Post your comments about F9 June 2013 exam.
How did you do? How did this paper compare to previous exams?
Vote in our Instant Poll

FM*** F9 June 2013 Exam was.. Post your comments ***
<cite>@satmah said:</cite> Thanks for your comment. But i think if they used the word incremental, that would have changed the meaning to what you are saying. But the question made no mention of incremental. What they said in the question was that as a result of investing into the new machine, it would cause production units to increase by 9000 units every year. The question then went on to say to assume all units produced are sold. What do you think?You see that's your interpretation of the question. And my view is my interpretation of the question. None of us remembers the exact words. The questions will be on ACCA website in a few days and we can interpret with a clear mind then. But have you ever seen any such questions in your study and revision where the capacity of the machine is not fixed or set? In such questions, we are looking for that extra contribution.
<cite>@jalapeno said:</cite> @nevyana said: That is how this examiner is maintaining low pass rate- by unclear questions, not by suffisticated scenarios. 2/3 of the people have different interpretation from what he ment in the question and they will fail, like I failed last time because I wrote on completely different topics that he ment, although I was very well prepared. This exam is not fair at all. ?????????????? The exam was the easiest ACCA exam I have ever taken. Easier than F1, easier than MA1. The questions were not unclear, I presume English is not your first language?? If you study and revise, you gain the marks. If you don't, you fail. If you don't read the question then you have no business aspiring to work in finance and accounting where accuracy is critical and the devil is in the detail. (Double facepalm.....)Man, that's rude and arrogant. I was brought up speaking English but I still found the interpretation a bit confusing. I had to read every requirement twice. learn some manners @Jalapeno
<cite>@nevyana said:</cite> That is how this examiner is maintaining low pass rate- by unclear questions, not by suffisticated scenarios. 2/3 of the people have different interpretation from what he ment in the question and they will fail, like I failed last time because I wrote on completely different topics that he ment, although I was very well prepared. This exam is not fair at all.You are quite right. The questions were manageable if you got the interpretation right. The exam was not as direct as some people think. That's how we fail by thinking it's easy.
<cite>@ifrah16 said:</cite> OMG REALLY? You mean like 9000 in year 1, 18000 in year 2 & so on? What was your NPV? I even messed up the WACC question by including retained earnings - I actually went back to fix it :( I guess I haven't been reading the questions properly... :(i'm not sure if it is correct i'm a lil worry about dat ques
<cite>@merkada said:</cite> i did but i don't know if it was correctIn the exam I also understand that sales volume will increase by 9000 per year, so i took 9000 for Y1, 18000 for Y2 and so on. But now i realize that that was not realistic.....Upset about that!! how dou you think many marks it will cost? Also reading other comments, i figure out how many silly mistakes did i do like not including overdraft in new net assets...ahhh... and all because of time pressure.... Will keep the fingers cross to pass!!!
<cite>@sharlene20 said:</cite> yes i included pref shares along with debt and equity, however i didnot include the loan as i did not have a market value???? any take on thisThe loan have to be included at the book value
<cite>@narinemalakyan said:</cite> In the exam I also understand that sales volume will increase by 9000 per year, so i took 9000 for Y1, 18000 for Y2 and so on. But now i realize that that was not realistic.....Upset about that!! how dou you think many marks it will cost? Also reading other comments, i figure out how many silly mistakes did i do like not including overdraft in new net assets...ahhh... and all because of time pressure.... Will keep the fingers cross to pass!!!I did the same with the demand, increasing by 9000 every year. Once I got to the (ridiculously high) NPV, I realised that I had made an error. I didn't want to waste time correcting it, so I put a footnote saying that the demand should have been 9000 for every year. At most we should be penalised 1 mark I would say. As I am sure I did everything else 100% correct. Any thoughts on this people?
<cite>@shincody said:</cite> I did the same with the demand, increasing by 9000 every year. Once I got to the (ridiculously high) NPV, I realised that I had made an error. I didn't want to waste time correcting it, so I put a footnote saying that the demand should have been 9000 for every year. At most we should be penalised 1 mark I would say. As I am sure I did everything else 100% correct. Any thoughts on this people?I clearly read that part of question where they say sales volume is 9000 per yr, I didn't see anything about increasing every year if I did I would have done the same like u guys, my NPV was 4.5m what was urs
<cite>@donizback said:</cite> for me WACC was 12.2% looks a decent figure to me, Q1 i think u r wrong the project was with positive NPVHe said that his NPV was 4.9m not the PV cash flow Mr.Decent
<cite>@narinemalakyan said:</cite> In the exam I also understand that sales volume will increase by 9000 per year, so i took 9000 for Y1, 18000 for Y2 and so on. But now i realize that that was not realistic.....Upset about that!! how dou you think many marks it will cost? Also reading other comments, i figure out how many silly mistakes did i do like not including overdraft in new net assets...ahhh... and all because of time pressure.... Will keep the fingers cross to pass!!!I remember the lecturer mentioning in class that if you get the units wrong, but compute the rest correctly, basing on the figures you have got, you only loose like a max'm of 2mks. Given in this question the units were copy and paste, you would probably loose just one mark. let's face it, there are 3mks for tax savings through CA alone. Then initial outlay and scrap value in their right periods (0 and 4); adjusting for inflation using the right rates; A mark for using the right discount factor; another for copying the right figures from PV tables. and one mark for making a decision basing on your figures. And all these are not really affected by the units. We shouldn't be worried even if we got the units fugures wrong.
