Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

FM*** F9 December 2011 Exam was: Post your comments and vote in Instant Poll ***

Oopentuition14y ago
Post your comments about December 2011 F9 exam.
What came up? How did you do? How did this paper compare to previous exams?

Vote in our Instant Poll
*** F9 December 2011 Exam was: Post your comments and vote in Instant Poll *** poll results
00500896714y ago#31
Q1 Volume – 100,000 units
Selling Price – $16
Variable Cost – $11 /unit
Fixed Costs – $ 160,000 per annum
Cap Ex – 800,000
Residual Value – 40,000
Working Capital – 90,000 (is needed in year 1 )
TAX at 30 % – In ARREARS

NPV – ?


I also released the working capital back in year 5.

NPV positive 104700 (something like that)
Former userFormer user14y ago#32
@sanjarbek
correct.
by the way in the last question bonds were to be issued or redeemed
Former userFormer user14y ago#33
Q 1 NPV £104,700
Sensitivity allowance meant that any slight changes to sales or variable costs would mean project not worthwhile
Q2 93 days cash operating cycle
Q3 WACC - 9%
Q4 Ex rights issue $7:20
I'll try to to remember some more
Former userFormer user14y ago#34
nogoodboy

i got 50700 on npv wonder how you got 104700
cash operating cycle i also got 93 days
wacc 9%
ex rights 7.20


pls expalain how you got 104 700

what rate did u discount the cash flow
Former userFormer user14y ago#35
nogoodboy

i got 50700 on npv wonder how you got 104700
cash operating cycle i also got 93 days
wacc 9%
ex rights 7.20


pls expalain how you got 104 700

what rate did u discount the cash flow
Former userFormer user14y ago#36
nogoodboy

i got 50700 on npv wonder how you got 104700
cash operating cycle i also got 93 days
wacc 9%
ex rights 7.20


pls explain how you got 104 700

what rate did u discount the cash flow
00500896714y ago#37
@nogoodboyo said:
Q 1 NPV £104,700
Sensitivity allowance meant that any slight changes to sales or variable costs would mean project not worthwhile
Q2 93 days cash operating cycle
Q3 WACC - 9%
Q4 Ex rights issue $7:20
I'll try to to remember some more


Good i feel better now :) Except my Q3 Wacc was a pile of mince.
Former userFormer user14y ago#38
sikander1985

At 12%
Did you include the scrap value?
00500896714y ago#39
Was it not 11%?

I wrongly started putting in the 10% values and then realised 11% was on the next set down of the value tables.

Sikander probably forgot to add back to working capital in Y5
Former userFormer user14y ago#40
Capital Rationing
Hard and Soft rationing (External and Internal factors)
Divisible projects should use profitability index and rank projects accordingly. Then invest in highest ranked projects first.
Former userFormer user14y ago#41
@05008967 said:
Was it not 11%?
It must be if we had same
I wrongly started putting in the 10% values and then realised 11% was on the next set down of the value tables.

Sikander probably forgot to add back to working capital in Y5
Former userFormer user14y ago#42
Interest Cover
Before was 27/10 = 2.7 times
After was 31.4/3.6 = 8.7 times (something like that)
I know that profit would go up and interest would have gone down
Ended up with $45 million bond
Former userFormer user14y ago#43
on q1 who ever got npv +104700 made a mistake by adding the 6th which was -54533 negative
Former userFormer user14y ago#44
Gearing
Before was 120/140 = 88%
After was 45/210 = 21%
I realised after the exam that there would be a share premium account in equity after the rights issue
Former userFormer user14y ago#45
Cost of Debt
Years 1-6 $8 & discounted at 4.767 = $38.14
Year 6 $100 discounted by 0.666 = $66.60
Total = $104.74
Then IRR
Former userFormer user14y ago#46
050089

please advise how you got +104700 i still dont understand
nogoodboy

the $8 was before tax it was suppose to 8*(1-.3) 5.6 than you discount
00500896714y ago#47
@sikander1985 said:
050089

please advise how you got +104700 i still dont understand



The cost of capital was 11%
you needed to release the Working capital in Year 5
and i am sure you are to include the tax from Y6 - this is still part of the project. Anyone agree/disagree?
Former userFormer user14y ago#48
yes i did just now including working capital in year 1 and release in year 6 but get +121537 anywhere thanks 05008967
Former userFormer user14y ago#49
Can't exactly remember q 1. Will try to write it down.
The cost of debt rate was given for you at 7% but that was before tax. So you had to calculate what the MV of the bond was first. Once you calculated that then you use 5.6 in the IRR calculation
Former userFormer user14y ago#50
05008967

refer to the Dec 2010 ecamination question 1 is similar problem you will see its in the question that it will need additional inital investment in working capital of 250000 and that was not including in the cashlow but was added to the year 0 and not released in year4 as per exam answer on dec 2010

similar was today
00500896714y ago#51
@sikander1985 said:
05008967

refer to the Dec 2010 ecamination question 1 is similar problem you will see its in the question that it will need additional inital investment in working capital of 250000 and that was not including in the cashlow but was added to the year 0 and not released in year4 as per exam answer on dec 2010

similar was today


Todays question asked us to ignore inflation and capital allowances. There was nothing said about ignoring the reclaim of working capital at the end of the project.

