Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

ATX*** P6 December 2012 Exam *** Instant Poll and comments***

Oopentuition13y ago
Post your comments about December 2012 P6 exam.

Please vote in our Instant Poll
*** P6 December 2012 Exam *** Instant Poll and comments*** poll results


Please note:
Remember that you are studying for a professional qualification - do not make postings that are abusive or threatening.
Former userFormer user13y ago#1
f***** disaster... nothing elz to say
Kkvn61813y ago#2
ffs!!! Felt very confident before the exam and thought should sail through the resit. No chance.... Found it very tricky especially first two questions. Is it just me? Or was it hard?
Aammadey202013y ago#3
A disastarous paper....
Kkvn61813y ago#4
I'm glad it's not just me... Felt very down after it. Will start all over again tomorrow. Last one to go
Former userFormer user13y ago#5
This was my third sitting but to tell u the truth I feel my previous two sitting were better than this. Diasaster couldn't figure out my way thru reconsidering my options. Over prepared for this paper
V&veer & lem13y ago#6
am dead
Former userFormer user13y ago#7
This is a joke
Mmuneebnawaz9013y ago#8
Well first 2 question were fine ! Optionals were all !! Huhhhhhhh :@ it was hard to decide which optional question will give me atleast 50percent from each optional question
Q1 involved simple share calculation with degrouping charge and indexation allowance .. Higher rate 26 percent used for tax cost
Trade assets was bit complicated .. Goodwill n building rollover was easy though
Upper lower limits were divided by 9 and 9/12 for profit period

First question was fine

Difficulty faced
Capital gain instalments yes or no
Lease asset :@ wat the hell
Conditions for lease asset entrepreneur relief! Can't they ask something good

Inherent tax was again shit ! Previous trust gift tax paid and NRB wasn't given so I added up all assets .. Used NRB .. Calculated tax .. Reduced by tax paid on share in foreign country. That's it !
Former userFormer user13y ago#9
I dont think i m gonna pass paper ... It was so boring paper!!!
Section A was worse than section B ... Overall paper was disaster!
CFCute Friend13y ago#10
huhhhhhhh after getting back into my senses still i dnt know wot i did ...n wot he askd actually ....
dnt know wot xaminer wants from us or thinks about us...em sure xaminer suppose we are already in tax practice with atleast 2 yrs xperience :(
Former userFormer user13y ago#11
like everyone else... i found the paper very difficult/disastrous... such a shame since it's my final paper...
Mmuneebnawaz9013y ago#12
I just want to ask something ..
In first question what cost value did u take ? I take full 100000 because in requirement it was mentioned that it was nb trading company so I don't think there any capital allowance involved plus in notes it said tax values in pool zero . Any idea ?
CFCute Friend13y ago#13
@muneebnawaz90 said:
I just want to ask something ..
In first question what cost value did u take ? I take full 100000 because in requirement it was mentioned that it was nb trading company so I don't think there any capital allowance involved plus in notes it said tax values in pool zero . Any idea ?

yup i did the same thing....bt i forgot to make an assumption on this n give note
Former userFormer user13y ago#14
anyone here on SGP variant?

Qn 1) Write a report to board of directors for the Singapore Tax issues relating to 3 scenarios. The tax issues should include withholding tax, GST (VAT in UK), stamp duty, property tax

1) Sale and leaseback of factory from a resident company
2) Purchase of equity investment (treat as transfer of shares)
3) Purchase of trade secret
(Can't remember if it's a R or NR company for 2 and 3)

Qn 2:Minimise group liability for 3 companies, which includes if s24 (election for group transfer of fixed assets) is useful and calculation of 1 of the company

1) touches on shareholding test, group relief/carry back relief and carry forward relief, and also same trade test
2) transfer of assets from 1 company to another within the same group and advise if s24 should be elected.

Qn 3: Outward investment: Treatment of 3 foreign sourced income when remitted into Sinapore

1) Dividend Income
2) Branch profit
3) Royalties

All 3 foreign income are sourced in 3 different countries in which Singapore has no tax treaty with. Exemptions available for foreign dividend remit back into Singapore but it is not tax efficient to do so. Foreign tax credit pooling method is preferred

Qn 4: Share option (i skipped this)

Qn 5: Non-Resident (NR) company licence a trademark to a Singapore Resident Company. Singapore resident company then pays a fee. Current NR has no tax treaty with Singapore. Alternative structure is for the NR company to licence to another NR company (from country X) which then sub-licence to the Singapore Company. NR company from Country X has tax treaty with Singapore.

