Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

SBL*** P3 June 2012 Exam was … Comments and Instant Poll ***

Oopentuition14y ago
Post your comments about June 2012 P3 exam.

?How did you do? What came up? How did this paper compare to previous exams?

Vote in our Instant Poll
*** P3 June 2012 Exam was … Comments and Instant Poll *** poll results
Former userFormer user14y ago#91
Q1b. I used Ansoffs Matrix as you could aaply all the information from SWOT analysis for example Existing Market and existing product was not reaaly acceptable due to decreased profitability, it couldn't increase the price due to the cheap imports and could reduce costs which were mainly labour as there was legislation to protect wage rates and redunancy payments etc. Could enter new markets via upgrading website for online sales and new shops in shopping villages. Could diversify into designer brands as fashion concious and high disposable income, could produce 'green' shoes as groing awareness of ethical issues and charge a premium. could introoduce a childrens brand of well fitting sturdy shoes (ie clarks) as parents are willing to spend on their children etc etc . So all in all i used all data supplied and fitted into Ansoffs Matrix and explained why they could follow that strategy.
Former userFormer user14y ago#92
Exam assessment = tentitive. Time pressure is the big enemy in this exam! Did you guys have real time management problems like me?

I Knew enough on questions 1,2 and 4 to get proper solid marks but only had time to write 75 points from having to leave questions half finished to move onto the next one. Hate that it feels ACCA value your ability to play the exam game over understanding. I would prefer shorter questions even if it meant there was more thinking involved.

Glad I left question 1 last and 1 b) was not easy and I can flush those professional marks down the toilet. Defo should have used a TOWS matrix looking at the comments since you can just go through the SWOT given and generate options in each of the 4 quarants for 5 marks each. I used ansoff which didnt help too much except to give a few headings and get the juices going. I think me using JSW's SFA will help scrape a few marks since you can bring in the big liquidity findings from 1a) in and basically slate options that would require too much cash investment.

Question 3 a) on a very specific part of PID for 13 marks was really odd - stayed well clear of that question!

Everything else straightforward but a real danger of going off the question as the requirements were very specific (use of technology in value chain and only highlighting weakness in question 4, and addressing all the bits of the critique in 2a). My answer to 2b was a bit superficial as I didnt specifically set out what is involved in procurement process as I didnt know but hoping common sense will get me decent marks there :S
Former userFormer user14y ago#93
My 2 main issues- TOO TIME PRESSURED its so devastating having prepared so well for the exam and knowing the answers to all the questions and yet not being able to answer well due to the extremely limited time! Had to end up writing one-sentence points for the Section B questions otherwise wouldnt have been able to finish the paper on time.. Dont know if that will be good enough to pass.. Also question 1b wasnt too clear.. I answered using Porters 5 forces, SAF and a bit of PESTEL.. Thought I was right but after reading these comments not so sure anymore.. If Im wrong then hello re-sit in December! :(
Former userFormer user14y ago#94
the exam was not as bad as i though it would be. Did all my question hope the examiner understand what i was saying. Look at other comments and some ppl did understand some of the comments. Guess we will have to wait and see.

Good luck everyone and remember if all over there is nothing we can do again.
Former userFormer user14y ago#95
Wow, everyone has different interpretations of Question 1(b). I am unsure on how to tackle this question myself. After reading the question a few times, I went with SAF to deal with it.

They said examine alternative strategic options, so I guess what I really did was evaluate the strategic options. Damn it, seems like completely strayed from the required answer.
Former userFormer user14y ago#96
well let me tell u briefly what i have done....
I did all question backwards so first i picked q4
in q4 i described primary activities in detail & briefly described secondary activities.... problems like delivery problem,inventory cost & other scenario related issues were discussed....
in part b i explained different form of technology that can resolved the problem such as use of e procurement to order on time & to use JIT to reduce inventory cost & to use SMS & Email to contact customer whether they r @ their home or not & thus reducing telephone bills....

