The topic is now OPENED, please reload/refresh the browser page and you should be able to post your comments
Vote in our Instant Polls and post your comments below
Please post your comments about ACCA P5 December 2013 exam
How did you do? How did this paper compare to previous exams?
APM*** P5 December 2013 Exam was.. Post your comments ***
The Q1 i does not ask to comments on the calculations. I think only calculations are enough.
But I have not reviewed performance gap part. When asked planning, I just moved some knowledge from F5 talking about variance between budget and flexed budget.
I chose Q4. League table looks like appearing in a technical article. Q2 I omitted RIFD in my revision.
Other part is ok.
I feel not to be very hard, but can't really understand q3. Q1and q2was easy.
It was hard.
Ques 1 was okay.
Ques 2 was easy but I messed up. Confused Pyramid with Prism :(
Ques 3 had no idea whatever that was
Ques 4 was okay as well
---> 20 marks totally wrong. 80 marks attempted fine. hoping I somehow manage 50
Hard!
Was hoping something like Eva , budgeting but no question about this at all!!
Q1 speechless no comment...
Confident for Q2 pyramid
While reading the requirement for Q3 ... I was feeling like that the hll is the RDIS???!!
Then Q4 is league table.... Done in rush...
I guess I will be failed in this paper...
The paper did not cover ze core areas of ze syllabus. ACCA is making fun of us!!!! CSF's ,KPI's ... is that all in the syll..Pity myself for so much sacrifice...
I have got exactly the same numbers in q1:)
myopia - consider focus on shorter term ROCE (delaying investments) rather than on overall objective of wealth max (suggestested Eva instead);
ossfication -mamagers reluctant to change the actual perf. sys although proble arise (complaints from customer, instit. shareholders etc):
Good luck to you!
The main core topic he doesn't have any question about that!
But the small topic like league table (just a small topic in benchmarking) have a 25 marks question!!
I really speechless lo!
posh's break even was around 68%, and cheerful's was 8or9% i guess...
is it right?
the paper was horrible! paper was very hard and i had to struggle with most of the parts!
i did not write about EVA at all, but instead wrote about prism and compared it against pyramid!
Dear guys, I do really hope that this time we will pass P5 and become affiliates!!! Wish all of us only PASS!!!
on the exam: Q1 i) required only to calculated and no evaluaiton of performance, I just don't remember whether fixed costs were in total $ millions or per unit? I understood as fixed costs and variable costs were per unit.
v) on strategies, I've got that Plan A and B will give more than 135 m, as I found it total profit per Cheerful and Posh divided by units and multiplied it by increased units in 2 years time. I guess there won't be target profit gap but will be performance gap as Posh was more expensive than Cheerful and demand in Beeline was increasing within middle class population.
on KPIs controlling vs operating, I wrote that most of KPIs are for planning as before entering to the market, there is a need to identify profit, selling price. but the same KPIs can be used after all for controlling purposes as well. You think would it be correct approach?
Q2: was ok. performance pyramid, in Graviton there was no concentration on productivity, revenue was increasing, ROCE withing industry, but investors complaining on dividend growth, so the problem would be in controllingn costs especially when they are paying for overtimes. Anybody would agree with it?
on part b) I think i confused ossification, as I wrote, that ossification is when fixing on one measure only, and wrote that senior manager is ossified on target profit when there are other measures to concentrate on.
Q4: I wrote that no measure on VFM, ranking will demotivate as some regions may be deprived or under development, high unemployment and will lead to higher crime rate.
part be, only 1 merit gave on improvement of performance, on employee behavior demotivation.
Please, guys, share with your ideas. I do really hope for PASS and become AFFILIATE FEBRUARY 2014!!!
Thanks to ALL!!!
After reading all the reviews i think maybe at first glance you may have think you have done badly.... the thing is with this exam for q2 and q4 there is so many things you can write i dont think there is any incorrect answer along as you have made a valid point and answered the question. That also goes for q1 most parts
Can someone just confirm to me what q2 a was actually asking about the performance pyramid, was is saying review the current one say good and bad things and suggest improvements.... because thats what i did. I think some people actually went on to measure the performance of the company using the pyramid.
@aida87 part 1 the question was vc in unts and fc was total.... very naughty but i suppose he has to tricl you somewhere.
