Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

APM*** P5 June 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***

Oopentuition_teamAdmin11y ago

Please vote in our Instant Polls about the P5 June 2015 Exam.

*** P5 June 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results *** P5 June 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results *** P5 June 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results Please note, the ACCA have asked us to allow posting comments only after 5pm UK time.
Former userFormer user11y ago#61
I have been sitting Mock exams every weekend and my tutor marking them but came the exam time its like i haven't done anything. i stopped in the middle of answering a question to ask myself if am answering the requirement, worse enough the lady sitting next to me was writing so quickly i could here her pen scribbling on the paper and calling for two extra answer sheets. she finished 15 minutes early, i was like are we doing the same exam. I felt so intimidated.
MMark11y ago#62
Does anyone remember what they calculated for the ROI and RI on question 4b. I think I got divisional ROI to be 20.75 and RI to be 41.36. Do these numbers ring any bells with anyone?
Former userFormer user11y ago#63
Does anybody know if the results are going to be out in time to register for the September session. Am not putting my books away yet so help me God.
Nnav198011y ago#64
Yes results are out on 1st August, deadline for september sitting entry is the10th August, on ACCA website - the idea is to give the 70% of students who fail P5 the chance to relive the dream every 3 months.
Former userFormer user11y ago#65
That 's great it is better than waiting till December, am gonna rest for a week and start again. If I pass thank God if not will go back with vengeance what can we do, we are at the mercy of ACCA.
Former userFormer user11y ago#66
I can't believe.......that after studying everything backwards and working past paper questions, that I might fail because I took so much time trying to understand what I was being asked...
Former userFormer user11y ago#67
I was surprised when I read through all the comments, I think last sitting got more positive feedback mostly saying paper was easy blabla, and then when results came out, only 30% passed. Whereas for this sitting, most feedback complained how vague the requirements are. It is so interesting, I am wondering what will be the pass rate for this sitting? Will still be the lowest among the 14 papers, that is no doubt for sure.
Former userFormer user11y ago#68
@opentuition_team said: <h3>Please vote in our Instant Polls about the P5 June 2015 Exam.</h3> Reply To: *** P5 June 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results Reply To: *** P5 June 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results Reply To: *** P5 June 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results Please note, the ACCA have asked us to allow posting comments only after 5pm UK time.
Ssamiirah11y ago#69
hi.i got this ans as well.but i think we should have deducted the r & d cost as well because it is nt controllable
Former userFormer user11y ago#70
This P5 is certainly a cashcow for the performance metrics of ACCA.
Kkami2211y ago#71
Well I believe Q1 was half straight forward and half compllex.... A lot of appendixes given to analyse.... Using SWOT analysis to suggest metrics well nt tht tough.... Q4 was pretty much straight forward with Assessing EVA giving its advantages and disadvantages.... However i dnt knw whether some one noticed tht the company was a family owned company...with only family shareholders....Was EVA suitable to assess performance... I did mentioned this point...other than tht reward system was really straight forward....Q3 was relatively easy as well also nt too complex using KPI to calculate customer perspective.... and commenting on the suggested KPI's.... This is what i understand from it....Did the whole paper in time... tht can be a plus point fr me I hope... lets hope for the best....
Cchrismar11200311y ago#72
First sitting of P5 and im here wondering if I have done the exam or was it a trick. Its the First I have done an exam and cant figure out what the requirements were. I think its better to set short hard questions. Three pages of information. Darn. I actually got lost in the information. This exam was horrible. It might turn out to be an easy exam but the examiner was doing trial and error with those requirements for question 1. Wish everyone the best despite the odds.
Hhassanhere11y ago#73
This was my first attempt at p5...My answers were super messy considering the vagueness of questions. Also the scenarios asked for more requirements than the questions themselves..or atleast that's what I thought...used expected values to calculate the profit...I saw someone mention payoff table..?!?! Q3 was really easy..4 and 1 not do much. My answer to EVA was so text-bookish as I was racing against time..they need to fix the paper pattern man!
