AAA*** P7 June 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
Overall, the exam was ok. The topics were fairly familiar, comparing to the last session, there were no tricky parts, I would be lying if I have said this was one of the harder exam sessions. If I fail this time, I will be the only one to blame.
I found the keeping the volume of writing under control to be the main challenge. With such a ethics/qc focus there was plenty to write about.
Quite surprised when i opened the paper.... close to half the marks were there to be had for qc/ethics and prof secpticism.
Can only say the same as leodjakovic... fair paper...if i didnt pass it was focus/time managment or being too vague in my responses. Time will tell.
For me the exam didn't go well. Too time pressured. I missed out on 30% of the marks. Was terrible for me. Guess this is it Fail.
professional scepticism - was on technical updates on ACCA website
audit quality - was on technical updates on ACCA website
No real surprises except for Q5 part a for 8 marks - you needed to know about construction contracts
Any failure will be down to me not putting enough effort in or poor time allocation across the 4 questions
The articles were there but relating them to the scenarios was crazy. The scenarios were impossible.
I wish the exam could be better
Thought it was ok, trying to approx me marks, I honestly can't remember questions or marks.
Q1 a) was about audit strategy for 6 marks
B) was audit risk 17
C) can't remember
4 professional marks as well
Q2 Q3 Q4 can't rember properly either
Brain dead
Easy if I had practiced enough, which I did not so... I am not sure what to expect
Paper didnt went well for me. It was very lengthy.Even though all topics were as predicted but scenarios were too much difficult.and relating topics to scenario was very difficult and time consuming.
Audit risks part, IAS33, analytical procedures given calculated,ethics question required a huge amount of information. Even isa 240 relation to scenario.
Unusual paper it was I must say..
time pressure was crazy!!!!!!
Tip for time pressure, at the reading time I multiply the amount of marks by 1.8 and that gives you the time allowance. I write this on the question booklet and move on to the next question when time is up
@snowia said: Paper didnt went well for me. It was very lengthy.Even though all topics were as predicted but scenarios were too much difficult.and relating topics to scenario was very difficult and time consuming. Audit risks part, IAS33, analytical procedures given calculated,ethics question required a huge amount of information. Even isa 240 relation to scenario. Unusual paper it was I must say..Totally agree with you. This examiner I believe was not so fair in this sitting. She tested too much accounting knowledge of P2 and F7. I mean the whole paper had accounting standards. Time pressure was crazy. How does she expect us to write explanations when there is so much to do? Question four scenario was very odd. Hoped for better. IAS 11 is going to be kicked out soon. Why bother even testing it?
i did that but stiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiilllll i couldnt beat time
Fingers crossed. Praying to pass this time.
paper was not good as questions were open ended-I mentioned a lot of accounting standards to substantiate answers. a few clarifications if anyone remembers:
q5-construction contracts- revenue to be recognised based on stage of completion-did anyone write that down?15% of the $5mil should have been recognised for the year-did anyone write that down?
i cant remember what was the other part of Q5.
Q3: 1st was a sale and leaseback-substance over form risks and rewards saty with the company-incorrect treatment of being recognised as an op lease-did anyone wrote that?
the other part for recognition of associate instead of a sub-mentioned that voting rights/share interest -more investigation needed for substantiating sub or associate-integration of systems??what was that about?
Q2: did anyone remember the indicators for goodwill impairment?the prof skepticism is a very VERY open ended matter so i just put down everything i knew relating to Silvio etc etc
Q1: This was really tricky as it had way too many things to discuss-for part b(17 marks?!?)did anyone mention about forward contracts and related party transactions and short term investments?
for strategy-did anyone mention about doing analytical reviews rather than substantive(transaction balances)as company size and complex-1st time client etc?
what about resources available in audit company?
paper was very daunting and time pressuring i did not manage to answer all of the parts of each question:(
I am very disappointed :( Wish I never chose ACCA seriously.
Can someone tell me whether question 5 was easier than question four? I think I did a grave mistake by choosing question four.
I thought it was a fair paper. Time pressure was extreme. It's impossible to answer everything in depth given the time constraints.
Professional scepticism well tipped as well as ICQ1.
Lengthy paper...full of tricks.
@gabreil exactly u r right.
I managed to complete the paper 100% but i was rushing and couldnt provide enough points to gain goor marks..
I attempted q3 and q4 because i didnt had time to go and read q5 then choose.. i think i did a mistake too as my friends said q5 was easy..
I can just hope that for such difficult attempt checking will be lenient si fingers crossed..
