APM*** P5 June 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
@lzyjzy said: Lol I think I got 12000 but I had a feeling I calculated it wrong so hopefully that was only one mark.I recall it was: 4.2mil of additional materials 800k of marketing 400k of auditing ( or something) made 5.4mil of additional to catch up, with sale of $75 and new cost of $21* an additional 10%, meant an additional 110k units were needed to be sold to keep teh same level of profit. Well that's how i dealt with it. Q1 i) The metric had to follow with the swot, in other words the metrics had to measure what the swot wanted, if they weren't there there needed to be some kind of measurement, lots of NFPI in my eyes. It's a dam tricky paper!
What about within the constraints that CFo had said? Like there should be only 5 measures on the dashboard?
It really was bad!
@Minaa said: I got p3 on Monday and I'm already disheartened!P3 is a good paper, very straight forward, got 40% on this last sitting and 67% on P3, it will be a breeze compared to this!
Thanks! Really appreciate it!
NAV1980 you are so right, this paper is really not straight forward. Those who found it easy and feel have passed are so lucky and I wish them well. Nobody enters that exam without preparing and giving their best effort. However the requirements make it almost impossible to apply any prior knowledge to the given scenario. For example, all of us know what EVA is but what did the examiner want us to do with it in the given scenario and ensure we were answering the examiner's requirement not what we think he was asking. Having to read and re-read the requirement, then re-arrange the knowledge so as to answer the question correctly in the little time available when the clock is ticking is never easy. Despite all the effort in preparing for the P5 exam, I feel I will never pass this paper. How I regret my decision now for choosing this option even though I am aware that there are no easy options. I have now lost the will to pass P5 and it is not due to lack of knowledge, exam preparation or anything else. I have done all I can for this paper and I do not know what else left that I can do.
:'(
I really am disappointed. I don't know if 15 minutes is enough to read, disect, understand question 1 let alone read the other questions. No matter how hard I try I end up with unfinished answers because of time constraints. Trying to ensure I understand the requirements takes up so much of my mind's power to effectively respond. I know the material, yet ACCA doesn't know that I know because exam definitely won't prove it.
rab22it01 I feel the same way. I am very discouraged and tired of doing this paper
@LATTY said: I really am disappointed. I don't know if 15 minutes is enough to read, disect, understand question 1 let alone read the other questions. No matter how hard I try I end up with unfinished answers because of time constraints. Trying to ensure I understand the requirements takes up so much of my mind's power to effectively respond. I know the material, yet ACCA doesn't know that I know because exam definitely won't prove it.I was taught to read more and plan before writing, I spent nearly 30mins reading and sorting out q1 before I started writing. I just hope that approach worked! Learning these courses at home is not easy, not being in industry won't help either. That's why they are at the post graduate professional level, they're the equivalent to a masters level degree.
"What about within the constraints that CFo had said? Like there should be only 5 measures on the dashboard?
It really was bad!"
I'm on my 3rd beer…
Let me walk you through my thought process (disclaimer: I've had 3 beers and may have got the answercompletely wrong anyway)
1. Anything over 2 metrics under design and brand awareness - won't score - need to suggest 1 only that uses SWOT as per question or maybe suggest replacing 1 with another
2. How do you get a metric for the threat - ambassador tripping over laces - what section:
Three areas: Financial, Design, Brand awareness
So the laces must be a design issue - but what metric? Do you measure quality - but hold on, that is not design - that is a supplier quality issue that is being discussed later on in the question "qualitative impact" - and hold on a minute a quality measure won't prevent him tripping - why has Alex Watt been specific about tripping on laces - is he saying it might not be a quality issue as he tied the shoes wrong himself and directing me to say a specific answer or is he simply leaving it to interpretation? How can you ensure quality of laces? How can a quality inspection prevent someone lacing the shoes wrong? It can't -okay he must be trying to force me to apply the answer to the question and be really specific….
Sh*t time is ticking....if I just put down a standard metric and justify I might get the marks, or will I??!?!?
HOw on earth can you mitigate teh negative threat of product malfunction that the user could be responsible for???!?!?!
Oh hold on - Icoudl say percentage of prodcust with laces!! Oh but wait the threat is teh ambassador leaving isn't it -t he bad publicity - so it coudl be a general threat for any MS product right? Not just shoes and laces?
Time is ticking away, need to write something…..finally what do I come up with:
"Metric: number of complaints from sports ambassadors during trial period of new products.This is to combat the threat posed by adverse publicity from sports ambassador incidents that are likely to damage the key aim to "prevent risk of injury" and maintain the current marketing strategy. BY addressing any issues prior to launch they can be offset."
