AFM*** P4 June 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
hello,
for qn no 4 how many contracts did you get, as in because I got 68 contracts.
Yes even I got 68 contracts.
Hi If I got you well you accounted for royalties twice; and you even inflated it once while if ,my remember is good royalties were not subjected to inflation..... Also for the WDA tax effect I rather used the machinery cost only since it was stated in the question that only machinery was subjected to WDA that should give you I think 1800 tax effect deffered 3 times to the 3rd year and 1800 in the 4th year::: I think these are the only divergent points we have for the rest we agree hope you ll get it I do not wish anybodu to go through this twice a life
I didn't mean to inflate them, the question Said that the company wants to increase the royalty fee by 80 percent so I did and I have only applied WDA on machinery on 18000 million which computes to 4500 as the WDA on machinery was 25% straight line so 18000 x 25%= 4500
@arnoldzongo said: Why why why..... Can a human being with one head; one brain and 2 hands complete this on time???? First attempt but if I do Fail will switch to P7 or something else.... OMG how can u understand that I ended up with positive NPV of 194 million usd abolutely ridiculous... A total messI suggest you to go for p6... as it is easy as compare to p4. :P
thank you
@arnoldzongo said: thank youKidding. May u pass your p4 in this attempt ameen... best wishes....
The lost contribution is in $ it discounted at the US DCF. it reduces the NPV of the project.
ok I get you now; you went on the assumpion that governement will accept the 80percent increase; wich I refused due to the fact that the have tight ,onetary restriction in that country but I accepted that the transfer price will actually increase to generate 80 dollars contribution as tis is raisonable.... I think that if in your asumption you stated that it willl go through marking this is not big deal..... Then for the WDA we are in agrement since the tax effect of 4500 WDA will be 4500 times 40percent which give 1800 net tax effect and since this can be carried forward in year 3 you will have a net tax effect of 1800times 3 i.e year 1,2,3 and in fourt year only 1800:::: we are then on the same lenght of things just that I totaly forgot to remove royalties from yilamde NPV inYR currency i just added the 20million USD in Imino Co NPV you are right about it.... If I Fail will not sit this again:::: Hope P5 will be better tomorrow but looking at the pass rate P4 is much more better/.... Loool
Hi everyone, can i ask how much u guys prepare for this paper before u attempt the exam yest?
Same to you Ohhhhh; Just looked at P5 pass rate which I am sitting tomorrow; the pass rate there are worst than than P4; just got anxious about that////
I passed P5 in 1st attempt :'D
I hope this will be my case also.... tomorrow will be my first attempt for P5 as yesterday was my first P4 attempt ans as I said, I do not which to my worst ennemy to go through this paper twice he will no more have time and strength for us to still remain ennemies looooollllllll,,,,
I envy those who could pass in 1st attempt, have failed p3 and p4 in the last dec sitting.. the passing mark is close and yet so far
agree with you, easier than last sitting. I did Q3
since March ; lsbf interactive class + revision+ Kaplan study text full reading and test your understanding solving + kaplan revision kit all exercices but never come across of questionlike Q1 in any of them
Well here's my perspective of the exam.
It was a fair exam, a bit lengthy a bit confusing but that's what you should expect at the level of P4.
Would i pass? I don't think so.
Did 3 and 4 from choice.
Q1- Npv was positive, assumed company successfully negotiates the price of components to be 280 and royalty fees increase by 80%, charged tax at 20%, no tax in year 1 and 2, had loss in year 1 carried it forward and set it off against the profit of year 3, npv was something like 56's. Discounted at 12%, ignored redundancy cost, Stakeholders analysis, their concerns, bad publicity, concluded project should be done but npv should not be looked in to isolation other investment appraisal techniques such as sensivity analysis should be taken, risk of changes in currency movements.
Q3-Did part a fairly well, didn't had any clue what i was doing in part b and c, tried though.
Q4-Blank on it, tried calculating futures etc. part b did fairly well, wrote about margins, losses charged on mark to market basis.
Overall my only chance of passing is getting around 35+ in Q1 which isn't realistic but considering i did report in report format concluded well and wrote all assumptions and risks i could think of, It could get me through chances are very low though.
