The topic is now OPENED, please reload/refresh the browser page and you should be able to post your comments
Vote in our Instant Polls and post your comments below
Please post your comments about ACCA P5 December 2013 exam
How did you do? How did this paper compare to previous exams?
APM*** P5 December 2013 Exam was.. Post your comments ***
I agree that the paper was too generic and not focused enough on the syllabus. Kpis, csfs, performance pyramid was okay I guess borderline on these.hoping the league tables qs 4 gives me a higher score. Just worried my basic knowledge went out the window for qs 1a, 14 marks and lost 9 marks as wrote crap for performance gap, don't have a glue what that is.
(POOR TECHNIQUE), I think in exam rooms I lose all common sense / memory. the stupid myopia, gaming and ossification tho I learned the problems but the specific names threw me off urgh should have been easy 10marks. also I think I made an error and numbered question 3 when I did question 4 don't know what was going on with me in there. Not feeling good at all was hoping to get it on 1st attempt and make member. Anyone knows what will happen if I mis-numbered the paper? Depression
In q2 i mentioned about the overload of data and it doesn't need to be overloaded when given to the CEO i said it would be better if he had a less detailed more accurate picture maybe with graphs and drill down option to look into further.
I also put about changing the current report to include better perf meas which will like to increasing SHV. I said that they didnt think it was necessary to change as company was making profits and i said if changed it would improve efficiency and effectiveness of the comp linking to the vision/mission.
louibee1024 - I can remember some bits although I did Q 4 first
In (a) I talked about how there should've been some financial measures in the score if it was supposed to measure value for money. Also that presenting rankings as a score and not the data itself diluted its usefulness (i.e. the forces couldn't see how much room for improvement). Then I talked about the individual measures relating them to the detailed goals and how the data could be useful/could be improved (can't remember much of that bit though!)
In (b) I talked about general advantages and criticisms briefly. Said employees might be tempted to act in certain ways to make sure they were on target e.g. not formally reporting crimes that were reported on the beat, call handlers under pressure to get through calls might not make the right decisions etc!! Re the school bit I was really rushing by then but said that public didn't have a choice about which police force to call whereas school league tables geared to parental choice and also that schools likely to be funded per child so probably why there wasn't a financial measure in the mix referring to my earlier point. Didn't get time for a conclusion! Thought I might come back to it but that was wishful thinking!
Sounds similar to what i put only i didnt mention about value for money.
I said stuff like employees may not concentrate on actually solving crime but how far up the rank they are and also same think here as what you said. They may just start arresting people for the hell of it to increase their rank. I think i also said something about maybe measuring against time taken for police to get to a crime scene. Another i put how to increase awareness in the community (it was one of the aims) i put maybe measure how many public meeting they have had. I just made allot of rubbish up here.
Was so time consuming. I actually did order 1 then 4 then 2. The thing that i find the hardest is the amount of info in the requirements and all the diff people he brings in.... i can never keep a track of where im upto.
How do you think you have done?
too generic 70% of paper on csfs n KPIs if u ask me coz the performance pyramid is also about same in many ways than one. 2b the myopia, gaming n ossification are behaviours exibited by those being evaluated I think. eg their refusal to change the measurement system is called ossification. hoping for a 50 though
What was qs 1 split of marks? Deffo mixed up myopia with ossification now have looked in books! 3/10 for that qs
Hi, i calculated the profit incorrectly as i used didnt realise the variable costs or fixed costs where in cost per unit so i had a loss for posh and based all my kpi answers etc based on the loss. Will i basically lose all marks or will they give me marks for correct answers if in fact posh was loss making?
i think it was
a 10
b 11
c 11
d 5
e 9
profess4
Okay... so i did Question 1 well ( I thought) but have been confused with what people have been saying.
What profit figure did you guys get in part a ? I got 87 million (total)
For the forecast in the last part, Plan B came in the 140s. Plan A around 115 million.
Guys what would be the correct answer?
Think it was 12, 12, 8, 5, 9, 4
Fixed costs were $120m each in total.
@mak7ali
My plan a/b answers were the same (or very close).
Think the profit was about that too split $45/$43 ish?
Cant remember what i got for total profit but i can remember i got average sell price pu at $400 and $700 and i think i got something like 9.5% for break even cheerful cant remember that one
Same average selling price, think I put break even in units.....
@ cazza99
Same figures for total profit you have just reminded me.
What about the last to i literally copied them from the question quality costs and awards won
Yay. Awesome. Yes.. same answers :)
This gives me happiness :D
If someone else confirms too, it would be nice. A lot of people got 140 million for part A proflt i don't know how.
Qt 1
Selling price $400 and $700
Margin of safety was around 26-27% for both.
Plan A was short by about 21 million Plan B was 140 Million or ahead by 5 million.
Long paper but which P level paper has ever been short?
Did anyone just feel like all they kept doing was repeating themselves?
I had 115-120 million profit using Plan A and 139.9 million using plan B
Happy to see similar answers!
Very tough, not what I was expecting. Started off well with q1(i) but all downhill from there. Had to spend too much time on Q1 and had to rush the other ones. Definite fail.
Yes ! Plan À was around 115-120 and plan B around 140-141 so only Plan B would reach the target of 135 ...
For Q1, The contribution of Posh was 375 $/unit ant sale price/unit was 700$
The profit was 42 m and 45 m ( roughly)
like a numpty i only increased for 1 year :(
Did you do any written on this part? Surely 9 marks wasn't just for calcs?
Also what did anyone put for planning KPI's??
This confused me because we have only ever been taught building and monitoring and internal and external.
Also what did people put for PEST?
Think planning KPIs is similar to the monitoring and building KPI terminology. I put planning as future KPIs and controlling as past, present financial based measures.
Thanks. Was thinking how was qs1a 11 marks, didn't leave time for commentary. Just wish other topics like eva,beyond budgeting and ema came up...felt too easy almost as if I was wrong as too much csf/kpi bollocks
@cazza99...ditto!! If we both pass then we were right else see you in June 2014. Good luck!
Oh dear, didn't answer the performance gap with numbers - just wrote some random stuff about them conflicting with one another. Lost loads of marks. Wish some of the theory had actually come up!
@louibee. There were 2 separate quality costs. One was per unit so needed multiplying up plus the fixed element. Can't remember the numbers tho.
The linking kpi's to planning and control was harder to think of and I think I went for which ones are more strategic/tactical/operational as strategic is more to do with long term and others to do with day to day stuff. There were only 2 which I picked as planning, roce and profit (I think)
I was pleasantly surprised as this was a retake and I had P4 1st take aswell (and that was horrendous!!) so I only revised for a day and a half!!!
Good luck to all. Merry Xmas
Qt 1
Selling price $400 and $700
Margin of safety was around 26-27% for both.
Plan A was short by about 21 million Plan B was 140 Million or ahead by 5 million.
This was what I got
sales were 700 and 400 per unit
contribution were 145 and 375 per unit
sales volume increased 4% each year
Fixed 120m
Question 2 and 3 were tough. Quite open to interpretation and very easy to repeat yourself
myopia - is shorted sightedness so the directors didn't want to change anything because the company was doing ok, so they weren't looking forward.
gaming - the guy was hiding invoices
ossification - being obstructive the