then i attempted q3...according to me it was a complete disaster because i didn't knew what the hell is "PID" I just use the scenario to identify the problem & stated that it will resolve problems like Quality of work,cost delivery time,Signed by responsible person,who will complete the task... etc... hopefully i ll get sum mark for it.... then in part B i just ignored the word critical & wrote all the benefits that it will give one by one....critical meant -ve but i just continued to waffle t+ve points....hoping will fetch sum mark here too..... Q3 was the worst Qs in ppr i had attempted....

then i did Qs 1 in last in Part A i first computed ratios like Gearing,Roce,Interest Cover,Profit change... & explained it...however due to time pressure i completely ignored Payable ratios....i do calculated NPV & commented that it is giving a -ve ans thus don;t accept it....
In Part B i used Ansoff Market Dev,Product Dev,Diversification & also used Porter Generic Strategy use differentiation....& explained it by using info from scenario... well one thing that i wrote of which i m proud of is that using diversification it should utilize the unused factory space & develop it into a small shopper village & then put retail shops in it(Strength) as it is away from city car free environment (opportunity).....
in part C due to time contraint i didnt explained much hoping for 2-3 marks there.....

well overall ok ppr but due to time constraint & due to overload of scenario info couldn't attempt it well...
Hoping For 50... Fingers Crossed... :)
Former userFormer user14y ago#97
this is what i DID lol..

1a… sales growth, profitablitty ratios, gearing, increased finance cost, increase in PA days, decrese in RA – company is in bad financial position..
1b.. i completely messd this part up.. i used aquisition, organic growth, franchising, strategic growth, society welfare, use of IT in production
1c.. was easier.. comunicating strategy because shareholders, stakeholders, directors, employees want to get informed..

3a.. PID.. Cost and time, Qulity..
3b.. generally i explained about the basis used for All four benifits, specialy what was the basis for engery, income increase, and staff morale, resisting the change, inflation factor in rental saving..

4a. alot weaknessess were there and i explained them..
4b. E-procurement.. E- payment.. upstrem.. E-marketing, integration, did not have time so explained it in general words, like orders should be sent directly to suppliers to avoid delay in delivery and All..

Any chancess of passing ?

any comments about my answer of 1b?
Former userFormer user14y ago#98
Messed up with Qs.1 and due to time it was turned in to bullshit..nothing was coming to my mind even porters frameworks..really feeling bad..no way to get 50..only Almighty God can do some miracle..
Ggheorrghe14y ago#99
Hi guys.

Q1a was pretty obvious and i believe many of us did what it should be done :)

Q1b... this was pretty tricky. Generally I used SAF. For Suitability I used a Pestel analysis and 5 forces... but I got really into it and this took me like 6 pages (really really bad I know). For Acceptability I analyzed the stakeholders from Mendelow`s point of view. Feasability - I already spoke of the resources that the company had in Q1a. After that I came out with 10 different strategies that the company should implement, all of them linked with the SAF analysis... DO YOU THINK THIS IS OK?

Q2a. I believe this should have been analyzed with the framework of Balogun Hope Hailey regarding change. I got through all the 7 features in the framework and explained why it did not work (Time, Scope, Diversity, Capacity, Capability, and the other 2 that I always forget:)) Also, i categorized the process with respect to Harmons matrix and explained why i should have not been automated in the first place.

Q2b i made up a formal procedure for procurement and explained why each step in the procedure would have brought advantages to the company (opposed to the current anarchic procurement process).

Q4... I only got to do part a, but only a bit on it.

My bastard mind started developping very much on each subject, so I found the exam to be really time pressured.

Is there anyone who used Balogun Hope Hailey in Q2a?

Also, my approach to Q1b was ok?
Former userFormer user14y ago#100
I don't know why people were using SFA for 1b. SFA is only useful for analysing the actual strategies, the question was asking for what types of strategies to use to improve its position. SFA is useless for this.

Did anyone else feel like it was one big reading comprehension exam?
Ggheorrghe14y ago#101
@davclav

I believe SFA can be used to assess new strategies... actual strategies are already suitable, acceptable, feasible, because if they weren`t they wouldn`t be current strategies, right?
Former userFormer user14y ago#102
@ lee1010

yep we will be looking forward for the best. my opinion is that since this is an international exam. wordings of the question has to be very clear as the English is not the first language of many students who is taking this exam. I am sure examiner will look in to this matter and he will identify that there is a small issue in the question it self.

