FM*** ACCA F9 December 2017 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
I used average receivables because the closing receivables does not give a true picture or accurate figure due to high year end balances.
I think even in the lectures on open tuition it was always advised to use average receivables once provided. But then again that was for F5 lol.
I guess the same holds true for F9.
Payback 2.4
Not wc - sales
For the wacc convert or redeem were we meant to calculate the cost of debt for both and use the lowest?!
What did you guys get for the mv for ordianry shares in WACC..i changed my answer to the 50 million x the share price and ignored the nominal value of the shares (0.25) i think.
Question 31
I put ordinary shares.. was unsure on what certificates of deposit are?!
Damn I forgot about other loans in sofp too and went purely off the paragraphs!!!
As usual calculation of cost of equity by dividend growth model. just calculate div growth rate by Gordon formula g=br
Peso forward rate - 143 ? Other option was 140 and I dont remember what. What were ur answers guys?
Q31, B) discuss the Grant Co dividend policy relevance to its equity market value (10 marks). What did u write for 10 marks? I spoke about the Dividend constant growth, dividend irrelevancy theory n thats it :). I referred also to the D growth calculated in part a and mentioned investor have confidence in this share bla bla bla. What 3 marks max? What did u write guys?
Finance Mngt Purpose Is The Actually Part A-G Of Our Syallabus ...... Invest Appraisal And WCM , But not Financial Appriasal ......... The Answer Is 1 And 3 Only ..........
I’m the section C question of working out the WACC I only remember have to work the the cost of equity as well as the convertible debt.
There was no other loan note or irredeemable debt, or was there?....
Can anybody clearly explain?: Should we choose 10 years or 4 years in NPV question?? and why????
I calculated both nominal and real rates NPV for 10 years.. Nominal NPV was around 84 K(after deduction of 50K investment) and around 74 K in real terms. Dont know correct or not..
MCQ Section B
NPV cant remember
Payback i got 2.4
ROCE i got 37 %
@aagshin said: Can anybody clearly explain?: Should we choose 10 years or 4 years in NPV question?? and why???? I calculated both nominal and real rates NPV for 10 years.. Nominal NPV was around 84 K(after deduction of 50K investment) and around 74 K in real terms. Dont know correct or not..NPV 1-4 adw 1-10 NPV 5+ perpetuity
For question 31, what did you choose between redemption 10 years or convert into 10 shares ?
It's my first attempt and i found it quite difficult ! i did not even have time to finish the exam, i guess we need more time or i'm not speed enough.
Also, they provide too much unnecessary information and you need to stay focus otherwise you might use information which is not necessary.
I found the MCQ more difficult that the ones i did in BPP... So i'm quite confused.
I'm just starting ACCA, and chose that exam but if i fail i could be demotivated...
Don't let it demotivate you it's probably one of the hardest of the F modules to start on in my opinion!
thanks
I guess payback was 2. since it was for the other project mentioned in below section in which 400k- 40k was the casf flow at the end of the year 4. Even I had wrongly marked 2.4 as answer but could not help it after marking th answer.
@aagshin said: Can anybody clearly explain?: Should we choose 10 years or 4 years in NPV question?? and why???? I calculated both nominal and real rates NPV for 10 years.. Nominal NPV was around 84 K(after deduction of 50K investment) and around 74 K in real terms. Dont know correct or not..I have calculated for 4 years only as it was mentioned in the paper that- "There is an ongoing management poilcy of quoting the projects for 4 years." And for the part b of the question, I remember studying in BPP that no matter how we calculate the NPV ( using nominal rate and cash flows or using real rate and real cash flows), the answer of NPV will be almost same.
Same answer for me too
The answer was around 23%
Something like that
ROCE = Avg Profit / Avg Investment
Avg Profit
Total Profit / Number of years - Depreciation
Avg Investment
Investment + Scrap Value / 2
ROCE = 37%
Surely all 3 were relevant for financial management, including financial appraisal?
@daisypeg said: How did you get 37? I added all profits together and took out scrap value and divided by 4 to get average profit then dividend by average investment and got 83%me too
@laughingcoffin said: ROCE = Avg Profit / Avg Investment Avg Profit Total Profit / Number of years - Depreciation Avg Investment Investment + Scrap Value / 2 ROCE = 37%wy are we taking depreciation to calculate avg profit?
ROCE is also called ARR
Accounting Rate of Return
It uses accounting profits
Depreciation is always deducted to get profit
For the two MCQ with the market value of the loan notes what answers did you guys get
In question 31 after finding conversion value the loan notes were convertible so i found the cost of debt from them and thats how i got WACC around 5 i dont know if its correct as most of you are saying around 12. I got ex dividend by subtracting current divided from cum dividend and used it to calculate Ve
In the dividend policy part b just wrote about Retention and inflation and limits on dividend distribution is to be considered and exaggerated it.
I think I screwed up pretty bad in question 32 as I used general inflation too after inflating the contribution and fixed cost and then found NPV with nominal rate
Then for real rate i used same inflated amounts and didnt use general inflation then found npv with real rate.
In Q32 i inflated the contribution and fixed cost by the specific rate and i discounted using the 10% rate for part a
For part b i didnt inflate sales and contribution and discounted at 6%
No idea if thats correct but it felt right
what I did was wrong...what you did is right. Do you think they will give me any marks for it even though it was wrong?
@amirawasim said: what I did was wrong...what you did is right. Do you think they will give me any marks for it even though it was wrong?I was thinking the same. Normally according to bpp they give marks for the reasoning if it's alright. But i'm not sure at all... I guess it depends .
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

