Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

AAA*** P7 June 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***

Oopentuition_teamAdmin11y ago

Please vote in our Instant Polls about the P7 June 2015 Exam.

*** P7 June 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results *** P7 June 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results *** P7 June 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results
Former userFormer user11y ago#61
Q1 A -6 marks -audit strategy B- 17 marks - evaluation on audit risk C- (i)Audit Procedure on investment - 4 marks (ii)AP on EPS - 4 marks Professional marks - 4 Total 35 Q2 A- 8 marks Sales and leaseback B- 8 marks Subsiadiary accounted as an associate C- 9 marks Weakness in IC Total 25 Q3 A- 5 marks Professional skepticism - meaning and enhance of planning B- (i) 6 marks Professional skepticism - Apply to statement made by finance director (ii) 5 marks Not remember what it is >.< C - 4 marks Suggest procedure on forensic investigation Total 20 marks Q4 Not remember at all but i know it relates to ISQC 1 and ISA 220 >..< and some ethics
Mmanvilles11y ago#62
I thought a fair paper my hand was hurting in the end and question five wasnt as bad as it looked hoping for a pass time management went well and the only prob was earning per share knew standard but couldnt remeber all audit evidence
RRahim11y ago#63
It was good paper. Attempted 94 marks. Mentioned the following in paper. Hope to crack. Q.1- (a)- Intial Audit Engagement- Wrote 7-8 guidelines mentioned in ISA-510 (b) Audit risk includes : Detection Risk- New Audit, Control Risk: No Int Audit dept IAS-38 misstatement of 100M, Online sale-business risk which led to Inherent risk,IAS-18 Revenue to be taken since R &R transfered. IAS 24 RPT and Non disclosures.FV to be taken in case of speculative investment. IAS 33, EPS wrongly taken. Reason for previous auditor resignation. Any Chances of fraud from Management. ISA 315 to be referred since new audit. Analytical review to be reviewed & adjusted. (c) Audit Procedures were ok for both items Q.2 (a)(i)IFRS 5, IAS 17 Finance Leas Sale back. It was tricky one. (a)(ii) ISA-600, 15% rules applies here to be significant component. Comparatives to be changed. Even though there is loss, it would compare with PBT of Group. In revenue it is 12%.Full audit is required and not analytical procedure (b) ISA 250 was cashed marks outlining the responsibilities of audits including the ethics point of Duty of Confidentiality to be broken as volunteer to the regulatory authority. Q.3 (a)- Professional Skepticism meaning and it helps in Audit estimates (ISA 540), Going Concern (ISA-570), RPT (ISA 550), Fraud (ISA 240). (b) PS- to be applied in situation. where i wrote, to check the Objectivity, competence and systematic & disciplined approach of Internal Auditor (ISA 610), Critically review last years file. IFRS 3 application correct or no. Reliance on FD. Profit inflation objective. Fraudulent financial reporting ISA 240. (c) AP of Impairment of Goodwill. It was revision of last June. Attempted ok. (d) Forensic auditing in bribe case. attempted well. Q. 5 (a) IAS 11, Stage completion either based on cost method or Surveyors completion % and qualify report on grounds of MM. (b) It is present obligation as per IAS 37. In Nov event happened and Jan is their closure. Lawyers confirmation is not Sufficient appropriate AE. Let them reverse and book profit if client don't pay this year. (c) Not attempted :) Hope to get 50...
Former userFormer user11y ago#64
Damn, its been more than 4 years since I took the P2 exam so my IAS/IFRS knowledge was totally rusty. Next time I attempt this paper (in case I don't scrape by 50 marks this time), I'll have to go back to study the current P2 syllabus first. I really like the auditing syllabus, but with zero auditing experience and no accounting experience in all these years, its getting a bit tough. Any other people in the same boat as me? The type of comments you guys are writing, you people were way more prepared for the exam. Wish I could do the same!
NNausheen11y ago#65
The paper was fairly okay. Too much to write though. I hope I pass.