@n.nadiradze said: I remember - 34ml/1ml x 6/3 = 68 contractsMany are saying that 125 contracts is right and many are saying that 68 contracts is right.. which one is correct?
pent too much time in NPV, I got negative marginal with 12% positive with 9%, wasted too much time on NPV, I guess where I failed the paper
I practised a lot but it doesn't matter since I couldn't show that on the exam
I think its more about grinding out marks than intensive preparation as the calculations involved are overwhelming really
@arnoldzongo said: ok I get you now; you went on the assumpion that governement will accept the 80percent increase; wich I refused due to the fact that the have tight ,onetary restriction in that country but I accepted that the transfer price will actually increase to generate 80 dollars contribution as tis is raisonable.... I think that if in your asumption you stated that it willl go through marking this is not big deal..... Then for the WDA we are in agrement since the tax effect of 4500 WDA will be 4500 times 40percent which give 1800 net tax effect and since this can be carried forward in year 3 you will have a net tax effect of 1800times 3 i.e year 1,2,3 and in fourt year only 1800:::: we are then on the same lenght of things just that I totaly forgot to remove royalties from yilamde NPV inYR currency i just added the 20million USD in Imino Co NPV you are right about it.... If I Fail will not sit this again:::: Hope P5 will be better tomorrow but looking at the pass rate P4 is much more better/.... Loool1800 is the net tax effect but it is the loss to be carried forward not the tax effect. If the company record profits in y2 than this allowance is applicable in y2 and decrease the level of profits to be paid. SInce there is no tax 0% in the first 2 years but profits, I didn t find a loss to be carry forward against taxable profits. confused
I also got 68 contracts as time for which hedge is required is 6 months (factor 0,5). The full time until future end is needed for unexpired basis to calculate expected futures price.
I started early April with light preparation, approx 4 hours/week and with hard preparation from May 20 onwards. This was my first attempt and I am pretty sure, I will sit the exam again...
I took 2 hours to complete q1 and hence could not do justice to the rest. It was a fair paper but too much time pressure
Looks like a sure pass for you. There shouldn't have been any tax payable after converting to US dollars as the tax rate in Yilandwe was higher than US tax rate.
Also wanted to ask if you used the ticks in question 4 as that confused me. Had no clue what to do in Q2 , was it a case of ratio analysis? what do you do with the Be figures?
@keyboard said: people who are saying this paper is difficult they should switch p4.. this NPV question is from article by examiner, infact 2 articles were written by him on the very same topic..and after looking at the questions i am sorry i dont feel the same... it was not a difficult paper you can say i m being very subjective... you could be right.. but 1 think im absolutely sure of..this paper was doable well within 3 hoursWe don't need people who have already passed P4 to advise us. If you are super clever fine but you have no right to tell others to switch from P4. Who the hell are you to say that?
many of you will be surprised that you have passed p4 on exam results day...believe me the marker is very generous.
@icedawn said: many of you will be surprised that you have passed p4 on exam results day...believe me the marker is very generous.
@keyboard said: people who are saying this paper is difficult they should switch p4.. this NPV question is from article by examiner, infact 2 articles were written by him on the very same topic..and after looking at the questions i am sorry i dont feel the same... it was not a difficult paper you can say i m being very subjective... you could be right.. but 1 think im absolutely sure of..this paper was doable well within 3 hoursI think youre way out of line to come on here and tell people to walk away from P4 just because you've passed and think this exam was easy. Were you in the exam hall trying to figure a way through this paper in 3 hours. Im shocked they let you be a moderator coming on here and talking to people like that. terrible. You would think open tuition would be about encouraging people
@smith2015 said: We don't need people who have already passed P4 to advise us. If you are super clever fine but you have no right to tell others to switch from P4. Who the hell are you to say that?well said
I don't think it is appropriate for someone who didn't even sit the paper to tell people to calm down'. This is a forum for people who took the exam to express how it went for them and it's very easy to say a paper is doable in 3 hours if you didn't actually have to complete it... Based on preparation it is not a simple choice to switch from P4 now.
I for one don't feel people should calm down, as I am glad other's had the same experience I did!!
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

