PM*** ACCA F5 December 2017 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
@anastassiya777 said: I also included the comission in calculation as it still sales.Yes, it was already included for us in the question from what I remember. What % did you get?
@heychi said: Yes, it was already included for us in the question from what I remember. What % did you get?im not sure about exact %.i believe something with 50%.
@heychi said: I included this and still got 50%.That's not possible because the contribution would increase by 3 to 33 p.u b/even point = 150000/33 = 4545 put Margin of safety 10000-4545/10000*100 is 55% F/C 15*1000 = 150000
@proticz said: hey guys can someone tell me how you people tackled the 8 marks variance question I mean what was the mix ratio for the sales mix variance ? and what was your answer for that? I struggled with itHey, You needed the OAR to be calculated so you could find out the standard profit for each Vacuum cleaner. Then you needed to write down actual mix amounts, total them up and then compare each amount to what the standard proportion would have been under the actual mix ratio. It's really complicated to explain online but it was a lot to do for just 8 marks in my opinion.
Anyone the variances from the 20 marks question? sales mix and quantity variances?
@odean20 said: That's not possible because the contribution would increase by 3 to 33 p.u b/even point = 150000/33 = 4545 put Margin of safety 10000-4545/10000*100 is 55% F/C 15*1000 = 150000Hmm OK
@heychi said: Hmm OKIt can also be wrong who knows. All the best still
@odean20 said: It can also be wrong who knows. All the best stillNot sure if I am right , but commission is an expense right ? Shouldn't it be subtracted , so ideally the contribution would be 27 instead of 33?
What about maximum price to charge for ink ounce to close gap?
@rajeshram said: Not sure if I am right , but commission is an expense right ? Shouldn't it be subtracted , so ideally the contribution would be 27 instead of 33?That's the point it should less. So I guess I'm wrong
@heychi said: Ahhh I remember one to do with Target costing.. What they could do to close the gap? I selected option 3 only which I think was to negotiate a bulk discount. Increasing the selling price isn't to do with closing the cost gap right? I can't remember the other two options but didn't think they were right for some reason... Anyone remember throughput questions?throuput was a theory question right?
@anastassiya777 said: throuput was a theory question right?And accepting a lower profit margin
@anastassiya777 said: throuput was a theory question right?I don't remember any through put question know of make or buy decision
No, in one department there was the current ROI higher.
@anastassiya777 said: throuput was a theory question right?Yes - In fact I just remembered one that said was it useful in a highly automated manufacturing environment or something like that? I can't remember if there were any more on throughput.
@evam said: No, in one department there was the current ROI higher.Yes.the northern department of 16% it was greater than the target Roi of 15% The southern department was 19% less than the target Roi of 22% therefore it will be rejected
@heychi said: Yes - In fact I just remembered one that said was it useful in a highly automated manufacturing environment or something like that? I can't remember if there were any more on throughput.Was that long term highly automated ? Option B?
I marked the option with both northern and southern because we were not given with targeted roi by head office and there was not much difference in both roi. So i marked that both of them should be continued forward.
In section b a question was given regarding comfer or comfee i think in which they asked which one should be stopped as two were making loss. What was the answer to that?
@anastassiya777 said: What about learning rate to calculate?which figure?anybody....81%
@rajeshram said: Was that long term highly automated ? Option B?Yes but short termand highly automated.
@pw44288 said: 81%I got this too!
@rajeshram said: Was that long term highly automated ? Option B?Throughput is only useful for short term both question that involve longterm are incorrect Option A is the answer that talk about short term automated machine
@anastassiya777 said: Yes but short termand highly automated.Yes I put short term and highly automated - think that was option B or A
@sanjaymehra said: I marked the option with both northern and southern because we were not given with targeted roi by head office and there was not much difference in both roi. So i marked that both of them should be continued forward.Yes it was given. The current ROI for each division was given
But the rate by HO was not given itnwas just the departements rate.
@odean20 said: Yes.the northern department of 16% it was greater than the target Roi of 15% The southern department was 19% less than the target Roi of 22% therefore it will be rejectedI also followed such logic but above guys said also a reasonable points about both of them to be continued.i was confused on which answer to stop.
@pw44288 said: 81%The learning rate is 75% D 38.6875/90^(1/3)
I had the same answers. Differential & opportunity cost for relevant costing and for the other ERPS was the correct.
@sanjaymehra said: In section b a question was given regarding comfer or comfee i think in which they asked which one should be stopped as two were making loss. What was the answer to that?It was a relevant cost question. Only serento the middle chair should not be sold. Only the attributed fixed cost is relivant
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

