Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

SBL*** P3 June 2011 Exam was … Post your comments here and vote in Instant Poll ***

Oopentuition15y ago
Please share here with community your comments about June 2011 P3 exam.
What came up? How did you do? How did this paper compare to previous exams?

Vote in our Instant Poll

*** P3 June 2011 Exam was … Post your comments here and vote in Instant Poll *** poll results
Rredrose15y ago#61
I used pestel and swot for q1.. i wonder swot was the correct model to use...
q2. npv, irr, payback??? more of f9.....
q4: emarketing... omg.. lengthy paper how on earth do u absorb so much info in such a short time span...
q3. i found it too daunting so i opted out.....
a pass.. is all that is needed.. so God help us all!!!!!!!!
Ttakamori15y ago#62
@muneebnawaz90 said:
well Outsourcing part required some calculation for discussing financial part
cost if outsourced ( 3500 x 6 ) + ( 250 x 6 ) - 1250 ( decrease in overhead ) = 21250 and if manufacture in house it will cost 4500 x 6 = 27000 . so financially beneficial but also discussed that make sure there might be some other cost which may make it financial not good. discussed quality issues and reliability in non financial part . attemted complete paper alhamdulilah . Hoping for good marks :)


how did u come up with 4500 x 6? as far as i know, there are limited number of hours available if u r manufacturing it in house.. i did the ranking using contribution per hour and then calculate the total profit for in house and outsource..
Former userFormer user15y ago#63
i wrote too much using pestel and 5 forces for q1 part a...over ran a lot then fluffed the make or buy decision totally...re part c the weaknesses were budgetary (PRIME) need to recruit and support either graduates or fast track internally or head-hunt from competitors third was basically the need to set up a risk committee or employee a risk manager to devolve this kind of thing to.. of the three options i thought q3 was the most time consuming and complicated (for me) so did the bobby blunt q which was - as others have said - bascially saying why he was completely wrong with his comments about the investment appraisal.. payback was the same - unless you took out the intangibles which should never have been included - NPV is to beat COC not inflation.. as seen in previous papers (Rick Hein Q i think) bobby autocratic and unfocused re control processes....matrix would never work as he'd scrap it before the benefits had a chance to show themselves....q4 seemed ok. i feel i've done enough to pass.. good luck to everyone
Former userFormer user15y ago#64
q1 part b. did you take production hours as a scarce resource and found profit without outsourcing and profit with outsourcing, besides it was irt necessary to do SFA analysis??
DDeep15y ago#65
Paper was ok.
Got a few doubts though.
Q1. (c I think) on controls, Senior Partners and risk weakness.
I answered as
controls weakness - Used Cultural web to explain why controls are weak.
senior partners - Used Strategic leadership to address this risk
risk Weakness - used knowledge from P1, risk awareness, culture, etc.

Q2. About NPV - I said it was prepared wrong as It included moral benefits as a revenue

Can ANy1 tell me whether I answered the above mentioned correctly
Thanks a bunch
SSagittarius15y ago#66
For Q1 - i used the PESTEL and as it was only asking external environment I used only the OT part of SWOT as SW is internal factors(hope i'm right) and for Marketplace I used porter's 5 Forces.

Option did Q3 & 4 - was real time pressured and could not think enough to write quality answers:(.

Will be happy with just 50% marks!

Goodluck !!
Former userFormer user15y ago#67
Well i thought the exam was pretty difficult but this is how i tackled the exam:

Q1) I used part PESTEL (Political, Environment, Socio-cultural), then i used porters 5 forces for the industry.

b)
I thought this was difficult to score with financial ratios etc. I ended up focusing on the non financial:

Adv - Better budgeting for cost, meets production demand, less conflict and legal issues

Disadv - Government grant could be removed, bad for company brand. Quality assurance problems. Transportation leads to high co2 emissions going against the companys going green car.

c)
3 weaknesses i used the following:

1) Bad internal controls, introduce computer system to ensure that products are ordered to order etc.

2) Mentioned about cultural web and also Halogens & Hope Bailey "reconstructive" phase etc.

