SBL*** P3 June 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
I Used PESTEL, Porters Dimond (National Competition said), and Weakness and threat. Not sure about 1.B.
Part B, 50 Marks was not good enough to have a hope. Lets see what happens...
Even I lost 20 marks from Section A! :( :( Completely unexpected and I didn't understand what to write, and how to write. :(
After rethinking part Q1 the scenario and mark allocation porter diamond could have been a better option. Although the requirement could have been more straight about it. i used forces.
Very time pressured but the content was fair and I managed to finish it.
For Q1 I used PESTEL and Porters 5 forces and had loads of points on political. I saw loads of points for political but I also had a few paragraphs for the others. Naturally the opportunities and threats in the conclusion flowed from the external analysis as they are external in nature (as opposed to strengths and weaknesses which are internal). For the riots I said that is a threat because the company may be seen to be supporting the riots with their investment, therefore exacerbating the situation.
For part b I used an NPV analysis essentially as I thought the clue was in the examiner saying to ignore the time value of money. The probabilities seemed like a bit of a red herring and I felt that you could only really mention them on the grounds of risk etc (think there is a 30m cost (10m + 20m) if you bid and don't win?)
Question 2 was fairly straightforward. I had 2 products that were cheaper to outsource and 2 that were cheaper to manufacture but I recommended not to outsource in the end due to the marketing strategy and the relatively low savings (I had 9k based on current production levels). I mentioned the potential loss of sales from boycotts etc.
Question 3 was also relatively straightforward. Last part of question 3 in particular was easy with 6 marks up for grabs if you used Mendelows and then gave an example in the case study e.g. the new mayor being the new project sponsor having high power and interest and so is a key player which the project manager needs to work closely with etc. etc.
Part b in question 1 really too much difficult.
I do not understand , what examiner wante from us.
I think there is a strategy of ACCA to increase revenue by failing students.
It looks likes in the future exams of p3 examiner will examine more topics from management accountancy and less from financial accountancy like he did in this one
P3 exam was a Barrier to Enter the ACCA Industry. Sigh
What about the 500m bid in q1 b?
Haha I agree darz
I need your opinion guys on this
Reading long and lengthy scenerio and picking points from there for pestel and porter is really testing skills for accountancy?
@fagan949 said: What about the 500m bid in q1 b?For one of the scenarios (bid and acquire) I had a working like 80 + (100 x 2) + (120 x 8) = the cash flows and then I took away the 550m bid and the 400m to acquire the company which left 290m profit..... don't think its quite right but I had a decent go at it so might get some marks hopefully.
Anyone attempted Q4 and used financial ratios ( GPM and NPM) and BCG in part A???
Also Q3 last part mendelow: mayor = key player, Ofroad = key player anf the private motorist = keep informed???
I used those ratios and BCG. Does it make sense??
I found this exam very long. I used Porters 5 forces but on re reading the scenario I felt there was a lot more material available for PESTEL so I tried to add that in at the end...ran completely out of time though. Also did not analyse the company's strengths and weaknesses appropriately I totally missed this from the question.
For the investment option I used 2 expected values based on whether the bidding process was changed or not...I concluded that the company shouldn't acquire and should bid separately...hopeful get some marks but items missing for sure here.
On the outsourcing option I referenced harmons matrix...got a saving for 2 of the products if outsourced but when the fixed overhead is taken into account I had a small saving of 2 or 3k per month. Advised not to outsource due to marketing , bad publicity etc.
Mayor key player; of road keep satisfied and private motorist keep informed
@hbilal said: Mayor key player; of road keep satisfied and private motorist keep informedI said that Of road had high power being a regulatory body and high interest since it issued it's own business management process. So key player.
Of road is similar stake holder eg like government therefore high power but with low interest therefore keep satisfied
I also said Ofroad had high power high interest as the regulator, put mayor as high power low interest as it made a point about the mayor being busy with other areas of the community.
Did anyone write about the 7 project benefits for q3 - functionality and support, operational, management, strategic, productivity gains, intangible, emergent. I think I have miss read the question which properly means a re-sit as it was for 14 marks!!!
i thought the question 3(b) asked to identify the cost and benefits according to the categories of benefit laid dowb by ofroad, the regulator. it classifies the benefits to 4 types, observable, measurable, quantifiable and financial.
My time management got so messed up..because the first question was broken down and the last question was 20 whole marks I was so tried by the time I got to it.just crammed for time.
The question paper defeated the purpose of P3 BUSINESS ANALYSIS.
Can i bring a time machine next time ?
I really doubt whether this Kaplan and bpp kits are reviewed by the examiner cuz then he will have noticed that there isn't that sort of probability question there in both kits. I don't think there's even a probability there
actually there is atleast one question in BPP examining that area. I am sure. But dont know if it was worth this much mark.
I still don't understand how all of u has been able to apply 5 forces.
I used porters diamond and it fit well to part a (ii).
It was a confusing time pressured paper with just too much content to digest. Will barely make 35%. I seem not to understand this paper at all
because that is the main theory linked to assessing competite environment, though as you say I'm sure diamond was relevant. Key thing is to get main points in, the models are only guides to that.
There was lots to say about both as the scenario was dense. I did not adjust for probabilities in iii) though did comment on them. Decided that acquire was best option as risk too great for other option as also depended on them developing market share which would have been difficult!
Were the probabilities relevant to the extent that applicants who were unsuccessful were awarded an exit fee (£100k?)? The fee was mentioned on page 2. I messed this part of the question up though.
yes the exit fee rule was already approved by the govt. so it should've been included in the calculation i guess.
Yes that offset the cost for existing operators so should not have been included on the scenarios with no acquisition.
Also cost of preparing the bid was 10 for existing, 20 for new operators.
Here's what I did.
Q1 a- I Pestel, ii Five forces iii OT of swot
B- Didn't had any idea what to do tried putting up conclusions and concluded that bidding directly is suitable but company should look around whether if it as at all worth to join mobile operator industry in TFS.
Q2- A- Put up calculations, calculated total cost of production now and total costs under outsourcing, outsourcing was beneficial by 16500 and mentioned that its a little margin, the only reason outsourcing is benefcial are cost savings and we can make up product b c d cheaper, loss of sales, quality issues, redundancy cost
Q2-b Explained all strategies with relevance to scenario and suggested cost leadership should be followed as labour costs are particularly low and did include that company could look into differentiation if enough cash reserves, focus were out of question.
Q3- a- redefined scope, constraints, objectives
B- sale of land, increase in parking revenue, less congestion, increase in number of commuters using bus, better services, less private cars. Costs including wages and buying buses and lost contribution due to the sale of land
C- Mendelow matrix- mayor power high interest high, Ofroad power high interest low, motorist power low interest unclear
All in all, it was my third attempt and very hopeful that gonna edge it this time around.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

