Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

AAA*** P7 December 2012 Exam *** Instant Poll and comments***

Oopentuition13y ago
Post your comments about December 2012 P7 exam.

Please vote in our Instant Poll
*** P7 December 2012 Exam *** Instant Poll and comments*** poll results



Please note: The ACCA has requested that no postings must be made in this forum before 15:00 GMT on the day of the exam - any postings before this time will be deleted.
Remember that you are studying for a professional qualification - do not make postings that are abusive or threatening. Anyone breaking this rule may be reported to the ACCA disciplinary committee.
Wwasimkhanwazir13y ago#31
overall paper was ok except Q. 2 containing some trap almost in all adjustments. but i just rise to the occasion and get the job done well.
Ssthilaireg13y ago#32
Reasonable exams but time pressured.

Thanks for the breakdown on q1. It was my my best question. Reckon I should pick up maximum points on the business risks and the 4 misstatements. (I even worked out the borrowing cost to be capitalized here ($0.46 m).

Question 2 was horrible and I did not even touch the balance sheet notes.
Don't remember the second part of question 2 for 6 marks but I think I answered it.

I did questions 3 and 4 which were not difficult but was time pressured. Dropped marks (maybe up to 10 in total) on these questions just for not attempting parts at all. Horrible, because they were easy marks (Internal/external audit ethics in q3 and forensic audit in question 4)

Anyone with the breakdown of the marks in questions 2, 3 and 4 please post.
Former userFormer user13y ago#33
Cheers ugras for breakdown. Glad it was "only" 18.
Uugras0513y ago#34
Q3 was 8 marks for specific tender document and 8 marks for ethics,

Q4 was 6 marks for Revenue Recognition, 4marks for Forensic Investigation and other 6 i left it.

Q2 was 4 marks for changing materiality during the Audit, 6 marks for advantages and disadvantages of joint audit and 18 marks for the horrible accounting treatment.
Uugras0513y ago#35
Adam no problem mate, Im glad it was 18 as well, wish it was 10 but hey.
Former userFormer user13y ago#36
Cool, had it in my head it was 22 marks but forgot 4 professional marks in question 1. Numpty. Good luck everyone
Former userFormer user13y ago#37
I thought Q1 was ok, but Q2 I seem to have gone waaay off track on...what was it actually looking for in Part B?

@sthilaireg, I *think* the breakdowns are:

Q2
a) Materiality Levels - 4
b) The 9 scenarios - 18
c) Joint audits - 6
Total - 28

Q3
a) Tender letter - 8
b) Ethics - 8
Total - 16

Q4
a) Jewellery (income realisation?) - 6
b) Window Salesman (Fraud) - 6
c) Forensic Auditing - 4
Total - 16

Hopefully that's right, if not hopefully someone can amend!

In Q1a (iii) for the ethical considerations, I remember the Financial Controller position and the auditor going for interview, but what were the others?

I'm very borderline, Q2b and Q3a really didn't go well for me at all, think it could be a resit :(
Ssthilaireg13y ago#38
O.K.

So in summary:

Q1 Business Risks 12 marks
4 Misstatements 8 Marks
Ethical Issues 8 marks
Insurance claim 8 marks
Professional marks 4 marks

Q2 Change in Materiality levels during planning 4 marks
Advantages and disadvantages of joint audits 6 marks
Accounting (various IASs) 18 marks

Q 3 Tender documents 8 marks
Ethics (Financial controller and Internal/External audit) 8 marks

Q4 Revenue recognition 6 marks
????? 6 marks
Forensic Audit 4 marks
Can someone please fill in q 4.
Former userFormer user13y ago#39
considering question 2 part b had 9 scenarios and every scenario was worth 2 marks. Major scenarios were related to revenue, goodwill, acturial loss, assets held for sale and 3 specific scenarios in which the audit team didn't bother to collect evidence. You only had to tell whether these scenarios would be susceptible to material misstatements and whether sufficient audit evidence was collected and reccomend if further evidence was needed. How was this question difficult?

I had trouble finding material misstatements in the first question. I found risks related to the overdraft and new loan and their impact on financial statements. The new supplier and the risk of the payables opening balance being understated, the foreign currency risk and the treatment of gain or loss as it would have to be included in full because the company had no hedge. I don't know if all were right but I made logic and it sounded correct. The business risks part was extremely easy and the ethical considerations was a walk in the park.