That's got to be a good answer surely? - it shows 1. I read the scenario 2. THe metric is addresses the SWOT analysis (i.e question) 3. The metric addresses a key aim "reduce injury" and maintains the brand image and sponsorship that is how MS does its marketing - as referenced in the opening paragraph.
I.e. multiple things from the scenario from all directions, more time thinking than writing and an answer that seems to be a bit weird or unusual - rather than "number of returns from customers" or simple "improve quality" or % defects or number of compalints.
OH damn - I've gone over time for this question - better speed up, oh look question 3 looks easy - what I have to do is obvious...
Agree with many comments.
Subject is ok.
Time-pressure is tough, still ok.
But... the question structure infuriates. It is built to be so imprecise, that it forces to ask questions back. And as you don't have such an advantage in exam hall, you start guessing.
The most uncertain paper and in controversy to examiner idea, it has less in common with real life situation actually.
LOL!! :D
Agree with comments.... questions were too confusing....challenging for sure.
I actually wished last night that swot pestel, valye chain or 5 forces are examined.. now I'm wishing I had wished whatever was examined I just understood the requirements
I got c100k units for breakeven in Q1. Not a lot else though! Ha.
Did you guys find there were more questions in the scenarios than within the questions at the end? Bizarre, had to keep flicking between the two to make sure I covered everything required.
Q4 was just a mish mash of requirements apart from EVA suitability.
Yep! That made me want to scream...requirements within a scenario and then you're detracked from the main requirement....
The problem with this exam is the time pressure. If I had another couple of hours I could maybe have taken in the scenario and had a proper think... like in real life. But... the time pressure just kills any 'thinking time' and you end up rushing out an answer and now feeling v depressed !
Did the same thing. 3 operating profits then the total. I also did a break even at some point. Or mentioned it in passing basing it on several assumptions. And there i was thinking this is the last time i see an ACCA paper. ????????????
I couldn't have put it any better. At some point, i had to close my eyes to untangle my brain...
If it helps I think the units for q1 was around 107k.. q1 was crazy, using a SWOT to create metrics, assessing qualitative and quantitative data and value chain for performance management?? Q3 and 4 were much kinder but we will see. Did anybody talk about over milking cows, invest in stars, R&D should be a cost centre and Baby be an investment centre?? Reading this back, it does sound weird..
i have messed up everything on this paper. Evrythng just went wrong though i know the full syllabus plus its my second attempt...will acca reduce pass mark? Am so depressed. Should o giv up here..ive passed all my previous paper fitst attempt only.so what is wrong now.
i think we should all complaints to acca for the confusing quest
Any1 did that? Used 2015 figures ie operating profit and current roce, solved for x to get capital employed.Then added the new investment cost(i took the w.c as well not sure about that) to the c.a and used the 103m /new c.a to get the new roce for the proposal of setting a factory.
overall the paper was fair but required a lot of quick thinking in order to make logical connections among all the info given. Anyway im pretty sure its 2nd round for me lol since i did only 70% of the paper.
i wanted to write ' see you next sitting :)' on my paper lol
I agree with what most of you guys are saying. The syllabus is difficult enough without having to second guess what we are supposed to do. The questions are vague to say the least. I really think its unfair. I took P7 on Monday and the questions were logical and easy to follow, in stark contrast to P5.
Do you know what we were supposed to do for the fourth part (I think) of question 1? It was the question we were supposed to use $103m PBIT?
As far as i understood, it asked how the current metrics on the dashboard will be affected by the 1st or 2nd proposal, i forgot which 1 it was.
I only did the incremental break even which was something around 27K
I am giving up changing to tax can't pass this
I agree to all questions set in p5 exams are so difficult to understand in time given..even after reading them for many times im still not sure i wrote what was asked..
Q1 had so much appendices it was very much irritating reading question then changing pages going through appendices then again going back to read question..
Plzz ACCA should recognise the fact about p5 that it is set too much difficult to solve in given time as required.
Did anyone use maximax, minimax etc when calculating the profits for the three different units? Im sure i done a couple of similar questions from the exam kit which required the same. As from what i can remember it was talking about risk in the profit calculation bit?
@robg89 said: If it helps I think the units for q1 was around 107k.. q1 was crazy, using a SWOT to create metrics, assessing qualitative and quantitative data and value chain for performance management?? Q3 and 4 were much kinder but we will see. Did anybody talk about over milking cows, invest in stars, R&D should be a cost centre and Baby be an investment centre?? Reading this back, it does sound weird..I also did that..got a revised ROCE of 47%. I agree with all the comments; here I was thinking this is my last exam but sadly will see it again in December. The requirements are so trick, ;lovely syllabus , unfortunately I feel like the PPQ did nothing to prepare for this madness.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

