Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

AFM*** P4 December 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***

Oopentuition_teamAdmin10y ago

Please vote in our Instant Polls about the P4 December 2015 Exam.

*** P4 December 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results *** P4 December 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results *** P4 December 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results Post your comments about P4 exam below
Former userFormer user10y ago#1
March
Former userFormer user10y ago#2
same here :l
Ffaisal199010y ago#3
How was the merger value calculated any suggestions?
Mmeester10y ago#4
question 1 threw me.
Oomgiamsoawesome10y ago#5
What did u guys do for qs 2, divde by eur rate or multiply. That threw my options and futures qs out the park :(
Former userFormer user10y ago#6
forward rate was based on direct quote and future and option was based on indirect quote.
Oomgiamsoawesome10y ago#7
So did u divide or mutiply for direct/indirect?
SSimran10y ago#8
Question 2...I was so happy..wen I got into it...I got confused and never did enugh for even half the marks
CChris10y ago#9
King of gutted not to be honest. I think this was a good paper for me but I sepnd way to long on the first question trying to figure out what the 18 marker was actually asking - I eventually worked it out that it was basically asking for you to compute the combined WACC and use that to discount the proposed acquisitions cash flows - I attempted this but got stuck a few times due to me not having confidence in my figures. One big question I still have is that if the acquisition company had to be split between the part that was going to be retained R&D and manufacturing. I think I attempted to split this out and calculate a value for the manufacturing part separately which I then added as proceeds to the NPV analysis. I was getting creative here - I knew the theory just had no practice of doing this so could be very wrong. Question two and three were fair I think but I had very little time to answer then - and my writing suffered from being tired. did anyone else have similar issues? I truly hope to have passed this time as I have studied like a mad man. also where was BSP model really pissed this didn't come up.
SSimran10y ago#10
Extremely time pressured
Eesoluyemo10y ago#11
You will divide.
JJurgita10y ago#12
Q 1 was too long and hard
Former userFormer user10y ago#13
Given how unprepared I felt going in I managed to do a lot of the paper. Probably not enough though. It was a pretty difficult paper, needed lots of thinking to figure out what the scenarios were saying before getting into it.
Former userFormer user10y ago#14
Q3 was divide, but I ended up multiplying in the rush to get the question out of the way. Q1 - I'm still not sure what had to be done in fairness. Personally, I went for the r&d Unit FCF discounted at A's wacc, calculated the market value of the the manufacturing division (sort of selling price estimate I suppose), added both together and taken away the MV of A plus 35% premium. Not sure it makes sense, but I specified in the report it is the value of the FCF to C plus the probable receipt for the sale of the business unit less cost to acquire both. Re synergies, I calculated the combined wacc and discounted at that - mind you I got both at 9%-ish so must have cocked up somewhere. Apart from Q1, which is renowed to be a hell of a lot, the other Qs were very fair. Let's hope for a pass!!
SSimran10y ago#15
Question one My cost of capital came up to 9 plus I rounded it up to 10%..what did u guys get
Former userFormer user10y ago#16
yeah, got a rounded figure of 10%.for wacc.......
Former userFormer user10y ago#17
When discounting FCF of R&D division should you use the merged WACC or A's WACC?
Former userFormer user10y ago#18
Q1, combine wacc that i have used was 6%. did i screw it up? actually i totally don't understand why the P/E of the manufacturing division is given ( to test if the co. is under valued??) and i don't know how to get the premium also, i tried but failed to compute the synergy returned to A shareholders. Q3. i used 3mth fwd buying rate for forward market hedging.(divide) for currency futures, i buy at march rate. and used 1/today buying spot rate to calculate basis risk. did i do it wrongly? And i don't understand what the examiner is asking for the theory part. I attempted Q4 last part on mudaraba only. Time pressured. Spent 2hr and 15min on Q1. Confused on Q3. I think i need to retake in March. Sigh~a torture to go through P4 again.
Former userFormer user10y ago#19
Q1) separate out the profit before tax for manufacturing and deduct the tax at 22% to get the earnings X P/E ratio of industry average (8 X 1.2) 9.6 to get value of manufacturing to sell. R&D division FCF to firm based on growths for yr1-4 and then using growth model for yr5 into perpetuity of 3%. Discounted a the new merged WACC which I got to be 9% using the 2 betas, combining based on weighted average of each MV of equity and using CAPM. Gave a small additional value to C shareholder after paying a 35% premium to A. Then added the $1,600m synergy savings for 4 years with the relevant % increase, discounted at WACC 9%.
BBenjamin10y ago#20
Q3: I multiplied for the forward rates, and divide for the futures and options. Can anyone confirm we sell futures?
AAini10y ago#21
