AFM*** P4 June 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
Equity value was 10m for me too, but i added another case with conversion to share, this improved gearing. Convertibles were available for conversion from the start.
@sssihl said: Everytime you go to attend this paper with can do approach ,you end up getting pressurised with large volume of calcuations that end u up in not being able to calculate even small issues. Really disgusting. This paper examiner should be changed and replaced with someone who is got common sense to how to set up questions. Either the questions is so diffcult that you cant think or the question is doable with millions of calculations. Either way he wants you to fail the exam.CHANGE THE EXAMINER AND REPLACE A ONE THAT HAS GOT BRAIN TO SET UP EXAM QUESTIONS.Totally agree with you. SHISHIR IS CRAZY AND NOT REALISTIC
@aleee93 said: Equity value was 10m for me too, but i added another case with conversion to share, this improved gearing. Convertibles were available for conversion from the start.How did u do part b of q3? How did you find out the additional value created for senior management? Any valuation method or just discussion based?
ACCA has established a new Exam fee futures market, where students, after writing an exam, can bet that the present value of their marks will drop below 5000 basis points by the delivery date ( 1 August)
The standard size of one futures contract is £111, this is equivalent to upfront initial margin required.
The hedge is set up as follows:
1. Buy £ exam fee futures
2. Delivery date: 1 August 2015.
3. No. of contracts: say £333/£111=3
A students sets up the hedge by buying 3 £ exam fee futures at (futures rate will be give)
On due date
*If the student fails, s/he wins the bet, but this will be offset by the initial margin paid upfront.
*But if the student passes, he loses the bet, and this is offset by the refund of initial margin. (futures rate at this date will be determined)
I thought the exam was ABYSMAL. This is my final ACCA exam, I've never failed any but I'm certain this will be the first.
Q1 - relatively ok but not enough time to consider all the information given in the scenario. I made many assumptions and estimations (made sure to note them also). I'm certain I calculated some of the inflated figures incorrectly but didn't stop to correct them.
I got a positive NPV. I also did an IRR calculation to support my recommendation.
As for risks/assumptions I could only write 8 in the time allotted: inflation, exchange rate, tax, social impact, politics, concessions, - I forget the others).
Q3 - I did this last and it was a complete miscalculation on my part. I could only answer the first part of MBO/MBI. For everything else I made up calculations. I had no time to consider all the details so I made up figures and discussed them. At least I attempted everything.
Q4 - Again not enough time to do all the calculation's and write a discussion. Did a basic proforma for the futures/options, dropped in figures and calculated an effective rate. Gave an answer based on my calculations whether they were right or wrong.
The second part of this question lost me. Had NO clue what hewanted. I basically talked (very briefly) about margin accounts, variation margins and how options work. My hand-writing had completely deteriorated by this point.
@beaus said: I appeared q3. I need to reconcile something to. For equity book value I used 10mn (5mn of the managers and 5 mn of the company providing debt) Is it correct? And for me the debt covenant was met on 1st and 2nd year and it wasnt met on the 3rd and 4th year.I didn't have enough time to work out the details based on the scenario so I went ahead and made up an Equity Book Value of $1 per share ($26.4 in total). Made sure to note it as an assumption as I was severely behind time.
@beaus said: How did u do part b of q3? How did you find out the additional value created for senior management? Any valuation method or just discussion based?Senior management as in venture capitalists and those asking for MBO right? It had to be done through free cashflow to equity, unfortunately i wasnt able to complete the whole thing... the growth in dividend was reducing and we had to project this after fifth year, had it in mind but couldnt put it to paper :/ score one for examiner I didnt know what to do with the benefit to parent company, so just calculated the mv of NCA and CA and told them 65 is more than their required 60
It's my first attempt at this paper and I'm wondering why I chose P4!!!
Q1 seemed to be a standard project NPV including foreign currency. Funnily enough I think this was easier than the optional questions, which is surprising because in the build up to the exam I found I did better on the 25 mark questions. However it was very time consuming. In Part A I spoke about if they had there own assembly plant they would have better control, acquire high calibre employees because the scenario said people from Yilandwe where ambitious and well educated.
