Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

FM*** F9 December 2011 Exam was: Post your comments and vote in Instant Poll ***

Oopentuition14y ago
Post your comments about December 2011 F9 exam.
What came up? How did you do? How did this paper compare to previous exams?

Vote in our Instant Poll
*** F9 December 2011 Exam was: Post your comments and vote in Instant Poll *** poll results
Former userFormer user14y ago#91
q1 why I got 104070 but not 104700? as i added back the working capital in year 5, also i got irr 16%,very upset
Q2 i got both negative for recourse and non recourse, because i included the savings in interest, wrong again
Q3,the wacc calculation was terrible! i didn't realize the mv of bond,and i didnot exclude tax in the interest payments each year in the npv, so ,,, may only get 1-2mark in this
Q4,ex rights price 7.2 that was right, in part b the is the PEration 16.7? and the new share price would be 6.02? as the interest cover ration, the PBIT does not change right?
i am quite worried ,,probably fail this easy f9!
Bbenfabregas14y ago#92
Messed up a lot of this paper, didnt cover factoring in revision so lost 14% straight off. Got about 60000 NPV in question 1, which doesnt seem to match anyone elses. Reckon I have got late 30's, early 40's! Hoping for a suprise come February!

Does anyone know when are these papers normally available to view online?
Ssherlynlum14y ago#93
I got NPV $50,000. I dint assume Working Capital to recover at the end of project life, I think there I have made a mistake :(

For the factoring, for non recourse I got a net gain as non recourse we need to tk into account the saving for bad debt.
Sskopa14y ago#94
Hi, can anyone explain the correct treatment of factoring in Q2? I've also got both negative for recourse and non recourse is that correct? Thanks
Bbenjamincozoemena14y ago#95
The f9 was generally touf for me...got no idea on how to tackle the question on capital rationing....Recourse and Non recourse...TERP was too technical for me. Operating cash cycle was rubbish i did....wot is it abt cost of debt before tax without a current value ? I pray for miracle in this exam.
Bbenfabregas14y ago#96
Hoping I did alrite on capital rationing question, spoke about hard and soft rationing, and divisible/indivisible projects
Mminiclaire14y ago#97
Quote:
what did you write for investment appraisal for 7 marcks question, i was running out of time and wrote on NPV and IRR, relating to mutually exclusive projects anyone write similar, starting to self doubt now!!!
Former userFormer user14y ago#98
skopa said 21 hours, 8 minutes ago:

Hi, can anyone explain the correct treatment of factoring in Q2? I’ve also got both negative for recourse and non recourse is that correct? Thanks

I got one positive and one negative, - the only difference in my calculations was the given percentage. I know this was not correct, but after discussions I agree that for non-recourse (1.25%) we should have decreased the level of bad debt from 0.9% to 0, in this case those who did it, told me that in both cases the values were positive but non-recourse was more favourable. In any case comments on the results will score marks.
Former userFormer user14y ago#99
Many Students are confusing about Factoring....8 Marks for calculation.......NOW 1) With Recourse ...2) Without/non Recourse
In With Recourse "Bad Debt" ....The ultimate Responsibility is still on Company not on Factor CO'.....it doesn't mean the decrease in bad debt is not yours benefit as like 9% to 6%......the benefit will only Decrease............

2) Without Recourse......means All Bad Debt is now Factor CO' Responsibility not the company who hire them........Explanation !!! if factor providing you services on Without recourse BASIS......NO matter how much bad debt you have 20%, 30% , 40%.....Its not your headache ......its now on factor..........In The Exam Question The ultimate benefit will be now, that all your Bad Debts which were 9%.......ALL IS YOUR BENEFIT THE WHOLE 9% BAD DEBT.......thats why factor charge premium in this service ....




In both options it was positive , but in "Without Recourse" its benefit is 158% higher than" With recourse" basis........as i explain above ...In without recourse the whole bad debt was your benefit......thats why it was higher.........
Hope you Understand.....
Former userFormer user14y ago#100
Well it was okay for me. The questions were not all that difficulty
Pprincefury00714y ago#101
well for me q1 was the best npv question ever! went blank at first but just decided to do it as the requirement stated it. hoping for at least 20 marks

q2 was alright only messed up my cal on factor a bit. in recourse got higher cost than benefit, while in non recourse got more benefit than cost. though calculation may be slightly wrong but hoping for atleast 17 marks
q3 did almost everything right but i notice that wen cal wacc there was a bank loan and a bond. used irr for bond make pre tax to post tax for bank loan etc.
dvm , talked about limitation and assumption briefly!other method was capm and risk adjusted wacc. hoping for 17marks

q4 was ok but not perfect by a mile did not finish but raised only7 points for q4 d and did very little part of the analysis but overall hoping for 13 or 14 marks

i think it was a really fair paper
Former userFormer user14y ago#102
I think it was a fair paper. Part of the Qs are straightforward, some are not. I will say It is 60:40