Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

AAA*** P7 December 2012 Exam *** Instant Poll and comments***

Oopentuition13y ago
Post your comments about December 2012 P7 exam.

Please vote in our Instant Poll
*** P7 December 2012 Exam *** Instant Poll and comments*** poll results



Please note: The ACCA has requested that no postings must be made in this forum before 15:00 GMT on the day of the exam - any postings before this time will be deleted.
Remember that you are studying for a professional qualification - do not make postings that are abusive or threatening. Anyone breaking this rule may be reported to the ACCA disciplinary committee.
Mmarcin06048213y ago#61
HI

The exam was ok. During 15 minutes reading time I started writing in answer booklet and then was interrupted by invigilator (I forgot I am not allowed to write in an answer booklet - exam heat, nerves etc). She took my booklet and has given me a new fresh one - do you think it will adversely affect my exam marking?

Cheers
Former userFormer user13y ago#62
Yeah gwen I wrote about impairment indicator of falling revenue and ifrs 5 but I don't quite remember the question. Paper was ok question 2
Was easy the time management destroyed the whole high hope praying to GOD I pass
Former userFormer user13y ago#63
And Marcin I don't think it will affect your marking! Happens all the time :) cheers!
Ttrinistudent00113y ago#64
I attempted Q1, 2, 3 and 5. Like you, Ikristalj, I avoided Q4 couldnt remember anything about Revenue Recognition. I was able to attempt 98% of the paper. Wasnt able to finish part (b) of Q1 due to time pressure. I spent a lot of time on Q1 and Q2, and most of the points that you all have mentioned I have gotten, praise God. Cuz I was praying that I was approaching it in the way that it should be.

I'm not being overconfident about my efforts, but I wrote until my arm started to pain me. This is my last paper, so I am praying for a pass. Really praying!
Former userFormer user13y ago#65
Best of luck Trinis :) cheers!
Mmarcin06048213y ago#66
hi khurramsalee1989

many thanks, I am too nervous I think :) Overall the exam was ok, nobody can say it was difficult. Definitely time pressured - I started with q3 and q4 and wrote well (I guess) and then I had less time to properly embark on q2 and q1.

By the way what did you write regarding associate - what was the problem with it ? I thought the problem was that it has't grown on B/S which was strange. Also I wrote that 1/3 of sub should not be separately disclosed on the face of B/S because that wouldn't comply with IFRS 5 - is it correct?

Re business risks q1:
- FX fluctuations exposure
- reliance on 1 supplier
and few other stuff I don't remember.

From F/S risks I wrote about inventory - should be written down, about FX losses and gains not included in reserves in full, about possible mistakes (loss of financial controller) and I don't remember the 4th one.

The problem was that I spent too much time on q3 and q4 ( I started with these q's).



@khurramsaleem1989 said:
And Marcin I don't think it will affect your marking! Happens all the time :) cheers!
Former userFormer user13y ago#67
Yeah the fact that the audit team did nothing and the associate balance didn't change could indicate that the movement in associate was un accounted for under equity method. Yes I was preparing accounts at one of our kpmg clients at least a heading held for sale should have been there under ifrs 5 (am an audit semi senior :) ) though I didn't write any procedures as question stated so and yes our q1 answers match major risks being exposure to fluctuations in forex debt servicing and repayment impairment of inventories and compliance risks
Mmarcin06048213y ago#68
I think there was one more business risk - if you looked at cash balance it was very very low compared to the size of the entity - poor cash balance is a business risk as the company may not be able to finance it's day to day operations which was even more exacerbated by the fact that they have already took a loan from the bank to fund large capital expenditure project.

@khurramsaleem1989 said:
Yeah the fact that the audit team did nothing and the associate balance didn't change could indicate that the movement in associate was un accounted for under equity method. Yes I was preparing accounts at one of our kpmg clients at least a heading held for sale should have been there under ifrs 5 (am an audit semi senior :) ) though I didn't write any procedures as question stated so and yes our q1 answers match major risks being exposure to fluctuations in forex debt servicing and repayment impairment of inventories and compliance risks
Former userFormer user13y ago#69
Yes I mentioned that as well relating to cash flows calculated interest covers further compounded that a 2.5 million overdraft existed in the company
Former userFormer user13y ago#70
Before being converted I thought that the banks were idiots but I didn't overtly blew the going concern trumpet because the bank is confident in the investment plus the company developing new production line means that the company still has some bite and the ratios weren't that bad especially the acid test ratio of .8 which values stock at 0 practically
Former userFormer user13y ago#71
@trinistudent001 said:
I attempted Q1, 2, 3 and 5. Like you, Ikristalj, I avoided Q4 couldnt remember anything about Revenue Recognition. I was able to attempt 98% of the paper. Wasnt able to finish part (b) of Q1 due to time pressure. I spent a lot of time on Q1 and Q2, and most of the points that you all have mentioned I have gotten, praise God. Cuz I was praying that I was approaching it in the way that it should be.