Q2 was about dark pools and deciding whether a company should or should not dispose of there shares. I found the written part of explaining what dark pools were ok but didn't really know how to answer the area of should they dispose of there shares. I valued the company using the P/E Ratio model and asset basis but didn't get much time to talk about the results, while also working our the EPS and Share price and comparing to the industry averages which were supplied. Basically said how every calculation was below industry standard and they should divest.
Q4 was about interest rate futures, options and collars.I found the calculations ok but part b was a written element about discussing margin payments and futures prices changing daily which I had no idea about and ran out of time so didn't really write anything. Seriously WTF did anyone write about the futures changing daily?? I thought those prices were valid for the whole month!!
Overall I don't think the exam was a BEAST and I'm already fearing i'll have to do it again.
Guys how did you handle the thing with INFLATION in Q1? it was year 3 onward, so was it supposed be 1.04 to power 3 or 1.04 to power 1?
I messed it up this time. I spent exactly 2 hours doing Q1 and after that noticing I had only 1 hour to complete 2 questions--i freaked out completely. I left marks, made mistakes in the later part.. I came out of the exam hall crying. It had such a bad impact on me. I knew the answers but couldnt write anything.
In q1 there was this average inflation rate and it was totally screwed up! I just added the inflation rates for 4 years and then divided by 4 to get the average inflation rate. I have no idea if this was right or wrong..anyone did it correctly?
I dont understand why the examiner is testing the basics by giving us silly and lengthy calculations? we already know hot to inflate figures there is no reason of testing us on whether we know multiplication and division of bigger numbers or not!
@aleee93 said: Guys how did you handle the thing with INFLATION in Q1? it was year 3 onward, so was it supposed be 1.04 to power 3 or 1.04 to power 1?Inflation was year 3 onward???? Seriously? I didnt notice it! I thought it was from 1st year.. Ok I am gonna start preparing for P4 from tomorrow then.. no ways i can pass this time!
@beaus said: I messed it up this time. I spent exactly 2 hours doing Q1 and after that noticing I had only 1 hour to complete 2 questions--i freaked out completely. I left marks, made mistakes in the later part.. I came out of the exam hall crying. It had such a bad impact on me. I knew the answers but couldnt write anything. In q1 there was this average inflation rate and it was totally screwed up! I just added the inflation rates for 4 years and then divided by 4 to get the average inflation rate. I have no idea if this was right or wrong..anyone did it correctly? I dont understand why the examiner is testing the basics by giving us silly and lengthy calculations? we already know hot to inflate figures there is no reason of testing us on whether we know multiplication and division of bigger numbers or not!I feel your pain. My eyes watered at the end. For the option questions (3 &4) I had insufficient time to understand the scenario and apply it to the requirements. At one point I was just seeing numbers and letters and it was like reading Russian. I did rough calculations (using estimated figures) so I could at least write a discussion. I feel gutted.
@beaus said: Inflation was year 3 onward???? Seriously? I didnt notice it! I thought it was from 1st year.. Ok I am gonna start preparing for P4 from tomorrow then.. no ways i can pass this time!In Yilandwe first and second year inflation was given. then there was this year 3 onward thing. Similar for EU inflation, same rate 5% for next 2 years then 4% for year 3 onward For the US, it was same all along, but it wasnt much help except for the royalties thing
Well after reading about your pains guys I though I'd share mine as my bones hurt from the stress of today's experience having to sit p4. And I am not joking.
Got to the exam hall with the great feeling of I am going to collect the 50 marks and this was my objective, stick to the mark collection.
Quick read in the first 15 min to see if any favourite topics. Luckily MBOs was there. So I started with Q4. Managed to complete it by 11.30.
They are right saying if you don't start with A question at the beginning it seems a bit overwhelming in the middle of the exam, having not even read the scenario.
So I quickly made up my mind and attempted Q4 next. By 12.15 I finished the 1st part of calculating the benefit of having interest rate instruments. And left it there as I was running out of time for the very famous Q1. I liked calculating NPVs until today. Never had so many variables, 3 currencies. So by the time that I skim read the scenario it was already 12.30 and didn't know where to start from. Panicked also as didn't know in which currency to calculate the cash flows. Then I saw the savers of assumptions and other reasons before choosing the plant investment. So I quickly jumped into writing a report assuming positive NPV in the last 20 minutes. And this was it, I have not even contemplated the cash flows...
