SBL*** ACCA P3 December 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
What is the role of a finance team member in change management?
Very fair paper... I just messed up on a few areas under time pressure! That finance member question threw me... I just said about when looking at risk management and outsourcing they can calculate whether it would be beneficial to outsource or not.. and also in project management they can do ARR & IRR, that question really stumped me!
It was very hard paper. Q1 was totally different from previous papers and only 18 marks for analysis. Q1b was very difficult bcz of calculations and was lengthy and not fair to make a question worth 32 marks. Q3 was ok but nothing much to write abt through scenario. Q4 was ok. But overall very difficult to attemp in exam time.
Yes agree.. Q1 very very different... think I used BCG matrix.. no Pestel or 5 Forces :(
Q1:
a. Portfolio Analysis - Boston Consulting Group Matrix - 18 marks
b. Memo on Project management / Financial Appraisal - 32 marks
Q2:
a. Regression analysis - 15 marks
b. Big Data - 10 marks
Q3:
a. Marketing Mix using emarketing - 15 marks
b. e-procurement - 10 marks
Q4:
a. Cultural web - 15 marks
b. Continuing Development / The learning organisation - 5 marks each
I like the new format. Now they don't mash 3 topics into one question.
It was really straightforward. You just had to study.
For me it was a difficult paper.
Have u done all questions???
gulshahbaz, if you ask me, then the answer is "nope".
I had 1, 3 and 4.
What was the NPV in Question 1 and i didn't use any model for portfolio analysis, is it fine enough? :/
Sobieski I mean have u done 100%?? I did 85%. But dishope from first question bcz no pestel no five forces no swot no strategic choices no SFA
I think in Q1a bcg and ashbridge both can be used but I used bcg matrix
gulshahbaz, not everything. I was out of project management. I guess I got maybe 10 out of 32points for part b from Q1.
@feti7a said: What is the role of a finance team member in change management?I wrote about how a change management would probably change the project scope and constraints, i. e. Cost requirements etc and so a financial team member had to be consulted before implementing changes regarding finance allocation for the project. Not sure if correct tho.
Sobieski that is my point q1b was not fair for 32 marks bcz information in scenerio was not worth so much marks I tried my best to make points but cannot and numbers were also difficult to evaluate
very fair paper.So long you studied the whole syllabus.I had a feeling that they would bring project managent.PDI document missed a lot of crucial things.Project drivers were there but not risk assessment,project gateways,dissemination plan,assigning teams-benefit owners and change owners.
observable,measurable,quantifiable and finacial benefits need to be distinguised
part (a) was straight foward.the sizes of revenue determined their contribution.BCG matrix can identify that PP had relatively low market share in its market.The industry was on decline but it would appear that PP revenues declined by 50% more than the industry.Probaly due to overreliance on internal sales (80%).May it is the structure of transfer pricing system.But the fact that the society is gradually becoming paperless and MLK has ventured on an E Business project, PP might be less relevant in the future.
Q1 a.
1st subsidiary - Dog, however of strategic importance as it supplies intragroup.
2nd subsidiary - Star - grow, finance, wait until market matures and the "milk the cow"!
3rd - Cash Cow - hold, harvest. Inflows to be used to finance star
It was a hard paper and I totally agree with you Gulshab. I hated the NPV question. It was just an evil paper I haven't done NPV in years. Although I did like the layout of the paper with the clear lines in question 1.
I used bcg, ashridge and parenting type for q1
@gulshahbaz said: Have u done all questions???in fairness, I did not get to practice as many as I would have liked - work committments!! If I have to repeat they will just have to give me time off again!! So no, I didn't practice as much as I should have. But...... having said that, I thought it was more difficult than previous P3 papers I have read. At times, I got lost in the questions. I attempted Q1 (obviously) and Q2 and Q3.
The September paper was easier then this. Its so difficukt with commitments I just feel like giving up.
I agree it was do hard, i chose q2 and 4
-relative performance to date
-contribution to the portifolio
-significance in future strategy
all per company would give you 6 marks per company.There was more than enough information in my opinion
yep, definitely failed! Q1 is really where I got lost.
What if i didn't use any model in question 1 but did all the analysis throughout with performance calculation and analyse the calculated data and give reasons like global warming and like that. Will it work? Because particularly it wasn't metion to use a model right?
It was an okay paper in my opinion.
Q1 - a was fairly easy, I did BCG, parental developers and basic financial analysis. Ended up spending about an hour on it though.
Q1 - b threw me like most people on here have already said and the final part of it I didn't answer. I didn't know what to write so I left it to come back to but didn't have the time. Didn't do it in report format as I only realised halfway through writing the answer that it asked for that.
Q2 - I started but couldn't figure out how they got their figures so gave up.
Q3 - Was okay. For me the line between e-business and e-marketing became very blurry but I think I did quite well. Ran out of time on the second part but got 2 benefits and 2 risks of e-procurement written down and explained.
Q4 - Part a was very easy, expecting near full marks from that (although I forgot to do organisational structure). Part b I had no idea, wrote a few sentences but not sure if I got any marks. Part c I wrote a few paragraphs on as it came up in a past papers but I couldn't remember it.
Expecting somewhere between 40 and 60 marks.
Yes that was very good question same as dec-14 question.
@matdemon said: What if i didn't use any model in question 1 but did all the analysis throughout with performance calculation and analyse the calculated data and give reasons like global warming and like that. Will it work? Because particularly it wasn't metion to use a model right?In past papers they don't always specifically tell you which models to use but you are still expected to use one or two. For 19 marks I'd expect to be using at least 2 models. Global warming? Were we sitting the same exam?
Q2 trend was first 4 numbers and divide by 4 for average, then the next 4 numbers and divide by 4 for average. Add the 2 totals and divide by 2.
I just added a part of global warming that why a paperless environment is encourged and i provided detailed discussion about the portfolio with explanation. So it won't be enough because my answer was a bit practical than bookish.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

