Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

AAA*** P7 December 2012 Exam *** Instant Poll and comments***

Oopentuition13y ago
Post your comments about December 2012 P7 exam.

Please vote in our Instant Poll
*** P7 December 2012 Exam *** Instant Poll and comments*** poll results



Please note: The ACCA has requested that no postings must be made in this forum before 15:00 GMT on the day of the exam - any postings before this time will be deleted.
Remember that you are studying for a professional qualification - do not make postings that are abusive or threatening. Anyone breaking this rule may be reported to the ACCA disciplinary committee.
Vvishal3213y ago#91
@belize202 said:
low cash balance but still able to cover current liabilities,saying one supplier is a gg concern issue is very absurd,sales decline doesnt mean failure production line,high debt equals gg concern is also very elaborate, directors leaving left on good terms with the company and immediately replaced - the very least is rmm since new directors might not have experience in the industry or experience preparing the fs of the company, saying its a gg concern issue again is very elaborate.


I'm only stating what I have read in the texts and learnt from the past papers, Im only saying that there are indicators of going concern issues - reliance on one supplier, If you refer to page 16 of the attached, the first paragraph will reflect what I am trying to point out i.e) loss of suppliers, loss of key staff
https://www2.accaglobal.com/pubs/members/publications/sector_magazines/in_practice_ireland/archive/2008/43/going_concern.pdf
I don't think highlighting operational issues which maybe seen as a potential risk to going concern are absurd in anyway, the question said identify the business risks.
Former userFormer user13y ago#92
2 days after exam..... Now I can speak about this exam being unprejudiced. First of all - time pressure was significant. I simply needed extra 30 minutes to complete Q2, but factually I only started it. I don't understand logic of our examinator - does she want we answer all questions not thinking deep or she wants we answer well? It is not the first time for me to sit P7, so I dare say that I know well ALL topics of this exam as well as all related technical materials. The problem is that if you know more - you can write more while answering questions but it requires appropriate time. What is tested in P7 - our knowledge or speed of writing?! We are not mashinegunes or troubleshooters, just human beeing! Questions (part 1) are always tricky - of course, we need time to cope with them. I hope - knowledge only is tested. All of us are reading past exam papers while preparing ot the exam. Have a look at answers - lots of text which was written while not beeing under time pressure and all materials available. All normal human being consider official answers - as STANDARD of answer to pass the exam, but factually it is 100% impossible to write all this thext in your answer even if you are prepared well due to incompatibility of time available and question requirements. I don't even say that for many of us English is not mother's tongue. I think, that ACCA team has to perform analysis of fact that P7 has the lowest pass rate for decades! God bless all students!
Aanjali1813y ago#93
question 1 has indicators of going concern as losing key staff and had only 20 customers and had an overdraft and a liquid ration of 0.5 and a current of 1 if i remember very cleary. i think they were indicators of going concern. and also the mention of contingent fees that management were dicussing about. as a stakeholder you would raise question on going concern before investing in such a company .
Vvishal3213y ago#94
@anjali18 said:
question 1 has indicators of going concern as losing key staff and had only 20 customers and had an overdraft and a liquid ration of 0.5 and a current of 1 if i remember very cleary. i think they were indicators of going concern. and also the mention of contingent fees that management were dicussing about. as a stakeholder you would raise question on going concern before investing in such a company .

Agreed - finally someone who understands where I am coming from.
Former userFormer user13y ago#95
@andriy said:
2 days after exam..... Now I can speak about this exam being unprejudiced. First of all - time pressure was significant. I simply needed extra 30 minutes to complete Q2, but factually I only started it. I don't understand logic of our examinator - does she want we answer all questions not thinking deep or she wants we answer well? It is not the first time for me to sit P7, so I dare say that I know well ALL topics of this exam as well as all related technical materials. The problem is that if you know more - you can write more while answering questions but it requires appropriate time. What is tested in P7 - our knowledge or speed of writing?! We are not mashinegunes or troubleshooters, just human beeing! Questions (part 1) are always tricky - of course, we need time to cope with them. I hope - knowledge only is tested. All of us are reading past exam papers while preparing ot the exam. Have a look at answers - lots of text which was written while not beeing under time pressure and all materials available. All normal human being consider official answers - as STANDARD of answer to pass the exam, but factually it is 100% impossible to write all this thext in your answer even if you are prepared well due to incompatibility of time available and question requirements. I don't even say that for many of us English is not mother's tongue. I think, that ACCA team has to perform analysis of fact that P7 has the lowest pass rate for decades! God bless all students!