I'm not being overconfident about my efforts, but I wrote until my arm started to pain me. This is my last paper, so I am praying for a pass. Really praying!


Another Trini!! Hope you get through!!!
Mmuneebnawaz9013y ago#72
Well as in report part . Non adjustment of provision was material to financial statement as stated in the question. Plus there was a present obligation , implied as the question against focused on past practices which makes them adjust the provision , if not give except for , if adjusted un modified
Ggudluck13y ago#73
^ Muneeb you were reviewing financial statements at the interim stage i dont think it had anything to do with expression of an opinion.
Ggudluck13y ago#74
1 part :) FS Risks
IAS 2 Inventory Write off
IAS 36 Production line impairment
IAS 23 Borrowing costs non-capitalization
IAS 1 Going Concern

I did know that FX risk is there, but wasnt soo sure about the treatment so did not write on that.


on 2nd Part :)

Wrote about the ISA 580 Written representations, Some quality issues, FS risks.
Ggudluck13y ago#75
@keyboard said:
cant remeber much, but in question 2 , i thought HFS item was wrongly placed in NCA, it should be under CA and I/s should show discontinued operations


I thought the classification was correct, but the amount recorded could have been wrong. Since you had to value it at lower of CV and FV, and the procedure they had used would only provide evidence about the FV. So i just criticized the procedure and said that it might have been recorded at FV and thus overstated.
And Plus you could write about depreciation there as well. Whether the entity has stopped depreciating the asset.
Mmarcin06048213y ago#76
good luck to everyone, let's forget this exam it's over now it's past let's concentrate on future;)

cheers
Former userFormer user13y ago#77
By my opinion it was a fair paper but very time pressured if you wanted to answer the 1st question properly...the 2nd one was ok but most of us by the time got there we realised we had 1.5 hrs left to finish 3 more questions...i wrote 21 pages, hope it's enough and no fundamental mistakes made...fingers crossed for all of us
Former userFormer user13y ago#78
@ keyboard, yes i said that about the fx havin to be recorded at spot rate first translated as sofp date and gains/losses to the I/s, that was Q1 as i think i had that as a potential material mistatement ? i said that the profit on disposal of 2M shouldnt be netted of expenses but i didnt go so far as to say that that would have decreased reported profit when taken out, hopefully get some marks for mentioning it.. think that was Q2 not sure. i also said about the ppe that we did not know what type of property was disposed off as not enough evidence so couldnt determine whether it was accounted for correctly hence a material misstatement.
In Q1, I think i messed up here as i stated as a business risk the new production line had just started (now dec) to comply with regulations in march 2013 and the risk of not being ready or sufficient could waste the capital expenditure and incurr penalties, reducing profits, however, in the matterial misstatement part i spoke about development exp and borrowing costs being capitialised incorrectly, this was a mistake, i should have been talking about the loan as if the work has only started then the the magority capital expenditure not incurred yet, ie loan funds not used yet
Ppatreinam13y ago#79
The paper was fair with the exception of ques 2. The requirements were not clear at all. Attempted 92% of the paper so I hope I can score a 50 although ques 2 really throw me off.

I rushed and forgot to mention a few points I had jot down on the question paper.

Really praying for the 50. All the best to everyone.
Former userFormer user13y ago#80
In regards to the 25% reduced turnover in subsidiary, well maybe not a area for a great deal of thought, as some subsidiaries can have very little or no turnover at all, whereby their main source of income is from inter-group dividends. The question did not classify the significance of the subsidiary, the parent's share holding, or it's statement of comprehensive income, so I left it at that.
I did however note the non-amortised Goodwill amounts, and enquired to management if they saw the parents investments as having an indefinate life.
Kkamran_bsh13y ago#81
I think Q2 was really hard.On its own exam was very time pressured.Section two was ok.Also Q1 was alright.The only mistake i made in Q1 was that i took loan as finance cost and not as a borrowing cost.I dont know if that was right or wrong.
Former userFormer user13y ago#82
UGHHHH first of all i regretted reading your comments,made me doubt my answers!!! lol

Q2 was definitely the trickiest,i read you guys mentioning some of the problem identified with the 9 key points,but from what i remember they asked how is the key points adjustments going to affect the closing of the audit..correct me if im wrong..but just mentioning whats wrong with the key points doesnt really answer the question in my understanding ,i mean how is it gonna affect the audit closing or something aaaaaa n i couldnt....goshhh lisa!