You will still get method marks though for the rest if you followed it through
Cazza99 - I did exactly the same for the performance gap. I also agree that the transferring of the marketing costs made no different to the overall profit of the company. I had Plan A missing the performance target and Plan B exceeding the target.
I answered Questions 3 & 4. I had a blank on the performance pyramid, otherwise I would have done question2.
I also think that time management/exam technique was key in this exam, I hadn't realised that variable costs was in units at first, so I had to re-calculate the first requirement in Q1, so I was playing catch-up from the start. I gave myself 1h15 for section B and managed to finish in time.
This was my first attempt at P5, so I'm hopeful that I've done enough to pass! I have P2 on Tuesday so I must get back to the books.
I think I did plan A like this
(1120X400x1.04) + (440x700x1.04) = total Revenue 786240
(1120x225x1.04) + (440x325x1.04)=variable costs ( 410800)
Fixed costs (240000)
Operating profit 135440
Thus Plan A would lead to favorable performance gap and would meet the target
can anyone check this and find any mistakes i did in the variable costs can any one confirm were the variable costs 225 or 255
did q1a asked for the calculations only...or as wel as the performance analysis basing on those calculated KPI'S? please someone remind me.
@soulhackerr
1120 & 440 i assume is your units? ( i used the 1.12m & 0.44m in that form)
400/700? Sales price?
Only thing i can see that i would disagree with is that it was over 2 years so you would need to do x1.04x1.04 to get to final totals
However, my Plan A came up quite short @$105m or $110m but then i just used contribution instead of recalcing the rev & costs.......
My calcs.................
Current
sales units 1.12 0.44
Price 400 700
Var cost -255 -325
Contr per unit 145 375
Fixed cost -120 -120
Total rev 162.4 165
less Fixed cost -120 -120
Profit 42.4 45 87.4
PLAN A
sales units 1.21 0.48
Price 400 700
Var cost -255 -325
Contr per unit 145 375
Fixed cost -120 -120
Total rev 176 178
less Fixed cost -120 -120
Profit 56 58 114
PLAN B
sales units 1.12 0.58
Price 400 700
Var cost -255 -325
Contr per unit 145 375
Fixed cost -120 -120
Total rev 162 218
less Fixed cost -120 -120
Profit 42 98 141
that looks funny but it should be columns with Product C then product P reading across
There was this short way (but may be I am wrong ?)
Plan A => Additionnal profit
(1.120.000 *1,04*1,04-1.120.000)* Contr per unit 145 + (440.000 *1,04*1,04-440.000)* Contr per unit 375
= 91.392 * 145 + 35.904 * 375
=26.7 M
Hence total profit 26.7 M + 87,4 M= 114,1 M < 135 M
Plan B => Additionnal profit
(440.000 *1,15*1,15-440.000)* Contr per unit 375
= 141.900 * 375
=53.2 M
Hence total profit 53,2 M + 87,4 M= 140,6 M > 135 M
effectively the same as mine - Maybe we're both right?
I think it is right...May be ! :-)
Almost identical answer, one change was I split the marketing costs to 40 -120 ratio as that is what the question suggested (drastic marketing spend cut on cheerful).
The GAP measurement in unchanged by that but I thought there might be 1 point for that and in this paper every point counts :)
https://www.accaglobal.com/content/dam/acca/global/PDF-students/acca/p5/exampapers/p5-2013-dec-q.pdf
Paper link
I quite liked the RFID question but it was a killer on how to measure.
I can't remember what I put but thinking back it should have been something like
get the drugs quicker
Prevents assets going missing
frees up capital
reduces arguments among staff
easier to trace theft
easier to analyse which departments are performing
It was a real tricky one, do-able but painful overall i thought not impossible but painful really hope I have passed as I am pretty sure I failed P6 today, was an awful paper.
@needs to pass
Can you remember which parts to allocate marks to for questions in p6? Also which question did you do?
Lets just pray altogether to get a pass.. Hopefully.. I am done with ACCA
Hope so.. As well.. I m too tired in the list..
My workings showed neither would cover the gap however one would reduce the losses.
Same results as mine. Plan B should be chosen, but wrote little about performance gap
not too bad
i hope the markers will understand my answers and match them to what they are expecting. under exams pressure, things happen differently....wishing myself goodluck.