i agree with you but not strongly because acca wants to test our time management. in real working life, the boss can ask you to produce a report within an hour. this is a good test. however i think it is only fair that ACCA re-consider to allow another one hour for professional level papers ie. four hours fromthe current 3 hours. this will be fair to those who prepared well but not so good at time management. after all, our application of knowledge is being tested and this is the most important. so start exam at 2.00pm and end at 6.00pm. good luck to all.
Mmuneebnawaz9013y ago#96
Well you guys don't forget here .. Those who talk about going concern ! The loan has a lot to do with risk of material misstatement and business risk
Listen revenue is declining .. Company is showing loss , loan is just negotiated and bank will not give loan with this health of the company. Yes current ratio is fine but loan of 30m give rise to significant finance cost !!! Take it in current liabilities what will be the impact ???? Liquidity ratio will dramatically decrease . Because currently inventory .. Receivable all in poor condition. Think broad guys !

1 - overseas supplier .. Supplying poor quality .. Evidence sales return due to poor quality material which comp purchased from foriegn supplier. Exchange and provisions !! Risk

2 - loan

They were the significant risks ..
Which leads to
3 - liquidity risk
Mmuneebnawaz9013y ago#97
4 risk of material misstatement

1 - inventory
2 - exchange rates issue .. Valuation of trade payable
3 - loss of key personnel leads to inherent risk in financial statement
4 - loan
Former userFormer user13y ago#98
In q1, I messed it up as I was talking about development expenditure and borrowing costs, but does anyone actually remember if the had secured the loan or was it still in negotiation?
Former userFormer user13y ago#99
Had they not secured the loan in the July, y/e Nov. Now Dec, and new production line due to commence in the march. Cud be wrong
Former userFormer user13y ago#100
no im not saying raising going concern is wrong , i can definitely see where you are coming from, there are "factors" quote and quote that might indicate that. its just for me to say that they might not be a going concern is very very harsh, are we asaying that the financial statements should not be prepared in a going concern basis? prepare it like theyre folding down their business? despite decline in sales i remember revenue was still very very healthy, sure its not ideal but the decline was less than 10 percent, what companies dont experience that in the current crisis? yet are we saying that all companies that are affected by the crisis or decline in sales have gg concern issues?
i know where youre coming from its just in my opinion to say that would be very harsh and almost like "an easy way out" to answer this type of question --- " oh increased debt gg concern, oh falling sales gg concern"
Former userFormer user13y ago#101
@andriy said:
2 days after exam..... Now I can speak about this exam being unprejudiced. First of all - time pressure was significant. I simply needed extra 30 minutes to complete Q2, but factually I only started it. I don't understand logic
of our examinator - does she want we answer all questions not thinking deep or she wants we answer well? It is not the first time for me to sit P7, so I dare say that I know well ALL topics of this exam as well as all related technical materials. The problem is that if you know more - you can write more while answering questions but it requires appropriate time. What is tested in P7 - our knowledge or speed of writing?! We are not mashinegunes or troubleshooters, just human beeing! Questions (part 1) are always tricky - of course, we need time to cope with them. I hope - knowledge only is tested. All of us are reading past exam papers while preparing ot the exam. Have a look at answers - lots of text which was written while not beeing under time pressure and all materials available. All normal human being consider official answers - as STANDARD of answer to pass the exam, but factually it is 100% impossible to write all this thext in your answer even if you are prepared well due to incompatibility of time available and question requirements. I don't even say that for many of us English is not mother's tongue. I think, that ACCA team has to perform analysis of fact that P7 has the lowest pass rate for decades! God bless all students!



