FM*** ACCA F9 December 2017 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
I have read almost all the comments many people did the common mistake while calculating the pay back and mcq no 1 avg receivable or end receivable.
Pay back was 2 yrs because there was 2 part in question 1st part relates to npv and the other relates to pay back and roce. Pay back was 2 and most of people did 2.4 which is wrong pay back relates to 2nd part where initial investment was (900000) and other cash flows was in between 420000 to 480000 if i am not wrong and also people calculate the roce wrongly it also relates to 2nd part of question which was 39%. Sale is not the part of wc if you read the wc topic there is 4 element of wc receivables inventory cash and pay able and about there balancing most people ans cash which is also wrong
Anybody Who Know MCQ Answer ????
First MCQ I Did Wrong - Because I Choosed Closing Balance , my big Mistake ....
I Need At Least 15-16 MCQs to Go On My Favour In Order to Be Pass Coz My Section C Dint Went Well , But i Will Score About 20 .
My MCQ were
1.C
2.C
3.A
4.A
5.A
6.C
7.B
8.D
9.C
10.D
11.C
12.B
13.B
14.C
15.A
16.C
17.C
18.B
19.A
20.C
21.C
22.D
23,C
24.D
25.D
26.B
27.C
28.A
29. A
30. B
My MCQ were
1.C
2.C
3.A
4.A
5.A
6.C
7.B
8.D
9.C
10.D
11.C
12.B
13.B
14.C
15.A
16.C
17.C
18.B
19.A
20.C
21.C
22.D
23,C
24.D
25.D
26.B
27.C
28.A
29. A
30. B
@tpara said: Who can write answers for MCQs sequentally?
@ali17 said: I have read almost all the comments many people did the common mistake while calculating the pay back and mcq no 1 avg receivable or end receivable. Pay back was 2 yrs because there was 2 part in question 1st part relates to npv and the other relates to pay back and roce. Pay back was 2 and most of people did 2.4 which is wrong pay back relates to 2nd part where initial investment was (900000) and other cash flows was in between 420000 to 480000 if i am not wrong and also people calculate the roce wrongly it also relates to 2nd part of question which was 39%. Sale is not the part of wc if you read the wc topic there is 4 element of wc receivables inventory cash and pay able and about there balancing most people ans cash which is also wrongI think it was 2,4 years because it was discounted pay back ! It would have been 2 years if it was only the normal payback if i remember correctly. But the question was about discounted payback.
I agree with you coralienana. I also calculated 2.4 as the correct answer. Since it was asking for a discounted pay back we had to Incorporate the discount factor.
Judging from past exams, it’s either you do 4 year comparison or a 5 year comparison if tax is paid in arrears. Since the contribution and fixed costs provided were only for 4 years and tax was paid in the year it occurred m, the correct layout would be to a 4 year analysis.
The question never mentioned that production will cease at the end of year 4 or 5.
Could you please let me know that in pay back question where was the discount factor in that question the discount factor was given in npv part not in pay back and roce question part
@jeromeb said: The question never mentioned that production will cease at the end of year 4 or 5.After thinking about it and talking a lil' bit with my manager, he thinks that we should have used 4 years and have a terminal value because they stated that capital allowance was on a straight line basis over 10 years and the terminal value was supposed to be 0 after 10 years. Therefore, after 4 years, we had to compute a residual value for our DCF and do the calculation. I asked him if doing it over 10 years was incorrect he said he thinks it's incorrect because they just hoped that it would be 2 for the future, and that was so hypothetical that the management asked to do it for 4 years. Providing us 10 years was the tricky part of the question. I did over 10 years and i'm now afraid i failed ...
@coralienana said: After thinking about it and talking a lil' bit with my manager, he thinks that we should have used 4 years and have a terminal value because they stated that capital allowance was on a straight line basis over 10 years and the terminal value was supposed to be 0 after 10 years. Therefore, after 4 years, we had to compute a residual value for our DCF and do the calculation. I asked him if doing it over 10 years was incorrect he said he thinks it's incorrect because they just hoped that it would be 2 for the future, and that was so hypothetical that the management asked to do it for 4 years. Providing us 10 years was the tricky part of the question. I did over 10 years and i'm now afraid i failed ...I'm so confused right now, I definitely know I've messed up on the last questions but the way it was written out definitely made it sound like it should have been at least up to 10 years. By terminal value do you mean perpetuity?
Yes but judging from mark allocation if they asked you to compute it for 10 years then that would require a lot more effort and time. This is just my opinion. All the very best for results day. The question simply asked you to compute the nominal NPV - If you felt the need to go beyond 4 years was fully justified then may God be with you :)
I can’t recall where it was in the question. But I am 100% sure that you were required to calculate the discounted pay back - which requires you to use a discount factor. If the question had asked for the pay back period then the answer would be 2 Years.
