FM*** ACCA F9 December 2017 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
@aagshin said: @hsnkzmi said: That’s cause you had to spread it over 10 years, that was also mentioned in the q. So, all calc for 4 years are 100% wrong, cause then you’d get a residual value and the q mentions complete dep to value 0 Hi firend, I did it for 10 years, do you think that it is correct? Because With ignoring the years 5-10 you can not calculate them by multiplying by annuity factor because of inflation. I calculated 1-10 years with nominal rate with inflation (with 1250 Tax allowed dep) and with 6%(real rate) without inflating the figures. Got arounf 84K with nominal and around 70K with real rate. Besides did anybody remember with what doscount percent we have to fidn a doscount factor for debt in WACC question(I guess it was q31)? I used 5% and 7% for finding it in valuation of debt.Prima facie it looks good.Although each of us gets different answers its really your grip of the concept that matters.
@guptashubhangi said: wy are we taking depreciation to calculate avg profit?Because they gave you cash flows, and the depn is added back to get to those, for profits you need to remove it again.
@lukman94 said: How are they wrong lol ? The Text clearly said the Scrap value was zero. If you look at previous exams where depreciation has been on a straight line basis you simple take the initial investment over the assets useful life multiplied by the tax rate. This gives you the tax relief per year. It was a fairly simple question that many people are over complicating.Thats's cause their perception of cash flows from a project is wrong. The question specifically said that from 5th year on wards the production will carry-on at 200,000 U's an year. How can you end the question at 4 years , when in reality it does carry on for a longer period? how can you just take cf's upto 4 years and not any further? the periods were as follows - 0,1,2,3,4,5-10 lol
@coralienana said: I understood your question but i have no idea ... I also asked on the forum to have an idea because i'm still confused ...Cf's will be taken for the years 0,1,2,3,4,5-10 . From 5-10 years there were same cf's and a cumulative disc rt might as well be used.
@hsnkzmi said:
I understood your question but i have no idea …
I also asked on the forum to have an idea because i’m still confused …
Cf’s will be taken for the years 0,1,2,3,4,5-10 . From 5-10 years there were same cf’s and a cumulative disc rt might as well be used.
I think the CF after the year 5 will not be the same because of inflation factor. If you are talking about real rates you are right. Am I right?
@aagshin said: @hsnkzmi said: I understood your question but i have no idea … I also asked on the forum to have an idea because i’m still confused … Cf’s will be taken for the years 0,1,2,3,4,5-10 . From 5-10 years there were same cf’s and a cumulative disc rt might as well be used. I think the CF after the year 5 will not be the same because of inflation factor. If you are talking about real rates you are right. Am I right?If the cash flows are the same the disc cash will give the same results no matter what rates are used
@lukman94 said: Yes but judging from mark allocation if they asked you to compute it for 10 years then that would require a lot more effort and time. This is just my opinion. All the very best for results day. The question simply asked you to compute the nominal NPV - If you felt the need to go beyond 4 years was fully justified then may God be with you :)I'll definitely be back in March.
@lukman94 said: I can’t recall where it was in the question. But I am 100% sure that you were required to calculate the discounted pay back - which requires you to use a discount factor. If the question had asked for the pay back period then the answer would be 2 Years.I got 2.4 years as well, The only figures I can remember are 960,000 initial and 40,000 scrap value which isn't much help.
In my opinion it would not make sense to appraise the project further than 4 years, as they specifically mentioned the company appraise projects over 4 years.
In reality, yes it would make sense to appraise the project over 10 years as this would look at the entire project life. But for appraisal purpose 4 years makes sense as this was their policy. In addition, the depreciation allowance was 50m/10*25% = 1,250 per year
And the reason why I think 4 years make sense is because at 4 years, you get a positive NPV therefore they would accept the project. And therefore at 10 years, they would also get a positive NVP, so working out up to 10 years seems redundant.
Can anyone remember the answer of mcq 6% loan note and 8 % loan note and in the same senario question what about the other mcq and in the forex senario question what are mcq ans
Who remembers exam answer for MCQ 1 (trade receivable days)? I know the way it is calculated.But i really want to check number. Was it 57 or 62 or another number?
Shafgat, if i am not mistaken, i got 18.9 (approx 19) for the 1st one and 118.2 for the second MV calculation? What about you?
As i remember for both of them i chose variant B
Sir,
Can you solve the December 2017 F9 question for us? So that we can be sure about our answers are right or wrong.
It is already published in the past exam paper page of ACCA GLOBAL.
Regards,
Arif
Bangladesh
Was mcq question 1 answer A or C?
Sir,
Can you solve the December 2017 F9 question for us? So that we can be sure about our answers are right or wrong.
It is already published in the past exam paper page of ACCA GLOBAL.
Regards,
Arif Ansary
Bangladesh
I dont recognise those questions
Yeah, so ACCA have released the "Sample Sept/Dec Questions".....both are from the Sept exam. Not very helpful!
*Edit - although could they have selected a question from the CBE December exam? Hadn't thought of that.
Does anyone remember the answer the mcq question 1 about the working capital cycle and whether to use closing receivables or av receivables. Was the answer A or C?
Actually , Same For F7 And F8 Questions ......... They Just Plucked Semptember Papers
I Passed Both On Semptember .... The Sample Paper Is No Use For Us Now ........
What’s done is done. At the end of the day we all have a different understanding of how the question should’ve been answered. I hope we all make it and move on to the remaining papers. Let’s enjoy the holidays and just wait for results day now.
does anybody remember the questions about cost of equity and loan note in section a what it was???????????
The ACCA has uploaded 2 Section C questions from the September/December exams.
I have prepared a suggested answer to Question 32 in the sample exam (Pelta Co), which from the posts on here seems to have been one of the December questions.
You can find it here:
https://opentuition.com/acca/f9/acca-f9-september-december-2017-exams-q32-suggested-answer/
Thx for the effort sir but those two questions didnt show up in the Dec sitting
option D - companies export will increase because the currency fallsdown when intrest rate increases
option D - companies export will increase because the currency fallsdown when intrest rate increases
Section C was quite fair but A and B were tricky
Hi,
I will be taking this exam in March. What types of questions are likely to come up in section C?
Thanks.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

