PM*** F5 December 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
Studied F5 Kaplan book, with tutor/teacher. Attempted Exam Kit, Studied a lot. Did not expect the paper to be this hard..., Kinda disappointed.
Are they teaching us Nuclear Sciences?
I agree with Material A being the limiting factor.
I can't remember the detail to the rest of it, though.
I calculated the making of material x at $31.00 . And therefore buy all of x as it could be bought at 28.00?
Material x took 1 kg of A at 1.60.
2kgs of B at 1.50.
2 hours labour at 12.00 per hour.
3 hours machine time at 80c per hour.
Total 31.00
Question 5 was the only question which was from Planning with limiting factors. The rest were: Budgeting, Advance Variance analysis, Performance Measurement and Control, Divisional Performance Measurement and Transfer Pricing, Performane Management Information Systems. In laymen's term, a Guaranteed Fail Paper - Did they really expect the tutor/teacher to cover these in 4 months? As for Question 5 my answer was to Purchase externally as cost of making was high (can't remember too much stressed).
that exam was beyond bizarre. very hard compared to june 2015, dec 2015. i ran out of time. looks like a do over.
Hi Sophie, $21 seems familiar so either we're both right or both made the same mistake!
I don't remember the detail but I vaguely think I got labour to be $8 rather than $12. However, since it is $ and not £ I must have calculated labor rather than labour.
All the best,
Ross
Yep really disappointed. I got 23 for cost to manufacture component x Calculated labour as 8 per hour. L took 3 hours at a labour cost of 24 if I remember correctly.
Looks like I misread it. The questions overall were written very poorly and deliberately confusing. ACCA ought to review the examiner in my opinion. Its not sour grapes as I think I done enough to pass but there is really no need to deliberately aim to trap students into mistakes with wording. Another poor exam from the f5 team.
I also got 23 to manufacture. The material was limited I got make 600 units and buy 200 as there was only 600kg spare for material a and component x needed 1kg per unit so only 600 could be made. This wasn't like any the practice one I tried was quite confusing.
Yeah I felt like I just rambled in the budgeting question. I thought q1 and 4 were ok. 2 was a disaster I still don't actually know what the question was looking for.
My full production cost for component X was also $23 and the limiting factor was Material A. 600kg left and therefore 600 X could be produced instead of the 800 requirement (400 for LX, 400 for MX) so 200 should be bought or consider to buy more material A as it means quite a lot of saving comparing to the buying price of X, mentioned shadow price in this connection.
Q4 was the roi Calculations and bonus and 2 was the investment options I think.
is it me or question two was really really confusing??
the one that was asking for net benefit of the options?
Well said...i dont know exactly what they are trying to do by putting so hard questions rather than make you fail...we are not going to be nuclear scientists but accountants...seriously
I believe also that ACCA really needs to have a look at the questions. You suppose to study and pass and exam not write poorly questions in order to trap! students..where is the ethics there? I am very disappointed
Why were the questions that ambiguous. I think questions should not be open to different interpretations ; that really trapped me. What did the question on throughout require from us exactly? The one with 3 options to choose from, and was anything like this in our syllabus? How are we expected to know such solutions.
That question is far beyond throughout in my opinion.
I agree the question on limiting factor is tricky but it is answerable, even though it requires too much time for just 7 marks.
Acca needs fair examiners, there is no point trying to make exams unanswerable, just treat the students fairly for pètes sake.
Q2 was testing throughput accounting with constraint. I did all exam kit and revision .. but first time i see this question. And i just read the technical articles something like q2. Do you all get a favourable yield for q1a? Q3 was just purely theory on budgeting and q4 i have division f manager entitle of bonus and division n did not hit the target roi. And division n is using more asset division.
After converting the standard usage from grams to Kgs.. Why is there significant difference between the standard (which is converted to Kg) and the actual (which is in kg already).
I think the standard usage should not have been in gramms but in kgs (from the question)
How did you calculate the roi?
