APM*** P5 June 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
90% of the comment are that the paper was very confusing difficult style.but will acca hear uus..wul they take action.or should we kept lamenting
I started by doing section B first, and opted for Q2 and Q4...after wasting time in deciding which ones will earn more points
i agree that the questions are worded in such a way that everytime i'm thinking of something to write , i'm having to re read the question again jsut to make sure i'm answering what is being asked.
I overan on Section B by 15 mins, and only had 1hr30mins to finish Q1.
Nearly missed writing in Report format,...
Breakeven in terms of units were needed, but my mind went blank as to how to calculate as my brain was mush by that time !
overall fair but by no means easy !
P6 in September for me.
Okay here are the facts:
The lowest pass rates for any ACCA paper since 2011 when Alex Watt took over:
P4 - 1
P5 - 4 + 1 tied bottom
P6 - 0
P7 - 3 + 1 tied bottom
So benchmarking P5 we see it scores top of the league table for difficulty
However lets look at the % difference between P5 and the next paper in each case over those sittings
Dec 2011 - 2%
Jun 2013 - tied bottom, bet lowest paper - 3%
Dec 2013 - 3%
Jun 2014 - 7%
Dec 2014 - 3%
SO I would say apart from Jun 2014 - there is only a 3% variance in being what is deemed the "most difficult" or "unfair" - does the presentation or bases for benchmarking obscure the understanding?
What should Alex Watt do? Does the cost of changing his exam creation technique outweigh the benefit? What impact will this have on the ACCA qualification? What systems will need to be changed and processes with markers?
Should he undertake a BPR initiative or look for linkages across the papers using the value chain?
Does the benchmarking take into account demographic factors? Should the exam be benchmarked internally or externally with CIMA? Should Alex Watt be benchmarked on controllable factors - he has to award 4 professional marks - are these marks controllable?
More of these exciting insights to follow after my September re-sit....
@nav1980- you , my friend, are a real poet or just went crazy by revising too much p5 lol
@nav1980 LOL brilliant real-life application there! Which other optional did ou attempt?
ACCA asks our opinion as to what we think of the exam. Every year I get an email asking me to give my feed back. I have made it clear in the past that questions are too complex and scenarios are too long and confusing. So far they have not taken any notice.
I noticed that when I made some remarks about the website, they have taken note of that! So we have to keep telling ACCA through our feed back that P5 has been unnecessarily made complicated. After all the exams finish, they put on the website, asking for our feed back. It will be good to make use of it and tell them how fed up we are with P5 style.
Yes, I ready the questions about 5 times and still could not make sense of them. I thought there must be some printing mistake why I cannot understand the questions, but of course, they are deliberately arranged to confuse us.
I did P7 - passed that at 52%, all other papers first time via opentuition self study.
I messed up the whole exam becuase of question 1 which was so confusing too much information. I am getting tired of P5 this was my second attempt i think last year paper was better than this year.
I had all the information and because i spent more time on question one i did not even attempt question 4 so i am not even looking forward to my results.
December here i come again .......
@acparmar said: ACCA asks our opinion as to what we think of the exam. Every year I get an email asking me to give my feed back. I have made it clear in the past that questions are too complex and scenarios are too long and confusing. So far they have not taken any notice. I noticed that when I made some remarks about the website, they have taken note of that! So we have to keep telling ACCA through our feed back that P5 has been unnecessarily made complicated. After all the exams finish, they put on the website, asking for our feed back. It will be good to make use of it and tell them how fed up we are with P5 style. Yes, I ready the questions about 5 times and still could not make sense of them. I thought there must be some printing mistake why I cannot understand the questions, but of course, they are deliberately arranged to confuse us.Whoever is the examiner needs to sort himself our i am not sure he just find happiness in making us all suffer he should get a life once in a while. The money we spend on ACCA is too much i think.
Tell me about it..This is the only paper holding me back from completion. It's becoming embarrassing now. I could have spent the P5 exam fees on a nice plot of land.
This sitting was obviously my fault because it wasn't has bad as I was expecting but I forgot my strategy of how to tackle this paper and was in pieces in the exam. I over studied for this paper, even all my lunch breaks was spent on past questions but I allowed the ambiguity of the questions to leave me in a state of panic, shock and confusion.
