The topic is now OPENED, please reload/refresh the browser page and you should be able to post your comments
Vote in our Instant Polls and post your comments below
Please post your comments about ACCA P5 December 2013 exam
How did you do? How did this paper compare to previous exams?
APM*** P5 December 2013 Exam was.. Post your comments ***
3rd attempt. Time-pressured as always. Fingers crossed for 50%)))
1
What was that exam i was not expecting that at all.
Really really prepared for this and the whole thing just seemed to be on KPI's and CSF's :(
Hoping for 50
I thought it was a very generic exam didn't require that much knowledge of the syllabus only kpi's and building block the rest was generic knowledge, was expecting Eva ema etc but none of that, also on q2 had no idea what myosis and the other one was
Building Block???? You mean Performance Pyramid?
I didn't either part 2 b i just chatted about that they were manipulating figures so there factory would look better. I said give them less autonomy and for second factory use EVA rather than ROCE so that the manipulation couldn't happen.
In Q1 which was so time pressured what did you do for the last part..... my working shown neither of the plans would cover the performance gap ???
Did you do Q3 or Q4?
For me very hard, ran out of time, did not finished here and there, very theoretical, not sure if will score 50% :-( feel really bad...tomorrow advanced taxes...
Time pressured - exams seems to lack depth, we had a hard time preparing for topics and model and in the end it was too simplistic!! All about CSFs and KPI's. 2nd attempt fingers crosssed to become affiliate!! :)
Sorry yes pyramid, I said pretty much the same for part b too about Eva
I had very little time on that bit of q1 but as at as I remember the first cal was about 45k away from there desired figure and by moving the advertising costs to the other product it turned profit negative? I could be seriously wrong with that it was rushed
I did q3 was under a lot of time pressue so I waffled a bit but tried to be specific to requirement I wish I had answered that with more time could have done better
Q4 looked confusing
First attempt. It wasnt bad. As always, time was a problem though. ACCA should consider making these P level papers 4hrs long. I think I passed though
No your probably correct in that second one i didn't move the adv costs i completely forgot about that. i just did the % increase in sales.
what did you think of the KPIs in q1 I spent forever on those far to long and then had to rush the rest of the paper.
I said in part a of question 2 after applying pyramid that they lacked in KPI's in waste and cycle time and maybe to concentrate more on the internal side of the company.
I think Q1 part b was the most time consuming ever for 11 marks i think it was. PEST external environment and then like it to KPIs done in question 1...... what a pain.
Q1 was ok I thought - caculations pretty straightforward and the discussion parts were structured so hopefully kept on track.
What did people do for the last part? I calculated the profits based on contribution from earlier part (i) then thought there was obviously more to it than that! Talked about assumptions being flawed in competitive environment and did sensitivity analysis on sales price for the cheap washing machine for Plan A then ran out of time.
I spent an hour on Q4 - oops! Seemed ok if I was on the right lines.
Rushed Q3 but hopefully I will have scored some marks. Think my part (a) was more like what differences the new system would make to operationally efficiency than how the performance management would change with hindsight.
rst calculation I did for strategy A was just extrapolate the sales figure for both products by 4% for 2 years..that was all about plan A though ..increase sales volume by 4% per annum for 2 years..and I wrote about EVA too..didnt know jack about myopic, gaming and ossification. .just rewrote the problems .. fingers crossed .. best chance of 50..otherwise failing
Did the last part of Q1 give you increased fixed costs? I did not see them! Both mine came out above the target so I obviously missed something!!
I remember talking about sensitivity analysis somewhere in Q1 i also talked about the posh dept being highly geared by fixed costs compared to the cheerful department.
There's just too many model to remember. i did Q1, Q2,Q3. i mixed up the performance pyramid with building blocks model. u just hope i get credits because i made a drawing what comprises this pyramid, how each aspects is integrated. i feel i made a lot of blah blah on Q3---- lean management? CSfs, market/product strategies. Cheerful- can be cost leadership, Posh- differentiation strategy focused on quality.....
this paper is tricky, i hope for 50% please...... i feel stucked with these option papers... i want to move on with my life too. :)
both mine also came above the target. if I remember total costs increased to $445 + 60 = $505 UNIT x 581900 units for Posh = $294m costs roughly less revenue of $407m = $113m plus add back on cheerful profit which increased as Fixed costs removed would make total over the $135m target. But saying that I could be completely wrong as I was brain dead by then
My view from this paper is that by not covering the usual specific models and questions being in different format the exam actually appeared more difficult at first sight then it was. Once I stopped panicking and read the question requirements properly it wasn't too bad - just very time consuming especially Q1. The calculations were straightforward as all info was there and no twists - just took soo long to do them!!!