i agree i wonder the same thing does she want us to answer in an uncomplete manner given the time constraint , im sure given the more time we could all answer better n more thoroughly. the pages of examiner's report she's going to come up with i doubt that it will take her less than 3 hrs n 15 mins. and shes typing it in a computer n we all wrote with our hands. so in that sense its a bit unrealistic but i guess the whole point of the acca exam also tests our time management and realistically its impossible to achieve perfection
Former userFormer user13y ago#102
I think people are saying that GC issues was a business risk, ie risk that the entity will not be able to meet its objectives in the future, and not GC as a ROMM as that is risk that company should not have prepared their accounts on a going concern basis at the SOFP, I do not think the latter was the case in the question.

IAS 23 is mandatory in IFRS international.

I dont think that point about the loan was very clear, going by the confusion stated by everyone here lol.

anyway lets forget it and enjoy Christmas :)
Former userFormer user13y ago#103
IAS 23 is optional in IFRS UK/Irish. you probably did UK/Irish version?
Mmuneebnawaz9013y ago#104
Haha I concluded business risk briefing notes and then I thought I didn't discuss compliance risk .. Of not using some chemicals :) I wrote it after conclusion haha presentation I hope marker won't mind as we all were nervous :)
And keyboard ..
U write exactly like me
Except for the loan
Well loss of key personnel was a major risk of material msisstaement because they said good terms means ok no litigation
But what will be the impact of leaving of core staff on financial statement , due to this loss of key personnel I mentioned most of the account balance will not be adjusted properly , definitely a control risk leads to many risk of material misstatement in FS :)
Mmuneebnawaz9013y ago#105
And you know what
Foriegn supplier the only supplier and exchange rates ? OMG ? Valuation of trade payables ? That's the risk anyone wrote that ?
Former userFormer user13y ago#106
it was nice exam. not the difficult one. if any body prepare more than 50% syllabus, s/he definitely pass it
Mmuneebnawaz9013y ago#107
@keyboard did u get time to relate all points in question 2 with income statement and balance sheet ? I just discussed the amount is material .. As per planning materiality not as in revenue , total assets etc .. And wrote insufficient evidence , telling it can be wrong do this n that as per ISA . What do u think ?
Former userFormer user13y ago#108
hey guys, any one attempted the audit report ques...my ans was a disclaimer of opinion because i thought there wasnt sufficient evidence and the matter was material, however was not too sure whether it was pervasive, but given that it affected >1 caption I considered it as such...any thoughts?
Hhalbesri13y ago#109
@frankie,
or any one who did Q5?was it a review engagement? so I think we do not have to write about audit openion I found this after I write and tried to make some adjustment any one else of the same view? any one who remeber Q5 all the marks and questions?
Former userFormer user13y ago#110
overall i didnt find the paper to be difficult but time was a serious issue, didnt have time to do the 22mark ques from q2. Here's a summary of my ans to whole paper as far as i remember...

Q1.
biz risk:
-xchange rate exposure+no hedge
-reliance on one supplier+decreased bargaining power
-Inability to increase local customer base+low market growth
-Loss overseas market share-->reduced revenue
-Faulty prod-->increased cost
-Development-->increased cost+no CF generation soon
-Loss for the year+liquidity issues

ROMM:
-Inventory overstated
-Borrowing cost (i mentioned it should be classified in WIP because development had not been completed @YE but im really not sure about this, it got me a bit) + I included the calculation, but for the part of borrowing cost to include in WIP I excluded to part relating to overdraft-dont know how correct that is)
-Misclassification of overdraft
-Going concern disclosure due to BR in Q1 (honestly i think my brain froze, i could pick up any other misstatements so, i just put the GC)

