SBL*** P3 June 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
Paper was not bad..the question of 3 Generic Strategy was quite straightforward and biggest gift is question on project management 14 marks only to identify cost and benefits..ques 1 first part i used PESTEL , Porter Five Forces and OT and part b i believe we should have used expected value and cost benefit analysis for the overall financial part and assess the advantages on also a non-financial perspective..i gues it's my interpretation..overall for me easy paper
There was a little tip for part1b Do not use decision tree, which meant use expected value that's why probabilities was given
Q.1 part 3 was a disaster. too confusing with that short time. 20 marks were too many for such a thing. it seemed examiner doesn't want students to pass by giving so much of marks to decision tree. i hope i get pass in the results
@vikramudassi said: Q.1 part 3 was a disaster. too confusing with that short time. 20 marks were too many for such a thing. it seemed examiner doesn't want students to pass by giving so much of marks to decision tree. i hope i get pass in the resultsThe question said a decision tree wasn't required. Also, there were 4 scenarios to cover, so maybe 4-5 marks each and the remainder for a conclusion.
hey guys, please respond to the ACCA survey with regards exam feedback. If it is done collectively I hope on the resit they will reconsider topics to be examined and balancing the paper for questions to be answered marks and time allocated for questions to be answered.
Thank you
@thomps91
You are correct there was loss of $16M from the expected value. now i feel confident that i did it correct.
I thought it was little book knowledge and a lot of application. Shame as I had learnt all the benefits for Q3.
Q1, wow! It wasn't hard if you had a day to write an answer but in 1 1/2 hours it was nigh on impossible. My time management sucked but managed to do questions 2 and 3 in under 1 hour. I just hope they can read my writing as I could hardly hold a pen by the end.
Still, I am not unhappy with how I did and will be disappointed if I don't pass.
Q
@eshwan23 said: There was a little tip for part1b Do not use decision tree, which meant use expected value that's why probabilities was giventhe examiner didn't explicitly ask for expected values. He asked for advantages. calculating the expected values and comparing which one is higher is part of stating the advantages. what I'm saying is decision trees and npv are disallowed but any other way of mentioning the advantages will be considered like stating the cost savings, potential costs rising, initial cost investments etc and comparing total costs of each phenomenon under the 4 headings. Expected values will still gain marks I think but it wasn't the definite requirment
q 1 was lengthy and i didn't use port force in proper way , also the probability was very difficult also q 2 outsourcing
@eshwan23 said: Paper was not bad..the question of 3 Generic Strategy was quite straightforward and biggest gift is question on project management 14 marks only to identify cost and benefits..I thought the whole of Q3 was very straightforward... a bit too straightforward really since the 14 marks part actually told you the categories - quantifiable, measurable etc - in the question. It's making me think there was more to it than met the eye.
Pls I need the p3 study materials. Anyone selling their pls hola me
Really time pressured exam!
The exam was time pressured. We could not do all on time provided though I feel it was average
The June paper was particularly hard. I am trying to prepare for the Sept sitting. The Bpp study text is too long considering the time available between now and 10 Sept. I am wondering if the OT P3 videos have the depth to @ least ensure a pass mark in the coming sitting, or if there is a better alternative to study.
hard
this p3 examiner is either not competent in english or is intending for people to fail. In question 2b, he asked "Evalute the claim that all 4 products can be produced more cheaply by the supplier in tanglia and DISCUSS THE ISSUES RAISED BY OUTSOURCING THE PRODUCTION OF YTR's PRODUCTS IN TINGLIA.
I just checked the official answers from acca website and the answer was the potential problems that might come up during the outsourcing.
"RAISED' was the key word and from elementary school, a verb in past tense is something that has already occured. In the exam, i for one fell for this trap as i was busy searching in the scenario for issues already raised and just managed to scribble down issues i found to be.
why not just ask, discuus the potential issues that might be raised during the outsoursing??.
This is a very time pressurred exam, being explicitly clear and avoiding vague questions should be very imperative to the examiner.
P.S. the requirement was for a hell 15 marks
I sat for the P3 exam last June. At the time of writing, the exam was tough. But now going through the same paper i realise it is unfair to cry too loud that the paper was a non starter. It was tough - true. Like every ACCA exam is tough. Perhaps it was tough under exam conditions, but a well prepared student could have attained at least a 50% mark. We meet again September. Thanks to September.
I passed that God!!
Hope that you all did too
I did too
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