Like most people say Q4 was ok. Just cost benefit analysis performance evaluation in terms of economy, efficiency and effectiveness (since public co) based on current systems vs proposed RFID system
Q3 wasn't too bad either
Wasn't really expecting the topics that came up but have long given up on predicting topics from ACCA exams - its just impossible & means we must suffer long hours of study to cover all topics and struggle to remember them in the exam
Will be interesting to read more of the comments that are posted
I completely agree with you poolsharkes - he ignored the fact that we had hard sleepless nights studying and simple bullshits the figures!!lol :(
I got roughly the same fugures, but still it could be wrong :)
First time sitting this paper and really wanted to get up and leave the exam and go to the pub, it was a nightmare for me. Did q1,3 & 4, q1 was ok but very timed pressured and spent too much time on parts 1&11 had to rush the rest and didn't managed to do part V of the question, where was RI or ROI and was about risk, EV maximin max max or maximin regret . I've worked so hard was so frustrated with the paper as it didn't test my knowledge of the syllabus. :-(
The paper was not too bad. As always time management was crucial and assimilating topics, scenario and questions quickly is always a challenge. Did Q2 and Q4 and these were okay. Too many calculations required in Q1. Did not have time to have a real go at the planning gap part. Fingers crossed everyone.
Thanks to open tuition flash card, i was able to figure out what gaming,myopia and ossification was in the exam. overall Exam was a bit hard, hoping for a pass by God's gracee.
Hi, could you please help thefixed unit costs were given per unit or in total in uestion 1? I misinterpereted the data and thought they were in given per unit - if it is not so will i be given marks per calculation in part "i"?or not? what marks?
Can anyone remember what they wrote about Q4 league tables?
I went on in part a about how they didnt really link to the aims of the police dept listed and that they needed to maybe adapt the table to suit them better i stuck in here " what gets measured gets done"
Part b i stated advantages like adoption of best practice and performance is transparent and that it will increase competition between areas. I then went on more about his issues in the question about the effect on employees and how it can demotivate them if the targets set are to hard and not under there control especially if rewards are linked. I did a conclusion about saying that it was fine to use league tables as they were very common in public sectors and it was fine to take it from a school but it needed more work to it to link it to the aims of company...... does this sound like what everyone else put?
Q2 part a about the performance pyramid it took me a while to figure out what he was asking but in the end i think i got it after reading it a dozen times.
What did anyone write about the planning KPI's? I put that the break even risk was planning as the can use this to plan what prices can drop to before break even i think i did a few more,
in question 1 part 5 both of PLAN A and PLAN B were above the target dis you got plan A 135.5million and plan B in one four-tees
question 1 part 5 both of PLAN A and PLAN B were above the target dis you got plan A 135.5million and plan B in one four-tees
the variable units were given in units the fixed were total..... pain in the ****.
I worked everything out and then worked them all out again because i reaised. :(
I felt at once this q1 is easy.but when read in depth speciall 2nd part PEST there we had to address the issues in external environment relating to P E S T?ISN' T it?i found favourable answers for them.it was v difficult to find adverse effects under those areas. I felt to go away from the hall.v sad:-)
This is my 2nd attempt at P5 and I was surprised by how comfortable I was with it. Kept looking for more complications!
Q1 wasn't that hard. Did the gap analysis and used units x1.04x1.04 x Contrib per unit and took off fixed costs for both products in plan A. Totaled for group profit. Plan B I just used current year fig for C and for P I increased volume again x contrib - fixed costs. Totaled for group profit. It didn't matter where the marketing spend was as it was a nil increase in group fixed costs (anyone else?) plan A came up short bug plan B beat the target.
Myopia I kind of remembered and gaming but not ossification so I guessed that by what the problem was.
RFID changes to perf system I stated what info they would be able to measure and linked it to efficient departments and value for money which the insurance co would look at.
Attitude of staff I used involvement, buy in, controllable. That kind of angle.
Perf pyramid I stated what bits they already kind of covered, then suggested the extra needed to complete the picture. ie external comparisons, year on year improvements. Oh and suggested costs of quality get split into prevention, appraisal, internal, external. If actions are taken to improve aspects of quality then cust satis would improve and could be useful measure.
Anyone anywhere near my answers?
Didn't realise the fixed costs in Q1 were total costs and took them as unit costs - based on that probably failed

