SBL*** ACCA P3 December 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
What did people write for the what was missing from the PID question? I wrote:
Risks not identified and analysed (use TARA)
No project sponsor listed
No measures given for how the objectives would be measured
Not sure if they were right.
No constraints, risk assessment, objectives not smart and can not be used in benefit realisation review.
@matdemon said: What if i didn't use any model in question 1 but did all the analysis throughout with performance calculation and analyse the calculated data and give reasons like global warming and like that. Will it work? Because particularly it wasn't metion to use a model right?The global warming/environmental analysis part sounds good, I didn't get too much into the future plans analysis as I looked up at the clock and noticed it had already been over an hour and I was still on Q1 part a. I just wrote something basic about how the industry was moving towards paperless technology but the company has large revenues (and so could be a large part of the group) and no info was given about profits so that would have to be analysed. In rare cases dogs can be successful.
I don't think I will pass..I didn't have enough time to complete the paper
@ashvir21 said: I don't think I will pass..I didn't have enough time to complete the paperI didnt finish either NPV wasted my time. Hopefully the questions in march are nicer.
Seems to be a common occurence that they maje the december exam toughm they threw a real curveball in last dec q1 too. Morale of the story is: revise the whole syllabue and dont get comfortable practising pestel and balogun hope hailey.
Seems to be a common occurence that they make the december exam tougher. they threw a real curveball in last dec q1 too. Morale of the story is: revise the whole syllabus and dont get comfortable practising pestel and balogun hope hailey.
@rosina23 said: The September paper was easier then this. Its so difficukt with commitments I just feel like giving up.
@lalawhite said: yep, definitely failed! Q1 is really where I got lost.Did you get stuck on project management? That was really different and not like any past questions?
@gtavicecity said: Please answer this. I used BCG matrix correctly but named it BGC matrix intstead of bcg. Wil i be penalised?As long as the classification is right as well as justification i think you should be ok.
@gtavicecity said: Please answer this. I used BCG matrix correctly but named it BGC matrix intstead of bcg. Wil i be penalised?It would have to be a very very harsh marker for you to lose marks for that.
@gtavicecity said: Yeah the classification was right. Thank youI think you will get the 3 marks then.
Hallo all :) I would like to ask you some things. First, maybe I misunderstood, but I wrote that one of tne omissions is the missing of initial investment. I saw only costs in P0 which are supplamebtary to initial cost but didn'n see the cost of the process. Am I right?
The next question is what did you write about 3Vs of big data. I gave only definitions of the 3Vs.
Thanks in advance :)
@ddmoo said: What did people write for the what was missing from the PID question? I wrote: Risks not identified and analysed (use TARA) No project sponsor listed No measures given for how the objectives would be measured Not sure if they were right.For PID I said a good PID contains time, cost, business case, project sponsor and project manager. then said the document didn't make clear who the project sponsor is and what's the implication of it. No mention of project manger and the implication and business case was not properly conducted as risk and impact on the business were missing. for 6 marks I though that was sufficient.
I would personally disagree with this. Studying this paper I have felt was easy to absorb the information/subject matter. Probably the easiest subject I had sat actually. However, I made a disaster of this exam.
The first question was fair for the most part apart from a couple of questions at the end. The Project initiation document or whatever it was and you had to state what was omitted and reasons why info should be included. I studied for this exam pretty hard but did not come across this at all. Then the question about what a finance team member should contribute to change, project & risk management (& one other can't remember) - where was this in the syllabus as I did not come across it? (maybe it was a think outside the box question but if you don't know you don't know- able to hazard a guess at project & risk). So much on strategy development I knew inside out but of no use here in this question - only really BCG as a model and could touch on few other things but calc's made it difficult for time and to scan for points and write up in essay format.
2nd part of exam focused on narrow topic areas in my opinion. I look at Q2 (regression and time series analysis) having looked at this just last night but decided not to do because my calculator bat went! and I thought prob take ages with disseminating/analysing the info anyway.
Onto Q3 and this was e-commerce model - again fine with that but then seemed to focus heavily on e-procurement. Again I did not come across this in so much detail in my study (I know what e-procurement is but for so many marks this threw me).
Q4 was fair enough but any previous questions re cultural web was more open ended - this question was specifically to address staff development with relation to cultural web. Bit harder question IMO. Competency and learning development questions (2 x 5 marks) fair enough.
I did the Sep 16 paper and thought that was a very easy paper. Guess just depends on luck sometimes with what you get - what suits one person won't suit another.
I disagree revenues determined their contribution as a company can have good revenues but still be loss making- if being anal about it you would probably have to state no cost data so have to go on revenue only. Although to be fair examiner would not mark you down for that given exam situation and thats all we had to go on
Well looking into the comments i m litrally shocked as question 1 was fairly easier...onlt the last part of the question was a bit challenging..the rest question i found pretty fair..!!!