3) Mentioned about risk awareness and embedding risk into company. Ensure cultural risk is started at top to bottom.
Former userFormer user15y ago#68
it was ok. too much time pressure.
Former userFormer user15y ago#69
Did anyone consider CSR re employees, community under the non-financial argument on outsourcing? Thought paper was fair, but, as usual, time-pressured. I will pass this paper before I go to my grave!
Former userFormer user15y ago#70
The paper was not difficult and in line with the pilot paper by structure and style. I try P3 for the second time, the first one was June 2010 (December 2010 was missed). Compared to that exam, the 1st question was much easier and shorter, which made me happy, but only until I had only 15 minutes for the last question. Questions 3 and 4 were both very long to read, which was unexpected. After all, this is an exam for 'strategic' paper, and everyone needs to develop their own strategy to pass, taking into account the time pressure, vagueness and uncertainty. Otherwise it would be too easy;)
Q1 - I did PESTEL and Diamond. Indeed, originally it was made for analysis of nations' competitiveness, but can be used for analysis of markets in geographic areas (as in the exam). For outsourcing, I used straight comparison of costs of outsoursing and in-house, not using contribution, as it is clear that there are not enough hours to produce in-house and there is no choice which model to outsource (may be too simple assumption). Other arguments included lost customers and gov.support in case of outsourcing.
Q2 was quite clear to me. Much is said about that.
Q3 - I had about 15 minutes so I tried to answer only 10-mark question. Don't know exactly what should be said here;)
Sspencerli15y ago#71
Did anyone use Harmon's Matrix for question 3 part b?

There were 4 options - testing, student invoicing, student adresses, and something else.
Did each fall into a different quadrant (outsource, automate, etc) or did I misinterpret the question?
Former userFormer user15y ago#72
I studied a lot for this particular exam, and even more for P2. To be honest I was pretty pissed when i saw the papers, as they were too easy and did not test the candidates. There should have been some tricks in both of these papers, but I hardly found any. The only problem I seemed to face was in the outsourcing question, as i did not remember costing from F5, and mistakenly thought the Eco Car co. was outsourcing its complete manufacturing division. I only did basic cost calculations, and advised in favor of outsourcing, and also jotted down some cons. NPV went well, could've written more if had more time, could not complete the IRR aspect, but debated on the discount rate intangible benefits realisation, and the fact that these benefits sometimes even take months or years after an internal job/project is completed. Did comment on the payback method and its disadvantages, and that no investment should be made on payback on a stand alone basis. Apart from that, i think it was one of the easiest papers ever to be made, and it was a complete and utter joke, with case studies so long, and there not being any link in questions to most parts of those case studies, i thought the examiner just made a joke out of himself. Might not get good marks in outsourcing and especially in its financial area, but gave a handful of valid points related to outsourcing that would influence a company, and in particular this one.
Former userFormer user15y ago#73
@tom.mcdonald217 said:
Did anyone consider CSR re employees, community under the non-financial argument on outsourcing? Thought paper was fair, but, as usual, time-pressured. I will pass this paper before I go to my grave!

Yes I guess in outsourcing that could be used, considering the loyalty of consumers and the grants received from govt. these all add up to expectations being there from these stakeholders, who love their company and are happy about what they are doing. The factor to be seen could be that would this outsourcing send a wrong signal to these stakeholders and would they figure that maybe the company in the future might outsource its complete manufacturing division, which a) would piss the govt. off as they have given grants to this company in substantial amounts, and they need to increase employment and the national income of their country rather than of another one. and b) might affect the loyalty of the consumers, who might transfer to substitutes in the future(refer to the people developing hybrid vehicles). These amounts do add up and could affect the company
Former userFormer user15y ago#74
@abbas 732 i guess u havent witnessed the option papers yett particularly p6 and p7 and when u do im sure the examiner will fulfiil all ur expectations of a difficult paper and a real test for the candidates..perhaps we cant forget an easier brings with itself a tough marking...so cheers
Former userFormer user15y ago#75
Thnks for the motivation @abbas. I did PESTEL for ques. 1 and some diamond. I totally ignored qu 2 and why oh why didn't i learn skidmore's model on process re-design and users' requirements for a software package ):
Former userFormer user15y ago#76
@Dania_Perveen said:
alancong.. 3 weakness part was all general things.. number 1 deals with need to coordinate n communicate budgets n monitor them.. tentions arose for not doing do.. number 2 was abt lack of succession planning.. plus employee commitment n morale new graduates were hire a facilitative leadership would be approporiate or anyother you think fine... number 3 was very straight.. Ecocar was being victim of Red tapism.. they js used to discuss risk bt never taken any action.. so recommending TARA framework or 4Ts i think would have been a good answer

@Dania_Perveen said:
alancong.. 3 weakness part was all general things.. number 1 deals with need to coordinate n communicate budgets n monitor them.. tentions arose for not doing do.. number 2 was abt lack of succession planning.. plus employee commitment n morale new graduates were hire a facilitative leadership would be approporiate or anyother you think fine... number 3 was very straight.. Ecocar was being victim of Red tapism.. they js used to discuss risk bt never taken any action.. so recommending TARA framework or 4Ts i think would have been a good answer

thanks a lot
Former userFormer user15y ago#77
hye guys & gurls,

I think the was 50-50...did Q1, Q2 and Q3...my forth attempt of dis paper...marks continue to decline since my 1st attempt, from 40s to 30 :( hopefully to pass this paper this time around...