@jeromeb said: I'm so confused right now, I definitely know I've messed up on the last questions but the way it was written out definitely made it sound like it should have been at least up to 10 years. By terminal value do you mean perpetuity?I don't know what he means. He just says the scrap value can't be 0 because they say it's on a straight line over 10 years and the scrap value would have been 0 after 10 years. Therefore, there was a little scrap value after 4 years. I don't know how ...
@lukman94 said: Yes but judging from mark allocation if they asked you to compute it for 10 years then that would require a lot more effort and time. This is just my opinion. All the very best for results day. The question simply asked you to compute the nominal NPV - If you felt the need to go beyond 4 years was fully justified then may God be with you :)Yes i know 10 years was requiring a lot of calculation for the time we had and the marks allocated ... That's true ...
@coralienana said: Yes i know 10 years was requiring a lot of calculation for the time we had and the marks allocated ... That's true ...I have myself screwed up pretty bad but it was 1,2,3,4 and 5-10 years 5-10 was cumulative in every sense of the word. Also, dep was linear so no prob.
@coralienana said: I don't know what he means. He just says the scrap value can't be 0 because they say it's on a straight line over 10 years and the scrap value would have been 0 after 10 years. Therefore, there was a little scrap value after 4 years. I don't know how ...That's cause you had to spread it over 10 years, that was also mentioned in the q. So, all calc for 4 years are 100% wrong, cause then you'd get a residual value and the q mentions complete dep to value 0
What about the roce and mcq 1 receivables for the year or avg receivables question ask the receivables not avg receivables
@hsnkzmi said: That's cause you had to spread it over 10 years, that was also mentioned in the q. So, all calc for 4 years are 100% wrong, cause then you'd get a residual value and the q mentions complete dep to value 0If i understand you correctly someone who did 4 years and had a residual value ; that's OK ?
@ali17 said: What about the roce and mcq 1 receivables for the year or avg receivables question ask the receivables not avg receivablesI wondered that as well but I presumed it wanted us to use the average receivables, as average receivables gives a figure which is more representative of the year so that's what I went with.
Out of all of the NPV questions I've practised including the ones in the BPP study guide this one was the most confusing to get my head around as I couldn't decide on how many years to use. I wasted more time trying to understand the question than I did actually doing it.
@coralienana said: If i understand you correctly someone who did 4 years and had a residual value ; that's OK ?Yes that's correct! The question itself mentioned linear dep, which never leaves a residual value and is proportionately spread over the effective economical life of the asset.
@ali17 said: What about the roce and mcq 1 receivables for the year or avg receivables question ask the receivables not avg receivablesBoth q's have been done erroneously by most students, roce is 37% , most students forgot roce uses accounting profits and not cf's therefore to arrive at acc. profs we deduct the dep. next we divide the total profits so calc, by initial inv + salvage value / 2. for the receivable q . its average and not year end
@ali17 said: Could you please let me know that in pay back question where was the discount factor in that question the discount factor was given in npv part not in pay back and roce question partwe use the same disc factor. its not different for npv or disc.payback
How are they wrong lol ? The Text clearly said the Scrap value was zero. If you look at previous exams where depreciation has been on a straight line basis you simple take the initial investment over the assets useful life multiplied by the tax rate. This gives you the tax relief per year. It was a fairly simple question that many people are over complicating.
@hsnkzmi said:
That’s cause you had to spread it over 10 years, that was also mentioned in the q. So, all calc for 4 years are 100% wrong, cause then you’d get a residual value and the q mentions complete dep to value 0
Hi firend, I did it for 10 years, do you think that it is correct?
Because With ignoring the years 5-10 you can not calculate them by multiplying by annuity factor because of inflation. I calculated 1-10 years with nominal rate with inflation (with 1250 Tax allowed dep) and with 6%(real rate) without inflating the figures. Got arounf 84K with nominal and around 70K with real rate.
Besides did anybody remember with what doscount percent we have to fidn a doscount factor for debt in WACC question(I guess it was q31)? I used 5% and 7% for finding it in valuation of debt.
I also chose the same.
Why I cannot to reply to the comments? I press reply but the comment area is empty..
@lukman94 said: How are they wrong lol ? The Text clearly said the Scrap value was zero. If you look at previous exams where depreciation has been on a straight line basis you simple take the initial investment over the assets useful life multiplied by the tax rate. This gives you the tax relief per year. It was a fairly simple question that many people are over complicating.Because the scrap value was zero after 10 years on a straight line basis. So after 4 years, it wouldn't have been zero !
I'm not sure if my original question has caused confusion. I know the premises was depreciated over 10 years with 0 scrap value, (50m/10*25% = 1.25m a year allowance). I was unsure to the amount of years the DCF should have actually been for, I did 1,2,3,4,5-10.
@jeromeb said: I'm not sure if my original question has caused confusion. I know the premises was depreciated over 10 years with 0 scrap value, (50m/10*25% = 1.25m a year allowance). I was unsure to the amount of years the DCF should have actually been for, I did 1,2,3,4,5-10.I understood your question but i have no idea ... I also asked on the forum to have an idea because i'm still confused ...
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