Are my material misstatement risks right? I have doubts over this area.
00500896713y ago#40
@abbas12345555 said:
considering question 2 part b had 9 scenarios and every scenario was worth 2 marks. Major scenarios were related to revenue, goodwill, acturial loss, assets held for sale and 3 specific scenarios in which the audit team didn't bother to collect evidence. You only had to tell whether these scenarios would be susceptible to material misstatements and whether sufficient audit evidence was collected and reccomend if further evidence was needed. How was this question difficult?

I had trouble finding material misstatements in the first question. I found risks related to the overdraft and new loan and their impact on financial statements. The new supplier and the risk of the payables opening balance being understated, the foreign currency risk and the treatment of gain or loss as it would have to be included in full because the company had no hedge. I don't know if all were right but I made logic and it sounded correct. The business risks part was extremely easy and the ethical considerations was a walk in the park.

Are my material misstatement risks right? I have doubts over this area.


Hey, I was a bit worried on Q2 after seeing everyone panic on here. For the 9 scenarios, I gave a heading for each (skipped a couple of the nasty ones to save time)... for example, the goodwill I wrote that it was subjective and complex accounting under ias38 plus no mention of whether the subsidiaries were aquired or if internally branded. Insufficient evidence. Said that the bank loan evidence from the bank was sufficient and approp.
Ssthilaireg13y ago#41
For the material misstatement, I did Inventory, Provisions, Borrowing costs (the loan for the new plant ) and the overdraft/cash and their presentation in the SOFP.
00500896713y ago#42
Anyone do Q5??
Vvishal3213y ago#43
Looking back I don't think q2 was as difficult as it would have seemed in the exam. The pressure in the exam and unexpected format of q2 would have made many people panic. Overall 9 small scenarios with 2 marks for stating risk of misstatement and sufficiency of audit evidence. Doesn't seem too bad. It's all easy in hindsight though.
Former userFormer user13y ago#44
@abbas12345555 said:
considering question 2 part b had 9 scenarios and every scenario was worth 2 marks. Major scenarios were related to revenue, goodwill, acturial loss, assets held for sale and 3 specific scenarios in which the audit team didn't bother to collect evidence. You only had to tell whether these scenarios would be susceptible to material misstatements and whether sufficient audit evidence was collected and reccomend if further evidence was needed. How was this question difficult?

I had trouble finding material misstatements in the first question. I found risks related to the overdraft and new loan and their impact on financial statements. The new supplier and the risk of the payables opening balance being understated, the foreign currency risk and the treatment of gain or loss as it would have to be included in full because the company had no hedge. I don't know if all were right but I made logic and it sounded correct. The business risks part was extremely easy and the ethical considerations was a walk in the park.

Are my material misstatement risks right? I have doubts over this area.




Would you mind sharing the ethics points you found? i was a bit stuck on this as wasn't sure if the audit manager going to the company was self review, and thought the fee might have something to do with intimidation but i wasn't entirely confident!!
Pprateshramjohn13y ago#45
Based on the breakdown, I think I got a pass. But Lets wait and see. If anything pulled me down, it was the option questions and the time management.
Former userFormer user13y ago#46
I'm new here so don't know how to quote. I'll just tag you and answer.

@05008967 Yes it was like that, however I didn't quote proper IAS's in a couple of scenarios I knew what had to be done and how they had to be treated. I just made 9 different headings and explained how they could be materially misstated Like in revenue it just said one sub had 25% less revenue and others were stable. I explained either this one subsidiary could be manipulating revenue or other 4 accelerating - as revenue should be recognized when rights transferred. To conclude properly we need to find more audit evidence, evidence not sufficient. I explained the scenarios like this and made sense and answered the requirements.

@makemesparkle I thought the auditor, Bob, interviewing would create some problems because independence and objectivity are seen as both from the point of view of one self and from the point of view of others. However I also said there are appropriate safeguards for this. The other thing was that bob was last year's auditor and our new team might at some point want to consult bob on opening balances and going concern issues as he would have more knowledge of the business. Him being enticed by Grahl co's offer would impede his judgement. I just recommended that he should take the interview after the audit is completed
Former userFormer user13y ago#47
in the first question related to material misstatements I wrote about the treatment of returned goods - the risk of double sales being booked. About inventory i wrote that the inventory returned should be added back and new value to the returned inventory should be calculated either scrap or resale after repairs. Then there was the foreign exchange bit and i blabbered about the risk of no proper treatment for foreign exchange and the recognition of loss or gain. I then came to the loan which I think I might have messed up because I didn't talk about borrowing costs and it being capitalised, I just said that the finance charges related to it weren't recorded as both years had 800 finance charges. Then i talked about payables and new supplier.