Obviously given the fact that Q1 was good , the rest part of the paper has to be pretty tough and challenging... i did Q3 and Q4..though i am nt very confident about the PART 2 of both the question.... i still feel that Q1 had easy marks to grab..!
The rest I believe that it is practically impossible to finish this paper on time, so just focus on puttIng as much marks in your pocket as possible!!!
Wishing some luck to happen .... so that i m able to pass it!!
I attempted Q3& 4 both were ok spend 1 hour and 45 mins ....
e marketing was relatively complex but e procurement was straightforward ...
In q4 the Web culture was good but part b was relatively complex ...
In Q1 part A I used Bcg and ashridge portfolio matrix there were rich information for part a
however when I came to part b I shocked bcx it was lengthy but not easy and I have just 30 mins for the last 32 marks it was hard to write in detail but ALHAMDULILLAH just managed them within time but don't know what I wrote in section b due to time pressure however hopefully I will pass in first attempt IN SHA ALLAH
Really struggled with this paper, mainly question 1.
for the omissions part I used the kaleidoscope headings like timings, capacity, capability, scope...do you think I would get anything for that? seem to be way off from what people on here have said?
You need to apply models to the scenario ...whole point of this paper. Global warming? you've lost me there lol
I agree with you totally. This is my third sitting with one year interval (thought I'd passed Sep 15 and started studying for P6!), but I feel I need to take it again. It's really frustrating. I found P5 more straightforward and interesting.
I feel I have knowledge, but don't seem to be able to get my head around the questions.
Good luck with your results.
Fair enough for thinking outside the box but I would think paperless environment is driven just as much - if not more - because of businesses reducing their cost base and due to advancements in technology...most people want ebooks etc rather than hard copy now because its more easily accessible storage wise and don't care so much about saving trees
The three companies in question 1...
How did u plot them on the ashtridge model?
What are the principles of e procurement
It was 8 marks I believe
@jamiemiu said: Does anyone remember how many marks on the last part of question 1, change mangement etc? I didn have time to go back to do the question :(It was 8 marks I believe
6 marks for the very last part of Q1 I think (was in reference to role of finance team member re change management, project management, risk management and one other can't remember)
Think the other was the business case
@suger890 said: The three companies in question 1... How did u plot them on the ashtridge model?I believe I said the paper company was alien business, the mobile app company was value trap and the other one I said ballast business.
@jamiemiu said: Does anyone remember how many marks on the last part of question 1, change mangement etc? I didn have time to go back to do the question :(It was 8 marks. I also didn't have time to go back to it. I wrote a couple of basic sentences to hopefully get a mark or 2 but realised I had already spent too long on Q1 and didn't want to throw away easy marks from the optional questions.
@kris1502 said: The Project initiation document or whatever it was and you had to state what was omitted and reasons why info should be included. I studied for this exam pretty hard but did not come across this at all. Then the question about what a finance team member should contribute to change, project & risk management (& one other can't remember) - where was this in the syllabus as I did not come across it? 2nd part of exam focused on narrow topic areas in my opinion. I look at Q2 (regression and time series analysis) having looked at this just last night but decided not to do because my calculator bat went! and I thought prob take ages with disseminating/analysing the info anyway. Onto Q3 and this was e-commerce model - again fine with that but then seemed to focus heavily on e-procurement. Again I did not come across this in so much detail in my study (I know what e-procurement is but for so many marks this threw me). Q4 was fair enough but any previous questions re cultural web was more open ended - this question was specifically to address staff development with relation to cultural web. Bit harder question IMO. Competency and learning development questions (2 x 5 marks) fair enough. I did the Sep 16 paper and thought that was a very easy paper. Guess just depends on luck sometimes with what you get - what suits one person won't suit another.There was a past paper question on PID, I believe it was something to do with a project for a mayor implementing a new traffic system. I don't believe the OpenTuition lectures mention it much though. I believe the finance team member question was more from P1. Sometimes the P3 exam does include some topics from P1, i've seen past exam questions on CG and ethics. I felt the same about Q2a. There were a few past papers and an article on ACCA website that had questions like this, one of them looked almost identical. However with 30 minutes left and a choice between Q3 and Q2 I didn't want to spend time trying to understand and do the calculations. Yeah, I don't recall coming across e-procurement either. I think it's just assumed knowledge or expects you to just develop your understanding of e-business. In regards to Q4 I have to agree. Saw a past exam paper with a similar scenario but the question was more just "evaluate the culture using the cultural web" rather than having to relate it to another aspect.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