I think one does not have to increase the sales units by 9000 each year. This is bcos the increase should be interpreted as an increase on previous production and sale. Hence, 9000 units wud be incremental units on whatever was produced b4. Also I don't think adding or not adding the bank loan makes any difference. I didn't add the bank loan bcos there was no mkt value of the bank loan given and the interest rate given wan an average of the variable interest which in it self is in appropraite to use. But I believe which ever calculation one did is based on assumptions.
<cite>@icedawn said:</cite> yea there was an inflation rate for working capital all recovered in year 4 . The line equal zero when u add all And tax savings start in year 2 , same as tax, Was told one year in arrears in questionWat was ur NPV
<cite>@bayigga said:</cite> I remember the lecturer mentioning in class that if you get the units wrong, but compute the rest correctly, basing on the figures you have got, you only loose like a max'm of 2mks. Given in this question the units were copy and paste, you would probably loose just one mark. let's face it, there are 3mks for tax savings through CA alone. Then initial outlay and scrap value in their right periods (0 and 4); adjusting for inflation using the right rates; A mark for using the right discount factor; another for copying the right figures from PV tables. and one mark for making a decision basing on your figures. And all these are not really affected by the units. We shouldn't be worried even if we got the units fugures wrong.Wat was ur NPV
<cite>@bayigga said:</cite> I remember the lecturer mentioning in class that if you get the units wrong, but compute the rest correctly, basing on the figures you have got, you only loose like a max'm of 2mks. Given in this question the units were copy and paste, you would probably loose just one mark. let's face it, there are 3mks for tax savings through CA alone. Then initial outlay and scrap value in their right periods (0 and 4); adjusting for inflation using the right rates; A mark for using the right discount factor; another for copying the right figures from PV tables. and one mark for making a decision basing on your figures. And all these are not really affected by the units. We shouldn't be worried even if we got the units fugures wrong.Thats good to hear, thank you!!!
<cite>@narinemalakyan said:</cite> Thats good to hear, thank you!!!Yeah I wasn't too worried about it. I even left a note for Marker to say it should be 9000 every year. It would have looked like a horrible mess if I tried to correct it all for one mark. NPV was around 40 million I think due to that error.
F9 June 2013 was really tricky but manageable.hope to pass more than 70%.Questions were of investment appraissal using net present value, business valuations , cost of capital and working management especially on receivables and foreign receibales on foreign currency management.
<cite>@merkada said:</cite> to me it increased by 9000 per yearif increased 9k per year then yur npv number must be really big :S how much u got?
<cite>@sharlene20 said:</cite> yes i included pref shares along with debt and equity, however i didnot include the loan as i did not have a market value???? any take on thisfor bank loan mv is the blance sheet figure for kd its 4%(0.7)
yea increase by 9k units every year produced and sold !!! this mean for year 1 you hav produced an incremental amount of 9k and sold all, Thensecond year onwards same thing.... i think it meant that every year it could produce an incremental amount of 9k units!!! not increase by 9k every year xD
Did anyone inflated the scrap value...like 5000,000 * .05 = 250,000 * (1.049)^4 ..........................supposing general inflation rate was 4.9%
Nope
No
In q1). For NPV, how many marks will be lost if the sales figures are wrong??. I did not increase the units by 9000 each year.
My paper was all messed up just bcz of this NPV question...I used 1.55 instead of 1.055 for VC ..and my NPV came (7000,000) ....and I wrote comments on this too :p ....later i corrected it but by cutting and overwriting but I don't know whether examiner accepts re writing and over writing..
<cite>@shincody said:</cite> Yeah I wasn't too worried about it. I even left a note for Marker to say it should be 9000 every year. It would have looked like a horrible mess if I tried to correct it all for one mark. NPV was around 40 million I think due to that error.My friend it's not one mark u lose more since u r given one mark for correct NPV one for correct selling price and another for inflating it
<cite>@narinemalakyan said:</cite> It was receipt as far as i remember, so the company sould be borrowing for 3 months.every year inflation was required to calculate the incremental WC required each year
i dont understand why people are saying they didnt increase the units by 9000 units ... in the npv calculation you should use 9000 for each year because that is the increment in units .. 9000 to 18000 ..increment of 9000 so use 9000 so forward so forth
<cite>@jshields said:</cite> I seem to have a different answer to everyone else on the money market or forward hedge. I came upo with the forward option being better as if you borrowed sufficint funds to have €500000 in three months time at an interest rate of 9% on the euro account you could only convert 500000/((9%/12months)x3months) = € 488,997.55 at the current rate the interest due over the three months would take the debt upto the €500000 to be recieved. Then even if you take into account that you would get 4% on that € 488,997.55 you were still better off taking the forward rate.that's as correct as it can be
Relating to the volume discussion. In my opinion setting up 9000 units every year was correct approach. But let's all wait for question release so we can have another cool-headed view.
ef="https://opentuition.com/members/narinemalakyan/" rel="nofollow">@narinemalakyan said:</cite>
Did you inflated working capital (500,000$) in Q1 a when calculated NPV for the project?
tax relief for WDA was starting with T2, right?
<cite>@narinemalakyan said:</cite> Did you inflated working capital (500,000$) in Q1 a when calculated NPV for the project? tax relief for WDA was starting with T2, right?
<cite>@narinemalakyan said:</cite> Did you inflated working capital (500,000$) in Q1 a when calculated NPV for the project? tax relief for WDA was starting with T2, right?
<cite>@narinemalakyan said:</cite> Did you inflated working capital (500,000$) in Q1 a when calculated NPV for the project? tax relief for WDA was starting with T2, right?Yes I think you just put on the extra amounts for the following years. I think I got 23, 24, 25 and 26! I didn't recover it as it said another machine would be bought. Not sure if this was right. And yes tax year 2 at 20 percent I think!
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

