Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

ATX*** P6 December 2012 Exam *** Instant Poll and comments***

Oopentuition13y ago
Post your comments about December 2012 P6 exam.

Please vote in our Instant Poll
*** P6 December 2012 Exam *** Instant Poll and comments*** poll results


Please note:
Remember that you are studying for a professional qualification - do not make postings that are abusive or threatening.
Mmuneebnawaz9013y ago#31
@jk0323 said:
yes, cgt is payable in instalments in two situations:
on certain lifetime gifts
and where payments are received in instalments.
an advice for p6 always use kaplan study text.


I used kaplan so ?
The issue of entrepreneur relief as in associate disposal , CGT installments WTH topics !
Mmuneebnawaz9013y ago#32
Have you cme across the inheritance tax calculation ? Transfer to trust prior to death ? What an incomplete info ! How can one identify on that transfer when their is no info on tax paid , NRB. These things are required to get NRB amount to be used at death !! Huh
Uugras0513y ago#33
Well what can I say, I have never sat an exam in my life and felt so deflated during and after, what a joke.

3months studying, anticipation and stress while holding down a full time job and neglecting quality time with the wife for a paper like this?.

Fair enough I wasn't well prepared in the last few days cos I concentrated on Audit last monday which was at least a humanely paper but these kind of questions wouldn't have made a difference even if I was fully prepared. Where did this guy get these questions from? I heard he has an argument with his wife and then writes the questions. Well if our future is in the hand of guys like this then God help us.

I sat 11papers from starting with F2 in 2009, sat 1or 2papers at time due to work, only failed F9 once and passed all of them, yet Im sat here thinking, am I capable? what if it takes me 10 attempts? Im seriously considering whether to drop Tax and do P5 although this was the first time. No chance of passing this one, at least hope to clear P7.

Good luck everyone.
Former userFormer user13y ago#34
Tax usually has best pass marks... I guess it's not the case for this sitting....
Ssyedmayaz13y ago#35
A bit in relief AFTER reading all the comments, atleast one can enjoy these comments rather than thinking bout the damn! paper
Nnagdam13y ago#36
does anybody think that marking scheme will be bit relaxed as presumably not a single person commented that the exam was OK/EASY/FAIR.
Former userFormer user13y ago#37
I actually feel much better after reading some of the other comments, the last 24 hours i've been so dejected and angry.

On day 1, i was told by my BPP tutor that there's no way to learn everything in this module in 3 months, you need to make sure you know the fundamental topics really well. That's exactly what I did, studying day and night for weeks on end, and I felt pretty confident going in.

What chance do you have when the examiner picks such obscure topics to examine in detail? In the end, he's not testing candidate's key knowledge of major topics, but their ability to recall specific facts about far flung areas of the syllabus.

Sometimes you get the impression the examiner is not testing your knowledge so much as trying to cause you problems.
Former userFormer user13y ago#38
Is good to know am not alone
Former userFormer user13y ago#39
@muneebnawaz90 said:
@jk0323 said:
yes, cgt is payable in instalments in two situations:
on certain lifetime gifts
and where payments are received in instalments.
an advice for p6 always use kaplan study text.


I used kaplan so ?
The issue of entrepreneur relief as in associate disposal , CGT installments WTH topics !

CGT instalments is given on page number= 151 in chapter number 6 and associated dispoal is give on page 230 in the entrepreneurs relief. Kaplan covers all the topics in the best maner.
Former userFormer user13y ago#40
Here is what i did. Only remember this.

Q1: messed up 18 marks part. expecting only 3-4.
Q2: loss reliefs: most tax efficient option was obtaining opening year of losses reliefs as it reduces liability of employment income as well in 2010. Other two options i mentioned were set off against current year total income and set off against last year total income and/or gains.

Q4: Vat registration adv/disad was peice of cake. Can vulcan partnerhips be subject to registration in future? I answered yes as their current per anum revenue is about 71K.

Q5: CLT to trust. 320000 CLT less 280000 NRB (dont remember exact figures but i took nrb of that year) * 25% IHT as he was going to pay tax. On death, No additional tax because NRB covers the amount.