I used the controllable profit and total assets less current liabilities and get both as getting a bonus.
I also just seen the technical article on q2 had never seen this before now so I don't think it's very fair.
Yes I for a favourable yield
MCQ - seemed fair, came back to a few as I got brain freeze and found them easier when I came back. Hope the rest were ok.
Question 1 - Practised long and hard for this question :D
Question 2 - I can't even remember this question
Question 3 - seemed very subjective. There were many things to comment upon, but the lead partners statement was where they were asking you to comment... I fear I ended up rambling. It seemed odd to me also, that part b was for 3 marks, considering it was asking for three points. I either aced this or disgraced it :-/
Question 4 - Seemed odd to be calculating bonuses, but it felt like common sense. I almost forgot one of the first things I ever learnt; capital = assets - liabilities. spent 2 minutes trying to figure out one of the principle accounting equations lol.
Ugh, question 5! - What a nightmare! I actually came back to part b of this question at the end of the exam as interrupting it was giving me a headache the first time that I attempted it. This was supposed to be one of my 'favourite questions', but the comment about limiting factors got me confused, as it looked like a 'linear programming' question to me.
Hopefully aced part a and c though. mentioned the learning curve, sourcing from different suppliers etc
All in all - I felt that Q3 was vague and Q5 b was horrible, I've studied so hard for this only to find that Q3 and Q4 could have been attempted by most people with a common sense. I feel confident I will be happy on results day, but I wouldn't make a bet on it.
I use net profit /ta-cl
I get the favourable yield also?but most of friends get it adverse.and Q1b asking the reason for adverse yield?this make me worried that the answer could be adverse yield
It was really disaster! A lot of questions were confusing. I didn't get how to calculate Question about limiting factor and about bottleneck. Agree with those comments that it feels that ACCA wants us to fail. I am curious, can students complain about the exams?
Got a bonus of 32.5 or 34.5% for division f - Capped at 30%
Division N as 11.7% minus the 10 and the point 7 (had to be a whole number). Total bonus of 2%
:-/
Q1 Mix variance - 3ish(A) Yield variance around 20ish(F). Answers weren't exact which was annoying. Then stupid discussion - weighing scales not working etc
Q2 I think about Goldratt's approach to bottlenecks. Divert resources to one resource until it stops being the bottleneck then divert to the next bottleneck etc.
I think the stuff about the top about throughput contribution was unnecessary just there to confuse. Just compare the £12500 long term benefit per extra unit/month to the costs of investments to find the investment with greatest NPV. I got Option 1 invest in just P as the best with +$900000NPV.
Q3 Stupid discussion question. Clearly incremental but not participative budget which you have to turn into 7 marks lol. Then 3 marks for saying the JT and CD will go and get unmotivated and cry in their office...
Q4 I did profit before central allocation (uncontrollable) divided by fixed assets. Division F I got 27.1% ROI division N 13.2% ROI. Convert to bonuses division F (27-10)*2%*120000 = 34% * 120000 but this is restricted to 30% so £36000. Division N (13-10)*2%*120000 = £7200
Part B waffle again. ROI favours old assets, ROI can cause dysfunctional decisions, ROI takes no account of the poor WC management.
Q5 I got 23 for internal cost, Make 600 X and buy 200 X (although my method wasn't exactly textbook. Then I think more discussion after quality concerns, training costs, possible extra fixed costs for supervisors, storage of X etc
@lesbella said: I use net profit /ta-clI think either will be acceptable as long as you explained why you used it as it asked. I used controllable as I didn't think they had control over the apportioned overheads.
It was really unfair as compared to past year question.
hey did anyone get mat. mix as $16.54 and yield as $82??
this was the only question that i was confident about!!! Also, the
RoI question did we have to reduce 6.8 mill(value of the investment) from the capital employed??
Q2 was about transfer pricing?
what was question 2.. did it require payoff tables.. or was it simple throughput investment option..
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

