Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

ATX*** P6 December 2012 Exam *** Instant Poll and comments***

Oopentuition13y ago
Post your comments about December 2012 P6 exam.

Please vote in our Instant Poll
*** P6 December 2012 Exam *** Instant Poll and comments*** poll results


Please note:
Remember that you are studying for a professional qualification - do not make postings that are abusive or threatening.
Former userFormer user13y ago#61
@kdsgreenmachine said:
Regarding question 2 and carry back of losses made in the first 4 years of trading, did anyone apportion the property business profits across the tax years. I just took it that property business profits for 2009/10 were the actual profits for tax year 2009/10, etc. I hope that was right and we weren't supposed to apportion the profits from April to March.


do you mean did people do the basis periods?

i think that was his way of testing more than one area! bit tricky with the pre trading expediture and the bonus also, i just added both in, wasnt sure about petrol, but didnt really think he wanted to go there with the whole AMAP/pvt use as there was basically no info, so i just allowed it as a cost!!
Mmuneebnawaz9013y ago#62
@haylee69 said:
I'm pretty sure there was details on the gift to trust - it said uk shares to the value of £320000? On q4 there were no details so had to assume but there was a line on q5 else you wouldn't have been able to work out the IHT?



Yes I know Abt 320000 so ? How much tax was paid ? Gross chargeable transfer ? I can't see any such thing ? Can u correct me ? And where bands are required they are given in exams
Former userFormer user13y ago#63
News People. I didn't take DTR. I hope that doesn't make difference to pass :( Lost easy 1 mark

@kdsgreenmachine said:
Regarding question 2 and carry back of losses made in the first 4 years of trading, did anyone apportion the property business profits across the tax years. I just took it that property business profits for 2009/10 were the actual profits for tax year 2009/10, etc. I hope that was right and we weren't supposed to apportion the profits from April to March.

It was written that the profits have been already adjusted for tax purposes.
Former userFormer user13y ago#64
You take the gift in life and take off the current year and prior year annual exemptions of £3000 to leave a net gift of £314000. Then you take off the NRB available in 2007 and the excess is charged at 25% to give the lifetime tax payable. As the donor paid the tax this is added to the £314000 to get the gross gift.

Then on death you need to revisit as it was within 7 years but now the NRB has increased to £325000 so it covers the gift and leaves a small amount left over in the death estate.

That's what I did anyhoo!!
Former userFormer user13y ago#65
Rehan - the question was only 10 marks so I doubt it was worth very much anyways :)
Mmuneebnawaz9013y ago#66
@haylee69 said:
You take the gift in life and take off the current year and prior year annual exemptions of £3000 to leave a net gift of £314000. Then you take off the NRB available in 2007 and the excess is charged at 25% to give the lifetime tax payable. As the donor paid the tax this is added to the £314000 to get the gross gift.

Then on death you need to revisit as it was within 7 years but now the NRB has increased to £325000 so it covers the gift and leaves a small amount left over in the death estate.

That's what I did anyhoo!!


Hmm you are right but I read in exam kit we will always have nrbs of different years when required , here it wasn't given so I believe there was no as such calculation involved. Again u r right but there was no info other then gift and exemptions. So I used full NRB in death IHT
Former userFormer user13y ago#67
All NRB are given in the rates tables at the start of the exam question paper they sometimes put on the question also but are there for the last ten years
Mmuneebnawaz9013y ago#68
@haylee69 said:
All NRB are given in the rates tables at the start of the exam question paper they sometimes put on the question also but are there for the last ten years



Oh sorry I didn't check then you are right ..
Former userFormer user13y ago#69
Did anyone else get an unreadable exam question paper? In parts of questions 2 and 4 my paper was unreadable and i had to get the invigilator over to find out what it should have said. As if the exam wasn't stressful enough. Couldn't have studied more for this exam if i tried, but still convinced i've failed it...... Never mind its over now, can enjoy christmas and then dread February!!!
Former userFormer user13y ago#70
A very difficult paper.
ALL the optional papers should be of the same standard. For e.g papers P4 or P6 cannot be more difficult than paper P7.
Former userFormer user13y ago#71
@nicolas03 do you (or anyone else) knows how we can leave feedback for this exam on the official acca website?

i am really hoping we can convince the markers that they should consider how hard the questions were and possibly ease up their strictness when marking our poor papers???

thanks guys!
Former userFormer user13y ago#72
@olkos said:
@nicolas03 do you (or anyone else) knows how we can leave feedback for this exam on the official acca website?

i am really hoping we can convince the markers that they should consider how hard the questions were and possibly ease up their strictness when marking our poor papers???

thanks guys!


I don't want to sound flippant towards yours and any other persons POV on this paper but really? It's a pro paper they are supposed to be hard. And TBH I don't think you'll get anywhere where there being a relaxed marking scheme because P6 is not that sort of paper.

