Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

SBL*** P3 June 2011 Exam was … Post your comments here and vote in Instant Poll ***

Oopentuition15y ago
Please share here with community your comments about June 2011 P3 exam.
What came up? How did you do? How did this paper compare to previous exams?

Vote in our Instant Poll

*** P3 June 2011 Exam was … Post your comments here and vote in Instant Poll *** poll results
Nnbaig15y ago#1
Hello guys,

What came up this sitting?
Former userFormer user15y ago#2
The questions are too long.
Former userFormer user15y ago#3
yeah, agree. time pressure. too much expected to answer, time pressure!!!!!!!!
Former userFormer user15y ago#4
Q1 Scenario was about an electronic car company, EcoCar
a) analyse the macro environment and the marketplace (PESTEL and Porter's 5CF's)
b) evaluate the decision to outsource a product line called EcoLite (cheap town car)
c) how EcoCar can manage the 3 weaknesses given (1. dont remember 2. knowledge and succession planning 3.understanding risk)

Q3
a) problems of the handling process (swimlane diagram)
b) i can't remember

Q4
a) I's of e-marketing specifically asking about independence of location, interactivity, individualisation, intelligence
b) e-procurement
Former userFormer user15y ago#5
q1: pestel and 5 forces
outsourcing 1 product --evaluate using financial and non-financial
lack of control and coordination , risk and R&D successive ---dow to deal with it
q2: NPV, IRR, DISOUCT rate , payback , tangible and intangible , evaluate
cannot recall
q3: process redesign
q4: 6i (4 of them how to use)
e-procure
Ppuiyee9015y ago#6
the swimlane diagram too small, all the arrows intertwined. i can't even see clearly the direction of the arrows.
Former userFormer user15y ago#7
In my first question i used PESTEL and Porters Diamond, not 5 forces. you think its ok also
Former userFormer user15y ago#8
someone usd ansofz matrix in ques 1. is that right?
Vvidi15y ago#9
Did question 1,3,4. Real time pressure though.. :)
Former userFormer user15y ago#10
funshine99...you will lose 10 marks
Former userFormer user15y ago#11
the 3 weakness parts? i have no idea how to answer that part
Former userFormer user15y ago#12
WOW! what a classic paper, calculation rocks. though bit time constraint faced by all of us, but their are some obvious marks. Thanks to Examiner
Former userFormer user15y ago#13
the paper was ok...

REQ...

1.PESTLE 5 FORCES
(:) financial and non financial benefits of outsourse (MAKE OR BUY DECISION)
(C) lack of control,R&D and risk weakness identification (IT or BPC,Succession Planning, Knowledge management)

2.NPV IRR PAYBACK Intangible benefit realisation.
(:) Matrix Structure...principles benefits and problems.

4.Interactivity, intelligence, independence, individualisation E-marketting
(:) E-procurement and application on case study.
Former userFormer user15y ago#14
i used pestel and swot in the first question - is swot completely wrong? i couldnt get a long enough answer by using 5 forces.
Former userFormer user15y ago#15
2.NPV IRR PAYBACK discount rates Intangible benefit realisation.
(:) Matrix Structure…principles benefits and problems.
Former userFormer user15y ago#16
@ funshine99... i dont think ull lose 10 marks fr dis...as only 4 professional marks were in place for identifying relevant model(s).....
Plus i think the examiner played a trick here....d question meant only to b analysed using PESTEL cus in PESTEL u discuss marketplace aspects also in all d relevent factors.....
had dere been required more dan two models...he would have clearly written MODELS instead of model(s)......
n wt else do u xpect from a 16 mark qustion....PESTEL analysis z way too long fr 16 marks......
Rrumaysha15y ago#17
i used pestel and porter's diamond. is diamond rule completely irrelevant in this case?? time was a limiting factor. lol
Former userFormer user15y ago#18
@hatifdar said:
the paper was ok...

REQ...

1.PESTLE 5 FORCES
(:) financial and non financial benefits of outsourse (MAKE OR BUY DECISION)
(C) lack of control,R&D and risk weakness identification (IT or BPC,Succession Planning, Knowledge management)

2.NPV IRR PAYBACK Intangible benefit realisation.
(:) Matrix Structure...principles benefits and problems.

4.Interactivity, intelligence, independence, individualisation E-marketting
(:) E-procurement and application on case study.

how did u answer q1 part c and question 2 a, thansk
Sspencerli15y ago#19
An ok paper I think, but can never tell!

For the weaknesses I used JSW's three lenses...
Former userFormer user15y ago#20
yes diamond rule is relevant only fr competencies of nations......not fr dis scenario......
i think PESTEL ws enough....
Former userFormer user15y ago#21
i dun know y examiners keep on pressing us fr time....a high profile analytical paper plus a lengthy one....either v cn think or v can write in dese papers.....
Mmrash15y ago#22
Overall paper was OK. Finally, back to normal life ahh!
Former userFormer user15y ago#23
@spencerli said:
An ok paper I think, but can never tell!

For the weaknesses I used JSW's three lenses...

oh, i did question one in the last. so i only got 1hour to do no time thinking ,couldnot think about anything
Former userFormer user15y ago#24
In Q 1 I think the examiner ideally wanted PESTEL and 5 Forces but any relevant models could score well if applied well. PESTEL on it's own would not be ideal as it only deals with macro environmental analysis, not industry specific which was also asked for.
Former userFormer user15y ago#25
The exam was ok, but again, very time pressured. You have to be very strict with you time allocation and move on once the time is up, so I did that. I sat this paper for the third time, and the Q1 was the shortest scenario I have seen for the three sittings, which I was relieved to see.

Q1 and 4 were fair, I attempted Q3, even though I struggled a bit with it, but I did write something.

I am hoping for a pass, 50 would totally do!

Lets enjoy the summer now everyone!
Former userFormer user15y ago#27
Did question 1,3,4. Real time pressure though.. :)

whats about the out sourcing, was drop in fixed cost is a relevant cost of decision
and what about the process redesign. can any one indicate what were the main issue so i know i havent waffled all of it
Former userFormer user15y ago#28
Q2 was a funny one with a CEO called Barry Blunt. 15 points on evaluating the return on two investments. Involved IRR, NPV, staff morale, discount rates and payback. Quite F9 really.

Part b of Q2 was on management matrix - the principles, pros and cons of the company in the scenario trying it. This was the last question I did and I was definitely making less sense by the end of it!
Former userFormer user15y ago#29
@ hujansan...u can surely analyse d market place in PESTEL analysis......depends upon explanation......
Former userFormer user15y ago#30
intangible benefit realisation ? how to explain this