AAbdul11y ago#66
Hey guys, sounds like P7 alright. Anyone with a copy of the paper? I did P7 3 times, it was the only problem paper I had, but I got across the line third attempt. If this paper is anything, it's unpredictable. I felt the following emotions after each attempt: 1. Felt terrible, time pressured- finished only75-80%. Got 46% - to my surprise 2. Felt too confident - finished with about 10min left . Got 41% - to my surprise 3. Felt borderline, P1 was lucky with business risk, so thought I'd scrape it. Got 62% - to my surprise So if your not feeling too confident, there's still hope. Good luck guys.
Rrutvik11y ago#67
@ Tez - why 15% recognition for Construction Contract? The Contract was over 14 months and at the year end date 7 months had elapsed - so under the percentage completion method if we take one month as a mile stone exactly half of the contract is elapsed - thus half of the work is done and if the margin was $ 5 million we should recognize half (i.e. $2.5 Million) whether billed or unbilled remains to be seen but the assumption that everything accrues evenly through out the year/contract. Q5 was all to do with Audit Reports - there are only 6 variations on the syllabus out of which one is an Unmodified Report which will hardly be tested in an exam thus making it an option between five. . . But everyone here is spot on with the time allocation - there is not enough time and a lot to explain and on top it all the examiner needs full sentences which is not always possible under these timed conditions - makes me believe that we as students are in a lose - lose situation.
Mmmabatho11y ago#68
The paper was standard the questions I believe are the same however time pressure is the only hick up but the is not excuse of me failing. I am hoping a pass!
Mmmabatho11y ago#69
that's true
Ddonatus11y ago#70
Time management was the problem, I couldn't finish because i ran short of time. ACCA should increase the writing time to four hours
Former userFormer user11y ago#71
I can't quite tell whether or not the paper was fair for me. I also attempted question 3 and 4. Hoping for the best, preparing for the worst.
TTez11y ago#72
@rutvik:Construction contracts...I took the cash received as expenses incurred to date to calc % completion. 3/20=15% x$5mil revenue but I may as well be wrong!!!! What did you put down for integrated report?I said other matters paragraph as it is not statutory requirement and it was incorrect growth rate mentioned? The paper was so vast,it felt long and i feel i was not specific enough:( also a lot of P2 knowledge comparative to previous papers... Does anyone remember what was part c of Q2?was that the legal requirmenets and the hazardous chemical?I mentioned about duty ofcare/breach of confidentiality/public interest/speak to management-again i felt elaboration was not enough...
TTez11y ago#73
@Rahim: Q1 part a] I thought we are on planning stage not initial engagement(before accepting the client where management integrity etc is the case)? I wrote down re. analytical procedures as part of strategy rather than substantive as company is big,we need to comprehend control environment.did anyone spoke about strategy and what strategy to implement?
Ppawelk11y ago#74
@tez "planning of an initial audit engagement". questions are out.
Ttallaghthoop11y ago#75
1) a) I went on the lines of areas of risk such as operational, compliance, financial and challenges of materiality new client and previous auditors circumstances of resigning.
MMatt11y ago#76
Anyone calculate any ratios for 1b for a few marks? I thought for a few easy marks GPM, OPM & Interest Cover? Found time pressure the main concern and only managed a further 6 audit risks for 1b. In the end i had to bullet point the majority of my answer for Q4b and pretty much all of it for 4c. Pretty worried now, what i was writing felt good in the exam, but who knows. And reading your comments is making me feeling like i have missed out on a few items. Totally cocked up Q4b as was worrying for time, and one of my bullet points mentioned the possibility of tax evasion/avoidance of the audit firm by off-shoring. Haha! All in all, I thought it was reasonable, but certainly not one of the easier P7 exams of the past based on mocks going back to 2010. But, it certainly was VERY time pressured! I needed at least another 20 mins to finish my question 4! Ahh, roll on 1st August!! I'm so anxious already!
