Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

AFM*** P4 December 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***

Oopentuition_teamAdmin10y ago

Please vote in our Instant Polls about the P4 December 2015 Exam.

*** P4 December 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results *** P4 December 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results *** P4 December 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results Post your comments about P4 exam below
Kkakataj10y ago#61
hello everyone, p-e was given to calculate the value of manufacturing part of victim comp. , total value to shareholder of aquirer was current value of shareholding of preditor + pv value of r&d dep.cash flow discounted @ combined wacc + pv of synergies benifit discounted @ combined wacc + value of manufacturing part of victim company less value of shareholding of victim + primium it really was quite ok question ,,how ever hedging question was tricky as future and options
Ffaisal199010y ago#62
@jeffrey1989 said: In terms is of Q3 - did it ask to just set up the hedges in relation to FRA,Futures and Options not to show the result of the hedges? Might be wrong here but I just set up the hedges using the three questions for Futures and Options, 1, Buy or Sell 2. how many conts 3. which date Am I on the right lines or have I missed something? Also thought the discussion section was worded funny - found it difficult to ascertain what they were after. So i describes the benefits of using derivatives to reduced Forex risk and then I described the difference between treasury and finance department and the benefits or having the sep department. My writing by this point was horrific though due to tiredness - hope this can be overlooked. Additionally i would advise anyone to tackle section B first as section one is very time consuming and can bog you down from collecting easier marks on shorter questions when you are fresh.
Not sure for the question about setting up or actually hedging, I did the whole calculations doing the premium for options, the tick size, and the cost of hedge. I found the part b of Q3 to be worded funny too, and ended up taking assumptions and other risks, but later figured it was actually asking about basis risks and the over and under hedging.
Jjigsaw199210y ago#63
hi mate, i failed to do all that cuz the mark allocation was just 18 marks and there was two calculations, finding the value of anatra first and then this one u talking about. i just tried to do the first one and i managed to complete it, probably thatll give me a 9 then i moved on. cuz iv read in the examiner reports that students should know that the easy marks are at the start. i traded 9 marks for time and energy to complete the other simpler theories which were worth 28 made a good report format and then i moved to the options with absolutely big time on my side. had i tried to be greedy in the other calculation , it will be so tricky and impossible to calculate and itl compromise my entire exam. i remembered having 10 minutes bonus time left, i then went back and tried to scribble down something there to get me a mark or a couple and thats all, it was worth only maxumum 10 marks. This technique of mine i suggest should be used by future p4 candidates
Former userFormer user10y ago#64
I got WACC of approx 14% in Q1 I used the following steps at arriving at this: 1) ungear C's beta equity to arrive at C asset beta 2) weight asset betas of both companies (C and A) to receive combined asset beta as instructed in question 3) re-gear combined asset beta to arrive at combined equity beta 4) using CAPM receive Ke 5) using pre-tax cost of debt 6% of combined Co receive WACC at approx. 14% (ratio of 40:60 holds after business combination) 6) this WACC was used to discount potential synergy (tax&lay offs) Why so many people here write that they got 9%?
Former userFormer user10y ago#65
It was to explain Mandatory bid, equitable treatment and squeeze-out takeover requirements
Wwajiman10y ago#66
@vasabk said: I got WACC of approx 14% in Q1 I used the following steps at arriving at this: 1) ungear C's beta equity to arrive at C asset beta 2) weight asset betas of both companies (C and A) to receive combined asset beta as instructed in question 3) re-gear combined asset beta to arrive at combined equity beta 4) using CAPM receive Ke 5) using pre-tax cost of debt 6% of combined Co receive WACC at approx. 14% (ratio of 40:60 holds after business combination) 6) this WACC was used to discount potential synergy (tax&lay offs) Why so many people here write that they got 9%?
Precisely, thats what i did
Ddennis10y ago#67
Was this the first ever foreign currency hedging question where you are given the contracts in the foreign currency (euros) as opposed to the home currency (dollars) ? I think this meant that when calculating the number of contracts there was no conversion to be done as the figures were already in euros. And likewise for the gain/loss on the futures and the premium for the options there was no conversions to be done as the figures were already in dollars?
Ffaisal199010y ago#68
@dennis98 said: Was this the first ever foreign currency hedging question where you are given the contracts in the foreign currency (euros) as opposed to the home currency (dollars) ? I think this meant that when calculating the number of contracts there was no conversion to be done as the figures were already in euros. And likewise for the gain/loss on the futures and the premium for the options there was no conversions to be done as the figures were already in dollars?
True, the currency wasn't supposed to be converted before calculating no of contracts. However when calculating the premium you had to convert because the premium prices were given in Cents. i.e Home currency.
Iijaz10y ago#69
thanks vasabk
Iijaz10y ago#70
