Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

FM*** F9 December 2011 Exam was: Post your comments and vote in Instant Poll ***

Oopentuition14y ago
Post your comments about December 2011 F9 exam.
What came up? How did you do? How did this paper compare to previous exams?

Vote in our Instant Poll
*** F9 December 2011 Exam was: Post your comments and vote in Instant Poll *** poll results
Former userFormer user14y ago#61
working capital shouldnt b added in Lst yr... Nothing bs mentioned .. Npv vs 50.7 ... And IRR 13.5% .. q2 factorn both beneficial but non recourse more beneficial
Ccazza9914y ago#62
Ok. Q1gave us 11% after tax rate (think thats right). Were we supposed to use a pre tax rate ( ie 11% x 10/7) = 16% ?? Cos if we use the after tax rate and then include the tax in the cashflow, arent we double counting the effect of tax???
Also, i got both negative values on the factoring. Thought it looked odd and tried to see what i was missing but couldnt see it :(
Hharripool14y ago#63
Working capital is always reclaimed in the final year as it is no longer required, regardless of whether it was mentioned
@hunibaba said:
working capital shouldnt b added in Lst yr... Nothing bs mentioned .. Npv vs 50.7 ... And IRR 13.5% .. q2 factorn both beneficial but non recourse more beneficial
Oollie7814y ago#64
started very easy with question ,calculation parts in other questions such as WACC and TERp were easymarkes but discussion marks were tough particularly 4d, 11 marks for discussion on not for profit vs lsited compnay seemed high considering its importance in the sylabus. Fingers crossed for feb though!
Rryzvonusef14y ago#65
@harripool said:
Working capital is always reclaimed in the final year as it is no longer required, regardless of whether it was mentioned
I didn't remember that bit :(
Kkalpesh14y ago#66
THE COST OF DEBT BEFORE TAX 7% WAS GIVEN THAN WHAT WAS THE NEED TO FIND BY IRR METHOD, CAN ANYBODY EXPLAIN ??

ALSO IT WAS BEFORE TAX SO I DISCOUNTED AT 7(1-03) AT 5 APPROX.

WAS I WRONG ??
Former userFormer user14y ago#67
@kalpesh said:
THE COST OF DEBT BEFORE TAX 7% WAS GIVEN THAN WHAT WAS THE NEED TO FIND BY IRR METHOD, CAN ANYBODY EXPLAIN ??

ALSO IT WAS BEFORE TAX SO I DISCOUNTED AT 7(1-03) AT 5 APPROX.

WAS I WRONG ??


i also acquired cost of debt after tax...we have to use cost of debt after tax while calculating WACC...u r right!!!
Former userFormer user14y ago#68
i screwed up the easiest npv calculation ever!for shame! :S i didnt add back WC and didnt do the tax in arrears..do u guys reckon theres still a mark or two in there for me?
Hharripool14y ago#69
It is because it was redeemable that IRR is used. Not sure why myself, but I think that is the general rule
Hharripool14y ago#70
Yes, you will have calculated pre tax cashflows, used the DF and arrived at PV and then got an NPV. There are usually marks for all that
@munazzeel said:
i screwed up the easiest npv calculation ever!for shame! :S i didnt add back WC and didnt do the tax in arrears..do u guys reckon theres still a mark or two in there for me?
Kkatieliu14y ago#71
I wasn't very sure on every of my calculations.
who can tell me the question in the factors?
Kkatieliu14y ago#72
ah, I use the same way, I don't think it should be just simply using before-tax cost of debt times 70%

I use 8 as interest in t1-t6 and DF 7% to calc the MV, and then use the MV to go into the IRR calcs.

@harripool said:
Yes, you will have calculated pre tax cashflows, used the DF and arrived at PV and then got an NPV. There are usually marks for all that
Former userFormer user14y ago#73
DF @ 7 % PV DF @ 10 %
0 mv -93.29 1 -93.29 1 -93.29
1--6 int 5.6 4.7665 26.6924 4.3553 24.38968
6 RV 100 0.6663 66.63 0.5645 56.45
0.032399999999981 -12.45032


IRR= 7.00778676442313
Rrolusola14y ago#74
Q1 NPV was 104,700....most people forgot to add back the Working Cap investment at the end of the 5th year, so the net effect was technically zero.
Jjoyce4514y ago#75
the f9 paper was good, i am feelin good.

