Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

SBL*** P3 June 2012 Exam was … Comments and Instant Poll ***

Oopentuition14y ago
Post your comments about June 2012 P3 exam.

?How did you do? What came up? How did this paper compare to previous exams?

Vote in our Instant Poll
*** P3 June 2012 Exam was … Comments and Instant Poll *** poll results
Kkaym14y ago#31
using ansoff product matrix. The bit on market development can be analysed through a Pestel. Can it not?
Kkateker14y ago#32
didn't have time to thought and answer 1b...hope for a pass
Kkaym14y ago#33
Im not sure now. I am confused.
Former userFormer user14y ago#34
just horrible paper as usual.
lots of things to write but little time. so lengthy paper
i did Q1,2,4
Former userFormer user14y ago#35
It was ok but time was not enough. In 1b U used Ansoff ans SFA, pro dev, market penetration (cost leadership and differentation)
Nnishina14y ago#36
@gudluck,
fuhh quite relieved to hear that, but im not sure how i explain it but at least im not totally wrong.. :)
Former userFormer user14y ago#37
The qestions in section B of this paper have become very lengthy. Time management has now become a threat,if not well-managed,to us in passing the exam.What is the point of giving us the extra 15 minutes reading time when it has been compromised by lengthening the case study? Evidence in the examiner's report suggested otherwise. Can somebody out there tell me the truth, are the questions too lenthy based on the time allocation? Thanks.
Nnishina14y ago#38
@kaym,
yes, tows is for external and internal analysis in strategic position, not strategic option
Former userFormer user14y ago#39
Greetings my fellow students.

I'd thought that exam was ok, I did questions 1, 2 and 4.

Question 1 was split into three parts. The first being some financial analysis and looking at the payback of an investment.

The second was discussing a strategy

And the third was communicating the mission, values and something else relating to said startegy and why it was important to do so.

For the first part I done some basic profit ratios, ROCE and gearing and commented on the ratios and what they meant. The investment I used payback to work out the total returns of the intial investment and that fact that whilst scenario 2 would have netted Hammond $2.5m, it did have the porbability of 0.3 so it less likely to happen. Coupled with the intial outlay of $37.5m Is aid that I would not think Hammond would have the cash flow and any further borrowing would only increase the gearing.

The second part was quite tough I thought. I wondered what framework to use. Thought about the PESTEL but then realised that this is environment and not strategy so I went with ye ole SAF analysis. I went with the strategy that they should relocate thier production to Oritheria and formed my SAF basis on that.

Bringing in Mendelow to help with the acceptablility of the strategy to the stakeholders of the company (the brothers, employees, the green group and the goverment) and the course of action that it should take. As a final foot note ementioned E-commerce as they had a website but no-one using it.

For the third part about communicating mission, values and objectives I just waffled a bit.

Anybody else print off the technical article about the above and not read it??!!

Question 2 was about Harmons business process and Skidmore framework regarding the procurement and implementation of software.

I mentioned about the process of batch production being a core competence, One that Flexi should keep and develop. And the fact that the CEO did not recognise this and as a result trying to automate part of the process resulted in a clash and destroyed the value and competetitve edge.

The second part was about the process involved in buying and implenting software fairly straight forward and there were plenty of references in the question.

Question 4 was my strongest question I felt. Talked about the value chain and the weaknesses with the company.

And the use of technology would be utlising the website more, log in's for cusotmers to view thier orders in real time, call backs. Giving drivers phones to contact customers to make sure they are in and a basic planing tool to help plan the driver's routes.

As foot note I suggested that they should completely over haul thier production process for something akin to JIT. Save on storage costs and try to bring down the lead time from 10 weeks to something less of which is the amin reason that customers cancel thier orders.

The above is by no means 'correct'

Good luck everyone come the 8/8.
Kkaym14y ago#40
@nishina
When u do ansoff product matrix. Within the market development, I was told a PESTEL can be used for that option is that not true.

I dont know I messed up.
Mmountain12314y ago#41
can anyone tell me how to answer Q2(b), any model/theory to use?
Former userFormer user14y ago#42
q1 was very strange...i spent 15 minutes of thinkin about part b. I tried to solve it using ASF approach, i wrote about two strategies and assess them by that approach.
q4 was quite good, value chain its not a difficult topic.
q3 part a) seems easy when im read requirement but with hard scenario
and part b) is completely bull shit. 12 marks for so strange question, i dont have idea how to collect more than 3-5 marks in this question.
Former userFormer user14y ago#43
Project management and mission statement was there as per open tuition guess paper. thax u so much open tuition. yesterday i saw ur paper and read that articles mission statement..:D
Eernstaugust14y ago#44
@mountain123 said:
can anyone tell me how to answer Q2(b), any model/theory to use?