I answered:
Q1: (a) PESTEL and 5 Forces
(b) Financial info not that much to wrte/calculate, just basics as I dont really know much on the calculation (im not into costing =p) just use much on non-fin info
(c) i: IS
II: elements of P1 (nomination committee & remuneration committee) =p
III: also elements of P1 (risk management committee) =p
Q2: (a) managed to answer Payback, discount rate and IRR only :(
(b) wrote 1 or 2 sentences only of matrix org principles and relate to case, 2 points each (i think =p) for the adv and disadv.

Q3: (a) used Harmon's process strategy but managed to answer for quadrant "adaptation" and "Revolution" only (poor time management)
(b) cant remember
Llebohang15y ago#78
Don't scare me guys, I used cycle of competition instead of five forces. How relevant was it?
Former userFormer user15y ago#79
question 1 a i used PASTEL and ansof matrix(market development),,,its a true answer???i guess the model is not given so its very flaxibal to student how to related with scenario....overall the question is ok,,but still in poor time managemant,,,i left q4 e procurement..hope i can get 50 so i can pass !!!!god help me.....
Former userFormer user15y ago#80
I faced the time constraint and lost 9 marks.
Former userFormer user15y ago#81
The paper was pretty general, but very long. I kept falling behind on time. Barely finished it all.
Former userFormer user15y ago#82
pestel n 5 forces was the obvious answer.. but is it ok in any way if i applied swot in q1? OT for macro environment n SW for marketplace? anyone?
Eevalstngj15y ago#83
I went into the exam hall very confident knowing all the models and how to apply them but when faced with reality my brain froze especially due to time pressure. The last qtn on process redesign was answered with the transformational, realignment and speed of change model but i was not confident i was doing the right thing. At this rate, all i am begging for is 50% - no more no less as there's nothing more to read, pls examiner :)
Mmostru15y ago#84
i will get 90 % for this paper - so easy!
Former userFormer user15y ago#85
The questions are very long. Q1 took me like the most of the time - I know I should have stopped but it wasn't a bad question and so I really wanted to do my best with it; hoping I can pick the remaining marks on the other 2 Qs to pass the paper. I'll wait and see...
Ssmartytaha15y ago#86
this paper had a lot of crossovers from f5....especially Q1 b and Q2......for outsourcing financial info. had to do the contribution per limiting factor and (Make or buy) calc....the examiner was testing hw much course do we remember
Former userFormer user15y ago#87
Time pressure is exagerated. I needed the 15 minutes just to carefully read Q1. In the end, it was a disaster for me.. :D
Former userFormer user15y ago#88
@cuid3 said:
@abbas 732 i guess u havent witnessed the option papers yett particularly p6 and p7 and when u do im sure the examiner will fulfiil all ur expectations of a difficult paper and a real test for the candidates..perhaps we cant forget an easier brings with itself a tough marking...so cheers


Man, I passed all papers and I cannot get through with this last one. And this is mainly due to the fact that I need about 45min reading and planning time for P3 questions.
Former userFormer user15y ago#89
omg, I thought for a moment I was doing a P7 exam and I know the professional papers are assumed knowledge but does mean I could be doing a tax question along with a audit question?

I also agree there was far too much reading (for a slow reader I didn't stand a chance) and by the time you got through the senaro there was no way I was going to read it the second time as I would have never got anything written down.

I did Pestel and Porters Diamond in question one, Q2 was a bit of a dister for me and I liked Q4, value chain, 6I's of e-marketing although I left a few gaps. Fingers crossed for August and good luck to the rest of you.
Former userFormer user15y ago#90
Q1, I used PESTLE, 5 forces model amd did a bit of prod life cycle to explain the threats of new entrants (though was not sure if it was relevant).
Q2, Used F9 info to explain the NPV, IRR and payback but was confused by the matrix in regards to the departments so i waffled a bit.
Q4 Was a bit confortable woth the 4 Is but was boubtfull what to say on e-procurement.
Comments guys!!!!