Thnx........
Former userFormer user14y ago#103
what do you think regarding 1b if using the 6i's and 7p's in order for the company to adopt sa strategy where it focus on online sales therefore emarketing is involved and obvoiusly marketing mix is effected?
thanks!!
Former userFormer user14y ago#104
Unfortuntely i will resit. Out of time running only 75 marks.
But Q1b i found it clear. Requesting strategic options which for me is either Ansof or generic strategies and justifying them by using S(making use of TOWS identified in the scenario) A(Meadolows justification)F(resources).
Good luck for those that are close to pass, for the rest we will talk in December.
For now have a good summer.
Former userFormer user14y ago#105
This, I feel, was a fair paper, although without the more popular models - PESTEL, Porter's Diamond, 5 forces .......
Some learning points that would help everyone in future exams:
1) It is good to know the models. But they only help you to generate ideas. Common sense will take you a long way in this paper, and related ones.
2) Don't neglect the TECHNICAL ARTICLES. They usually contain materials you won't find in the approved study packs.
Examples in this paper- Question 1c (12 marks), Question 3b (12 marks)
24 marks bonus, if you read them that is!
Wish everyone success come August.
Ssogan014y ago#106
Yes the paper was fair, it was my first attempt but my approach was completely wrong, i ran out of time MANAMENT WAS very poor. I dont think i made it. as i did not complete all my questions.
Ssboyle0114y ago#107
I was a bit confused about Q2 i about the CEO choosing the software. Was it asking why the software package wasn't a good fit for this organisation?
Cchansabue14y ago#108
The paper was fair.
For the first time i was pressured for time. Spent too much time on question 1a. In the end walked out of the exam room with answers in my head.
Former userFormer user14y ago#109
For Q1(b) you can use any model that you think fits the appropriate context within the question. I decided to look at its external and internal position and analysed this using McKinsey 7S,Porters 5 forces and the strategy Clock to determine in what direction they should focus, what they need to bring to the market and how they could compete, expand or differentiate within the market.
Vvacamas200214y ago#110
Adedavid said 18 hours, 37 minutes ago:
Question 3b (12 marks)

What was the technical article related to question 3b?

Thanks
Former userFormer user14y ago#111
@vacamas2002 said:
Adedavid said 18 hours, 37 minutes ago:
Question 3b (12 marks)

What was the technical article related to question 3b?

Thanks



Titled - Project Management : Business Cases and Gateways, April 2011.
It explains observable, measurable and quantifiable benefits.
Former userFormer user14y ago#112
hey everyone..just want to ask,,q1a i just do a ratio and plus benefit and problem of have new operation facility...its OK? i not calculate npv n expected value...hope i still gain same mark there...as overall..its difficult paper.q2 i not have time coz i do value chain fist....i do q1,q2,q4 i hope i can get 50 mark...
Jjrow14y ago#113
Hi guys,

I might have been way off the mark here, but for Q1b I also discussed a couple of strategies and then use SAF. It asked for a framework, so I thought SAF was acceptable, as Ansoff is a model, may be I'm wrong. I did however mention elements of Ansoff's model -namely diversification, I also suggested exporting as a means of market development, little outlay fees , the business was cash strapped so would be good option/
Jjrow14y ago#114
Additionally. I cant remember but I vaguely remember seeing in the question the brothers, for ethical reasons, would not want to move production abroad so that was not an option as far I was concerned.......????
Former userFormer user14y ago#115
EXAM WAS GENERALLY OK. HOWEVER, LOTS OF TIME WAS NEEDED TO READ, SINCE ALL THE QT WERE RELATIVELY LONG.
Former userFormer user14y ago#116
paper was fair but time management was a prob on my side. It was my first time I felt like giving up in the middle of the paper due to time pressure!!!! Oh my God, qtn 1b...have no wrds....!! I did Qtn 3 but had run out of time and didn't analyse well the scenario, qtn 4 was ok but since i was time bad, i didn't do to my best!!! I just pray for a 50