How much of this could be right? I think I messed this part up pretty bad
Former userFormer user13y ago#48
the paper was ok overall..except the 18marks question of number 2..
now since many has found the paper affordable, i fear they reduce the pass mark and correct the paper severely leading to failures...

i mentioned that interest is materially mistated as compared to the interest should be payable to the loan in the first question.
any1 mentioned tht?
Wwillynwilson13y ago#49
This is completely irrelevant to the answers to the questions, but did anyone else notice that the company's in the Q's were rockstars surnames?!

I think Hendrix was one,Dylan another can't remember the others.
Former userFormer user13y ago#50
Kobain too!

Can anyone remember the ethical query surrounding fees in Q1? What was that about again?
Aaliboy913y ago#51
As far as I wrote in ethical issue regarding fee...Contingent fee is is not allowed as it will threat auditor's objectivity by creating self interest threat as auditor may compromise any key audit findings in order to collect fee from Grohl. I recommended Lowering the fee if possible considering no effect and no compromise on quality of audit.
Former userFormer user13y ago#52
Thanks!

I remember it coming up, just can't remember how it was worded in the paragraph...it's been a long day :(
Aaliboy913y ago#53
Kindly let me know where I was right and where wrong...

Did Q1,2,3,4 but found Q2 ,18 mark part quite difficult as I was unable to figure out what examiner is trying to ask.

Time pressured definitely.

Q1. There were lots of Business and Material misstatement risks, but was unable to put all of them into answer sheet.

ethical issues regarding Bob joining Grohl was a fair question.
I wrote advising Bob of any adverse consequences of joining Grohl to both the client and the firm. Self interest threat ,self review threat , familiarity and intimidation threats would rise if Bob joined Grohl.

-Recommended to advise Grohl not to hire Bob,
- Changing entire engagement team to eliminate threats
-or resign considering the level of seniority involved ( though wrote that resigning should be the last resort if safeguards could not be implemented to lower the threats)

Q2 faced real difficulties in 18 marks question though a tricky question was expected as usual.

Reassessing materiality:
- auditor may come accross further findings during audit
- acquisition can require reassessing materilty at component level as well as group level
-Severe litigation can result in provision exposing amount to Material misstatement therefore materiality may be reassessed
-
Q3 -revenue recognition discussed its importance to investors shareholders and therefore is subject to manipulation

- Matter of risk and rewards
-consignment matters
and couple of other matters

part (:) I pointed out that revenue should not be recognised until 9 months have passed or the stuff was sold at the external retailers

where as for internal retailers revenue should not be recognized until sold

there was joint audit question as well and wrote some points such as cost timing dispute between auditors , high fee engaging 2 auditors etc.

Q4 dont remember now :( can any body write the break down of question 4
Sstar13y ago#54
the papaer seemed fair, except for Q2 which was quite difficult, apart from that the major issue was time to complete all the requirements.
I trust God that I will pass.
Hharripool13y ago#55
Did anyone else notice that the financial controller and senior exec team had left the firm in Q1 to pursue a recyclable business opportunity? I went on about the remaining board not developing strategies to keep them competitive and this could give rise to going concern risk, given the other issues in the scenario
Former userFormer user13y ago#56
at first i didnt think it was too bad.., however, questions where so long and so much to think about, i spent over half hour reading it, toooo long on business risks for only 12 marks! so many there, but then should have focused on significant ones, so my fault! F/s risks - inventory impairment, capitalisation of borrowing costs along with capitalisation of development expenditure, cant remember fourth one i did, finished rest of Q1 ok, but now 12pm! Q3 and Q4 seemed easy but attempted Q2 next, the short bits were fine but part B was a disaster, looking back on it now, i am kicking myself as i just didnt get what they were looking for! everything seemed material to 700k! however things like the pension i think should have said no mention about service cost, net finance charge, liability/asset in the b/s think this is what they were looking for.. no mention of disclosures anywhere in my panic. and no time to do question 3 or 4. :( wished id done q3 and q4, and bits in q2 and leaving q2 (b) to the end as it swallowed up everything my calculator was barely touched.. arrrrgggghhh
Former userFormer user13y ago#57
did anyone mention in Q2 B on the goodwill, revenue gone down by 25% in one sub so clear sign of impairment of goodwill? or what about the associate, as it was kept for investment income was is asset held for sale?
Mmuneebnawaz9013y ago#58
Business risks
Exchange risk
No hedging - forward exchange contract
Poor quality - increased provisions in future
Loan - current loss situation bank would restrict to provide finance
Liquidity position - now fine but after including intrest and revalued inventory will go down dramatically
Compliance risk as new production line involves non use of some chemical

Risk of material misstatement :
Inventory valuation
Loss of key personnel specially finance controller leads to non adjustments of provision. As we have just draft financial statement at the moment .
Foriegn supplier : valuation of trade payable risk involved due to exchange risk
Loan : non adjustment of loan interest

Ethical threats :
Appointment of financial controller hmm perceives to be taking management role , significant threat. Again self intrest and self review threat.

