AFM*** P4 June 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
68 contracts would be correct.the borrowing was for 6 months
@demashi said: 68 contracts would be correct.the borrowing was for 6 monthsif i remember well it was told that the company wishes to borrow 34 mil in 5 months time for a period of 11 months. this means 125 contracts
@supergaga said: if i remember well it was told that the company wishes to borrow 34 mil in 5 months time for a period of 11 months. this means 125 contractsAgreed. The borrowing was starting in 5 months for 11 months. This leads to 125 contracts being needed.
Does anyone know if method marking is guaranteed?
I relying entirely on method marking to pass this exam.
34/1 x5/3=56
Third attempt.It was definitely better than last year's, but question 1 was soo time-consuming.It's almost like they want us to fail! :(
This exam is ridiculous and as you mentioned guys it's not for 3 hours (without Excel). I’m just trying to figure out what is the purpose of this exam and what exactly is being checked, why on earth exam questions are written to confuse candidates and make them waste their time looking for information? At this level I would expect real life scenarios that reflect the complexity of the real world and the fact that the paper is recommended for people with practical experience. Instead, we get complexity – academics’ style. Time to change for P5.
I got 124. Probably a rounding difference
It actualy said the repayment will be made in 11 months therefore 68 contracts is correct.
@sadiyakhan93 said: It actualy said the repayment will be made in 11 months therefore 68 contracts is correct.Interesting. In the heat of the moment I read that in 5 months there were taking out a loan that last 11 months. Anyways I hope I get a method mark.
I also got 68 contracts (because the loan was for 6 months).
However, generally, I am very upset with myself today.
I left the question 1 for the end and did not even manage to finish calculations.
Did not even start writing the report, where all the easy marks were available for the assumptions.
Q1 was more than a test of understanding, there was unnecessary detail and unfair figures. For instance, why use YR40,000,000,000 as a figure as opposed to $10,000 for example. Frustrating but it explains why it has a low pass %!!! Will be switching to P5
Lets hope the marking is fair. The last sitting I got 40 and thats without doing the report or finishing the calculation in question 1. This time I was able to complete question 1 but I only did half in each of the option. Hoping for the best. I am ready to be done with ACCA exams.
I agree that the figures in Q1 were just time consuming, not really testing the understanding of subject.
In question one my NPV was around Negative 125 million. I dont understand how can people get positive npv. Knowing that large investment amount with lower exc rate and no effect of discount factor because of year 0. First year was a loss. And only the two big inflow chunks were in year 3 and year 4 , exc rates were high in year 3 and 4 moreover discount factor also applied so how can it goes positive? I dont know. May be you guys didnt convert it to $ and taken out npv first.
Moreoever number of contracts i calculated were 124. I m not really sure but i read that twice the borrowing period was 11 months.
I had only 15 minutes left . And i had to do q2 part b worth 20 marks and Q4(b) which worth 10 marks. I decided to do part b q2 as it carries more marks. I read the question and menawhile i had 8 mins left and in 8 minutes i just calculated dividend yield decline in growth and intrest cover. I was actually writing that and time was over , dint even recommend whther to dispose off equirt stake or not!
Hoping to pass inshaAllah
I don't think you missed anything. there was really no currency given for the redundancy cost and contribution.
I got 68 contracts. The company was going to borrow in 5 months and repay in 11. Therefore the length of loan was 6 months
34 * 0.5 = 17
1 * 0.25 =.25
17/.25 = 68
Made many silly mistakes in 1 just cut my losses after redundancy and did the report. Did 8/9 issues risks.
Managed 4 a and a tiny bit of 4b was too confusing. Scribbled a few lines down for Q2. Just compared co to market and benefits of having equity/not having equity.
September sitting looking very likly. Disappointed as I was well prepared going in but time pressure got me.
I think it was reasonable to get positive NPV in Q1 as the initial outlay was not big in comparison with the cash flows in the following years.
@lunix said: I think it was reasonable to get positive NPV in Q1 as the initial outlay was not big in comparison with the cash flows in the following years.Inflows were indeed good but in last 2 years where tax has taken 40 percent of the profits. But 21000 + 18000 and i think 3000 millions rand investment was a huge amount. Cashflows were not that of large amount.
heyy guys, hv been reading ur comments.
i agree the questions were loaded. my first time of writing this paper. was caught up with ques 1. was confused abt the conversions because of the 3 currencies.
the issue abt the components been exported direct into Europe threw me off. my mistake was nt converting the selling price of €700 into yilandwe. was able to inflate the figures well though but was nt abt to use them in the computation.
took too much time to analyse whether the final computation should be in yilandwe or euros befor converting to dollars.
was able to set up the report well though.
for the options, i did que 2 & 3.