i expect more than just a 50, but guess what any thing over 50 marks is good enough for F9.
Former userFormer user14y ago#76
how could I get 104,700 NPV taking into account that I forgot to include WC of $90,000? but because like you say guys the WC would have to be deducted in year 5, the net effect was really zero. I'm glad I got the NPV right.
Had only 2 days for preparing after F6, but wrote all I could. Found the paper OK, that I could write anything on each question, although went mind blank on question 2. came out happy after the exam unlike after F6. Guys, the main thing is we are FREE now (the ones who are done for this session). Good luck to all!
Rrolusola14y ago#77
@emira said:
how could I get 104,700 NPV taking into account that I forgot to include WC of $90,000? but because like you say guys the WC would have to be deducted in year 5, the net effect was really zero. I'm glad I got the NPV right.
Had only 2 days for preparing after F6, but wrote all I could. Found the paper OK, that I could write anything on each question, although went mind blank on question 2. came out happy after the exam unlike after F6. Guys, the main thing is we are FREE now (the ones who are done for this session). Good luck to all!



Good for you! I guess this is one of those rare times when it forgetting something works in your favour! Well done. 7 marks down 43 to go. I wish you all the best my friend.
Ffaizan14y ago#78
Okay so am i the only one who got the IRR 14.8 or .9 ? i used the the 15 discount for irr plus the NPV was 50k something. screwed up valuation but got one correct. I think i screwed up WACC as i have no idea how you incorporat irr into tht as mentioned by some and i thought the value of debt was give plus i didnt do anything about the bond so i know i'll lose mark in that. Factor valuation i read somewhere we didnt need to take interest amount into consideration but i took the interest saved from overdraft and the interest payble to the factor for advancing the receivable? umm what else theoratical was easy the tricky part was b and c of that question but i did okay though i did part b calculation in part c but i mentioned it in b.

Overall looking at the june paper this was definitely easier but a little technical.
Former userFormer user14y ago#79
Working capital was supposed to be add during first year of operation which is year 1? and Working capital is normally recovered at the end of operation which shud be year 5.

My NPV is 112,980.

Anyway for Q3.. is there a need to do IRR for the bonds? I thot the Kd was already 7% pre tax.. the MV of the bond was not known tho so we actually need to discount back to get the MV but not the IRR which was what I hav done tho..

Bank Loan Kd should be 6% since it is a straight debt?
Former userFormer user14y ago#80
@omyrbutt
based on your calculations 2-4 marks will be deducted
Vvesela.jana14y ago#81
really upset this exam. I have spent hours and hours of studying for this one. It was not 50:50 exam. It looked to me more like 70:30 - too much theroie!! Really gutted.
Xxiaan14y ago#82
i forgot to tick a couple of questions on the main sheet :(
Mminiclaire14y ago#83
what did you write for the investment appraisal question, i wrote npv and using irr for amutually exclusive project any one write similar??? was happy with the limitations on the dividend growth model, also wrote i marc on the sensitivity analysis, i did not add back the working capital, i read question wrong when it said ignore capital allowances i took it as ignore WC,!!! oh well lets hope i pass all i want is 50!!!!!
Ffaizan14y ago#84
could someone explain how you incorporate irr in calculation of debt for cost of capital? was it needed in question 3?

Want to know about question 4 b? just gearing? debt/equity? what calculations did you do?

Reading comments 3 have got npv in 50s while ppl who did add back working capital have still got different npvs. Oh well i will lose a mark in it or so.

got operational cycle 93 as well so i guess i was correct in it :D
Mmustafamillwala14y ago#85
Q2? Factoring
I got net benefits from both recourse and non-recourse ...
Did any1 else got this???
Former userFormer user14y ago#87
hunnibaba

i also got 50700 on npv

i thought as well we are dont have to put working capital in year 5
Former userFormer user14y ago#88
I also got 50700 npv :P
Former userFormer user14y ago#89
ACCA F9 Relevant Cash Flows for DCF Working Capital (example 2)

Check out the lecture presentation about 8 minutes in. Working capital is assumed to be returned to the business and we no longer need the extra inventory, expect no more payables and receivables associated with the project. Question doesnt have to tell you to put WC back in. I did it automatically but had to check to make sure it was correct.
Former userFormer user14y ago#90
thanks Rolusola. wish you all the best as well :)