SBL*** ACCA P3 December 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
I was pretty much confused about the exam. I answered 1.a, 1.b.ii, 3.a & 4.a. quiet good. These 4 consists of 53 marks and answered other 22 marks.
Wheather i am gonna pass or again cought out !!!
@ddmoo said: I may be wrong but I wouldn't say "What's this?" would be a heartland business. I went with Value Trap as MKI could provide them with large benefits but wouldn't really understand the mobile apps industry.I think what's this is a heartland business iit was benefiting from MKI's help and profitability was increasing. If it was value trap MKI would be destroying value.
@joashbill said: so were we asked to calculate the payback period?We were told to use appropriate appraisal techniques. With the information we had payback and NPV were the obvious ones but if you came up with something else I'm sure you'd get marks for it.
Anyone worked out the npv as the first two lines of benefits were observable and measurable so ended with negative npv so did not approve project. Did anyone get same
I approved the project as it had an NPV oof positive at end of year four
Can someone kindly remind of how the marks were allocated in question 1? cant remember I think question 1 was an 18 mark one and whats the rest to make 50? kindly advise
Hi Matchamulonde,
Q1 allocation marks:
1.18 marks
2i. 9 marks-about benefits;
2ii. 6 marks - PID;
2iii. 5 marks - cost/benefits analysis;
2iv. 8 marks - management accountant;
Plus 4 proffesional marks.
Thanks mayadoncheva so does the 4 professional marks relate 2i which had a report? thanks alot for updating me
@tlobo said: Anyone worked out the npv as the first two lines of benefits were observable and measurable so ended with negative npv so did not approve project. Did anyone get sameI think you were just supposed to do the appraisal based on the table, ignoring the validity of the figures. You then tore the figures to shreds in the next part of the question.
When the model answer will be uploaded?
@aimeer85 said: I think you were just supposed to do the appraisal based on the table, ignoring the validity of the figures. You then tore the figures to shreds in the next part of the question.I did this as well but it didn't make sense to me. They ask you to evaluate the project with benefits included in it that you knew shouldn't be included and then you had to explain after why certain benefits shouldn't be included. If I was really writing a memo or report on the project I'd explain why certain benefits shouldn't be included first before then removing them. But the paper didn't ask you to do that.
So ACCA have uploaded a hybrid September/December 2016 paper under past papers. Q1 from the September 2016 exam was a joke compared to the December one.
38 marks for Pestel, Porters 5 forces and SA (suitability and Acceptability) of SAF in Q1. And then in Q2 you've got 18 marks for Balogun and Hope Hailey! That's 56 EASY marks!
So if you fail the December 2016 sitting do not be discouraged, seems like they decided to give us an overly difficult paper as an early Xmas present. Thanks ACCA.
@david0011 said: I think what's this is a heartland business iit was benefiting from MKI's help and profitability was increasing. If it was value trap MKI would be destroying value.Profitability may have been increasing but the industry revenue was increasing in general so I would guess that was the cause of it. The way I thought of it was that a company producing and selling physical hard copy instructional books would not understand the mobile apps industry. Although they could help the company (large benefits) they wouldn't understand the industry (low feel). Value trap doesn't necessarily mean they destroy value, it can mean they just don't help them as much as they might have first thought. The example for value trap given in the technical article was a large pharmaceuticals company trying to help a small video games company with marketing. Although they'd have a lot of knowledge of marketing (large benefits) they wouldn't know how to market video games (low feel).
Well it does not make sense to approve the project and say the NPV was positive when in reality the two lines of benefits should have been eliminated
NPV was positive 494 or 474 cant remember , I am sure you can forgive me for forgetting! When the discount factors were applied to both benefits and costs, the benefits were more, hence viable and doable project!
Hi Ally, E-procurement is all the jazz about buying using IT , otherwise clever ways of purchasing and stuff . Linking to suppliers via IT, websites etc. Searching online as well to look for markets , prices , products quality and to bring them in at most convenient time and price in the most efficient way (E-Procurement!) . In other ways, pimped-up backward vertical integration at best!!! Going to market/suppliers using IT
@ddmoo said: 38 marks for Pestel, Porters 5 forces and SA (suitability and Acceptability) of SAF in Q1. And then in Q2 you've got 18 marks for Balogun and Hope Hailey! That's 56 EASY marks! .How did you use porter and pestel?
@feti7a said: How did you use porter and pestel?I was talking about the September 2016 exam which is now on the ACCA website.
Hallo,
I am writing about Q2 ii. I wrote only explanations about 3Vs. Do you think the examiner would give marks about it?
Thanks!
in q1 part b do we need to calculate npv or simple critically evaluate the technique used in calculating npv in table provided
in q4 part a do we need to discusse the question by only taking in mind the problem in culture or simple commenting the culture of org
Question one was very long and tried to manage time noticed it was almost 2hrs and i was still on question one.I left the remain question then rushed to section B .Time was moving too fast I only attempted the 15marks question just to maximize on remaining time .
Hello all
Paper wasn't that bad I think !!
This was my 4 attempt failed at 42 and 43 twice ?.
God please , show me the miracle ??.. !
I think 85% paper was easy , the main thing was unexpected question of npv and irr which make it hard, and i waste more time for this area due to which 10% paper left bcz of time shortage.
do we need to calculate npv in q1 part b or it is just simply evaluate the npv given in the table
n in q4 do we need to discuss the problems or the whole culture of org
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