@Faisal 1990: I think regarding premium, you didn't have to convert because premium will be in $ already and when you convert the Euro receipt on 28th feb to $ then you will deduct $ premium from that receipt. That's how I did it regarding currency option.
Former userFormer user10y ago#71
hopefully i got some luck with March sitting.
TTamara10y ago#72
I started with Q3, then did Q2, it was rather easy, then I had 1.5 hour left for Q1 but it was so hard for me...I did all about theory, but the main part of 18 mark was terrible for me((
Iijaz10y ago#73
Does Anybody remember How many parts Q3 had. I think there were only two parts. if anybody remembers pls share and respective marks aswell.thanks
SSenya10y ago#74
If I m not mistaken, the Q3: a - chose hedging option (13 marks) b - factors to consider when chosing a hedging strategy (5 marks) c - should a separate treasury function be created (7)
Former userFormer user10y ago#75
Can't remember all parts of Q1 question: 1) Sale-off vs MBI (4 pts) 2) Calculations (18 pts) 3) Assumptions (8 pts?) 4) Shareholders rights (8 pts?) 5) Professional marks (4 pts) and what else? There should be one more question
Former userFormer user10y ago#76
discussion on CEO defense strategy
Former userFormer user10y ago#77
this was the most difficult paper that I wrote since starting my ACCA journey.
Wwei10y ago#78
oh my god..realized my Q3(a) answer was wrong!! The hedging should be sell euro right? I answered buy euro..does anyone know will I get any mark out of the total 13 marks? SO SAD..
JJD10y ago#79
.
JJD10y ago#80
@weih said: oh my god..realized my Q3(a) answer was wrong!! The hedging should be sell euro right? I answered buy euro..does anyone know will I get any mark out of the total 13 marks? SO SAD..
Relax! Even if you didn't reach the right answer or make the right recommendation, the examiners score you on everything you do... from structure to calculations. If you've manged to show on paper what you were thinking and what your process was then you will only lose a small proportion for not giving the correct answer or recommendation with 100% accuracy. Bottom line, there are partial marks for everything that you do correctly... if you leave the answer space blank then that's another story.
Former userFormer user10y ago#81
Vasabk, that's also what I did, got a similar answer so I am glad to see someone else didn't get 9%. Where I went wrong was I used the FCF model to calculate the value of the company using the P&L figures plus adjustments to sales, operating profit and WC provide. Everyone seems to have used the PE ratio method. Over all it was ok. Question 2 was good so I hope I score high there and make up for the rest in the other 2 questions. There were some good theory questions as part C's and D's. Best of luck everyone.
Cconstantinos10y ago#82
I think in part b the R&D and manufacturing divisions should not be separated as C was to buy the whole company and not an individual division at first. After the acquisition C was going to separate the divisions and the relevant question concerning this was something about whether demerger was better than a sell of
NNaser10y ago#83
If you did what Jordanlyo said wacc is 9 If you did what Vasabks said wacc is 14 We must wait and see what examiner wants... But both will gain marks That is why it is said that P4 questions donot have one correct answers(because of different assumptions) Let us wait...
Nnati10y ago#84
https://www.accaglobal.com/content/dam/ACCA_Global/Students/prof/p4/Exam%20docs/d15_hybrid_p4_q.pdf
Mmishk10y ago#85
Did anyone complete the entire Q2? What was NPV in a) - positive/negative?
MMuhammed10y ago#86
Jeffrey, bro thats the right thing to do. Atlest that's what i wanted to do for qs1. U hav to split btwn those 2 and then add the the other divisions value which u get after adjusting the p.e as stated in the scenior. Man i screwed this qs.. i didn't do that. I just forgot or rather didn't hav confidence. So i didn't split, neither did i get the sale value. And further more i didn't even deduct from the total value the debt value to get the equity value. So i don't knw hw much out of 18 will i get. Then qs 2. Silly mistakes.. man i discounted at the real cost of capital. I had even inflated the sales and variable cost. For some reason myb bcz i was running out of time.. i didn't infalte the workign capital and the resale value. And discounted using real cost of capital. Again I hope the examiner doesn't penalise me more than 4 or 5 marks man.. otheriwse m doomed. Then qs 3.. silly blunder. Forgot the underhedge in the options. Oh man ! The theory's of the exam i didn't knw alot. Was relying on the calculations. Now don't knw what's gonna happen.
Ssuni641910y ago#87
@vasabk said: I got WACC of approx 14% in Q1 I used the following steps at arriving at this: 1) ungear C's beta equity to arrive at C asset beta 2) weight asset betas of both companies (C and A) to receive combined asset beta as instructed in question 3) re-gear combined asset beta to arrive at combined equity beta 4) using CAPM receive Ke 5) using pre-tax cost of debt 6% of combined Co receive WACC at approx. 14% (ratio of 40:60 holds after business combination) 6) this WACC was used to discount potential synergy (tax&lay offs) Why so many people here write that they got 9%?
This was the exact thing I did...! Still not sure if its the right way!
JJD10y ago#88
@nati said: https://www.accaglobal.com/content/dam/ACCA_Global/Students/prof/p4/Exam%20docs/d15_hybrid_p4_q.pdf
So... Q1 & Q4 of September 2015, and Q2 & Q3 from December 2015 will be lost forever?
Zzimbvekat10y ago#89
same here. cant even understand it up to now
Ttayyab10y ago#90
guys does anyone remember answer of que 3 part b that was related to derivatives.i just wrote its defination and and then wrote exchange detivatives and over the the counter
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.