Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

SBL*** P3 June 2012 Exam was … Comments and Instant Poll ***

Oopentuition14y ago
Post your comments about June 2012 P3 exam.

?How did you do? What came up? How did this paper compare to previous exams?

Vote in our Instant Poll
*** P3 June 2012 Exam was … Comments and Instant Poll *** poll results
Former userFormer user14y ago#61
Thought it was an OK paper, scenarios were boring and uningaging compared to some past papers I've done, lack of models that could have been used, only one really was the Value Chain, no Diamond, 5 Forces, Pestel etc. Didn't like question 1 at all, thought it was one of the worst I've done out out of all practice ones.

Answered it all as best as I could....heres hoping for a pass!!
Former userFormer user14y ago#62
Hey All,
First off best of luck to all and heres how I tackled it.
Was conscious of time so did Q1 first and kept pushing myself on if I found I was waffling. Prob went to far though as I had 15mins spare at the end.

Q1 a. Ratios etc. Company in big trouble.
Investment. Expected value using two scenarios. Negative payback. Dont do it.

B. Generic strategies. Price, Differentiation and focus. Went with Diff.

C: Define and waffle. Read article weeks ago. remembered nothing.

Q3 a: Project initiation doc. Summarized what went wrong and how the document could have prevented it.

b: Quantifiable, Measurable and observable benefits. Increased income in year 3 went through the roof??? Also how do you quantify staff morale etc.

Q4 Value chain weaknesses. nice question. Lots of weaknesses in case study.

B Technology. Accounting software. Integrated supplier systems, improved manufacturing technology, CRM software and e mails instead of Telephone.

That's basically what I did. Anyone answer along the same lines or is it way off. Hope we all passed. Good luck!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Former userFormer user14y ago#63
part(b) of question one has asked about strategy development using TOWS model, Porters Generic model and Ansoff matrix. Instead of doing that i have evaluated the second option of the managers using Suitability, Feasibility and Acceptability. I have used the points analysts has come up with. will i not get any marks for that part of the question? am i going to loose 24 marks? please share your views
Former userFormer user14y ago#64
@ Jamesohagan

What u have written for part(b) of question 4 is how to replace value chain activities using IT in order to add more value but question has asked about managing up stream and down stream supply chain management. Up stream supply chain management includes E-purchasing, E-payment, E-sourcing and Down stream supply chain management includes E-marketing, E-branding, CRM software. i dont know as to how scenario is used to quote examples for this. run out of time
Hhhhmmm14y ago#65
I have a question about question one, I did Ansoff and Porter's generic strategies which I think is correct. I also mentioned E-commerce. Is e-commerce a stratgic option? It's just that they said no shoes were sold online

Q3 part b was strange in how to classify the benfeits while q4 wasn't too bad at all

Fingers crossed though
Sserenade14y ago#66
Did anyone calculate AR collection day and compare AP pay day as given in the last paragraph? The company pay faster than collection. I did Q1,3 &4 but no enough time for Q3a. Hope I can pass.
Hhhhmmm14y ago#67
I commented on how the AP days were going up. Don't think I realised AR was in there as well. My head was all over the place at that stage. E-commerce as a startegy for 1b anyone??
Former userFormer user14y ago#68
Lost a few marks there so. Still hoping for a 50% or 51%.
Former userFormer user14y ago#69
what you guys think? Q1(b) has asked about generation of strategies models can be used here are TOWS, Ansoff and Porters generic model. (Strategic Options) Suitability, Feasibility, Acceptability comes under Strategic Choices. Question was based on Strategic option to generate strategy.

What i have done was i have evaluated directors alternative strategy using S A F but question has asked to generate alternative strategies. i have made a mistake there and i thought question was to analyse the alternative strategy by the managers.

What is my position there? plz comment guys.
Former userFormer user14y ago#70
I am at a loss for words, I remain in suspense until exam results are out.
Former userFormer user14y ago#71
It was my first sitting and for sure the paper was nothing like the past papers. The paper was tough question 1(b) threw me off but i was able to talk about some Ansoff. It was bruttal and was a total of 24 points. 1(c) was ok as it looked at the mission, objectives and values.
I had fun in section b cause i have good knowledge on Software applications and the whole procurement cycle.