I spent 5 mins after reading time trying to decide which option questions to tackle (poor exam technique) and I over ran the first question by 15 mins so I had to abandon it, then did the second option which was also over ran so I was now panic stricken, watching the time..could not make all the points I knew....even in the exam I knew the answers but kept on going back and forth between questions, I was demoralised.
Did everyone realise q1 was based on Nike?
Then it's question 1..trying to make sense of the case study, could not even focus..and was picking information in bits.
The truth is that the format and style of the question will not change because people do actually pass this paper. We all have the ability and knowledge but it's about time management, confidence, ability to stay focused under pressure.
Knowing the subject inside out is 50% of the job done..It's the ability to pick out the key issues from the scenario and link them together quickly is what is actually being tested.
Nevertheless, the style of the questions is not very helpful because if you're not careful, your inability to decipher the question requirements will make you panic and you end up forgetting everything you know.
Also as I've realised, do not ever start a P5 exam by doing the optional questions first. It's a recipe for disaster.
I'm still thinking what I could have done better for me to finish and understand the requirements. The questions were so vague esp Q1. Had I done the optional questions first, it could have been better qns 3 and 4 of cause.
Q1 part question, I remember doing this:
4.2mil of additional materials
800k of marketing
500k of auditing
made 5.5 mil of additional costs to catch up, with the selling price of $75 I ended up getting $5 500 000/$75 = 73 333 units for it to breakeven and maintain the same level of profit.
Well that’s how I went about it. Don't know if I did the correct thing, seems my answer is different from everyone else here.
@dwilliam468 said: I'm still thinking what I could have done better for me to finish and understand the requirements. The questions were so vague esp Q1. Had I done the optional questions first, it could have been better qns 3 and 4 of cause. Q1 part question, I remember doing this: 4.2mil of additional materials 800k of marketing 500k of auditing made 5.5 mil of additional costs to catch up, with the selling price of $75 I ended up getting $5 500 000/$75 = 73 333 units for it to breakeven and maintain the same level of profit. Well that’s how I went about it. Don't know if I did the correct thing, seems my answer is different from everyone else here.u forget the cost to produce these extra units. 5500000 / profit per unit which is 75 - 23,1. 23.1 = 21 initial + 10 % extra cost
Ladies and gentlemen, this paper is not as straight forward as it seems.Suprises are on the pipe line.Good luck to everyone.
What can I say, I hope Djokovic will win Roland Garros and that I will pass this exam.
My first time sitting P5 and despite feeling that some past exam papers were terrible, I didn't think this was too bad. I can't say for sure that I think I've passed it (you never can with this type of exam), but I know that I've given it a good shot.
I agree with what's everyone saying on here and it is a very tough exam. I'll share a few tips that I did to unravel the maze of this and apply a logical approach. As you've all said, it's not about knowing the subject matter, but more about how you cope with all in the information in the exam.
I felt very panicky in the few days leading up to the exam and very overwhelmed by the low pass rate and resits of P5. On the morning of the exam, this hadn't changed, but then I realised that panic was my enemy and if I had any chance at all, I just had to stop giving in to panic and just ignore it. Remarkably, this seemed to work and calm me down. Taking deep breaths seemed to help too.
Next came the reading time. I spent this reading the requirements, highlighting the relevant words (eg in Q1 a), I highlighted Appendix 1) and deciding which options to do and in what order. I then planned out my time giving 1.6 marks for Q1 (as more to read) and 1.7 marks for the options (less to read). I then wrote down timings next to each question, so for example, I knew that by something like 11.57 I should be starting Q2 b). This might sound time consuming, but it seems to control my time management during the exam. I was 10 mins behind on Q1, but caught up on the options papers, writing my last sentence when the time was up.
Next I read through Q1 highlighting everything important. (I'd got about a third of the way down the Q1 scenario by the end of the reading time.) I write the letter M in the margin next to anything that's a mission or objective, and I write the requirement letter next to any text in the scenario that gives more detail of the requirement. This really helps when you get to the next requirement as you can quickly cross reference the additional detail in the scenario. When I do the first requirement, I ignore anything not relevant, so eg, for the first requirement, I haven't bothered to read any of the other Appendix which aren't relevant at this stage. It helps me focus and helps me concentrate.
This technique should help no matter which P5 exam you do. I know it certainly helped me through.
I hope this is of no help to anyone as you all will get a pass :) However, if you are faced with a resit, this technique may help get those precious few extra marks.