VVibes11y ago#74
Did anyone use maximax minimax in profit calculations Q1?
Llzy_jzy11y ago#75
I used expected values as well. Since it said decision under risk, not decision under uncertainty. Did not do maximax minimax.
Hhannah15311y ago#76
@vibes said: Did anyone use maximax minimax in profit calculations Q1?
i thought the question asked on expected operating profit..where should we use the maximax minimax? although i am aware he stated there under risk decision making uncertainty
Vvictoriaaa11y ago#77
@hannah153 said: i thought the question asked on expected operating profit..where should we use the maximax minimax? although i am aware he stated there under risk decision making uncertainty
I don't think we need to use maximax and minimax?! I guess the management is risk neutral
Hhassanhere11y ago#78
does anyone know when the Questions would b uploaded?
IIlona11y ago#79
You are absolutely right! You have pointed exactly the core.
Former userFormer user11y ago#80
@nav1980 said: Yes results are out on 1st August, deadline for september sitting entry is the10th August, on ACCA website - the idea is to give the 70% of students who fail P5 the chance to relive the dream every 3 months.
all your comments amused me a lot :)) I m sure you will pass. 3 beers bet. I did not spent much time to study this paper since it seems so subjective. However, i would gladly change to a more apparently difficult but controlablle paper. on p4 i have worked a lot but I felt i have a goal. It is controlable if you have enough practice behind but there is no time to think in exam. With P5 it appears that external environment is more influencial that your capabilities on solving the problems. all in all probably it will be a fair fail but I do no think this exam add value to me.
Former userFormer user11y ago#81
this is what i have done in exam. comments on the actual ratios. reveune ok operational profit ok but can be changed to profit margin roce - to be switched to EVA I have added 2 ratios for brand awarness and awards plus comments. Did not succesfully related all with SWOT. A lot of bla bla ..looking for inspiration from heaven. b. calculated the loss from v1 which deacreased the profits by 5% overall. 4,2 from 2 mil pieces, 0.5 + 0,8 audit and commercial. qualitative factors - I do not remember exactly what I was inspired to say at that moment. c. V2. around 105 K extra to recover the loss. potential selling capacity - calculate using the probabilities. If i remember well it was slighlty under 2 mil , 1960 or something. given that the market is limited to 6, 25 mil I notice that MS must have 30-33% market share to be able to sell all the production in Ceeland. Adapt the ceo dashbord with this. discuss about the ability to go outside the ceeland borders i did not recomend v2 because of lack of expertise. value chain - I wrote that is not appropriate for MS since its CSF is the ability co promote but with proper information can be utilized to assess the third parties (wtf??). q3. i did it at the end, confused about the ratio to determine on time vs rapid time delivery. - very condensed on reward system. - to be clear, fair, motivable. q4. I wrote about EVA, mainly positive. b) ROI / RI adjust controlable profit ( PBIT - management fee- R&D) Ri - instead of using notional cost of capital i have used wacc. both was positive, like EVA. management attitude. for chocolate i said it should have more freedom to act since it has limitative power and has proper knowledge in industry. same for baby. a lot of others bla bla comments in the paper. gl all!
Iicedawn11y ago#82
for q3 i remember getting 0.5 km per min for the quick delivery metric which is quite fast, so i concluded that the complaints for late delivery could be that theres too much work for 1 lorry
Ttakeshi11y ago#83
hug hug,i got the same breakeven units as yours.