Info to request:

list of all cash gifts made to family members because only small gifts less than 250 are exempt.

list of gifts made to spouse because this is fully exempt.

Confirm whether spouse NRB is still unused to take advantage.

and 3-4 more things

Can someone please confirm the above answers and remind of remaining parts of these questions so that we can confirm?
Former userFormer user13y ago#41
come on guys stop complaining now you should have studied hard earlier.....you should have read the whole finance act thoroughly before passing this exam...do you really think you can become an affiliate with just putting a miserable effort........grow up.....
Mmuneebnawaz9013y ago#42
well there were 4 things in death calculations
i added them up
used nil rate band.
calculate tax at 40% then deduct tax of 25% on shares DTR . and IHT was there.
question stated that no tax was paid on that trust gift. that was the hint that it was just because was due there, he didnt know abt that. ur calculations and mine are totally different .. plus as penalty i said 3% intrest on IHT due for 4 months i think . he died on 1 feb so IHT was payable 6 months after the death month so it was 31 july. and he paid 4 months late so intrest was of 4 months .
Former userFormer user13y ago#43
I thought the exam was okay.

Q1 (a) I added the degrouping charge to the consideration and deducted the cost + indexation. For the trade and assets I got a balancing charge for the equipment and mill machine, chargeable gain for the goodwill and building. I know the question stated rollover relief, but I thought it was holdover relief, as the reinvestment was in fixed plant & machinery, i.e. a depreciating asset. So I said the £8,500 gain was now chargeable (as it now met one of the 3 holdover relief tests).

(b) I talked about the approved v unapproved schemes and stated that CSOP is good as he wanted to only offer it to senior managers. I also said employees/directors who own >25% are inelligible.

(c) Ethics was a gift

Q2. (a) I calculated the basis of assessment for the first 3 tax years. I only got a loss in the 3rd tax year. I then discussed how this could be relieved - take it back 3 tax years on a FIFO basis, against CY and/or PY in any oder, against gains after other income in CY and/or PY, and carry forward (which I stated she didn't want to do).

(b) Gift relief was available because it was a CLT and the claim must be submitted within 2 years of the gift by both the donor and donee.

(c) Information required for IHT - value of the gifts, who they were to, if any tax was paid on the previous CLT to trust, when the gifts were made.

Q3 (a) I calculated the car benefit as normal and said it would be treated as a dividend because the company was a close company (controlled by any number of directors). I said it would be taxed at normal dividend tax rates.

(b) I talked about pre-liquidator it would be a dividend, and post liquidator it would be treated as a capital disposal and entrepreneurs relief would be available on any gain because Katherine (?) owned over 5% of the company and would probably have held the shares for 12 months pre-liquidation.

(c) I said that the company would be taxed at the main-rate of 26% as it was a close investment company. I also said DTR was available on the overseas chargeable gain. I wasn't sure which expenses were/were not allowance so just put them all in and taxed at 26% less DTR.

Q4 (a) I had no idea about entrepreneurs being available on disposal of a lease, so said the lease must have been held for at least 12 months and be part of the trade. I've had a look online for this and can't see anything - does anyone have any ideas about this?

(b) I calculated the gain on the lease disposal (proceeds less (cost x lease % now divided by lease % acquisition), the gains on the disposal of shares in Vulcan, the part disposal of the land, and the loss on the shares. I put the AE first against gains not qualifying for entrepreneurs relief and the remaining AE against the entrepreneurs gains (lease and business disposals).

(c) VAT - they are not required to register as taxable supplies (standard and zero-rated) were less than £73k, but as they were expected to rise voluntary registration was advisable. Advantages and disadvantages of registration were fine.

(d) I ran out of time, but said that POA are due on 31 Jan and 31 July based on 50% of the prior year's IT liability. A claim could be made to reduce these, but... (ran out of time here).

Q5 - did not do.
Former userFormer user13y ago#44
@wiz7279 said:
come on guys stop complaining now you should have studied hard earlier.....you should have read the whole finance act thoroughly before passing this exam...do you really think you can become an affiliate with just putting a miserable effort........grow up.....