Q1 in 2010 specifically said 'ignoring any scrap
value or working capital recovery,'
Former userFormer user14y ago#52
Q1 After discounting at 11%
Year 0 (890,000)
Year 1 306,306
Year 2 193,166
Year 3 174,023
Year 4 156,788
Year 5 218,390
Year 6 (54,533)
NPV = $104,130
Former userFormer user14y ago#53
nogooboy

thank u very much
Former userFormer user14y ago#54
Round-up of the paper as far as I can remember:


Q1 - Investment Appraisal:

a) NPV of investing in the machine (7marks)
b) IRR (4marks)
c) Defining Sensitivity Analysis (1mark)
d) Calculation of sensitivity analysis to SP and DF. (6)


Q2 - WC Mgt

a) Cash operating cycle and it's relationship with working cap policy etc (7)
b) Calc cash operating cycle (4)
c) Calculation of factoring with-recourse &non-recourse (7)
d) Why factor? (7)

Q3 - Biz Valuation
a) THeory - rights issue & P/E ratio (7)
b) Theory - rights issue & gearing (7)
c) TERP (3)
d) Calculation of WACC (8)

Q4 - WACC
a) Valuing the biz using; NA, DGM, Earnings Yield (5)
b) Weakness of DGM (5)
c) Don't remember o_O (4)
d) Objectives of NFP orgs etc (11)

Overall, I believe it was a fair paper. I'm sure we will see very high marks for it. Although, I must say the paper was not without it's tricks. Careful reading of the question's requirements was paramount as always.
I've also noticed not many people are complaining about time being a problem, which is good.

Best wishes, everyone! The paper is done - no use worrying about it anymore. Just pray for the best and keep positive! Those of you who are done with exams, relax and enjoy! Those of us who have papers, back to reading. We're almost done...I can't wait :D
Former userFormer user14y ago#55
Oh yeah, capital rationing theory was also tested under Q1 for 7 marks ^-^
Hharripool14y ago#56
@freshmint said:
Round-up of the paper as far as I can remember:
Q4 C was whether the shareholders were happy I think?

Q1 - Investment Appraisal:

a) NPV of investing in the machine (7marks)
b) IRR (4marks)
c) Defining Sensitivity Analysis (1mark)
d) Calculation of sensitivity analysis to SP and DF. (6)


Q2 - WC Mgt

a) Cash operating cycle and it's relationship with working cap policy etc (7)
b) Calc cash operating cycle (4)
c) Calculation of factoring with-recourse &non-recourse (7)
d) Why factor? (7)

Q3 - Biz Valuation
a) THeory - rights issue & P/E ratio (7)
b) Theory - rights issue & gearing (7)
c) TERP (3)
d) Calculation of WACC (8)

Q4 - WACC
a) Valuing the biz using; NA, DGM, Earnings Yield (5)
b) Weakness of DGM (5)
c) Don't remember o_O (4)
d) Objectives of NFP orgs etc (11)

Overall, I believe it was a fair paper. I'm sure we will see very high marks for it. Although, I must say the paper was not without it's tricks. Careful reading of the question's requirements was paramount as always.
I've also noticed not many people are complaining about time being a problem, which is good.

Best wishes, everyone! The paper is done - no use worrying about it anymore. Just pray for the best and keep positive! Those of you who are done with exams, relax and enjoy! Those of us who have papers, back to reading. We're almost done...I can't wait :D
Hharripool14y ago#57
Q4 C Was about whether the shareholders were happy I think. Cant remember the marks for it though?
Former userFormer user14y ago#58
For Q1 NPV I got:

0 machine 800k + w/cap 90k= (890k)
1 contr 500k - fixed c 160k = 340k @11% = 306,340
2 cont 500k - fixed 160 - tax 102 = 238k = 193,256
3 cont 500k - fixed 160 - tax 102 = 238k = 173,978
4 cont 500k - fixed 160 - tax 102 = 238k = 156,842
5 cont 500k - fixed 160 - tax 102 + w.cap 90k + scrap 40k = 368k = 218,224
6 tax (102) = (54,570)

total npv 104,070

working cap was req'd at the "start" of the first period so i thought it made most sense to include it under time 0
anyone agree?
Former userFormer user14y ago#59
Then used 20% to calculate the IRR and got 16.22%
Former userFormer user14y ago#60
@mongadobbin said:
Then used 20% to calculate the IRR and got 16.22%
...
working cap was req’d at the “start” of the first period so i thought it made most sense to include it under time 0
anyone agree?


Yes, working cap is included at Year 0, along with the initial investment, and written back in the final year. :)