There is a process established by Skidmore itself. It's in the BPP course notes. But I think if you wrote common sense things this will also earn you a few marks.
Eernstaugust14y ago#45
I also had problems with the time allocation. Never sat an exam before where I left so many questions unanswered. Even those that I could answer - I had no time to plan and structure my answer.
How can anyone do that? Because it doesn't matter whether you have learnt or not - P3 success depends on something else for which you cannot really prepare yourself and that makes me sad :(

Otherwise: I think the questions were all okay (Haven't done Q3 though.)
Former userFormer user14y ago#46
@notforu said:
q1 was very strange...i spent 15 minutes of thinkin about part b. I tried to solve it using ASF approach, i wrote about two strategies and assess them by that approach.
q4 was quite good, value chain its not a difficult topic.
q3 part a) seems easy when im read requirement but with hard scenario
and part b) is completely bull shit. 12 marks for so strange question, i dont have idea how to collect more than 3-5 marks in this question.


Glad you are not the only one regarding SAF approach.

I said that the brothers had not had any input into the company for 20 years and the comany itself was in a strong position regarding it's brand.

Said the only reason the brothers did not want to upset the locals and business is because as per the question they were paying themsleves a fairly large dividend and did not want ot see that stop.

So I said that they should relocate production to the foreign country and based my SAF analysis on that. Hope it gets me some marks or I may have failed.
Nnishina14y ago#47
@kaym,
im so sorry, i dont understand yr question. u mean using PESTEL in 1b? from my understanding, we cannot use PESTEL but hey, im a student, maybe i was wrong, we dont know bout that, right? maybe it is acceptable by looking how you wrote the answer
Mmountain12314y ago#48
@ernstaugust I thought of it as a project, so I used project management model...
Nnishina14y ago#49
oh man, i guess i made a mistake on q2b.. i do not know the formal process, so i just put something relating to formal and informal planning process and answer according to the scenario... i was totally wrong,am i? :(
Former userFormer user14y ago#50
which brothers are you talking about? they died many years ago ;) i suggested in 1b to sell shops and lease back what is usual practise in their land.. this would give additional working capital and improve gearing.. did anybody write same idea?
Former userFormer user14y ago#51
I THOUGHT IT WAS SO EASY IM GOING TO GET 100% NANANANA
Former userFormer user14y ago#52
@milachika said:
which brothers are you talking about? they died many years ago ;) i suggested in 1b to sell shops and lease back what is usual practise in their land.. this would give additional working capital and improve gearing.. did anybody write same idea?

gearing of the company was reducing without doing anything. but if u will use sale and lease back scheme it will increase (!) gearing, coz u will recognise liability in the BS.
my strategy is about to focus on green customers, which can pai premium margin and to avoid direct competition with cheap products from some country (dont remember the name)
Former userFormer user14y ago#53
heyy all guys regarding question 1b.i think its the points u justify regarding any framework used its not the frame that fetches marks its the justification of points u described.i used pestel because i found it appropriate as there were points to fetch envoirnmental.social culture technological.legal so i used pestel
Former userFormer user14y ago#54
@milachika said:
which brothers are you talking about? they died many years ago ;) i suggested in 1b to sell shops and lease back what is usual practise in their land.. this would give additional working capital and improve gearing.. did anybody write same idea?


lol, seriously I think I may of cocked up 1b. I'll wait and see come results day.

I'm just hoping that Skidmore and his gang when they produce the marking scheme will keep it fairly open when allocating the marks to the various strategies and ideas offered.

Or they make just keep it purely to the question that should have been answered in the first place!!

Me thinks I'll be doing a re-sit in December.
Eernstaugust14y ago#55
@notforu said:
gearing of the company was reducing without doing anything. but if u will use sale and lease back scheme it will increase (!) gearing, coz u will recognise liability in the BS.
my strategy is about to focus on green customers, which can pai premium margin and to avoid direct competition with cheap products from some country (dont remember the name)


gearing was increasing as far as I know.
and they should lease it back with operating lease... then you have only the monthly payments under current liabilities.
Ggeorgetav14y ago#56
orla333, are you serious?!?! :)

I thought it wasn't hard either. But I am crap at time allocation!!

