause production units to increase by 9000 units every year. The question then went on to say to assume all units produced are sold.
What do you think?
I got 4510 for NPv and 292 for the forward contract WACc 8 % I know I am wrong
<cite>@bayigga said:</cite> A machine has limited capacity. Isn't it rather odd for a machine to double productivity the older it gets?Can't agree more with u here, the PV I got is 10m initial investment 5.5m which gives an NPV of 4.5m.
<cite>@Sabrina1942 said:</cite> I got 4510 for NPv and 292 for the forward contract WACc 8 % I know I am wrongNPV was 4 million+ and the Forward maket was 296000 and money market 294000 and the WACC was 12.2% I think I am correct :D
<cite>@donizback said:</cite> NPV was 4 million+ and the Forward maket was 296000 and money market 294000 and the WACC was 12.2% I think I am correct :DDid u add the scarp value as well as the working capital .
Return of 18% should exclude issue cost? N regarding the factors to be considered for the traded bond, equity finance,can I mention on the dilution control issue?
<cite>@donizback said:</cite> nevermind bro it cant be more than 2 marks chill nowso if loan is to be added, what market value will you use
<cite><a href="https://opentuition.com/members/Lambyang/" rel="nofollow">@Lambyang said:</cite>
why didnt u use irr estimate formula? i get it and i use 3% and 5%, 3% will get you a positive npv
yes i used 5% and 3%- the cost of capital was 4% though to make the NPV =0<cite>@lfrancus said:</cite> I may be mistaken but sure Pref.shares are included in wacc calcsyes i included pref shares along with debt and equity, however i didnot include the loan as i did not have a market value???? any take on this
<cite>@donizback said:</cite> yup right the exam was fair indeed but yea Q3 was a bit tricky with the part a, but i managed to write something( might be stupid i dont know :P) but I think it was managable exam I managed to do the exam and wrote a lot extra too and was free 10 mins before the time finishedConerning Question 3: The factors for the receivables policy ! I guess the same question came out last year ! Again with 8 marks ! Quite tricky and amazing at the same time. I've just elaborated on those factors: (1) Assessing creditworthiness (2) Credit limits (3) Invoice promptly and collect overdue debts (4) Monitor the credit system
NPV for the first question is positive .....Im I r8 ?
could you tell me the answer for financial objective
Concerning Question 3: The factors for the receivables policy ! I guess the same question came out last year ! Again with 8 marks ! Quite tricky and amazing at the same time. I’ve just elaborated on those factors:
(1) Assessing creditworthiness
(2) Credit limits
(3) Invoice promptly and collect overdue debts
(4) Monitor the credit system
Please advise if it's right !!!
Thanks
I seem to have a different answer to everyone else on the money market or forward hedge.
I came upo with the forward option being better as if you borrowed sufficint funds to have €500000 in three months time at an interest rate of 9% on the euro account you could only convert 500000/((9%/12months)x3months) = € 488,997.55 at the current rate the interest due over the three months would take the debt upto the €500000 to be recieved. Then even if you take into account that you would get 4% on that € 488,997.55 you were still better off taking the forward rate.
I thought it was a fair exam, even though i messed up the WACC by calculating wrong figures, hopefully get something for method marks...
Not wanting to have to resit in December... :(
@nevyana said:
That is how this examiner is maintaining low pass rate- by unclear questions, not by suffisticated scenarios. 2/3 of the people have different interpretation from what he ment in the question and they will fail, like I failed last time because I wrote on completely different topics that he ment, although I was very well prepared. This exam is not fair at all.
??????????????
The exam was the easiest ACCA exam I have ever taken. Easier than F1, easier than MA1. The questions were not unclear, I presume English is not your first language?? If you study and revise, you gain the marks. If you don't, you fail. If you don't read the question then you have no business aspiring to work in finance and accounting where accuracy is critical and the devil is in the detail. (Double facepalm.....)
<cite>@jalapeno said:</cite> The exam was the easiest ACCA exam I have ever taken. Easier than F1, easier than MA1. The questions were not unclear, I presume English is not your first language?? If you study and revise, you gain the marks. If you don't, you fail. If you don't read the question then you have no business aspiring to work in finance and accounting where accuracy is critical and the devil is in the detail. (Double facepalm.....)Ok, I will go back and delete my post, but please keep offenses for youself. I am sitting already P7, so if I pass F9 I will be qualified + I have the experience already. I did not post to argue.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

