Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

SBL*** ACCA P3 December 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***

Oopentuition_teamAdmin9y ago

Please vote in our Instant Polls about the ACCA P3 December 2016 Exam.

*** ACCA P3 December 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results *** ACCA P3 December 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results

Post your comments about the ACCA P3 exam below

KKarl9y ago#61
@ddmoo said: There was a past paper question on PID, I believe it was something to do with a project for a mayor implementing a new traffic system. I don't believe the OpenTuition lectures mention it much though. I believe the finance team member question was more from P1. Sometimes the P3 exam does include some topics from P1, i've seen past exam questions on CG and ethics. I felt the same about Q2a. There were a few past papers and an article on ACCA website that had questions like this, one of them looked almost identical. However with 30 minutes left and a choice between Q3 and Q2 I didn't want to spend time trying to understand and do the calculations. Yeah, I don't recall coming across e-procurement either. I think it's just assumed knowledge or expects you to just develop your understanding of e-business. In regards to Q4 I have to agree. Saw a past exam paper with a similar scenario but the question was more just "evaluate the culture using the cultural web" rather than having to relate it to another aspect.
Ddmoo the e procurement was in the it chapter. Its called upstream supply chain management. I had it on my to do list but only glossed over it. Seems they are spreading lots more questions out over the "last" chapters these days as in the old style of the exam, the 50 marker always used to cime from the first 7 chapters
KKarl9y ago#62
@lauren7 said: Really struggled with this paper, mainly question 1. for the omissions part I used the kaleidoscope headings like timings, capacity, capability, scope...do you think I would get anything for that? seem to be way off from what people on here have said?
No they usually say contextual features and list out the headings for you if they are after the Balogun Hope Hailey Model. Model for part A was the BCG Matrix Omissions was based on project initiation document. I drew a blank and really stuffed this one up.
KKarl9y ago#63
Found the e marketing very challenging. Couldn't work out whether to use 6 i's as they also listed 5 ps of pricing. Nightmare question. It was that or Regression Analysis
Former userFormer user9y ago#64
@kbourne said: Ddmoo the e procurement was in the it chapter. Its called upstream supply chain management. I had it on my to do list but only glossed over it. Seems they are spreading lots more questions out over the "last" chapters these days as in the old style of the exam, the 50 marker always used to cime from the first 7 chapters
Yeah I think your right I've looked at the technical articles and it was one of only 2 I hadn't looked at by mistake (Project management explains PID and the learning development was the other technical article I hadn't printed and read -bloody typical!) Yeah the Linear regression was very similar to the technical article but I didn't feel the technical article explained the time series part very well so thought also I'm best not trying to explain something I didn't quite get myself 100% (interpretation of the numbers rather than calculations that is) Yeah also agree P3 seems to add questions from other papers...ratio analysis, P1 Governance & Ethics etc Yep I thought the same if you understand e-commerce and also understand procurement you should be able to have a stab at answering the exam question but few minor points like this I thought was not exactly fair i.e. I didn't see any syllabus objectives saying must be able to explain e-procurement in detail but I will go back and check :)
TTin9y ago#65
Trust me I read the question time and time again and have seen quesitions like those.It was not a must to apply BCG matrix.However in conclusion BCG matrix would have made your life easier in identifying the relative contribution of each company to the portifolio and whether they will be significant in the company`s future strategy. The company`s future growth strategy was that venture on a project that would introduce E-commerce.As the society was gradually becoming paperless and paper industry growth contracting, it ca be doubted that PP would be significant in the future strategy.After all they controlled only 4% of the market share yet market growth slowing down.It was a dog which would be prone to divestment in future. However diagram was the cashcow by no doubt.Controlling about 36% market share in the market thathas stagnated.It`s revenues grew more than the industry.It has managed to secure a unique niche which might be depending on their bespoke engineering and technical books.The future e bussiness model should be modelled to accommodate Diagrama as it is clear it isvery important as a financier in this portifolio. Whats this has been enjoying a persistent increase in revenues and the industry is surging.The industry grew by 86% overall while Whats this recorded a 288% growth in sales since 2011 in general.This should remind us the extent to which the paperless society has rose to prominence in that country.Controlling about 27% in the growing market it is a star.It is the perfect foundation which is consistent with the ongoing project to introduce an E BUSINESS model.Therefore it is very relevant to the future strategy. The question wanted you to assess: performance to date,contribution to the portifolio, and significance of each business to the future strategy.You shouldnthave been restricted to any model but it would have made your life easier.
TTin9y ago#66