@muneebnawaz90 said: Inflows were indeed good but in last 2 years where tax has taken 40 percent of the profits. But 21000 + 18000 and i think 3000 millions rand investment was a huge amount. Cashflows were not that of large amount.Did you convert the component sales price from Euro? That conversion really increased the revenue figures for the cash flows.
@angleo86 said: Did you convert the component sales price from Euro? That conversion really increased the revenue figures for the cash flows.Yes i did 700 x inflation rate x 150000 units x exc rate
@muneebnawaz90 said: Yes i did 700 x inflation rate x 150000 units x exc rateWell I'm not sure then. My revenue figures were fairly large. The more I think about this exam the more depressed I get!
Q1 was really time consuming....i left it incomplete to attempt d other options. There was no currency value provided for d redundancy cost so i left it out. Provided som assumptions but i'm nt sure they r enough given d no. of marks allocated to da part.
D optional questions i chose were q3 and q4. I really didnt knw wa q2 was askin for and given d amt of figures it probably wud hv req'd more calculations which i didnt hv time for.
More time was needed to do an entire paper. Sigh.
The question says inflation started in year 3?? All I remember is that inflation started first year onwards! omg.
Hi,
Q1 - I got a positive NPV $72m, before US taxes. I did considered that in the first two years Co does not pay any taxes to Yilandwe Government.
Also, I did a comparison with the PV of the CFs in case of licensing the plant (was about $68m, this does not include an estimated growth with 80%) - also before US taxes.
My assumptions and risk discussion was based mostly on this comparison.
This was my view..
@muneebnawaz90 said: Yes i did 700 x inflation rate x 150000 units x exc rateI got positive results starting with y1. Why to record losses in y1 since the fixed cost was not that high? Finally + NPV seems resonable.
@esoluyemo said: Third attempt on P4. I will change to P5. This course is time pressured and the volume of calculations involved is killing. I regret doing P4 in the first instancei just want to say, don't give up, if it is humanly possible, it is in your realm of possibility
Why why why..... Can a human being with one head; one brain and 2 hands complete this on time???? First attempt but if I do Fail will switch to P7 or something else.... OMG how can u understand that I ended up with positive NPV of 194 million usd abolutely ridiculous... A total mess
Q1 was time consuming but it was manageable, I completed the whole question in 1hr 40 mins, took me 10 mins extra as I wanted to make sure I havent left anything out in the calculation, theRe were quite a number of things going on in the question but I kept myself calm and kept on focusing on each and every variable I was working on, as per my calculation I computed the following: 1. Sales, 2. Local variable cost, 3. Foreign component cost(@ $280), 4. Fixed Cost, 5. Royalty fee (inflated by 80%), 6. Tax allowable capital allowance on machinery (which was 4500 million per anum), then I computed the following and I got a loss in the 1st year which I carried forward to the third year as stated in the question that all the losses can be carried forward after 2 years, 7. Computed the tax on 1-6 stated above, 8. Added back the capital allowance as it is a non cash expense, 9. Computed the working capital changes, 10. Computed the cash flows, 11. Converted the cash flows into $ currency since I assumed the amounts to be remitted back to Imoni Co.
Then I computed the Cash flows of Imoni Co, 1. Contribution, 2. Royalty fee, 3. computed tax, 4. Deducted the lost contribution and redundancy cost, 5. Added the remittable cash flows from yilandwe's project, discounted the figures using 12% ( as it was project specific) and got a positive NPV of $17.8 million
Attempted q3 and q4.
q3 A. and B. went good, C. ( I don't remember even what I wrote :'D)
q4 A. went amazing (effective rates were 4.7% hedging via interest rate futures, 5.33% @95.5 ex price and 5.1% @96 ex price hedging via options on interest rate futures and 5.281 % hedging via collars. B. ( couldn't do it as I had no idea what it was asking about and I was just left with 3 minutes).
So yes overall attempted 90% of the paper. I hope to pass. Rest depends upon the examiner.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