I just cross my fingers and pray that i get a 50. I really dont want much.
Former userFormer user14y ago#72
ok... good approach. yep its better to wait until the result date. predictions may not work some times. even you think you wont get any mark, still there is a chance to get some marks. hope for the best.

good luck you guys.
Former userFormer user14y ago#73
I'm repeating from last June and I can honestly say I think I did worse today then last year. Such dull and boring scenarios.

It seems the same topics, Business Process Change & Project Management are coming up each sitting since the syllabus changed in 2011?

What about the other topics in the course. Strategy & People? Change Management? (I obviously mention these as I prefer these than the above mentioned topics)

Maybe 3rd time lucky!
Eernstaugust14y ago#74
Im asking those who resat this paper. Is it always so time-pressured or was it extreme this time?
Hhassan078614y ago#75
Hey Guys,

I tried to stick to time first off otherwise you ruin your chances as question 4 was a doddle

Q1 a. Ratios and growth rates between the years, maybe should have looked at expected values
b) Generic strategies and Ansoff cant use pestel as its not the environment it mentioned strategic option
Q3 a) Project initiation doc had learnt this so it was simply to apply to case
b: Quantifiable, Measurable and observable benefits.
Q4 Value chain pretty straightforward
Former userFormer user14y ago#76
qno 1 was really surprising .......examiner has writteen he will not test difficult calculation from previous sylabuss but qno 1 b evaluation of investment decsion is really tough
Ggeorgetav14y ago#77
@orla333 said:
Hi georetav
No definetly not serios left this open at my desk and when i came back my brother had written this. Apologies. I thought paper was fair for question one i did ansoff, i said they should do the investment even though looking at others now it appears this might be wrong i thought 1c was ok. Then in the options i did question three and four i thought 4 was grand 3a was ok didnt have a clue what to write for 3b and waffeled. what was supposed to be the answer for 3b does anyone know. Dissapointed bigger topics didnt come up but all in all thought it was ok.

Funny guy your brother :)

On question 3b I basically challenged the 4 cost savings:
- Rental savings - how do they know they will find somebody to rent waffled on this one questioning wether the renting contract they have for the old place has any clause with regards ending it any time. Could they swithch rent off straight away? Or did they have to continue pay for long time due to contract (say contract would be agreed for 10 years)
- Energy savings - the targets are not specified. The actual consumption is not specified. The actual ways in which they are going to save energy is not specified
- Improved staff morale - that is an observable benefit, you can't measure it accurately. Indeed, it can improve efficiency if people are feeling happier but this should be measured differently: number of tasks per hour/day performed compared to previously, time it takes now to perform a certain task as opposite to how much it took before, improved customer satisfaction through better service (number of complaints, number of customers returned, etc.)
- increased revenue - again, no basis for the Profit amount assumed. The country is going through recession, people won't have more money to spend on entertainment just because the city centre looks prettier. The buying power for people will stay the same. And during recession people care more about what they eat at home and feel like going out less.

A question above on E-commerce-is this strategy - maybe, I don't know for sure. I didn't put it as a separate heading, but discussed it quite a lot

I think we should now focus on the next exam or if you are lucky enough to not have any more, just enjoy your 'holiday' now!. And maybe come back in August and put the mark you got against your comments

God help us all (there's nothing else we can do now!)
Eemmasanders14y ago#78
am i alone in the use of tows ? 1B thought it made sense at the time but dont think many poeple used it thought because they gave the swot analysis it made sense doubting my chose now
Former userFormer user14y ago#79
Hey Ashen

I'm in the same boat as you with respect to using the SAF basis for the strategy moving production to the foreign country.

I'd need to read the question again, but from my recollection it mentioned strategy choices.

Thinking about it now, being given a SWOT analysis in the question this should automatically bring you onto to doing a TOWS analysis for the various strategies available.

However I don't think imo that you'd be penalised for developing a strategy as long as you can back it up. After all the question did ask for strategic choices (I think, or did it just ask for strategies)

Remember though that I maybe wrong and it is just my opinion.

But from the small sample on this board alone, it looks like a variety of ideas backed up with various models that have been generated. And as I said before, I just hope Steve and the other markers when it comes to drafting the marking scheme have the TOWS & ANSOFF matrix as the primary models used, but give credit for other models used, just as long as there are to do with a pacific strategic choice and can be backed up.

Good luck.
Vvacamas200214y ago#80
Getting worried after reading the comments on here.