I got carried away with qu4 and spent an hour on it, trying to get at least 20 marks!
Nobody did qu 3???!!!! I did...But probably only half cause I realized I need to get started on qu1!! On qu 3 I wrote what should project intialisation phase be made of and then discussed why those 4 savings that they are talking about are not accurate/what the issue is with each one of them. Didn't have time to discuss other issues :(
Qu1: Ansoff, although not all were applicable (e.g. developing in other markets - one would have been O....but the treatment received by employees there doesn't match the Co's social responsibility. I argued tho that they could implement the same policy about ppl there as well, which might make them a loved brand; on the other hand, they seemed to be extremely good on footware, so there was little room for any new products; the only thing I could think of was a 'value' range that they can export for less wealthy countries)
I mentioned outsorcing - but more negatives, the only positive was cost saving.
Also, strategic alliances (didn't discuss it tho) and selling/renting some of the redundant/underperfoming factories/retail shops (I mentioned a cost/benefit analysis before doing this)
And I discussed about the benefit of improving their web site - that would allow them to sell internationally with minimum costs. I actually ended up with the conclusion that this is the main thing they should focus, as they need to 'combat' international competition and they don't seem to have loads of money for investing oversees at the moment

Again, poor time allocation and loads of things to say!
Really hoping for a pass!!

...what a surprise that no big frameworks came up!!!
Uugras0514y ago#57
baral,

my views exactly, as long as you made reasonable suggestions, it doesn't matter about the model you have used. We can only work with information we are given and there was lot of logical points to be made.
Ddongqin1414y ago#58
Does anyone think q2 as change management....?
I used contextual model...
It asked to "critically evaluate the decision made" and "why it likely to fail"
Former userFormer user14y ago#59
This was my first sitting at a P level paper and I really struggled to stick to the time limit, I felt I didn't answer the B questions that well as I was so rushed for time!!

For Q1(a) - the first part of the qu asked you to analyse the fin position of the company and evaluate the investment proposal. Quite a big requirement for 14 marks. I did ratios for all 3 years and then discussed them in relation to Hammond. Next to Evaluate the investment decision I used SAF - Suitability - does investment fit with strat objectives, Acceptability - Risk, return and acceptability to stakeholders and Feasibility - the resources - 9 m's!

Q1 (b) Strategic choices - I used Porters Generic strategy's, Ansoff and I used the Swot analysis and details given in the question. I didn't use PESTEL as I thought that was for use in strategic analysis, but it may have been fine here too!!

Q1 (c) Was about Mission, value and objectives - I defined these and related them to paragraph 1/2 in the question eg they provided housing, education, better working conditions etc. For objectives I also mentioned the SMART criteria.

Q2 (a) Evaluate the software package - I used Harmon's process strategy matrix and stated they were treating the process as low strat importance and low complexity, but this was wrong as the production process was the CSF of the company and evaluated the software package pro's and con's. I recommended a bespoke package with training in-house was more suited to company needs.

Q2 (b) The process for package procurement, evaluation and implementation - I just mentioned how they go about deciding what package to buy, evaluate it by testing etc and implement it - possibly alongside old system etc, I was running out of time so I bullet pointed on this and tried to put a few examples in from question.

Q3 (a) Wanted to know the contents of a PID - Project Initiation Document basically and how it would of helped the company had there been one in place. Again because of time I rushed this,I tried to see in the question what went wrong and tried to answer the question using this.

Q3 (b) I ran out of time so I put quick bullet points. Basically it asked you to critically evaluate the project benefits such as rent savings, staff morale etc. I just quickly put that such savings would not be the same year on year due to external factors eg inflation and how could a figure be put on staff morale as this wasnt quantifiable, but qualitative. Basically I didn't answer this part too well, but I don't think it was the best question.

I haven't a clue how I've done, I thought I answered Q1 reasonably but I'm worried that my Part B question's may have let me down due to time constraints!!
Former userFormer user14y ago#60
Hi georetav
No definetly not serios left this open at my desk and when i came back my brother had written this. Apologies. I thought paper was fair for question one i did ansoff, i said they should do the investment even though looking at others now it appears this might be wrong i thought 1c was ok. Then in the options i did question three and four i thought 4 was grand 3a was ok didnt have a clue what to write for 3b and waffeled. what was supposed to be the answer for 3b does anyone know. Dissapointed bigger topics didnt come up but all in all thought it was ok.