AAshish11y ago#84
Hi. I fully agree with everything you have said. I also love this subject but the way exam is set, it is extremely difficult to pass. I have failed 3 times and my marks are going down instead of going up! I also got 75 on average during mock exams but I find this time my performance is disastrous. I found that Q1 was complex and very confusing as to what it was asking us to do. Everything you have said is how I found it. The scenario was unnecessarily too long. I had to read the questions about 5 times and still could not understand what they were asking me to do. It seemed as if the exam was testing my ability to solve a puzzle and not my understanding of performance management. Anyway, only the result will tell what we have done. Best wishes, Ashish
AAshish11y ago#85
Hi. Yes, I found that the exam was set to trip us up and it was not testing our understanding of performance management, but was testing our ability to solve puzzles. There was simply no time to use SWOT that was already provided. 2 different questions asked how the metrics were affected. I got completely confused. I managed to calculate the 3 operating profits, but there was no time to show the workings. I got so confused that I calculated the breakeven point but with different figures! The breakeven point was not even mentioned in the question, it was in the scenario. I found this exam to be disastrous. No wonder the pass rate for P5 is only 29%, the worst of all the subjects. Regards, Ashish
Kklown11y ago#86
hmmmm, so I thought the exam went well, much better than I thought it would be, but it's a obviously a difficult one to call seeing as how particular the marking can be. Question 1 I was flying through and wrote an absolute ton for, the bits about analysing the metrics, suggesting new metrics (I drew out my new design for the dashboard, did other people do that?) and risk analysis I thought went well. The bit about the value chain is a difficult one to call, I just wrote about the benefits of having further knowledge into the areas they're currenly detached from - i.e. opertions and sales. Question 2 - saw ERPS and instantly knew this was the one I was going to avoid (looks like most other people thought the same!), so on to 3 and 4! Question 3 - I devoured this question like a rabid piranha, thought it went well, but once again you can never call it. Was happy with my responce to working out the customer KPIs and analysing the rewards system, but I don't know if I answered part a) the right way, we shall see... Question 4 - had revised EVA like mad so overjoyed to see this come out, but the issue remains whether I actualy answer the question right. Happy with my ROI and RI calculations, but dunno about part a), running out of time at this point slightly so just churned out what was in my head....for last bit I thought maybe beyond budgeting for Baby and budget constrained for Chocolate. Q4 is probably the one with the biggest question mark over it for me. So it was an okay paper, I knew the questions at least, and it wasn't massively time pressured, just the obvious issue of whether I worked out what they were asking properly.
Former userFormer user11y ago#87
Very annoyed! I had to read the question over and over again to try and understand what the examiner was asking for! Is there a procedure to make a formal complaint to ACCA about the paper being unfair and vague?
Former userFormer user11y ago#88
I agree what is the procedure to complain?
Rrab22it0111y ago#89
Thank you Latty. To be honest my first words when I walked out of this exam were "It seems I will never pass P5"! Just like someone has commented on this platform that they were doing a mock every weekend, I did at least 5 mock exams, read all articles concerned with P5, examiner's comments, quality newspapers, etc.attempted as many questions as I could, re visited the study text, for topics I wasn't sure of , and, this was on top of the earlier full time lectures, revision, mock exams from preparing for the previous exam which resulted in failure. So I felt I was pretty well equipped for the exam but on the day, I was completely paralysed by my inability to apply all that knowledge to the paper. You can now see why I am seriously contemplating whether or not to give P5 a final trial or go for another option! By the way I noticed at my exam centre that this time there were fewer people sitting the P5 exam than the previous sitting! They could not all have passed because the pass rate is so low but who knows may be, just may be they have decided that enough is enough with P5 and moved on to something else. What a smart move if this is the case! Nobody is asking for free marks or easy options, but when one has prepared themselves for the exam, they should not be penalised by the style of the questioning. To get to this level we surely have proved our intellectual capabilities and that we have what it takes to be qualified ACCAs! Why are we really failing to prove this to the P5 Examiner? There is no excuse that the standard of this paper is post graduate level but so are the rest of the other options which some of us have already passed. We cannot be spending the rest of our lives attempting P5! I am really disappointed and it is pointless for me to wait for the results. Like some commentators on this platform have already said, I too are just giving myself a quick break to recover from the recent exam and start preparing for September. The problem is now I am not sure what I will be preparing for.
Iicedawn11y ago#90
quick test to know if your ready for p5 Find 3-5 csfs for (any kind of business-ask someone/friend to give some random businesses ) Find 1-2 kpis for each csfs If you cant do this simple exercise under 5-10 mins then your not ready for the exams!!!!!!!!-this is what i just realised lol
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.