Ttallaghthoop11y ago#77
Time pressure is the biggest issue. Its very difficult to assimilate the information quickly to put a coherent well structured answer with enough detail required. For me the P2 standards may save me. What did people do for 2 a) part (I) - I went with 2) a (I) there was two separate transactions that are both linked. De-recognition of asset IAS 16 and the creation of a finance lease asset which meant the sale proceeds >FV had to be deferred over the 20 year lease term and could not be recognised immediately. I also mentioned that in derecognising the asset, its sale proceeds less cv as opposed to fair value which may also need to be considered. The lease asset had 20 years depreciation as opposed to 21. So many tricks in that part all P2. Some people say IFRS5 but I am not sure if it leisure centre qualifies for that because the activities are not being discontinued.
Jjay1411y ago#78
i think we can point these out when they send the feedback forms as they do after each sitting. I think that is where all the complaints can be put to good use.. In truth, the paper was not horrible, but there was tooo much to write for each question.If one had to answer all questions as it should be done, it would have meant maybe leaving off one whole question..so either way, you are trapped between the devil and the deep blue sea...either way..you are dead!
Former userFormer user11y ago#79
Hi Tez in Q5 (a) Why 15% of $5mil to be recognized? How you got 15%? As per IAS - 11 $2.5mil should be recognized hence profit was overstated by $2.5mil.
Former userFormer user11y ago#80
Hi Tez in Q5 (a) Why 15% of $5mil to be recognized? How you got 15%? As per IAS – 11 $2.5mil should be recognized hence profit was overstated by $2.5mil. It was a 14 month contract and 7 month profit and revenue to be recognized assuming evenly completion of work. 15% is unrealistic.
@tez said: paper was not good as questions were open ended-I mentioned a lot of accounting standards to substantiate answers. a few clarifications if anyone remembers: q5-construction contracts- revenue to be recognised based on stage of completion-did anyone write that down?15% of the $5mil should have been recognised for the year-did anyone write that down? i cant remember what was the other part of Q5. Q3: 1st was a sale and leaseback-substance over form risks and rewards saty with the company-incorrect treatment of being recognised as an op lease-did anyone wrote that? the other part for recognition of associate instead of a sub-mentioned that voting rights/share interest -more investigation needed for substantiating sub or associate-integration of systems??what was that about? Q2: did anyone remember the indicators for goodwill impairment?the prof skepticism is a very VERY open ended matter so i just put down everything i knew relating to Silvio etc etc Q1: This was really tricky as it had way too many things to discuss-for part b(17 marks?!?)did anyone mention about forward contracts and related party transactions and short term investments? for strategy-did anyone mention about doing analytical reviews rather than substantive(transaction balances)as company size and complex-1st time client etc? what about resources available in audit company? paper was very daunting and time pressuring i did not manage to answer all of the parts of each question:(
TTez11y ago#81
@malimerchant:you are absolutely correct,i misread the questions and applied incorrect % of completion! tbh,i dont know how many marks one can miss if calcs are incorrect(due to silliness)yet applies standard correctly when assessing materiality-does anyone know? i dont have any confidence!!!
Former userFormer user11y ago#82
Nothing out of this world but time is surely a big enemy in these kind of examinations
Rram45611y ago#83
All the best
Former userFormer user11y ago#84
@Tez dont worry. 1 mark for materiality, 0.5 mark for calculation, 1.5 mark for accouting treatment and risk, 1 mark for impact on report. So nothing to loose much. Good luck !!
@tez said: @malimerchant:you are absolutely correct,i misread the questions and applied incorrect % of completion! tbh,i dont know how many marks one can miss if calcs are incorrect(due to silliness)yet applies standard correctly when assessing materiality-does anyone know? i dont have any confidence!!!
DDublin1011y ago#85
The Industry wouldn't matter
Ssikandaracca11y ago#86
Thanks God...i didn't attempt this time. It was very difficult. I will attemp t in Dec 2015...:-)
Sstanley11y ago#87
The paper was a fair one but highly time-pressured.lts difficult to give sufficiently detailed answers due to time pressure.The time-frame is simply unrealistic.Hoping to pass though!
Former userFormer user11y ago#88
Difficult paper presurred by time
Oogg2711y ago#89
When will answers get released so I know if to start studying for Sept session? Topis still very fresh in my head I dont want to forget them and have to restart all over again :(
Kkolive11y ago#90
Q1- loved the Fr Ted references, laughing throughout!
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.