Ethical issues: (im not really good at those)
FC:
-familiarity to audit team
-self-interest
Audit fee:
-size of fee should not be >norm
-risk profile of client
-No contingent fee

b)Insurance recoverabilty:
*Assess mgnt's assumptions for recoverable amount
*Recoverability of balance from insurance
-obtain confirmation of recoverable from insurer
-obtain policy docs
-review policy's terms and conditions of claim recoverability
-Obtain management's schedule
-Check accuracy of schedule
-Trace a sample of items to invoices (Inventory purchase)
-review classification of adjustment

Q2: (only had time to answer general state the adv and disad of joint audit did not relate to the small scenario:
ADV:
-share resources
-shared knowledge of incumbent auditor
-cost efficiency
-way of reducing 'big 4' power
DISAD:
-2 fees to be paid (increased costs)
-different metholodgies (potential for conflict)

Q3)
a)Tender doc: (wasnt sure about this either)
-audit firm and audit team's competence & experience
-time-table
-fees
-audit methology
-management responsibilities
-regulations of stock exchange

b)Ethical issues (not my strong point):
1)-risk of taking on high risk client simply to boost sales & ultimately bonus
-put company in an advocacy threat position if the company were to ever be GC
-self review
-familiarity
2)-self review
-management threat-reporting to board as external audit on issues about management which as internal auditor contributing to

Q4)DID NOT CHOOSE THIS OPTION

Q5)
ai)Effect on audit report
-evidence=insufficient
-written representation=insufficient (cannot delegate responsibility for obtaining evidence to the outsourcee)
-issue=material
-issue=pervasive (affects >1 caption in FS)
-inform TCWG (ISA260)
-inform mgnt of deficiency (ISA265)
-Issue modified audit report (disclaimer of opinion)

ii)QC
-2nd partner review of appropriateness of opinion
-review of evidence supporting opinion
-review documentation and work of audit team members-whether followed appropriate QC policies

b)Interim review (did not go over this topic, so just scribbles some notes)
-calculation of materiality (@YE and interim period-both material)
-appropriateness of zero provision given unlikely that all 3year warranties would have expired even if no new ones
-Interim report-subject to more adj @YE
-should review above before providing negative assurance on interim report on whether free from any material misstatement, esp related to warranties.


ANYONE THNK I CAN AT LEAST SCORE A 50%, its my first attempt and did not have time to practice past papers so i really dont know how examiner approaches marking....
Former userFormer user13y ago#111
@halbesri
Q5) discuss the actions that auditor should take and the implication to the audit report.
my ans is referred above..i think a review engagement was part b)
Mmuneebnawaz9013y ago#112
In review part . I mistakenly took it as audit
But anyway provision must be recognised . As per given numbers , provision was material last time
Plus an implied obligation! So they can't stop like that.
Discuss with mgmt , adjust it , no change to the interim report.
If not adjust then obviously it will have an impact as per negative assurance
Former userFormer user13y ago#113
in q5 one of matters was below materiality, so only second one remains materially misstated so proposed a except for qualification
Former userFormer user13y ago#114
Q2 is required to write too much... and it is not so hard, but again, it seems test on writing speed.
Former userFormer user13y ago#115
Q2 is tough.

It asked to explained to junior auditor who dont know why a change in materiality from $ 700,000 to $ 900,000 on goingly throught the audit.

My Conclusion,
Part a)
IAS 200 Objective and conduct of the auditor - remain scepticism/objecticity
IAS 320 materiality and IAS 600 Group audit - consider the risk as a whole.

Part b) Consider material mistatement and the sufficient appropriate of evidence
For no mention of evidence simply quote related International accounting standards like IFRS 9 Financial instrument or IFRS 3 Business combination for goodwill to discuss the inherent risk. External evidence is a reliable source. Internally generated non written evidence is less appropriate.

As no related internal control information is mentioned, control risk is not a main issue here.

It relates more to the detection risk:
fraud/error/understatement/overstatement/omission at the financial statement level.

For this question, there is impossible to know exactly what the examiner required of, as long as we show a profound knowledge in auditing standards and practices. Should be ok!
Aashebir213y ago#116
Relatively with the previous p7 exams this one was fair,but still little time shortage
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.