Why would you make us using valuable time of applying inflation and currency conversion for every single line of the c.f.? I lost the big picture of the forest from the lots of trees. This q needs good 2 hours of workings at least and this is after a careful reading which would have taken me 30 min.
How much contracts you all got for the interest rate futures?
How many contracts did you guys get for the interest rate hedge? Q.4
just like previous exam written with grammar mistakes and some kind of thought shortcuts which are known and understood only for the examiner.
q1 wasn't hard but veeeeery lengthy ,
q3 ridiculous
q4 collars... so mean, nothing on acccaglobal was provided about it
didn't do q2 cause it was very unclear
I ended up with a negative npv for question one, but show all working so should still pick up marks, used the neg answer in report and based conclusion on this,
Answered q2 first and was ok,
Q4 had a mental block and forgot what to do, left it to late to attempt question 3 instead,
Not likely to get 50 out of 75 marks,
Anyone else planning retake for sept?
boh una di talk na talk i see wanders today,after i don read until way no deh ,but man go go na for P5 oh
@jason91
I got 68 contracts.
@aleee93 said: Guys how did you handle the thing with INFLATION in Q1? it was year 3 onward, so was it supposed be 1.04 to power 3 or 1.04 to power 1?y1 = value * (1+inflation y1) y2 =value *(1+inflation y1)( 1+inflation y2) y3= value * (1+inflation y1)(1+inflation y2)(1+inflation y3) y4= value *(1+inflation y1)(1+inflation y2)(1+inflation y3)^2
This is my second attempt at this paper and I have to say P4 is the mother of all ACCA exams. The topic on the whole is not hard because these are things that happen in every day business/companies, but the setting of these papers are beyond ridiculous to attempt in three hours. If the examiner is going to set these types of papers , the least they can do is allocate more time to P4.
Most of the students have reach this far only to be stomp by P4. Something is wrong with the way this paper is set if so much students are complaining. We all can't be wrong. ACCA should really look into this.
I know my NPV figure is wrong, there was just to much coversion and inflation and large figures to even contemplate a right NPV. I am banking on the method marking to score points. As for the option question didn't do so well. The option questions were harder this time than the last sitting.
@flexi said: one question 1 ..what did you guys do with the lost contribution.? The question just said the amounts are....! ...but didn't say in which currency these were.. so I ignored them but mention that I have left the lost contribution because they currency has not been given.And then i further said if I included them they were going to reduce my cash inflows and therefore affect my NPV So instead of just leaving them out completely ..i told the examiner what the treatment would have been if I knew the currency.. Or maybe I missed something guys? The question just said the amounts are: and then gave the figures in years 1 to 4..You are very right, the contribution figures confused me as well! No currency given.
We are in the same boat Natalie. Although, this diet was easier than. Dec 2014, if will take a genius to attempt all questions within allotted time. We hope examiners are a bit generous with their marking else P4 is not worth all the trouble.
@n.nadiradze said: @jason91 I got 68 contracts.34mil/1mil x 11 months/3 = aprox 125
Yup supergaga 125 contracts is correct well 124.66667 rounded to 125 :)
@supergaga said: 34mil/1mil x 11 months/3 = aprox 125I got 125 also. Didn't have time to work out the closing price on the futures so I made up one. *cries*
@supergaga said: 34mil/1mil x 11 months/3 = aprox 125I remember - 34ml/1ml x 6/3 = 68 contracts
@demashi said: We are in the same boat Natalie. Although, this diet was easier than. Dec 2014, if will take a genius to attempt all questions within allotted time. We hope examiners are a bit generous with their marking else P4 is not worth all the trouble.I didn't even realize no currency was given. I just assumed they were US$ seeing it was a cost incurred in USA...
@magda111 said: just like previous exam written with grammar mistakes and some kind of thought shortcuts which are known and understood only for the examiner. q1 wasn't hard but veeeeery lengthy , q3 ridiculous q4 collars... so mean, nothing on acccaglobal was provided about it didn't do q2 cause it was very unclearQ4 was my weakest topic but had to do it because I had NO CLUE what Q2 wanted from me. I couldn't relate the requirements to the information given.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