For question 1b, I gave a qick Pestel paragraph (this didnt feel right at time but mind went blank) then i write a a bit about SAF but then focused mainly on choosing to be a cost leader of differentiator.

Have I missed the point completely with this question? Thanks
Former userFormer user14y ago#81
Think I may have misinterpreted 1(b), thought the question was asking to evaluate the alternative strategy proposed by the managers so I used SAF. Hoping for some marks here otherwise I've failed.
Vvacamas200214y ago#82
Can anyone remember the exact wording of question 1b ?
Former userFormer user14y ago#83
on the investment bit q1 a i just mentioned the pros and cons according to the case, Q1b i believe any framework is fine as long as its according to the case.
Former userFormer user14y ago#84
@vacamas2002 said:
Can anyone remember the exact wording of question 1b ?


Give it a couple of days and the paper will be on ACCA's website. The P6 paper from Friday is on there now, so I'd guess by Wednesday.
Former userFormer user14y ago#85
I thought it was an ok paper. Alot of the technical articles he had written were in there. I put for Q1 a) Profit ratios, gearing and the effects of the family drawing dividends adding to the mix and then I did decision trees with both scenarios not paying back (???) Q1 b) I did Ansoffs and did a SAF on the proposal, as I wasn't sure which way the question was asking it. Q1 c) I did the strategic purpose of the company and how the mission tied into that. Q3 a) I mentioned the PID, the contents and tied in the elements into quality, time, risk and cost (sharp increase in Year 3 and measuring staff morale. Q3b) I mentioned measurable, quanitfiable, financial and observable benefits. Also, Q4 was a nice question, however you can never tell with these exams. Good luck everyone:)
Former userFormer user14y ago#86
this is what i DID lol..

1a... sales growth, profitablitty ratios, gearing, increased finance cost, increase in PA days, decrese in RA - company is in bad financial position..
1b.. i completely messd this part up.. i used aquisition, organic growth, franchising, strategic growth, society welfare, use of IT in production
1c.. was easier.. comunicating strategy because shareholders, stakeholders, directors, employees want to get informed..


3a.. PID.. Cost and time, Qulity..
3b.. generally i explained about the basis used for All four benifits, specialy what was the basis for engery, income increase, and staff morale, resisting the change, inflation factor in rental saving..

4a. alot weaknessess were there and i explained them..
4b. E-procurement.. E- payment.. upstrem.. E-marketing, integration, did not have time so explained it in general words, like orders should be sent directly to suppliers to avoid delay in delivery and All..



Any chancess of passing ?
Former userFormer user14y ago#87
I used TOWS in Q1, applying strengths to take opportunities, counteract weaknesses. Could have done SAF too.

Also suggested e-commerce as strategy, together with differentiation.

No clue how to answer Q3b so did Q4 first then settled for Q2. Tough paper but nothing totally unexpected.

Good luck everyone!
Eernstaugust14y ago#88
@emmasanders said:
am i alone in the use of tows ? 1B thought it made sense at the time but dont think many poeple used it thought because they gave the swot analysis it made sense doubting my chose now

don't be worried, TOWS was the most straightforward solution which will earn the most marks. it was not an accident that he gave us the SWOT.
Eernstaugust14y ago#89
@haseebwasti said:
qno 1 was really surprising .......examiner has writteen he will not test difficult calculation from previous sylabuss but qno 1 b evaluation of investment decsion is really tough


I dont think its a tough requirement to add up 6 numbers and then subtract the sum from another number and multiply it by a third number :D
Pprincefury00714y ago#90
my fellow acca P3 student! p3 has done what p3 does again!
gosh! it was so time pressured!

q1 a did the fianancial position with roce, liquidity and the rest.
1b struggle with wat to wite cos it was not clear if we should analyse the managers alternative theory or suggest new one. 15 mins to end of exam decided to write on ansorff, differentiation, ashgrid. but could do it as i would have if question was clear.
1c talk about the advantages of missions,values and objectives. was not perfect also.

Q2a talked about what you should consider when purchasing software such as cost, support, scalability etc.
Q2b simply talked about use of project gateways....
q3 did not do
q4did not do well but talked a little about value chain
q4b talked about 6Is but could not fully read scenario as was out of time

this is not absolute in fact. don't no if am right!but pray to pass. thought paper was quit OK but scenario were too long and time pressured!