i think the NPV was $492,000.we did that at F9 anyway.We needed net cash flows of which year 1 realised a loss of $220,000 beyond which postive cashflows were made.Discount year 0 by 1 (250k) and the others by thegiven discount factors.deduct the intial investment from the net discounted cashflows overall will give a positive NPV.the payback period was 4 years. even though a negative cash inflow would be made in year 1, superior posotive cash inflow in year 3 (300k) will payback the initial investment leaving a balance of 280k.Both the selected investment apparaisal techniques suggested that the project was financially feasible besides their inherent limitations. 5 marks only and must nit worry anybody
TTin9y ago#67
that was the only information which was available.anything else becomes hypothetical.ys the relative performance was based on their revenues against the whole market
LLiza9y ago#68
The content for answering question 1 and case study itself is hard to bring as the time for answering is limited. For question 1a, I put in the answer about BCG, parenting matrix and some porter five forces as the reason why the subsi are acquired. For 1b, is about the project management, content for PID, CBA and finance role. Combination for part 1a and 1b make it heavier and actually need a lot of time to answer it. The application itself really technical. It is different from past year which is heavy syllabus combine with easy syllabus which is more to general application. I move on to next question as the time is out. For optional question, because question 2 really technical, I choose question 3 and 4. Question 3 and 4 is straightforward and I answering it the best that I can with the time limit.
Jjoashbill9y ago#69
Oh my were we asked to calculate the payback period too? I got same npv as you tinaboy but i did not notice payback was asked ... easy marks gone since i am also doing p4
VVipin9y ago#70
It was fair paper. It was tough for me. Q1. A 18 marks. Bcg, ashridge matrix Rest of them was tough. Totally unexpected questions. Pid , NPV calculations..... Q2. linear regression and seasonal variations. I got scared seeing thr figures. Just intrepreted the figures given. Big data. But i didnt write big. Q3. Service marketing mix Principles of eprocurement. Got scared again. So i left it. Q4. Cultural web. Just intrepreted the situation Partb. Competency framework. I forgot it. Learning organization. I forgot it again. 10 marks gone. Attempted 72 marks. But not sure of passing.
RRosina9y ago#71
@fran29 said: i hope you have better luck in this sitting. This was my first attempt at P3 and I feel so annoyed. I studied hard but found that I was always questioning my answers throughout the exam. When you sat it in September did you think you had passed or failed it... I'll be worrying/hoping between now and 16th January.. its such a pity they make the exam so difficult..
I was not really prepared for the September exams due to family commitments but had I done exam practice then I should have been ok as I missed out an entire question so in answer to your question I knew I had failed. This paper was more difficult due to the project management NPV element despite being for less marks, it through me off and wasted my time and therefore I could not spend as much time on the other parts as I would have liked so I ended up rushing and missed easy marks. There is a page in the Kaplan text book about the role of the account changing and developing to a strategic partner which I had gone through however time wasted meant these marks were lost as I couldn't develop the answer and panicked about time. The struggle is to pick yourself up and start again. Is the exam results out on the 16th of Jan? That is a very quick turnaround.
KKarl9y ago#72
@rosina23 said: I was not really prepared for the September exams due to family commitments but had I done exam practice then I should have been ok as I missed out an entire question so in answer to your question I knew I had failed. This paper was more difficult due to the project management NPV element despite being for less marks, it through me off and wasted my time and therefore I could not spend as much time on the other parts as I would have liked so I ended up rushing and missed easy marks. There is a page in the Kaplan text book about the role of the account changing and developing to a strategic partner which I had gone through however time wasted meant these marks were lost as I couldn't develop the answer and panicked about time. The struggle is to pick yourself up and start again. Is the exam results out on the 16th of Jan? That is a very quick turnaround.
Yep 16th. Best of luck
AAmirul9y ago#73
I hate this question. The scope is too narrow. There is 4 porter's model, not even 1 come out. Question 1 is not hard but i maybe missing mark on last subquestion where they ask for contribution of finance team. BCG, NPV and benefit analysis i do perfectly. Option question I can't do any of them perfectly. I did not study about time series analysis so I can't answer it. Definitely regret not study it. Question 3 is not too difficult, but its quite hard to apply the case. and what is principle of e-procurement? I didnt study that, and what i write is speed, linkage, easy, etc. Question 4, erm i hate culture question but I have no choice and it's kind of hard to explain why the dicrimental of staff motivation from culture perspective. 4(b) i don't even know it exist in the syllabus. Just blabbering hoping to get 1-2 points.
HHaddon9y ago#74
Question 1, PP co, was the Dog on BCG Matrix, I just wanted to point out that , whilst it was ok to say divest as future strategy, the Dog could contribute to economies of scale, and improving the synergistic element of an acquired company, seeing it was simlar industry to an existing entity in the MKI group. Another accusation of BCG is that it does not highlight profitability. Dogs can have low market shares but could be well profitable and contributing to shareholder wealth, hence acceptable by shareholders You cannot throw away a Dog without as much as a thought :)
Dds3ce9y ago#75
