Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

FM*** F9 December 2011 Exam was: Post your comments and vote in Instant Poll ***

Oopentuition14y ago
Post your comments about December 2011 F9 exam.
What came up? How did you do? How did this paper compare to previous exams?

Vote in our Instant Poll
*** F9 December 2011 Exam was: Post your comments and vote in Instant Poll *** poll results
Former userFormer user14y ago#1
it was ok
Former userFormer user14y ago#2
what areas been examine?
Former userFormer user14y ago#4
what topics?
Former userFormer user14y ago#5
I think the first qn on NPV was rather simple. But Q2 and Q4 is quite tough.

Q1 - NPV with sensitivity analysis
Q2 - Working capital management with debt factoring
Q3 - Valuation of companies with WACC
Q4 - EPS, financial analysis and discussion of financial objectives.
Former userFormer user14y ago#6
what topics pop up plz.
Former userFormer user14y ago#7
what topics pop up plz.
Former userFormer user14y ago#8
Easy Paper!

Q1 – NPV, IRR with sensitivity analysis
Q2 – Working capital management with debt factoring
Q3 – Valuation of companies with WACC
Q4 – EPS, financial analysis and discussion of financial objectives.
The last question was a bit tough but managed and overall did fine :)

Was expecting hedging and at least bit of Islamic Financing!!! :(
Came out Happy!
Former userFormer user14y ago#9
there was too much theory although calculation was not that hard however too much hard theory just pissed me offf..... i hate theories..... ;(
Former userFormer user14y ago#10
how did u calculate wacc in the exam?
Former userFormer user14y ago#11
can anyone tell me in Q3 last part what other techniques were there apart from wacc for investment appraisal i just cam up with capm help plz ;(
Former userFormer user14y ago#12
well cost of equity was given and for cost of debt i deducted tax and in debentures i use 100 as market value discounted interest for 6 years after deducting tax and then used discounted 100 as redemption was at par value ..... then used irr @ 8% & 13% then used all three rates my final answer was like AROUND 9 % ANYONE GOT SIMILAR ANSWER....
Ssherlynlum14y ago#13
quite ok ~ hope to get a pass :)
Former userFormer user14y ago#14
Yes, I got 9%
@ammar-shabbir said:
well cost of equity was given and for cost of debt i deducted tax and in debentures i use 100 as market value discounted interest for 6 years after deducting tax and then used discounted 100 as redemption was at par value ..... then used irr @ 8% & 13% then used all three rates my final answer was like AROUND 9 % ANYONE GOT SIMILAR ANSWER....


Yes I got around 9%
Former userFormer user14y ago#15
@aliizafar said:
how did u calculate wacc in the exam?


Using Ke, Kd(loan) and Kd(8% bonds)
Aadam1131014y ago#16
WACC i messed it,didnt have time to use IRR
Former userFormer user14y ago#17
Hi everyone,
How was factoring? I calculated that in both cases: with recourse and non-recourde it is not financially worthwile to use factoring, it is more expensive than currect.I have suspicion that it was not correct. :(
Former userFormer user14y ago#18
@annasrei said:
Hi everyone,
How was factoring? I calculated that in both cases: with recourse and non-recourde it is not financially worthwile to use factoring, it is more expensive than currect.I have suspicion that it was not correct. :(


When I first calculated factoring, both recourseand non-recourse were negative. So when I moved to part d I realized that we were not supposed to include the interest on 80% as it's simple recourse and non-recourse administrative services , not financing. Re did and found them both positive, but non-recourse was more benefecial because even though the fee was high, the benefit of bad debt recovery (full) was more than that.
Former userFormer user14y ago#19
Thanks for the info, now I see. Really, a small word like "administration" can change whole exercise. :(
Former userFormer user14y ago#20
@shadedrose said:
When I first calculated factoring, both recourseand non-recourse were negative. So when I moved to part d I realized that we were not supposed to include the interest on 80% as it's simple recourse and non-recourse administrative services , not financing. Re did and found them both positive, but non-recourse was more benefecial because even though the fee was high, the benefit of bad debt recovery (full) was more than that.


Yes.. both are beneficial .. but non recourse is more beneficial :)
Former userFormer user14y ago#21
How IRR coud be 9 % if at 11% it's coming to $122,000 ?
mine was 14.1 % I donno ;)
00500896714y ago#22
Well when i first opened the paper i was really pleased! There was so much to do though, ran out of time on some bits. Think i am now on a 50/50 footing... :(

Q1 NPV ended up with something +104700
IRR came in about 13% so accepted on that basis
Easy to describe what sensitivity analysis was.
Had a mind blank at the sensitivity calc!

Q2 talked about conservative, moderate and aggressive polices and effects they would have on the wc cycle.
got 93 days i think for the working capital cycle
Debt factoring bit confused me... ended up with 2 negative values. Based my answer on what i had calculated and stated the company would be worse off and if unable to source finance from elsewhere then this would be a good option for immediate cash which could be used to service the overdraft debt.

Q3
Net assets was easy enough, 490m i think, or 470.
Div growth model method: mindblank
Earnings method, think i got about 690m

Messed up my wacc and ended up with 10%, was thrown by the pre tax bank rate, i changed it to 4.9% :S

Q4
wrote a lot for the 11 mark section: talked about max shareholder wealth, this being done at any cost previously and now shareholders are more concerned with environmental and social impacts to meet the financial objective, plus agency theory, then spoke about value for money and the three e's




Q4 Terp =
Former userFormer user14y ago#23
@ammar-shabbir
in question 3 market value of bond was not given...it had to be calculte..i calculted it to be 103
Former userFormer user14y ago#24
@sanjarbek said:
How IRR coud be 9 % if at 11% it's coming to $122,000 ?
mine was 14.1 % I donno ;)

My NPV is $103,000 and IRR Is around 15.8%.... i think its the rounding off effect
Former userFormer user14y ago#25
I calculated WACC being 9.13 % ?
Factor with recouse: benefits: $206,000 vs costs $193,000
non-recourse: benefits: $294,000 vs costs: 298,000
Former userFormer user14y ago#26
Hi Guys,
I wonder if any one can recall the different parts of the questions and allocation of marks for each part.

Thanks
Former userFormer user14y ago#27
@jk0323 said:
@ammar-shabbir
in question 3 market value of bond was not given...it had to be calculte..i calculted it to be 103





Market Value of Bond is calculated: Future interest payments at PV + Redemption value at PV
Former userFormer user14y ago#28
Q1 Volume - 100,000 units
Selling Price - $16
Variable Cost - $11 /unit
Fixed Costs - $ 160,000 per annum
Cap Ex - 800,000
Residual Value - 40,000
Working Capital - 90,000 (is needed in year 1 )
TAX at 30 % - In ARREARS

NPV - ?
Former userFormer user14y ago#29
@hadpole said:
Yes.. both are beneficial .. but non recourse is more beneficial :)

I'm glad. Thank god I corrected and reconsidered. :)
Former userFormer user14y ago#30
@sanjarbek said:
I calculated WACC being 9.13 % ?
Factor with recouse: benefits: $206,000 vs costs $193,000
non-recourse: benefits: $294,000 vs costs: 298,000


for non recourse, the cost is more than the benefit? i have got net benefit for both factoring arrangement