There are 2 parts to this question.

1) Forget
2) Comment on the alternative structure and advise the company why IRAS (Singapore tax authority) may challenge.
Llaila-yama13y ago#15
ABSOLUTELY DISASTER. IF YOUR GUY GOES TO PQ MAGAZINE, THE EXAMNIER ACTUALLY SAID IF YOU DON'T HAVE 1 YEAR WORK EXPERIENCE UNDER YOUR BELT, YOU STAND NO CHANCE. THE ARTICLE NOVEMBER 2011. I THINK THIS REALLY IS UNFAIR FOR STUDENT LIKE US
Former userFormer user13y ago#16
seriously disappointed. . though I was fully prepared but paper was really tough especially Q1 & 2 . . Anyone who can share the summary of all the questions along with their requirement. thank you. .
Former userFormer user13y ago#17
nightmare..
Former userFormer user13y ago#18
What on earth was that? Optional questions seemed easier then compulsory questions. Q1 and Q2 seemed abstract for me. Not seen those type of questions in that style in the P and R kit. Really frustrated to have worked so hard and then to get that kind of paper. June's exam was much better. Just could not get a real foothold with this exam. Real shame.
Former userFormer user13y ago#19
I feel the same. Even length of questions was shorter, usually there more guidance and clues what needs to be done. Did q3&5, as knew nothing on leases. I agree q1 and q2 ( especially q2) weren't very straight forward... :( was very prepared and confident before exam, but now just hope to get 50...
Former userFormer user13y ago#20
Same here not happy with what I have put down. Can anyone remember the questions..
Former userFormer user13y ago#21
Leave your feedback on acca website. They may take it into account for marking the exams
CFCute Friend13y ago#22
@nicolas03 said:
Leave your feedback on acca website. They may take it into account for marking the exams


can you please share the link of site where exactly we have to leave the feedback ?
Former userFormer user13y ago#23
very tricky paper,very few hints in question 1 and 2 ,stuck up dont knw to do...
Former userFormer user13y ago#24
anyone please tell me what was the treatment for first part of Q1 where two ways of disposal of a subsidiary was given and asked to calculate tax related to both options, what was the treatment of first one? where all the shares were disposed off for 1million. . as it was also mentioned in the end that no SSE is available than what was the treatment and reliefs that could be applied?
Mmuneebnawaz9013y ago#25
@fahim
Consideration x
Add degrouping charge x

Less indexed cost
Indexed gain @ 26 as per limits co is large

Share calculation was easy


Trade assets
Balancing allowances on equipment and miller machine
Add : profit on disposal of goodwill
Add capital gain on building ( base cost after rollover )

Again tax at 26 because trade holder asset company profits lied in higher rate

Tax value was zero . And as no SSE so it wasn't trading. So no capital allowance was there so straightforward cost had to be taken in finding out balancing allowances.
Llaila-yama13y ago#26
@muneebnawaz90 said:
@fahim
Consideration x
Add degrouping charge x

Less indexed cost
Indexed gain @ 26 as per limits co is large

Share calculation was easy


Trade assets
Balancing allowances on equipment and miller machine
Add : profit on disposal of goodwill
Add capital gain on building ( base cost after rollover )

Again tax at 26 because trade holder asset company profits lied in higher rate

Tax value was zero . And as no SSE so it wasn't trading. So no capital allowance was there so straightforward cost had to be taken in finding out balancing allowances.

Check this examiner comment out guy : https://www.pqaccountant.com/pmag-FFFF00500180024B02171957.html
Mmuneebnawaz9013y ago#27
@laila what can we say :(
Former userFormer user13y ago#28
there are 1000s of students who pass this paper each year with out any experence.According to me just ensure that you have revised the book with in 3-4 days before exam.
Former userFormer user13y ago#29
Yes, quite a disastrous paper. Every question was really difficult. Question 4 on leases was impossible, it left only Qs 3 and 5 as the 2 options to choose from !

The question on CGT payment by installments - I have not come across this issue in my study course, nor in any practice questions. Does anyone know the answer? I didn't think CGT is payable by installments only that payment due by 31 January following year of the CGT gain. I said that CGT is not payable by installments, but as the question asked "if CGT is payable by installments what other factors should the client know about", I probably got it completely wrong. I suppose the examiner gave the answer away there. What a really obscure part of the syllabus to test our knowledge on!
Former userFormer user13y ago#30
yes, cgt is payable in instalments in two situations:
on certain lifetime gifts
and where payments are received in instalments.
an advice for p6 always use kaplan study text.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.