SBL*** P3 June 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
@mozi4u said: actually there is atleast one question in BPP examining that area. I am sure. But dont know if it was worth this much mark.which question???? I have mastered both Kaplan and bpp kits brother. There's no question on probability maybe the one u referring to is the one on decision trees but that is just little probability.
@avishhi5 said: I still don't understand how all of u has been able to apply 5 forces. I used porters diamond and it fit well to part a (ii).porters five forces was well suited. there was nothing on the threat of substitute so that reduced it to 4 going for 2 marks each there was so much on barrier to entry: ""the 100 m entrace compensation, the bidding 20 million,its so tough to get a liscene the minimum criteria to meet , cash needed"", rivalry, bargaining power of consumers and suppliers
Q1 part b was deliberately put in to fail the candidates at 48-49%? Q1 part a was way too lengthy as a lot of information related to requirement was present. and less time was left to attempt part b and there we see a 20 marks requirement with a disastrous hard level. question 2 and 3 were manageable. However by passing each question we still await a miracle to happen to pass us!
There was quite a bit on substitute products, in that there is no real alternative to a mobile device.
Could also quote from the scenario that mobile devices are prized amongst the young as a status symbol.
I was very strict with my time management, literally only spending the time limit allocated for each question, i.e. 1hr30 for Q1, 45 mins each for 2&3, managed to have 30 mins at the end for Q1 b) and was still a struggle to put together a reasonable answer.
I would like someone to explain exactly how the probabilities should have been treated in the NPV calcs, only mentioned them in the narrative, didn't do anything with them. In hindsight thought maybe should have divided the quote price by them to 'gross' up but this would mean the higher probability would have resulted in a higher price...
Multiplying by them also didn't make sense as again you got a reduced licence fee for the higher probability.
Any ideas anyone? Hopefully was only worth a couple of marks and having NPVs for each scenario plus narrative then a conclusion will be enough to get 10 marks on it at least.
Also confused with part (b) of 1st question
I also faced the same situation , short time and lengthy questions. Section A Part b question 20 marks I left due to short of time and lots of probability
Question 1st part b was totally out of my understanding wat was that aboutt it cofused me alott nd thts y taken alot of my timee
We are all blaming ourselves for poor time management. The requirements were just too much considering the reading, planning, calculation and writing. I am doubtful whether its knowledge and application testing or just business for ACCA. I am already considering moving to academic qualifications...
@akm9825 said: We are all blaming ourselves for poor time management. The requirements were just too much considering the reading, planning, calculation and writing. I am doubtful whether its knowledge and application testing or just business for ACCA. I am already considering moving to academic qualifications...Lool! At this level?!
Really wondered! Why most of the candidates found it time preasured, Q-1 last part was a bit confusing, but time wasn't the issue...
@tokelo said: The exam was basically designed to fail students how could the exam become so different over9t has the p3 examiner been changed?totaly agreed
Everyone please do the exam survey check your emails and tell them that P3 paper was not fair from all aspects.
The paper was fair. but too time pressure, part b of question one was one of the main issue.
i attempted question 3 and 4.
question 4 was straight forward for me, 3 was a bit challenging i use mendelow for the last part of the question hope it was relevant.
i just hope for 50...u
I totally agree with everyone, q1 part a was ok but part b was very vague
I took one look at the giant scenario and thought I'm not spending my entire reading time reading that.
I spent my reading time skin reading the option questions and decided on 2 and 3, worked out the minutes per each part question and then did all the calculations in full on my question paper for q2. Then started planning the wordy bit. As soon as I could write I copied my number answer over and then wrote my word plan out for q2. Then did q3 to time. This meant I was ahead when I hit q1.
I then read the question and then my first read of the scenario write if it was political economical etc alongside the relevant bit. Was massively ahead going into the stupid decision tree rubbish (attempted it 4 times and know all were wrong) but at least it meant I had spent plenty of time on everything else.
Now just hoping I did enough to pass!
BTW guys, ACCA has sent an email with a survey regarding the exam. Please let them know the issue of time and the difficulty in finishing the exam. (they have asked in detail regarding this)
I also found section b of question 1 a little hard for 20 marks, time constraint although I did manage to finish it, but not enough time to digest all the info given and I think the style of the questions this time was a little out of line whereby you had to guess the answers. More reading time would be appreciated.
Not enough time, in 15 min I did not even managed to read the whole first question :( There is no time to think-you need to read it and reply straightaway - it's how I felt
exactly. Reading taking so much time. Planning and structuring takes time too...and writing too! If it was rote learning and writing then theres no need for such planning but this is P3 !! we do need some time to think and write accordng to the scenario. Guess the examiner ws trying to fail many.
dani88
Participant
I used those ratios and BCG. Does it make sense??
How Bcg could be used in question 4?????. there was no information aout industry/market turnover...
I think d paper was not well balanced and from all indications we're gradually moving back to F5 and I don't think dat's good enough, we had so much to read dat it's not really practicable to concentrate on every part and now we're gradually deviating from what P3 used to be!
I did questions 1,2 &4. They were completely tough but hopefully can gain pass and no need resit. Wish I will fall into ACCA stand for "Always Come n Come back Again". I have voted on ACCA exam survey let them know my personal opinion on their exam...
i only attempt 70 percent of the paper,time pressure,only q#1 and q# 2 only
well i attempted all questions, i am just not sure whether what i wrote were convincing, but to top it all i manage my time properly to write on all question eventhough i did not go deep
I am not certain why that last part really appeared in Question 1. It just shows
again how determined ACCA is to fail students. It is sad to see. The paper was
confusing. So much to do and write on this paper. What does the examiner really
expect of us? It was terrible.
I am sad this is my 4th attempt. Still hope I will pass it although the last part of
question 1 really threw me off.
accahere is sad.
I just hope they end up applying a rescale moderation ! It seems that all of us didn't have enough time on this one :/
Seems everybody had a problem with time...let's just hope that a rescale happens then
It was inevitable for people to fail this sitting.
More people fail = more re-sits for the new September sitting = more money!
Any positive opinions out there? Seems everyone is expecting to fail!
Given we got PESTEL, 5 forces, outsourcing, project management and financial analysis I'd say they were core subject areas. They didn't examine a lot of the smaller parts of the syllabus.
Have to admit I'm feeling confident as answered the questions directly, got the main theories in there and applied then to the scenarios, fail to see what else I could have done to improve my chances.
Time management was a joke, v little time to digest scenario then having to write hurriedly to get the answer down.
If you answered the Qs with application of the models and with explained points, should be enough to pass...
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