Contingent fees issue .. Intimidation threat .. In order to secure fees , audit firm will not be objective in finding and act in favour of client again significant threat and should be properly death with. Contingent fees ? NEVER !


As second part : insurance cover
Correspondences , confirmations regarding amount and likelihood. If virtually certain record it as contingent asset , not receivable . And probable then give disclosure !!

That's the first question :)
Former userFormer user13y ago#59
Really not sure how I've done in this paper, keeping my fingers crossed I've done enough to pass.

On the whole the paper seemed reasonable (it's my first sitting of P7), however I just felt Q1 anmd Q2 were quite timely and like everyone I struggled to finish the exam through time constraints!

Q1 - I started the question going on about the material mistatements, however I realised that the question was asking about business risks, so I integrated Parts i) and ii) together - for business risk, I explained about Exchange rate risks, interest rate risks and the main risk as being that the company had a clear going concern risk (suffering in export market (half it's customers), supplying faulty goods to domestic (other half of customers), less revenue, very low current/quick ratio etc. I also outlined the material mistatements and concluded that 4 that needed attention were the fact that fin statements could of been manipulated by company in seeking the finance loan (eg o/s of assets and u/stating liabilities etc, risk that loan was not correctly classified under NCL'S and CL's and interest wasnt included in accounts as finance charge had remained the same, also risk that company had not prepared accounts on a break up basis for going concern etc

The ethical issues were auditor becoming an employee of client - argued this was cause of his removal from audit team - self int, familiarity and intimidation threats could arise. Also advised he should not be allowed to hold a position with audit client until 2 years have passed etc. The other issue was contingent fees - argued these are not permitted for audit work - self int threat and issue of audit being of lower quality etc.

Th other was audit matters and procedures re insurance claim. I just waffled on this - Advised possible contingent asset - disclosure required though unsure on this? Also procedures eg looking at insurance claim submitted, viewing insurance documents, asking for expert advice, writing to insurance company as to whether claim is likely to succeed etc.

Q2 - a) Materiality - why it will change, just defined materiality and stated it will change when circumstances come to light n risk increases etc

b) I left this til last and if I'm honest didn't answer it too well!

c) Advs/disadvs of joint auditors - used common sense hope I got some of them - Advs - Gives better credibility to process for fin users as more independance, better detection of risk etc disadvs - conflict as they may have different ways of working, more timely and therefore costly, coulks severely disrupt business operations etc

Q2 - Not answered greatly on the whole!!

Q3 - Tendering process - listed what I felt should be in tender document again using common sense - eg, fees and how calc, timescales, the list goes on I did try and waffle around 7/8 points. Part :) Ethics - Firm wanted to increase revenue - offer of other audit work - explained threats eg objectivity compromised - self int threat etc. Offer to do internal audit function - eg self review threat and highly unethical etc

Q5) made a quick decision to do this over Q4. Diificult to remember the question. I remember part of it was to comment on a warranty provision that had been left out the accounts as the company had stopped doing warranties in the year. Argued provision needed to be left in as warranty had a 3 year life, so warranty claims were possible during this period. Also impact on audit statement would be an modified opinion if this miststaement was not corrected. The other part was that the companys receivable, payroll and revenue data was outsourced and had been destroyed etc and discuss matters and what audit opinion. Sted audit opinion was to give a diclaimed of opinion as the issue was material and pervasive and there was insufficient info on which to base the opinion etc. Think there was a 3 mark qu on quality. Not sure what I wrote, something quick!

Good luck, here's hoping I don't have to do a re-sit in June! :)
Former userFormer user13y ago#60
Practically every name was music related.. I wrote them on my docket to remember.. But my docket is in the car.. Haha...

I did question 5 and avoided 4 like the plague as I couldn't remember anything on Revenue.. And four marks in fraud wasn't enough.. I'm sure I was able to get more than 4 out of the 16 for q5.

I managed to finish the exam with 5 minutes to spare and this scares me. Hoping for the best!! On to p5 now!!
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.