The whole tax system is rule based - you either know the rules and where to apply them or you don't, how can you relax a marking system to accomodate this?

Again I don't want to sound flippant but I've had a look at the paper and it really is not that bad. Having experience of working in tax does help of course but ultimately you should have built up your knowledge through the study text and practised your application of this knowledge through doing PPQ's.

Ask your fellow colleagues or friends how much work they put in to pass. As a benchmark for me it was roughly 120 hours and 86 PPQ's and even then I only got a mark in the mid 50's (but I did study and pass P2 and P3 as well in the same diet).

I'm saying this for everyone's benefit as the saying goes ''You can fail many times, but the moment you blame something else for your failings is when you truly fail.''

Good luck with the results and (if applicable) the resit.
Mmuneebnawaz9013y ago#73
@lee you have cleared p6 that's why you are saying all this
We know better then you , we have also practiced past papers and all that

To be honest , what they tried to do this time ?
Nil rate band in rates areas? What the hell was that ?
Just because of that I thought their is no such info how can I do the IHT but here someone said that IHT rate which is usually given in the question info was in rates section ? You don't need to hide the digits to check someone's capability to perform ! But a cheap way to confuse the students
Former userFormer user13y ago#74
Nrbs are always in the rates tables on every single paper! You should be aware of what is given so you know what you need to remember.

On second glance the paper was actually ok but very pressured in 3 hours 15 mins it's easy to look back at a paper you havent done and say it's ok but the IHT question was alot to handle for just ten marks if you can't do it with your eyes shut!

If there was more planning time I think people would do better, there's no way you can read all 5 questions properly in 15 mins.
Mmuneebnawaz9013y ago#75
@haylee69 said:
Nrbs are always in the rates tables on every single paper! You should be aware of what is given so you know what you need to remember.

On second glance the paper was actually ok but very pressured in 3 hours 15 mins it's easy to look back at a paper you havent done and say it's ok but the IHT question was alot to handle for just ten marks if you can't do it with your eyes shut!

If there was more planning time I think people would do better, there's no way you can read all 5 questions properly in 15 mins.


Haylee u r right
But It's really disappointing when you do something wrong in the area u r quite strong. Just of nil rate band I left that otherwise I knew there was exemption , NRB 25% rate . Then 40% rate at death deducting tax paid in life. I can just curse myself for doing that blunder :(
Former userFormer user13y ago#76
I know but don't kick urself too much there was alot t think about for 10 marks so it's probably got 11 marks available so you may have lost nothing. People are worrying too much, have faith in ur hard work you will find you did more than you think!
Former userFormer user13y ago#77
I calculated a degrouping charge for Q1. Im now convinced this is incorrect as the initial asset transfer wasnt done at nil gain/nil loss.
Did anyone else calculate a degrouping charge for Q1?
Former userFormer user13y ago#78
@paulfletcher said:
I calculated a degrouping charge for Q1. Im now convinced this is incorrect as the initial asset transfer wasnt done at nil gain/nil loss.
Did anyone else calculate a degrouping charge for Q1?


I've seen questions in the Kaplan Exam Kit where is said "X is part of a gains group, and an asset was transferred 3 years ago for its market value of £x" which I then assumed it meant they'd actually paid the MV. However, in the answers it always calculated the degrouping charge, and it gives you the MV just to confuse you. It makes sense I suppose because why would they accept a CGT charge when they can take advantage of the gains group rules? Also, they gave us the indexation values for a reason.

That's what I'm hoping anyway!
Former userFormer user13y ago#79
Just a point about the examiner stating that experience of working in the tax department is required in order to pass this exam - I think this is complete nonsense! A few years ago I worked for a top 8 firm in London and studied for the ICAEW exams. My experience in the tax department was pretty much doing simple personal tax calculations for private clients - sorting out bags of receipts and invoices to prepare sets of accounts and tax calculations. Also completing the odd VAT return for a business client. The 3 month "experience" in the tax department did nothing to prepare me for a difficult tax exam. Ok it was useful for an exam like F6 or the CA equivalent, but the experience did nothing to help with this ACCA Advanced Tax exam. I was supervised most of the time, dealing with pretty simple basic tax work, and I did not get exposed to any detailed IHT or complex CT calculations for example. This was reserved for those who were based there full time, those more experienced and qualified and probably had a specific tax qualification. I am sure my 1st year tax department experience was similar to many other trainee accountants in other firms - my practical experience of working in a tax department in no way prepared me for the questions in this specific tax exam.

I believe going through the study text and doing lots of question practice is enough to get anyone through this Advanced Tax exam. Relevant work experience is not a prerequisite.
Former userFormer user13y ago#80
Too much to read to figure out what each question is asking. There are other ways to test a subject area without adding so much drama in the limited time available.
I know I made a mess of this paper again. I need help!!!! there must be a better way.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.