PM*** ACCA F5 December 2017 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
What's the answer for the rolling budget sum? Was that 890?
If we would have discontinued both the end depts then dept A would have to bear both of the fixed costs & this would have occured greater loss than continuing both depts. I marked that no one should be stopped.
My learning rate was 61 lol it was just a guess
Does anyone know the tricks of the life-cycle and target costing questions? I calculated, and there wasnt my result. I thought these would be easy! :D
life cycle costing answer was A for me you have to deduct from every 2 nd month to get the increase in customers and add them to get total customer .
Learning rate was 81% for me too.
@evam said: Does anyone know the tricks of the life-cycle and target costing questions? I calculated, and there wasnt my result. I thought these would be easy! :DThose two questions are the trick for f5 exam. Both question I choose C. 800 for life cycle cost and 11042 unit for target cost
@odean20 said: It was a relevant cost question. Only serento the middle chair should not be sold. Only the attributed fixed cost is relivantI put that the last chair should not be sold. I remember thinking general fixed costs aren't relevant yes but at the same time, each product was allocated a part of the general fixed cost to bear. I working out the total general fixed costs across all three plus the attributed fixed costs for the first chair and the second chair because if they stopped any chair the contribution of the other would need to cover the fixed costs. I worked out that both fixed costs types would still be covered by the contributions from both the first and second if they got rid of the last chair. Ah well.
@odean20 said: Those two questions are the trick for f5 exam. Both question I choose C. 800 for life cycle cost and 11042 unit for target costU manage to calculate them or just assumption?!)
@sanjaymehra said: I marked the option with both northern and southern because we were not given with targeted roi by head office and there was not much difference in both roi. So i marked that both of them should be continued forward.The current ROI was in the question. It was definitely the Northern division.
Mine too
@anastassiya777 said: U manage to calculate them or just assumption?!)Well my answer was close to 800 for the life cycle cost and I calculated the target cost of 96 and the estimated cost 106. So I just divided 106/96*10000 = 11042 unit
@rajeshram said: What's the answer for the rolling budget sum? Was that 890?I get that as well
Guys there was a question about continuing to make a product that was budgeted to make a loss. Options for valid reasons were:
To gain market market share and another option. The question asked which reasons were valid/acceptable - Was the answer both?
A few more:
Which chair should be they keep on making?
Quoting the transfer price at minimum to gain a new customer implications:
I put it would both reduce the perceived value and it wouldn't be easy to raise the price later without loosing the customer. something like that.
@heychi said: Guys there was a question about continuing to make a product that was budgeted to make a loss. Options for valid reasons were: To gain market market share and another option. The question asked which reasons were valid/acceptable - Was the answer both?Another option was to sell as complementary product ? I selected only 1 i.e only complementary products, hbu?
@odean20 said: Well my answer was close to 800 for the life cycle cost and I calculated the target cost of 96 and the estimated cost 106. So I just divided 106/96*10000 = 11042 unitI also find taget and estimated costs but tried several times by different ways but didnt had such as ur way to calculate it.
I marked neither of them.
@rajeshram said: Another option was to sell as complementary product ? I selected only 1 i.e only complementary products, hbu?I also choosed only complimentary as about raise price for not profit making product seems not realistic.who knows)
What was the answer for the quarterly rolling budget question... I choose 880,000 as 3 months in a quarter and increase was 10,000 per month .. I don't remember it all by I'm not sure I did it right... How foolish of me to loose 2 marks for a just a simple question as that if I'm wrong with 880,000 :(
How did you calculated 880,000... It was quarterly increasing ... How can u say 880,00p
@anastassiya777 said: I also choosed only complimentary as about raise price for not profit making product seems not realistic.who knows)I think with penetration pricing they can also sell products at a loss to gain market share. I also found this on google so I put both options are valid: https://smallbusiness.chron.com/companies-keep-unprofitable-product-line-10280.html
@aglong said: I'd be interested to know how other people approached the last question - as there was no BS sheet info, couldnt perform ROCE (etc.) calculations... apart from gross and net profit margin %'s, what other calculations did other people use? ThanksI used C-P/P formula for every other possible calculation .. Because nothing was quiet shown
@heychi said: I think with penetration pricing they can also sell products at a loss to gain market share. I also found this on google so I put both options are valid: https://smallbusiness.chron.com/companies-keep-unprofitable-product-line-10280.htmlYes that makes sense , but what I thought was with selling at a loss , the mindset of costumers would be that the product is of inferior quality and hence that might not increase market share ..
The last question about their performance. I used interest cover as well for the the new loan, but there was no interest cover since the made a loss. So mentioned a bit about that. .
@aglong said: I'd be interested to know how other people approached the last question - as there was no BS sheet info, couldnt perform ROCE (etc.) calculations... apart from gross and net profit margin %'s, what other calculations did other people use? Thanks
I think it was 81%
@sonia.ataaye said: I think it was 81%
@viscera said: I used C-P/P formula for every other possible calculation .. Because nothing was quiet shownWhat do you mean by C-P/P? Thanks
@sonia.ataaye said: I think it was 81%It was - The first 16 units is to the power 1/4 so yeah 81%.
@rajeshram said: Yes that makes sense , but what I thought was with selling at a loss , the mindset of costumers would be that the product is of inferior quality and hence that might not increase market share ..I get you - they didn't ask for the effect of it though, just the reason(s) why they would in the first place.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