I don't know where to begin other than that I left exam hall with tears of frustration had I not worked hard I won't have felt that bad, despite doing everything all past paper, articles, exam kit, yet I still failed to understand the language examiner uses for this paper, I don't know who to blame.
audit was 0.5m
how we can do it, mine is 6th time, even i dn;t remember
I am writing 6th time, what are the options available if p5 does not allow to complete acca.
is that examiner is acca qualified, person? also now difficult to switch p4 or p6, 7 year period may be over by the time, lost acca title with life
@girlfriday good tips! I also especially find it very useful to write down the time allocation up front before answering each question, highlighting and writing the requirement questions in the margin. And writing down keywords during the reading time so I didn't forget points while writing out the answers I had thought of during reading. Also didn't look at any of the optionals until I finished q1.
It's not fair after all the hard work that has gone in. I still feel I won't be passing this exam
It was well time pressured and vague
I am still trying to figure out if I did P5 or P3 (with all those Models)
I want to say something abut acca exams, acca as institute only given a syllabus but acca never tried to supply notes , those who sell kits and text, even confused how to complete one subject matter in one section, notes are not summarized,any one who rely on these text never pass p5,p4, p3 also p2 is dam confused, i realized this matter in f9, never pass by reading these text books, some kits, they write their own answers, not the examiner's.
one . i failed p5 five times, this time i felt ok, the reason i only read pass papers, i put in to bin those kit and text.
the acca should supply notes for each subject.even examines does not write articles, i could not find Mr Alex single article , instead nick rayan is writing? why .
acca should realize that acca should not be just certificate purpose, it must be knowledge purpose.Some students pass acca fully at the age 23 to 25, just by memorizing, most of then full time student, in my office one day acca member came for an interview , I just given a test, he could not write what is accrual accounting and any single Jv given, I felt shame on acca,
The reason is acca create a business for book writers and tuition providers.Certain Kaplan and bpp tutors are flying other counties for revising and tips, tips never work in acca, Tutors are charging heavily.
acca must ban giving tips.
one of the tuition provider in dubai, sending emails for revision saying that acca marker is attending in revision and great tips, also they said bPP mock and tips are provided, I went in this class and paid 1200 AED for 3 days, now 12 months passed, still i am waiting for mock that they promised.
acca never take responsibility of notes, why they are not breaking in to Kaplan and BPp.?
Please note p5 cannot pass readng text or kits. only examiner answers plan will help, he knows his style, but pbB or kaplan does not know.
Hope acca will give attention to start providing only syllabus, but notes also, then this students conflict will end. acca will give knowledge, not certificate.
The Kitts are accredited by acca!
@dwilliam468 said: I'm still thinking what I could have done better for me to finish and understand the requirements. The questions were so vague esp Q1. Had I done the optional questions first, it could have been better qns 3 and 4 of cause. Q1 part question, I remember doing this: 4.2mil of additional materials 800k of marketing 500k of auditing made 5.5 mil of additional costs to catch up, with the selling price of $75 I ended up getting $5 500 000/$75 = 73 333 units for it to breakeven and maintain the same level of profit. Well that’s how I went about it. Don't know if I did the correct thing, seems my answer is different from everyone else here.But they don't make $75 profit per unit. This is how I approached it.... Assuming they sold all 2m, then their previous profit was $108m (2m x ($75-$21)) With 0.8m advertising, 0.5m audit and increased costs of 10% the unit cost became $23.75 ($21*1.1+0.5/2+0.8/2) So profit became $51.25 per unit To maintain profit of $108m they had to sell 108m/51.25 = 2.107m units So they had to sell 107k more
Only be able to attempt 2 questions (section A plus question 3). Do I have the chance to pass?????
I really regret that I did not try question 3 and question 4 first. Question 4 is so easy yet I even didn't have time to read the scenario.
Neyazi, bpp o kaplan is just delivering knowlege n concept to us , whereas for acca exam, it requires analysing skill & critical thinking skill ,cant blame the publisher.
@felix2322654 said: Only be able to attempt 2 questions (section A plus question 3). Do I have the chance to pass????? I really regret that I did not try question 3 and question 4 first. Question 4 is so easy yet I even didn't have time to read the scenario.It's possible, you just need 67% for the 2 questions you did
may be the examiner wanted for us to know that P5 isn't easy.
Night mare for Q1 and I did not have enough time for value chain. Q3 & Q4 are little bit better but not sure I could pass :( :( :(
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