Im very much dissapointed i dont wana attempt p5 now :(
@tez
I didnt atempted q5
Q3 was an operating lease i wrote that :-/ because we were paying rentals at normal market rate and we had an option to buy but at market value not lower than.. thats y i treated it as op lease.
And second should have been recorded as subsidiary for 3 months.
Q1 really was hard. For that treasury dept i mentioned due to its newly established there will be lack of knowledge
1. a) don't know what to write, so i explained what is audit planning and audit strategy, and write about what need to be considered during planinng - so write about the ICS, nature of business, risks, materiality, laws and regulation.
1. b) Audit risks, i don't expect to get marks for the forward contract and also short term investment, as i don't even know the correct accounting treatment, then how to explain the risk? So my risks are capitalisation of licence, revenue recognition from online sales, amortisation of licence, retranslation of oversea sales, split between equity and premium, new audit client, opening balances, capitalisation of development cost of games, and the rest im not sure whether it is a correct classifying it as audit risks, so keep it for myself. lol.
1. c) i don't even know whether i got the procedures right, but i tried my best using the word inspect, confirmation, written rep, disclosure checklist, enquire, ap, recalculate etc...
2. a)i) sale n leaseback, similar to one of the pyq J13. hopefully could answer this well.
2.a)ii) subsi treated as associate, i think no pyq on this, but it is manageable.
2.b) ISA 250! straight away write that on the answer booklet to secure the 1/2 mark and generally discussing responsibility of management n auditor with regards to laws n regulation, lol. and also with some comment on objectivity n intimidation.
3. did not attempt question on professional scepticism cause i'm not sure about the forensic part.
4. From the article audit quality, the scenario is also similar to the one in the article, hopefully secure good marks here to pass the paper.
5.a) this question was a mess, i start reading this question 25 minutes before the exam ends, so everything was rushed, up to some point my handwriting goes up to 2 lines. construction contract ias 11, say company should recognise for 7 months, since the project start from july, and company year end is 31 january,
if not then AR modified, qualified. n basis for qualified.
5.b) provision. ias 37, n contingent liability, adequacy of disclosure, so if inadequate, qualified opinion.
5.c) material inconsistency, OM paragraph, but i did not write this in the answer booklet. I REALLY HATE IT when the invigilator always starts with you collecting the answer scripts, and i don't have any extra time to write, meanwhile others are still writing securing that last bit of passing marks, in order to keep them from drowning, urgh, hopefully not answer this easy 6 marks wont reduce my chance to pass.
Q2 Q4 and Q5 was ok. Q1 im hoping for at least 18/35 inorder to pass the passing mark for this question(provided that other questions also secure half of the marks)
time to focus on P6 on friday. but taking some rest for today and start revising for p6 tomorrow.
Handwriting is another problem. towards the last 5 minutes, God knows what i've written...hoepfully the examiner could read my handwriting.
I think gross profit was overstated because the previous owners were worried about a share price decline if the institutional investors saw a bad performance.
@Byron, i had going concern in mind too when I was reading the scenario 5. b) as the fine is $40mil and the PBT is only $22.5mil, but im not sure whether it is correct, since the lawyer states that the payment is only possible. so i changed my mind and write about adequacy of contingent liability disclosure in notes of FS.
I looked at question 2 b) not only from a fraud and error point of view but from point of view of potential money laundering as criminal concealment - I am probably way of the mark.
As others said, the standards are vital in this exam. Whole range of IAS examined.
Did Q on ethics and in the main talked about ISQC1 as opposed to the normal ethics although there was some objectivity threats.
Q2 a) was challenging - mentioned IFRS13, IAS16, IAS17, Definitely finance lease, new finance asset, new depreciation over 20 years lower of lease rental period and p/l on disposal should be deferred over 20 years.
2nd part was more straightforward with sub being treated incorrectly as an associate.
Challenging paper - dominated by IAS standards.
It was a finance leaseback as lease term is equivalent to asset's remaining useful life and option to repurchase is there at the end.
@Nizar: I also stated about contingent liability as it is possible not probable and extended on the standard...i really hope for a pass...
for q1 part b i also mentioned retranslation of inventory? due to manufacturing is done overseas....aaargh such a bad paper:-(
I have to confirm some previous postings - objectively the exam was fair. Though expected more standard FS and PnL instead some broad EPS calculations...
I think i wasn't enough precise to gain passing marks. Q4 seemed to be complex at first glance so I decided to opt for Q5 however I did have some problems.
Good luck to all.
ya agree it was a finance lease, as the lease term is substantially of the economic life of the leisure centre comples and the company has option to repurchased the leisure centre complex at the end of lease term.
finance lease as it also risks and rewards stay with the Group-sale and leaseback agreement
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