overall i think it was a fair paper. i got excited first reading the requirements for Q1 until Q3 as i've been practicing and expecting valuation and forex risk. but as i was jotting and planning my answer i'm starting to feel doubtful and start consuming time thinking and rethinking about my answer. man that was tricky. yeah i got 9% wacc for q1 as well but couldnt finish until i got the final value, just had to be ruthless and jump to assumptions and go straight to Q2 and Q3 still i couldnt finish all especially on calculations bit because as the tutors said easy marks are given in the theory bit. this is my first attempt, hoping for pass inshaAllah. i'm happy that i took the decision to enrolled P4 for optional papers as opposed to P7.
Former userFormer user10y ago#22
If it says: replies :2 next to your post, how do you see them? Please comment on forum and not a reply as cannot see how to access them . Thanks in advance
Former userFormer user10y ago#23
Ignore me! Replies means number of times I have written on forum....penny just dropped!!
Ffaisal199010y ago#24
Harriet88 i did almost the same for question 1 but only did it till the premium bit, spend way too much time on Q1 to be fair. What was the requirement for Question 3 part b? under time pressure got me really confused.
Oomgiamsoawesome10y ago#25
From what i see here, q3 was divide
Eesoluyemo10y ago#26
You will divide all of them. You buy futures and not selling futures. You will sell futures if you are borrowing or making payments. Here, you are expecting to receive payment in Euro and the bank is buying dollar. This means the bank is buying futures.
SSam10y ago#27
@harriet88 said: Q1) separate out the profit before tax for manufacturing and deduct the tax at 22% to get the earnings X P/E ratio of industry average (8 X 1.2) 9.6 to get value of manufacturing to sell. R&D division FCF to firm based on growths for yr1-4 and then using growth model for yr5 into perpetuity of 3%. Discounted a the new merged WACC which I got to be 9% using the 2 betas, combining based on weighted average of each MV of equity and using CAPM. Gave a small additional value to C shareholder after paying a 35% premium to A. Then added the $1,600m synergy savings for 4 years with the relevant % increase, discounted at WACC 9%.
Question 1 Took an identical approach and got the same figures as above, but spent a good hour and ten doing these calculations, part 1a and 1c which meant only 20 minutes to complete the actual report, discussing the assumptions and part 1d. Tried to discuss as much as I could relating to the assumptions, estimates and models (WACC, FCF to firm, P/E, ungearing equity betas etc) but was extremely time pressured. Suggested alternative defence tactics after discussing the crown jewell (CEO recommendation) as I ran out of discussion points to get 6 marks from the scenario. Literally had to guess Q1d based on the words in the question as I'd never seen this in the syllabus (only 6 marks so hopefully not the end of the world!) Question 3 Started with Q3 which went the best given it was fairly similar to other Hedging FX questions from past papers. Hopefully gained a fair few marks here. Question 2 The first part was ok, but the capital rationing bit for the 2 and 3 marks completely threw me so didn't even bother looking at these bits and only did the final part on ethics for 5 marks once finished 2a. This is potentially the most time pressured exam I have ever sat in my ACCA qualifications. Given I only actually answered 90% of the paper I expect it to be my lowest mark to date. Certainly not anywhere near the other 4 Professional papers which I've averaged 74% in so far. I can imagine this might be a low pass rate!
SSam10y ago#28
It was a dollar receip
@esoluyemo said: You will divide all of them. You buy futures and not selling futures. You will sell futures if you are borrowing or making payments. Here, you are expecting to receive payment in Euro and the bank is buying dollar. This means the bank is buying futures.
Question 3 Think I misread the question. The hedge was related to a 20.56m Euro receipt in 3 months time. You decide to buy or sell wrt the contract currency. Contract currency was in Euros therefore you would want to translate the receipt into dollars (buy dollars) hence sell the Euro contract currency. Surely this would be go short on the futures contract (sell futures)? Similarly this would be a put for the options, no? Got forward as best rate to use and then explained if the rate had increased above 1.3500 to c1.3600 or 1.3700 (they gave the indirect rates and direct rates, so I just converted them so they were all comparable and consistent: (Direct rate = 1/indirect rate)) then this would have made the option worthwhile as the premium paid would have been outweighed by the exercised option. Think I may have got confused in the heat of the exam as a result of the contracts being put compared with many example calls in the question banks.
Former userFormer user10y ago#29
Sam: you averaged 74% in your other P papers? I don't think you will have trouble passing :) is this your final? What other option you choose?
Former userFormer user10y ago#30
felt ok after that exam for the forst time, considering its like my 3rd attempt. Q1 was ok i think, lots of parts - ending up with WACC 9% i think Q2 forex hedging a bit of a curveball by quoting spot rate in euro:dollar, but all futures and options in dollar:euro - i just converted all rates to euro:dollar to make it easier Q3 pretty simple npv question, just learnt nominal/real rates topic the morning of the exam and it came up!!!
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.