There is a term for idiots like you making such crass comments about other students who struggled with this exam: COMPLETE W*NKER!
Former userFormer user13y ago#45
@kdsgreenmachine

i just want to say thank you because i pretty much wrecked my exam overall and u just confirmed that i havent done it as much. seriously thanks man

btw i messed up q2 a the 18 marks part. panic took over me i guess was expecting a better question with tax treatments of individuals and such really didnt have a chance there.
Mmuneebnawaz9013y ago#46
@cimafan said:
There is a term for idiots like you making such crass comments about other students who struggled with this exam: COMPLETE W*NKER!

Well said cimafan ! Some people are so selfish. Obviously we tried to give our 100 percent but paper was such a crap. No one can deny
Mmuneebnawaz9013y ago#47
Kds green machine I had balancing allowance in question 1 because . SSE wasn't available . It wasn't a trading company .there was no capital allowances that's why tool showed zero
Former userFormer user13y ago#48
with reference to your comment cifaman, you got me wrong. Exams are supposed to be tough..that is how you are going to create worth for yourself if you overcome a diffcult hurdle..
Former userFormer user13y ago#49
@muneebnawaz90 said:
Kds green machine I had balancing allowance in question 1 because . SSE wasn't available . It wasn't a trading company .there was no capital allowances that's why tool showed zero


I took it as a balancing charge because the question stated that the TWDV on the main pool was zero, suggesting that the capital allowances had been fully utilised. You then take the market value less £0 to give a balancing charge. That's a shame if I got that wrong, but it was quite subtle.
Mmuneebnawaz9013y ago#50
The thing where I did a mistake is I included that xyz company profits in trade asset calculation arghh :@

Secondly can anyone tell me IHT calculation question ?.
One trust gift ( with no info I assumed it was covered by reliefs , assumptions and bands )
Secondly share were charged to IHT in foreign country
I just added all 4 things to estate like home , cash , shares etc , used full NRB .. Then 40 % tax deducted dTr on shares .. Is that ok or there was another way ?
Former userFormer user13y ago#51
From memory here's what I did for Q5

Calculated original IHT on estate only including uk assets an full NRB as it was assumed non Dom and no gifts.

Then wee told they were Dom and did make gift so calculated the IHT on the lifetime gift, grossed up 25% as donor paid.

At death the NRB covered the gross gift so no further tax to pay. Then calculated all the assets in the new comp and deducted remaining NRB - was only a small amount about £7500 left?

Then calculated the DTR only the shares as cars were exempt, so 25% of the shares and then compared this tithe uk tax paid at the estate rate, due to small NRB I got this at about 38% so only allowed the 25%. The deducted the IHT paid in the first comp to see the extra payable.

I didn't think the question was too bad tbf you just had to think it through, but it was in an unusual format, never aren't anything like that before!!!
Former userFormer user13y ago#52
Also, for Q2 I did:

Set out the basis periods - 1 three months to April, 2 the whole 9 months again and had to force a 12 month period so add 3/12 of the loss but was still a profit 3 take the remaining 9 months of loss only as can't do this twice unlike overlaps.

Then I set up a proforma for each yeah of income to see what income she had.

I explained she could do current year, or carry back in any order, but as one year wa under brb would only get relief at 20% the other year was only little bit over so not much relief.

I also explained she could set against cgt but only after making a full claim against total income and as that exceeded the loss, there would be nothing left to do this.

I then talked about opening year relief and that losses in the first 4 years can be carried back 36 months on a fifo basis so it would go back to the year before she started trading this year had the most income over the brb anyway so would provide the most loss relief.

Even if i got my calcs etc wrong I think just stating those 4 main options and explaining them would give a lot of marks so if you did that u wouldn't worry too much about it :) I'm sure people did better than they thought.

Overall I thought Q1 wa horrible, but there was a fair few cgt calcs in there which may give you more marks than you think, and I couldn't do the regrouping charge as it totally went out of my head but I did explain why it's charged and it increases the proceeds so hopefully a Mark even though I didn't actually include it in the calc!!
Former userFormer user13y ago#53
@kdsgreenmachine said:
I took it as a balancing charge because the question stated that the TWDV on the main pool was zero, suggesting that the capital allowances had been fully utilised. You then take the market value less £0 to give a balancing charge. That's a shame if I got that wrong, but it was quite subtle.