Q1 had a lot of possible answers to it but I saw a lot of u guys mentioned gg concern as business risk?? i dont know it didnt really cross my mind as if they were having going concern problem,sure they're adding debt but from what i remember current ratio was still more than 1 (1,1 if im not wrong) and they have enough cash to cover the interest.it didnt really strike me as they are having going concern,i mean revenue is just down by less than 10percent i think,seems to me its just like another company in the current crisis / financial weather having difficulties. i might be wrong but i didnt list out gg concern.

i still wish i hadnt read your comments,really doubting myself now lol 8feb come faster!! all the best guys!
Mmarcin06048213y ago#83
I think the business risk was not going concern but relatively low cash balance compared to the whole business - it was around thousands something like that - how are you going to fund your working capital requirements etc with such a low cash balance on a daily basis?

And going concern would be an Finan. Stat. Risk not a business one I guess :)

btw I THINK the exam was not easy it is just so time pressured - I am sure most of us would guess what was the problem with loan and rest etc having more time. I just didn't have time to think more about these issues, but it's always better to write something and make an assumption than to write nothing ( so always a chance for a mark )

Also there was an issue with revenue and costs - there was a fall in revenue and rise in cost of sales? why???


@belize202 said:
UGHHHH first of all i regretted reading your comments,made me doubt my answers!!! lol

Q2 was definitely the trickiest,i read you guys mentioning some of the problem identified with the 9 key points,but from what i remember they asked how is the key points adjustments going to affect the closing of the audit..correct me if im wrong..but just mentioning whats wrong with the key points doesnt really answer the question in my understanding ,i mean how is it gonna affect the audit closing or something aaaaaa n i couldnt....goshhh lisa!

Q1 had a lot of possible answers to it but I saw a lot of u guys mentioned gg concern as business risk?? i dont know it didnt really cross my mind as if they were having going concern problem,sure they're adding debt but from what i remember current ratio was still more than 1 (1,1 if im not wrong) and they have enough cash to cover the interest.it didnt really strike me as they are having going concern,i mean revenue is just down by less than 10percent i think,seems to me its just like another company in the current crisis / financial weather having difficulties. i might be wrong but i didnt list out gg concern.

i still wish i hadnt read your comments,really doubting myself now lol 8feb come faster!! all the best guys!
Vvishal3213y ago#84
Low cash balance, only one supplier, failure of production line, high borrowings, senior directors leaving = going concern issues
Former userFormer user13y ago#85
@abbas12345555

I wrote exactly what you posted on page 3 and 4. We are sailors of same ship :P
Jjabran13y ago#86
Hi guys,
any idea about marking scheme of Q1(A). i mentioned only 8 business risks. 0.5 marks for identification and 1.5 for explanation, was that right or i had to mention twelve to score full.
Former userFormer user13y ago#87
can anybody remember the questions for Q5

remember marks were:
7
3
6

but not what each was for?? this is my defining Q - pass this and im done i think??!!
Former userFormer user13y ago#88
@vishal32 said:
Low cash balance, only one supplier, failure of production line, high borrowings, senior directors leaving = going concern issues



low cash balance but still able to cover current liabilities,saying one supplier is a gg concern issue is very absurd,sales decline doesnt mean failure production line,high debt equals gg concern is also very elaborate, directors leaving left on good terms with the company and immediately replaced - the very least is rmm since new directors might not have experience in the industry or experience preparing the fs of the company, saying its a gg concern issue again is very elaborate.
Former userFormer user13y ago#89
@vishal32 said:
Low cash balance, only one supplier, failure of production line, high borrowings, senior directors leaving = going concern issues



low cash balance but still able to cover current liabilities,saying one supplier is a gg concern issue is very absurd,sales decline doesnt mean failure production line,high debt equals gg concern is also very elaborate, directors leaving left on good terms with the company and immediately replaced - the very least is rmm since new directors might not have experience in the industry or experience preparing the fs of the company, saying its a gg concern issue again is very elaborate.
Former userFormer user13y ago#90
The questions were fairly easy but like you all rightly said, TIME was an issue and for paper P7,it will always be an issue. I salute the guy who said he had 5mins to spare. Thats totally a tall order for me personally. I however have concluded that this P7 is designed for NO ONE to finish. I dont exactly know what acca is testing with that.

Question 1 was ok but extremely loaded
Question 2 also. I barely answered the 18 marks parts cos of time but i knew it.
Had no clue as to question 5 so didnt bother.
I only pray for a pass. This paper has been a burden to me for over a year!!and this diet is sure my time. I remain positive. ]

Goodluck to those still writing exams!!!
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.