This was my 4th attempt in the last 12 months. Hopefully 4th time lucky. I don't read the comments about the details of other students' answers as I don't need any more worries or frustration. It is all down to the marker and each individual response now. As they say, in P3 there is no right or wrong answer in terms of what you write as long as you can back it up. I also found this paper a bit more difficult compared to September in terms of the topics. I would have passed in September if I hadn't messed up because of time management issues. However, this time around I focused on my time management more and I ended up answering more, writing more, therefore I will have a higher chance of passing even thought it was still challenging, but overall an okayish paper.
MMark9y ago#76
Ha, snap, I'm exactly on the same boat, if I got 10pts out of the 32pts in the second part of the first question I'll be happy with that, I just hope I did enough in the rest of the questions to make up for it as this whole project question was a shamble
MMark9y ago#77
Totally agree those 32 marks were nasty
33mr9y ago#78
I said that Diagrama and what is this are starts as they have both "high maket share" and "high growth over years" and said that PP is a question mark as it has low on both. But suggested to keep in the portfolio because it serves both MKI and Diagrama In analysing the three benefits of the appraisal, specifically in the increased sales, i stated the porters strategy clock to assess whether the increase will have the value NEEDED by customer and whether the right price is charged or not. I stated that MKI is a 'synergy manager' as a portfolio strategic manager. In Q2 i suggested that the time series analysis is good as a forecasting technique, but care should be taken to use the regression analysis, the time is not correlated and forecasting cannot be made using data of 2016 only. And the number of stores is not correlated either with increased sales.
AAimee9y ago#79
@ddmoo said: What did people write for the what was missing from the PID question? I wrote: Risks not identified and analysed (use TARA) No project sponsor listed No measures given for how the objectives would be measured Not sure if they were right.
I wrote no sponsor/project manager No deadline Constraints I'm sure I put a few more in...
BB9y ago#80
@feti7a said: I said that Diagrama and what is this are starts as they have both "high maket share" and "high growth over years" and said that PP is a question mark as it has low on both.
Low low is dog. Question mark is low market share and high market growth. Also I believe Diagrama had low market growth.
NNidhi9y ago#81
General question : which is easier p1 or p3? As in which one can we study quickly ? Is p3 a little more conceptual than p1?
AAimee9y ago#82
@ddmoo said: Low low is dog. Question mark is low market share and high market growth. Also I believe Diagrama had low market growth.
Pp dog - analyse profitability and consider divesting if appropriate Diagrama cash cow - milk What's this Star - invest
Jjoashbill9y ago#83
hello can someone tell me whether we had to calculate the payback of the project also? please the part with npv
CCat9y ago#84
I ran out of time and missed the 32 mark part of question 1. Not much hope of passing but at least I know for next time it's all about time management with this one!
Ddavid9y ago#85
For question one i said PP CO was a cash cow because the company had a large market share and the market did not grow. For the other two companies i mentioned Ashridge and how they are heartland businesses.
BB9y ago#86
@david0011 said: For question one i said PP CO was a cash cow because the company had a large market share and the market did not grow. For the other two companies i mentioned Ashridge and how they are heartland businesses.
I may be wrong but I wouldn't say "What's this?" would be a heartland business. I went with Value Trap as MKI could provide them with large benefits but wouldn't really understand the mobile apps industry.
IIbitola9y ago#87
I wrote P3 in June, was horrible, I was surprised I even got 41. I think the paper was fair. I didn't have enough time to read due to work pressures but lucky that the topics I read and practiced a lot of questions on came out like the Cultural web which was 15marks, Linear regression and trend analysis also 15 marks. Question 1a was quite okay though I spent a lot of time on it and it was 18 marks. Question 1b the NPV I messed that up that's some 9 marks lost, but for the Project initiation document, I wrote no project title, no start and end date, objectives should be short and concise, no project sponsor, manager, no business case, no evaluation of if a an off the shelf or bespoke should be used, no proper analysis of constraints etc, figured I had to get the full marks here. The last part of Question 1, was a bit hazy from the 8 marks maybe I will scale through with 4 marks just wrote down a few points. Hoping to pass and not fail the second time. Jan 16th is even to far for me, wish I could get the result this month
Mmayadoncheva9y ago#88
Hi! What did you write about NPV and payback question? I only calculate the NPV - nevermind that I put 250 of P0 as a pisitive cash flow due to hurrying up and not looking. I calculated in the payback but not put any comments about discount factor and pros and cons of the methods.
Jjoashbill9y ago#89
so were we asked to calculate the payback period?
Aacca33369y ago#90
Not sure what to expect 16th of January. I hope it's a pass. Very lengthy paper and difficult. Could be approached with many different models. As for the investment appraisal question, I analyzed it both NPV & payback period. There was a similar investment appraisal past paper question......otherwise I would mess up ? Lol I chose to do q2 because of the standardized marks of the exercise Q4 would require lots of blah blah and because of the time pressure it means that I would write rubbish.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.