This is what I got too the twdv was probably zero as the stuff qualified for AIA when purchased. Therefore I got a balancing charge. On the other equipment I said no cgt as assumed bought and sold for under £6000 and the goodwill had no cost so straight proceeds. I then did the two parts sales of the buildings with IA for each. I hope this is all correct there was a question almost identical to this in the Kaplan exam kit so fingers crossed
Former userFormer user13y ago#54
OMG...what a paper. Qn1 and 2...really? Why do they keep doing this to us? And i hate this 'no experience no passing nonsense'. They shouldn't be taking our money if they clearly know we have no experience to pass the paper. It should be clearly highlighted when booking for such exams that we wont pass unless we have the experience,otherwise this aint fair.
Former userFormer user13y ago#55
@haylee69 said:
Also, for Q2 I did:

Set out the basis periods - 1 three months to April, 2 the whole 9 months again and had to force a 12 month period so add 3/12 of the loss but was still a profit 3 take the remaining 9 months of loss only as can't do this twice unlike overlaps.

Then I set up a proforma for each yeah of income to see what income she had.

I explained she could do current year, or carry back in any order, but as one year wa under brb would only get relief at 20% the other year was only little bit over so not much relief.

I also explained she could set against cgt but only after making a full claim against total income and as that exceeded the loss, there would be nothing left to do this.

I then talked about opening year relief and that losses in the first 4 years can be carried back 36 months on a fifo basis so it would go back to the year before she started trading this year had the most income over the brb anyway so would provide the most loss relief.

Even if u got my calcs etc wrong I think just stating those 4 main options and explaining them would give a lot of marks so if you did that u wouldn't worry too much about it :) I'm sure people did better than they thought.

Overall I thought Q1 wa horrible, but there was a fair few cgt calcs in there which may give you more marks than you think, and I couldn't do the regrouping charge as it totally went out of my head but I did explain why it's charged and it increases the proceeds so hopefully a Mark even though I didn't actually include it in the calc!!


It stated that there was no double tax treaty between the country and UK. Why do we take DTR then?
Former userFormer user13y ago#56
Rehan - no double tax treay just mens there is no restrictions on the tax allowed - so revert to the UK rules, which is that tax relief is allowed at the lower of uk tax applicable to that asset, and the foreign tax that was paid, because the foreign tax was lower, take this.

no double tax treaty doesnt mean no tax relief is allowed, i tripped up on this on one of the practise questions so remembered it in the exam, but probably wasnt worth more than 2 marks anyway
Mmuneebnawaz9013y ago#57
@haylee69 said:
Rehan - no double tax treay just mens there is no restrictions on the tax allowed - so revert to the UK rules, which is that tax relief is allowed at the lower of uk tax applicable to that asset, and the foreign tax that was paid, because the foreign tax was lower, take this.

no double tax treaty doesnt mean no tax relief is allowed, i tripped up on this on one of the practise questions so remembered it in the exam, but probably wasnt worth more than 2 marks anyway


ya haylee u r right

but lifetime trust gift . there was no such info so i assumed it was covered by relief assumption n lifetime nrb
dtr was only on shares because other asset wasnt charged to iht in foreign country.
Former userFormer user13y ago#58
Regarding question 2 and carry back of losses made in the first 4 years of trading, did anyone apportion the property business profits across the tax years. I just took it that property business profits for 2009/10 were the actual profits for tax year 2009/10, etc. I hope that was right and we weren't supposed to apportion the profits from April to March.
Former userFormer user13y ago#59
I'm pretty sure there was details on the gift to trust - it said uk shares to the value of £320000? On q4 there were no details so had to assume but there was a line on q5 else you wouldn't have been able to work out the IHT?
Former userFormer user13y ago#60
Looks like the paper has been published folks: https://www.accaglobal.com/content/dam/acca/global/PDF-students/acca/p6/exampapers/uk/p6uk_2012_dec_q.pdf
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.