PM*** F5 December 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
This F5 exam was prepared according to prefect or ideal standard no allowance is given by F5 examiner even multiple choice questions was completely bring different style of question I working on exam kit and past paper I normally answered very will but exam multiple choice was not answerable question may be question was bring from P5 overall very disappointed pepar
Weird questions in part B as compared to Sep session,
Part A was ok, though too much questions requiring hard calculations (e.g. advanced variances)
Part B:
Q1-Adavnce variances (ok)
Q2-Decision making (so-so)
Q3-Budgeting (discussion)
Q4-Divisional performance measurement (ok)
Q5-Make or Buy decision with limiting factors (run out of time, odd question)
In September in part B it was:
Target costing, CVP analysis, Performance measurement, Minimax regret, NFPO, Advanced Variances.
More common and easier questions were in September.
Don't know how do they think it is possible to write in 3h 15m.
Not fair.
This was a very tough exam.
Section A was a bit fine.
Some questions in section B were hard and confusing. I never thought an F5 exam could be this hard.
I am from South-Africa. I earn a small salary. To pay a ridiculous amount to enter for an impossible exam, is heart breaking to say the least.
I read the exam articles to get a feel for what I can expect.
I knew the content well, worked through enough past exams, to feel quite confident.
I hope the exam setters are really pleased with themselves; NOT!!!
I agree with you Shah
that exam was messed up...holy crap. Thst is the hardest ACCA paper I have done, and I have completed F9 already btw.
Also, part A of the exam is very hard. I am saying this because I constantly did well on the Open Tuition Moc Exam MCQ 20 questions tests scoring 90% regularly.
Yet, I would battle getting 50% in section A of yesterday's examination.
From my view, it is not easy to pass F5, if you cannot at least get 10/20 for section A in Paper F5.
@gonko said: Looks like I misread it. The questions overall were written very poorly and deliberately confusing. ACCA ought to review the examiner in my opinion. Its not sour grapes as I think I done enough to pass but there is really no need to deliberately aim to trap students into mistakes with wording. Another poor exam from the f5 team.totally agree. how do you ask questions in parables. english is a second language for 60% of the candidates
Was there actually a limiting factor in question 5? I converted the prices into kilograms and couldnt find one when I added all the kilograms up. Then I panicked and pretended I got one by messing with my calculations and then that lead to a big mess because the contribution per kg was the same for two of two products.
I also put Material A as a limiting factor, but I can't remember the detail.
@lauracam said: I also got 23 to manufacture. The material was limited I got make 600 units and buy 200 as there was only 600kg spare for material a and component x needed 1kg per unit so only 600 could be made. This wasn't like any the practice one I tried was quite confusing.you seem like the only person with the right answer .-.
Hard... difficult.. going to retake again...
Hi,
Anybody know how to decide the X calculation in Q 5
is it its cost which we have to multiply in qty
clarify please any how the exam was a big shock to me ....
(f5)Multiple choice is unpredictable,its 50-50.Section B was just a day robbery i think ACCA want to make us poor how many time should we sit/pay for F5.The harder the paper the more we getting poor with ACCA.Lets be fair
My multiple choice answers were
A
A
C
A
B
D
B
D
D
B
A
D
B
A
C
C
A
C
C
A
Did anyone else get any the same? Section B was not what I expected at all!! There was nothing on learning rate or mr/mc nothing on building blocks or scorecards. Thought yet again question are poorly written.
When will we receive results?
Thanks!
I read the comments after exams how hard ,tricky and unfair it was and one thing comes to my mind, this qualifications are not for everybody !
I passed F5 high after first attempt and I only started ACCA because I knew I was capable of doing it.
R u not a bit too over confidence about urself. (mr beata)
i believe passing acca is a bit of both luck and hard work, not only intelligence.
i know other people with less intelligence than u , pass level 3 papers with flying numbers.
so i believe acca gives everyone equal chance to earn their qualifications, not only super intelligent people.
thanks very much
reshma
by 12 january 2016 by email and online 18.01.2016
Q2. The easiest question, I attempted it first. I got option 1 for best option with net benefit of$900000 and increased capacity to 800 units. Q3. Very subjective. I got mostly incremental and barely particaptive. Q4. I got bonus of manager F capped at $36000 and manager N got no bonus. Roi was 28.5% and 8%ish. I used net assets - current liabilities. Also i added the $6.8m investment to manager N's ROI because he is an investment centre manager. Q5. Was okish. I got $24.80 for manufacture of component X :( However I got make 600 buy 200. I would like to hear from you guys :)
I got 23$ too for material A in question 5, with 8$ per labour hour. I studied from a BPP text book, and from here, and I think it was not that bad. I expected much worse. :)
But what about variable overhead for component x?
The examiner was not fair on the limiting factor question and the one for net benefits.....we hope acca addresses that
Disaster thats one word for us...if acca tryin to.make a fortune from.us by failing us...these are hard times.paying exams fees..studying so hard to get a question which u cannot tell what its realy askin for is an insult
Does anyone remember Q2 with a table? I would like to complete it but can't remember the case...
I thought I did okay on the exam, until I read the comments in this thread that is! Just a quick question on the bottleneck and the throughput figures at the top. I used those figures to arrive at the cost of the materials for the extra units to be produced. However, based on the comments where people ignored those figures, I am now worried that I shouldn't have. Can anyone put me out of my misery?
For question 4. Who else excluded the trade payables when calculating the ROI and used net profit?
I would like to look at this task (Q2) particularly after reading technical artical part 2, as it a fresh look:))
it was my third time writting f5 paper. this paper was the worst ever.
Because of this type exams a lot of students here in Malawi are no longer doing ACCA they have switched to Degree programs and no wonder we are writing 3 to 5 papers in a day without the centre (hall) being full to its capacity as it used to be in the past.ACCA please do something.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

